The Institutes of the Christian Religion
Book Fourth: The Holy Catholic Church
Rewritten in modern English by Paul Lintott, following the same approach used for Books One to Three
About This Book
Book 4 is the last of the four books of Calvin's Institutes, and the longest. Having shown in Books 1 to 3 who God is, what Christ has done, and how the Spirit applies it, Calvin asks what God has given us to keep us in it. His answer is the church and its ordinary means: the preaching of the Word, the sacraments, and the discipline and order of a worshipping community.
The book falls into three parts. First comes the church itself: its marks, its ministers, its government, and the abuses Calvin saw in Rome. Then come the sacraments, baptism and the Lord's Supper above all. The book ends with a short chapter on civil government, on the calling of rulers and the duty of obedience.
Reading it today. Parts of this book answer arguments of the sixteenth century, and Calvin writes against Rome with a heat that can be wearing. But under the argument lies something that still matters: why Christians should gather, what a church is for, and why baptism and the Lord's Supper are given to us. Readers who find the long polemical chapters hard going can skim those and read the sections that matter to them.
About this edition. This is a modern-English rewrite. Calvin's order and arguments are kept, and his long sentences are broken up for clarity. It is not a scholarly translation. If you are studying a particular phrase closely, check it against a standard translation.
Paul Lintott
Argument
The first three books expounded the three parts of the Apostles' Creed that concern God the Creator, the Redeemer and the Sanctifier. What remains, in this last book, is to treat the Church and the communion of saints: that is, the outward means or helps by which God invites us into fellowship with Christ and keeps us there.
The twenty chapters of this book fall conveniently under three main heads: I. The Church. II. The Sacraments. III. Civil Government.
The first head takes up the first thirteen chapters, which can themselves be gathered under four topics:
I. The marks of the Church, the means by which it may be recognised, since we're bound to cultivate unity with it. This is treated in chapters 1 and 2.
II. The government of the Church. The order of its government is treated in chapter 3; the form it took in the early Church in chapter 4; the form it now takes under the Papacy in chapter 5; the primacy of the Pope in chapter 6; and the gradual growth of his usurped power in chapter 7.
III. The power of the Church. Its power over doctrine, whether exercised by individuals (chapter 8) or collectively in councils (chapter 9); its power to make laws (chapter 10); and the extent of its jurisdiction (chapter 11).
IV. The discipline of the Church. Its proper use is treated in chapter 12, and its abuse in chapter 13.
The second main head, the Sacraments, has three parts: I. The sacraments in general, chapter 14. II. The two sacraments in particular: baptism in chapter 15, infant baptism in chapter 16, the Lord's Supper in chapter 17, and the profaning of the Lord's Supper in chapter 18. III. The five so-called sacraments falsely added to these, chapter 19.
The third main head, Civil Government, is treated in chapter 20: first in general, and then under the separate heads of magistrates, laws and people.
Chapter 1
The True Church, and Our Duty to Cultivate Unity with Her as the Mother of All the Godly
1. Why we now turn to the Church
In the previous book I showed that it is by faith in the gospel that Christ becomes ours, and that we come to share in the salvation and eternal blessedness he has won. But our ignorance and sloth (and, I might add, the fickleness of our minds) mean that we need outward helps, by which faith may be born in us, grow and make progress until it reaches its goal. So God, accommodating himself to our weakness, has supplied such helps. He has secured the effective preaching of the gospel by entrusting this treasure to the Church. He has appointed pastors and teachers, through whose lips he builds up his people (Eph. 4:11); he has given them authority; and, in short, he has left out nothing that might serve holy agreement in the faith and good order. Above all, he has instituted sacraments, which we know from experience to be immensely useful aids for nourishing and strengthening our faith. Shut up as we are in the prison of the body, and not yet raised to the rank of angels, we have been given by God, in his wonderful providence, a way of drawing near to him even across so great a distance, suited to our capacity.
The right order of treatment, then, is first the Church, with its government, offices and power; next the sacraments; and last civil government. At the same time I'll be warning godly readers against the corruptions of the Papacy, by which Satan has debased everything God appointed for our salvation.
I begin with the Church, into whose embrace God is pleased to gather his children: not only so that by her help and ministry they might be fed while they are infants and children, but also so that they might be guided by her motherly care until they grow to maturity and finally reach the goal of faith. "What God has joined together, let no one separate" (Mark 10:9): for those to whom he is Father, the Church must also be mother. This was true not only under the Law but is still true now, after Christ's coming, since Paul declares that we are children of a new, heavenly Jerusalem (Gal. 4:26).
2. What we confess in "I believe the holy catholic Church"
When we profess in the Creed to believe the Church, we mean not only the visible Church I'm about to discuss, but all of God's elect, including those who have already died. That's why the word "believe" is used: very often no difference can be seen between God's children and the ungodly, between his own flock and the wild herd.
The word "in" ("I believe in the Church") is often inserted, but without good reason. I grant that it's the more common form, and not without ancient support, since the Nicene Creed as quoted in the Ecclesiastical History includes the preposition. Still, the early writers show that the form accepted without dispute in ancient times was to believe "the Church," not "in the Church." This is the wording not only of Augustine but also of the ancient author, whoever he was, of the treatise On the Exposition of the Creed that circulates under Cyprian's name; and both expressly point out that adding the preposition would make the phrase improper, and they give good reasons. We say we believe in God because our mind rests on him as true and our trust is wholly satisfied in him. That can't be said of the Church, any more than of the forgiveness of sins or the resurrection of the body. So although I've no wish to quarrel over words, I'd rather keep the proper form, which expresses the thing more accurately, than adopt terms that obscure the meaning for no reason.
The point of the article is to teach us this: although the devil leaves no stone unturned to destroy the grace of Christ, and God's enemies rush with blind fury in the same direction, that grace cannot be extinguished. Christ's blood cannot be made barren or kept from bearing fruit. Here we must keep in view both God's secret election and his inward calling, because he alone "knows those who are his" (2 Tim. 2:19). As Paul puts it, he keeps them enclosed, as it were, under his seal, even though they also wear his insignia, which distinguish them from the reprobate. But since they are a small and despised number, hidden in a vast crowd, like a few grains of wheat buried in a heap of chaff, the knowledge of his Church, whose foundation is his secret election, must be left to God alone.
Nor is it enough to hold the number of the elect in mind as a mere idea. By the unity of the Church we must understand a unity into which we are persuaded we ourselves have truly been grafted. For unless we are united with all the other members under Christ our head, no hope of the inheritance to come awaits us. That's why the Church is called catholic, or universal (Augustine, Letter 48): two or three churches cannot be devised without tearing Christ apart, and that's impossible. All God's elect are so joined together in Christ that, as they depend on one head, they grow together into one body, knit together like its various members. They are made truly one by living under the same Spirit of God in one faith, hope and love, called not only to the same inheritance of eternal life but to share in one God and one Christ. So although the grim devastation we see on every side may seem to announce that no Church remains, let us know that Christ's death bears fruit, and that God wonderfully preserves his Church, though he places it, as it were, in hiding. So it was said to Elijah, "I have kept for myself seven thousand in Israel" (1 Kings 19:18).
3. The communion of saints, and the comfort it brings
This article of the Creed also bears in some measure on the outward Church: each of us must keep brotherly harmony with all God's children, give the Church its due authority, and in short behave as sheep of the flock. Hence the added phrase, "the communion of saints." Though the ancient writers usually leave it out, it mustn't be passed over, because it expresses admirably what the Church is: as though to say that the saints are gathered into the fellowship of Christ on this condition, that whatever blessings God gives them they share with one another.
This doesn't rule out a variety of gifts, for we know the gifts of the Spirit are distributed differently. Nor does it rule out civil order, under which each person is allowed to own private property, since distinct rights of ownership are necessary for keeping peace among people. Still, a real sharing is affirmed, such as Luke describes: "the full number of those who believed were of one heart and soul" (Acts 4:32); and Paul, when he reminds the Ephesians, "There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope that belongs to your call" (Eph. 4:4). If they are truly persuaded that God is the common Father of them all and Christ their common head, they can't help being united in brotherly love and sharing their blessings with one another.
It matters greatly, too, that we grasp the benefit that comes to us from this. We believe the Church so that we may be firmly persuaded that we are its members. In this way our salvation rests on a foundation so firm and sure that even if the whole frame of the world collapsed, it could not be overthrown. First, it stands on God's election, and can no more change or fail than his eternal providence can. Next, it is bound up, so to speak, with the steadfastness of Christ, who will no more let his faithful people be cut off from him than he would let his own limbs be torn to pieces. We may add that as long as we remain in the bosom of the Church, we are sure the truth will remain with us. Finally, we feel that promises like these belong to us: "In Mount Zion and in Jerusalem there shall be those who escape" (Joel 2:32; Obad. 17); "God is in the midst of her; she shall not be moved" (Ps. 46:5). So powerful is communion with the Church in keeping us in fellowship with God. There's great comfort in the very word "communion": since we're assured that everything God gives to his members belongs to us, every blessing they receive strengthens our hope.
But to embrace the Church's unity in this way, it isn't necessary, as I've said, to see it with our eyes or touch it with our hands. On the contrary, the very fact that it's placed in the realm of faith reminds us that we must hold to it just as firmly when it escapes our sight as when it's plainly visible. Nor is our faith any the worse for taking hold of what is unseen. We aren't told here to sort the elect from the reprobate (that belongs to God alone, not to us); we're told to be firmly assured in our minds that all who, by the mercy of God the Father and the working of the Holy Spirit, have come to share in Christ are set apart as God's own special possession, and that since we are among them, we share in this great grace.
4. The Church as mother: no salvation outside her
But since my present purpose is to discuss the visible Church, let's learn from the single title "mother" how useful, indeed how necessary, it is to know her. There is no other way into life unless she conceives us in her womb, gives us birth, nurses us at her breast, and keeps us under her care and guidance until we put off this mortal flesh and become like the angels (Matt. 22:30). Our weakness doesn't allow us to leave school until we've spent our whole lives as pupils.
Furthermore, outside the Church no forgiveness of sins and no salvation can be hoped for, as Isaiah and Joel testify (Isa. 37:32; Joel 2:32). Ezekiel agrees when he says of false prophets, "They shall not be in the council of my people, nor be enrolled in the register of the house of Israel" (Ezek. 13:9); while, conversely, those who turn to true godliness are said to have their names written among the citizens of Jerusalem. That's why the psalmist prays, "Remember me, O Lord, when you show favour to your people; help me when you save them, that I may look upon the prosperity of your chosen ones, that I may rejoice in the gladness of your nation, that I may glory with your inheritance" (Ps. 106:4-5). In these words God's fatherly favour and the special evidence of spiritual life are confined to his own people, and so to abandon the Church is always fatal.
5. God teaches us through human ministers, and why that is good for us
Let's set this out more fully. Paul says that Christ "ascended far above all the heavens, that he might fill all things. And he gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the pastors and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, until we all attain to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to mature manhood, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ" (Eph. 4:10-13). Here we see that God, who could perfect his people in a moment, chooses to bring them to maturity only through the Church's instruction. We see the means he uses: the preaching of heavenly doctrine is entrusted to pastors. And we see that everyone without exception is placed under the same arrangement, so that with a meek and teachable spirit they allow themselves to be guided by teachers appointed for the purpose. Isaiah had long before named this as a mark of Christ's kingdom: "My Spirit that is upon you, and my words that I have put in your mouth, shall not depart out of your mouth, or out of the mouth of your offspring, or out of the mouth of your children's offspring, says the Lord, from this time forth and for evermore" (Isa. 59:21). It follows that all who reject the spiritual food of the soul that God offers them through the Church's hands deserve to die of hunger.
God breathes faith into us, but he does it through his gospel, as Paul reminds us: "faith comes from hearing" (Rom. 10:17). God keeps to himself the power of sustaining faith, but, as Paul also declares, it is by the preaching of the gospel that he brings it out and makes it grow. With this in view, he willed in ancient times that sacred assemblies be held at the sanctuary, so that agreement in the faith might be nourished by teaching from the priest's lips. Those magnificent titles, where the temple is called God's resting place, his sanctuary, his dwelling, and where he is said to sit enthroned between the cherubim (Ps. 132:13-14; 80:1), serve no other purpose than to win respect, love, reverence and honour for the ministry of heavenly doctrine, which might otherwise be undervalued because of the unimpressive human beings who carry it out. So, to teach us that the treasure offered to us in clay jars is of inestimable worth (2 Cor. 4:7), God himself comes forward and, as the author of this ordinance, requires that his presence be recognised in his own institution.
So, after forbidding his people to consult mediums, sorcerers and other superstitions (Lev. 19:30-31), he adds that he will give them what ought to be enough for everyone: he will never leave them without prophets. Just as he didn't hand his ancient people over to angels but raised up teachers on earth to do what was truly an angel's work, so today he is pleased to teach us by human means. And just as in the past he didn't stop at giving the law but added priests as its interpreters, from whose lips the people could ask its true meaning, so now he wants us not only to give ourselves to reading, but has appointed teachers to help us. There's a twofold benefit in this. On the one hand, he tests our obedience in a remarkable way when we listen to his ministers just as we would to him. On the other, he provides for our weakness by being pleased to address us in a human way through interpreters, drawing us to himself rather than driving us away with his thunder. All the godly know how well this familiar way of teaching suits us, from the dread that God's majesty rightly inspires in them.
Those who think the authority of the teaching is weakened by the lowliness of the people called to teach it show their ingratitude. Among the many excellent gifts with which God has adorned the human race, one of the most remarkable is that he condescends to consecrate human mouths and tongues to his service, making his own voice heard in them. So let's not refuse to receive obediently the doctrine of salvation delivered at his command and from his mouth. Although God's power is not bound to outward means, he has bound us to this ordinary way of teaching, and fanatics who refuse to keep to it entangle themselves in many deadly snares.
Many people, from pride or fastidiousness or rivalry, persuade themselves that they can profit enough from private reading and meditation, and so look down on public worship and consider preaching unnecessary. But since they do all they can to loosen or break the sacred bond of unity, none of them escapes the just penalty of this ungodly divorce: they fall under the spell of pestilent errors and the foulest delusions. So, that the pure simplicity of the faith may flourish among us, let's not refuse to practise this exercise of godliness, which God has shown to be necessary by instituting it and which he commends so highly. Not even the most insolent person would dare say we should shut our ears to God. Yet in every age prophets and godly teachers have had a hard struggle with the ungodly, whose stubbornness can't bear the yoke of being taught by human lips and ministry. That is no different from erasing God's own likeness as it is shown to us in his teaching. For it was for no other reason that believers in ancient times were told to seek God's face in the sanctuary (Ps. 105:4), a command repeated so often in the Law, than that the teaching of the Law and the exhortations of the prophets were to them a living image of God. So Paul declares that in his preaching the glory of God shone in the face of Jesus Christ (2 Cor. 4:6).
All the more detestable, then, are the deserters who delight in splitting churches, as though they wanted to drive the sheep from the fold and throw them into the jaws of wolves. Let's hold fast, in line with the passage from Paul quoted above, that the Church can be built up only by outward preaching, and that the saints are held together by no other bond than by keeping, with one mind, the order God has appointed in his Church for learning and making progress. It was above all for this purpose, as I've said, that believers under the Law were told to gather at the sanctuary. When Moses speaks of God's dwelling place, he calls it at the same time the place of God's name, the place where he will cause his name to be remembered (Exod. 20:24), plainly teaching that it was useless without the teaching of godliness. And there's no doubt that this is why David complains so bitterly at being kept from the tabernacle by the tyranny of his enemies (Ps. 84). To many the complaint seems childish, as if little were lost, not much pleasure missed, by being shut out of the temple, provided one had other enjoyments. Yet David laments this one loss as something that fills him with anxiety and grief, torments him and almost destroys him. He does so because there is nothing believers value more highly than this aid by which God lifts his people step by step towards heaven.
We should note that God always showed himself to the holy patriarchs in the mirror of his teaching in such a way as to make their knowledge spiritual. So the temple is not only called his face but also, to rule out all superstition, his footstool (Ps. 132:7; 99:5). Here the unity of faith is happily achieved, when all, from the highest to the lowest, reach up towards the head. All the temples the pagans built to God with any other intention were a mere profanation of his worship, and the Jews fell into the same profanation, though less grossly. Stephen rebukes them for it in the words of Isaiah: "The Most High does not dwell in houses made by hands, as the prophet says, 'Heaven is my throne'" (Acts 7:48-49). For it is only God's word that consecrates temples to their lawful use. When we rashly undertake anything without his command, we start from a bad principle and at once bring in invented additions, through which evil spreads without limit. Yet Xerxes acted thoughtlessly when, on the advice of his magi, he burned or demolished all the temples of Greece, thinking it absurd that God, to whom all things should be free and open, should be shut in by walls and roofs. As if God couldn't, in a sense, come down to us so as to be near us, without either changing his place or binding us to earthly things, but rather using these as a kind of vehicle to lift us up to his own heavenly glory, which in its immensity fills all things and in its height is above the heavens.
6. How far the ministry is effective, and what belongs to the Spirit alone
There's a great dispute at present about how effective the ministry is. Some exaggerate its dignity beyond measure; others wrongly claim that what belongs to the Spirit of God is being handed to mortal men if we suppose that ministers and teachers reach the mind and heart, correcting the blindness of the one and the hardness of the other. This controversy needs to be put on its proper footing. The arguments on both sides are easily settled by attending carefully to two kinds of passage: those in which God, the author of preaching, joins his Spirit to it and then promises a fruitful result; and those in which God, separating himself from outward means, claims for himself alone both the beginning and the whole course of faith.
The office of the second Elijah, as Malachi declares, was to "turn the hearts of fathers to their children and the hearts of children to their fathers" (Mal. 4:6). Christ declares that he sent the apostles to bear fruit from his labours (John 15:16). What this fruit is, Peter briefly defines when he says that we have been born again of imperishable seed (1 Pet. 1:23). So Paul boasts that through the gospel he became the father of the Corinthians, who were the seal of his apostleship (1 Cor. 4:15; 9:2); and that his was not a ministry of the letter, which merely sounds in the ear, but that the effective working of the Spirit was given to him so that his teaching would not be in vain (2 Cor. 3:6). In the same sense he says elsewhere that his gospel came not only in word but in power (1 Thess. 1:5). He also affirms that the Galatians received the Spirit by hearing with faith (Gal. 3:2). In short, in several places he not only calls himself God's fellow worker but takes to himself the task of bestowing salvation (1 Cor. 3:9).
He certainly never said any of this to claim for himself one iota apart from God, as he briefly explains elsewhere: "We also thank God constantly for this, that when you received the word of God, which you heard from us, you accepted it not as the word of men but as what it really is, the word of God, which is at work in you believers" (1 Thess. 2:13). And again: "he who worked through Peter for his apostolic ministry to the circumcised worked also through me for mine to the Gentiles" (Gal. 2:8). That he grants ministers nothing more than this is clear from other passages: "So neither he who plants nor he who waters is anything, but only God who gives the growth" (1 Cor. 3:7). And again: "I worked harder than any of them, though it was not I, but the grace of God that is with me" (1 Cor. 15:10). We do need to keep these statements in view, since God, in claiming for himself the enlightening of the mind and the renewing of the heart, warns us that it is sacrilege for any human being to claim the least part of either. Yet everyone who listens teachably to the ministers God appoints will learn from the good results that God has good reason to be pleased with this way of teaching, and good reason for placing believers under this modest yoke.
7. The Church invisible and the Church visible
What judgment we ought to form about the visible Church that we can observe should now, I think, be clear enough from what has been said. I've noted that Scripture speaks of the Church in two ways.
Sometimes, when it speaks of the Church, it means the Church as it really is in God's sight: the Church into which no one is admitted except those who are children of God by the gift of adoption and true members of Christ by the sanctification of the Spirit. In this sense it includes not only the saints living on earth but all the elect who have lived since the beginning of the world.
Often, though, the name "Church" refers to the whole multitude of people scattered across the world who profess to worship one God and Christ; who are initiated into the faith by baptism; who, by sharing in the Lord's Supper, profess their unity in true doctrine and love; who agree in holding to the word of the Lord; and who keep the ministry Christ appointed for preaching it. In this Church there is a very large mixture of hypocrites, who have nothing of Christ but the name and outward appearance. There are ambitious, greedy, envious and slanderous people, and some of still more impure life, who are tolerated for a time, either because their guilt can't be legally proved or because the proper strictness of discipline isn't always kept.
So, just as we must believe the invisible Church, which is visible to God's eyes alone, we are also commanded to honour this Church, which is called the Church with reference to human beings, and to maintain communion with it.
8. God alone knows his own, yet he has given us marks
Since it mattered to us to be able to recognise this Church, the Lord has marked it out with certain signs, or tokens. It is, of course, God's special prerogative to know those who are his, as Paul says in the passage already quoted (2 Tim. 2:19). And no doubt this has been arranged as a check on human rashness, since daily experience reminds us how far his secret judgments surpass our understanding. Those who seemed utterly lost and had been entirely given up on are called back to life by his goodness, while those who seemed most secure often fall. As Augustine says, "With respect to God's secret predestination, there are very many sheep outside, and very many wolves inside" (Augustine, Homilies on John 45). For he knows, and has his mark on, people who know neither him nor themselves. And of those who openly wear his badge, his eyes alone see who are genuinely holy and will persevere to the end, which alone is the completion of salvation.
On the other hand, foreseeing that it was in some measure useful for us to know whom we should regard as his children, he has accommodated himself to our capacity in this matter. Since full certainty wasn't needed here, he has put in its place the judgment of charity, by which we acknowledge as members of the Church all who, by confession of faith, an orderly life and participation in the sacraments, join with us in acknowledging the same God and Christ. As for the body of the Church as a whole, knowing this to be more necessary for our salvation, he has made it known to us by surer marks.
9. The marks themselves: word and sacraments
From this the shape of the Church emerges and stands clearly before our eyes. Wherever we see the word of God purely preached and heard, and the sacraments administered according to Christ's institution, there we can be in no doubt that a church of God exists, since his promise cannot fail: "where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them" (Matt. 18:20).
To get a clear summary of the subject, we need to proceed step by step. The universal Church is the multitude gathered from all nations which, though scattered and far apart, agrees in the one truth of God's teaching and is bound together by a common religion. In this way it includes the individual churches set up in different towns and villages as human society requires, each of which rightly bears the name and authority of a church. It also includes individual people who, by their religious profession, are counted as belonging to such churches, even if they are in fact strangers to the Church, so long as they haven't been cut off by a public decision.
There is, however, a slight difference between the way we judge individuals and the way we judge churches. It may happen in practice that we must treat as brothers, and regard as believers, people we don't consider wholly worthy of the fellowship of the faithful, because the Church by common consent tolerates them and bears with them in the body of Christ. We don't endorse such people as members of the Church by our own vote, but we leave them the place they hold among God's people until they are lawfully removed from it. With regard to the body as a whole, we must judge differently. If it has the ministry of the word and honours the administration of the sacraments, it undoubtedly deserves to be counted as a church, because it is certain that these things do not exist without bearing fruit. In this way we both preserve the unity of the universal Church, which malicious spirits have always been eager to tear apart, and give due authority to the lawful assemblies set up as circumstances require.
10. Never forsake a church that bears these marks
We've said that the tokens by which the Church is recognised are the preaching of the word and the observance of the sacraments, for these can never exist anywhere without bearing fruit and prospering by God's blessing. I don't say that fruit appears immediately wherever the word is preached, but that wherever it's received and has a settled home, it always shows its power. However that may be, where the preaching of the gospel is reverently heard and the sacraments aren't neglected, there, for the time being, the face of the Church appears without deception or ambiguity. No one may with impunity spurn her authority, reject her warnings, resist her counsel or make light of her censures, much less desert her and break her unity (see chapter 2, sections 1 and 10, and chapter 8, section 12).
The Lord sets such value on the communion of his Church that he regards all who stubbornly cut themselves off from any Christian community in which the true ministry of his word and sacraments is kept as deserters of religion. He commends her authority so highly that he counts any violation of it as an attack on his own. For there's no small weight in the titles given to her: "the household of God," "a pillar and buttress of the truth" (1 Tim. 3:15). With these words Paul indicates that the Church is the faithful guardian of the truth, keeping it from perishing in the world, because God has been pleased to preserve the pure preaching of his word through her ministry, and to show himself to us as a Father in feeding us with spiritual food and providing everything that serves our salvation. No small praise is given to the Church, either, when she is said to have been chosen and set apart by Christ as his bride, "without spot or wrinkle or any such thing" (Eph. 5:27), and as "his body, the fullness of him who fills all in all" (Eph. 1:23).
It follows that desertion of the Church is a denial of God and Christ. All the more reason, then, to beware of so wicked a separation. Since by it we aim, as far as we can, at the destruction of God's truth, we deserve to be struck by the full thunderbolt of his anger. No crime can be imagined more monstrous than sacrilegiously and faithlessly to violate the sacred marriage that the only begotten Son of God has condescended to enter into with us.
11. Satan's twofold attack on the marks, and the need for caution
So let these marks be carefully impressed on our minds, and let's value them as the Lord does. There's nothing Satan works at harder than to destroy and erase one or both of them: at one time to wipe these marks out and so abolish the true and genuine distinguishing feature of the Church; at another, to bring them into contempt and so rush us into open revolt from the Church. It was by his schemes that for several centuries the pure preaching of the word disappeared, and now, with the same dishonest aim, he is working to overthrow the ministry, which Christ has so built into his Church that if it is removed the whole building must fall.
How dangerous, then, indeed how fatal, is the temptation even to consider separating ourselves from an assembly in which we see the signs and badges the Lord thought sufficient to mark out his Church! We see how much caution is needed on both sides. So that we aren't deceived by the name "church," every congregation that claims the name must be brought to this test as to a touchstone. If it holds to the order the Lord instituted in word and sacraments, there will be no deception: we may safely give it the honour due to a church. On the other hand, if it presents itself without word and sacraments, we must be just as careful to avoid being taken in as we were, in the first case, to avoid pride and presumption.
12. Disagreement on secondary matters is no ground for separation
When we say that the pure ministry of the word and the pure celebration of the sacraments are a sufficient pledge and guarantee that we may safely recognise a church in any community where both are found, we mean that we must never cast it off so long as these remain, even if it is otherwise riddled with faults. Indeed, even in the administration of word and sacraments, defects may creep in that ought not to drive us away from its communion.
Not all the articles of true doctrine are of the same kind. Some are so necessary to know that everyone must hold them as fixed and beyond question, as the very essentials of religion: for example, that God is one, that Christ is God and the Son of God, that our salvation depends on God's mercy, and the like. Others, which are disputed among the churches, don't destroy the unity of the faith. Why should it be a ground of division between churches if one, without any quarrelsomeness or obstinate dogmatism, holds that the soul flies to heaven on leaving the body, while another, without venturing to say anything definite about the place, holds it as certain that the soul lives with the Lord? The apostle's words are: "Let those of us who are mature think this way, and if in anything you think otherwise, God will reveal that also to you" (Phil. 3:15). Doesn't he show clearly enough that differences of opinion on matters that aren't absolutely necessary shouldn't be a cause of division among Christians?
The best thing, of course, is to be in complete agreement. But since there's no one who isn't wrapped in some cloud of ignorance, we must either have no church at all, or forgive mistakes in matters where people may be ignorant without harming the substance of religion or losing salvation. I have no wish here to defend even the smallest errors, as though I thought they should be encouraged by flattery or by turning a blind eye. What I'm saying is that we mustn't abandon a church over every minor disagreement, provided it keeps sound and unimpaired the teaching on which the safety of godliness rests, and keeps the use of the sacraments the Lord instituted. Meanwhile, if we try to correct what is wrong, we are doing our duty. Paul's words point this way: "If a revelation is made to another sitting there, let the first be silent" (1 Cor. 14:30). From this it is clear that every member of the Church, according to the measure of grace given, is charged with seeking the common good, provided it is done decently and in order. In other words, we must neither renounce the communion of the Church nor, while remaining in it, disturb its peace and its duly ordered discipline.
13. Moral failings in the Church: the error of the Cathari, and three parables
Our forbearance ought to stretch much further still in bearing with imperfections of life. Here the danger of falling is great, and Satan uses every trick to ensnare us. There have always been people who, filled with a false conviction of their own perfect holiness, as if they had already become some kind of airy spirits, spurn the company of anyone in whom they see something human still remaining. The Cathari and the Donatists of old were infatuated in this way, and so today are some of the Anabaptists, who like to be thought further advanced than everyone else.
Others go wrong here not so much from that mad pride as from ill-considered zeal. Seeing that among those to whom the gospel is preached, the fruit doesn't match the teaching, they promptly conclude that no church exists there. Their offence is certainly well grounded, and in this most unhappy age we give far too much cause for it. Our accursed sluggishness can't be excused, and the Lord will not leave it unpunished; indeed he's already beginning to chastise us sharply. Woe to us, then, whose loose and reckless wickedness wounds weak consciences! Still, the people I'm describing sin in their turn by not knowing where to set limits to their offence. Where the Lord requires mercy, they leave it out and give themselves over to excessive severity. Thinking there's no church where there isn't complete purity and integrity of life, they withdraw from a genuine church out of hatred of wickedness, imagining they are only avoiding the company of the ungodly.
They insist that the Church of God is holy. But so that they may also understand that it contains a mixture of good and bad, let them hear the parable from our Saviour's lips in which he compares the Church to a net that gathers fish of every kind, which aren't sorted until they're brought ashore. Let them hear it compared to a field sown with good seed, into which an enemy has slipped weeds, and which isn't cleared of them until the harvest is gathered into the barn. Let them hear, finally, that it is a threshing floor on which the gathered wheat lies hidden under the chaff until, cleaned by winnowing fan and sieve, it is at last stored in the granary. If the Lord declares that the Church will labour under this defect, burdened with many wicked people, until the day of judgment, it is futile to look for a church entirely free of blemish (Matt. 13).
14. The example of Corinth and Galatia
They protest that it's impossible to tolerate vice that stalks everywhere like a plague. What if the apostle's judgment applies here too? Among the Corinthians it wasn't a few who had gone astray; almost the whole body was infected. There wasn't one kind of sin only but a great many, and they weren't trivial lapses but in some cases appalling crimes. There was corruption not only of morals but of doctrine. What did the holy apostle do, the instrument of the heavenly Spirit, by whose testimony the Church stands or falls? Does he separate from them? Does he expel them from Christ's kingdom? Does he strike them with the thunderbolt of a final anathema? He does none of these things. On the contrary, he acknowledges and proclaims them a church of Christ and a fellowship of saints.
If the Church remains among the Corinthians, where jealousies, factions and quarrels rage; where disputes, lawsuits and greed are rife; where a crime that even pagans would abhor is openly approved; where the name of Paul, whom they ought to have honoured as a father, is insolently attacked; where some scoff at the resurrection of the dead, though with it the whole gospel falls; where God's gifts serve ambition rather than love; where much is done neither decently nor in order (1 Cor. 1:11; 3:3; 5:1; 6:7; 9:1; 15:12): if the Church still remains there, simply because the ministry of word and sacrament isn't rejected, who will dare deny the name of church to those who can't be charged with a tenth of these crimes? And how, I ask, would those who are so harsh towards present-day churches have treated the Galatians, who had all but abandoned the gospel (Gal. 1:6)? Yet the same apostle found churches among them.
15. Eating with the wicked: each must examine himself
They also object that Paul sharply rebukes the Corinthians for tolerating a notorious offender in their fellowship, and then lays down a general rule forbidding us even to eat with someone of immoral life (1 Cor. 5:11-12). "If it's not lawful to eat ordinary bread with such a person," they cry, "how can it be lawful to eat the Lord's bread?"
I admit it's a great disgrace if dogs and swine are given a place among God's children, and much more so if the sacred body of Christ is prostituted to them. And indeed, when churches are well ordered, they won't harbour the wicked in their midst, nor admit worthy and unworthy alike to that holy feast. But because pastors aren't always diligently watchful, and are sometimes more lenient than they should be, or are prevented from acting as strictly as they'd like, the result is that even the openly wicked aren't always excluded from the fellowship of the saints. I admit this is a fault, and I've no wish to make light of it, seeing that Paul sharply rebukes it in the Corinthians.
But even if the Church fails in its duty, it doesn't follow that every private individual may decide the question of separation for himself. I don't deny that a godly person ought to withdraw from all private dealings with the wicked and not entangle himself with them by any voluntary tie. But it's one thing to avoid the company of the wicked, and quite another to renounce the communion of the Church out of hatred of them. Those who think it sacrilege to share the Lord's bread with the wicked are in this respect stricter than Paul. When he urges us to pure and holy communion, he doesn't require us to examine others, or each of us to examine the whole church, but each to examine himself (1 Cor. 11:28-29). If it were unlawful to take communion alongside the unworthy, Paul would surely have told us to make sure there was no one in the whole body whose impurity could defile us. As it is, by requiring only that each examine himself, he shows that it does us no harm if some unworthy people come forward with us. That's the point of what he adds: "anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment on himself" (1 Cor. 11:29). He says "on himself," not on others. And rightly so, because the right to admit or exclude shouldn't be left to the decision of individuals. Authority in this matter, which can't be exercised without due order (as I'll show more fully later), belongs to the whole church. It would therefore be unjust to hold any private person polluted by the unworthiness of someone else, whom he neither can nor should keep from communion.
16. The pride behind schism, and Augustine's counsel
Even good people are sometimes carried away by this ill-considered zeal for righteousness, though we'll find that such excessive harshness springs more from pride and a false idea of holiness than from genuine holiness and true zeal for it. So those who are most forward in stirring up desertion from the Church, its ringleaders as it were, usually have no other motive than to display their own superiority by looking down on everyone else.
Augustine, then, speaks well and wisely: "Godly reason and the method of church discipline ought above all to have regard to the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace, which the apostle commands us to keep by bearing with one another; for if we fail to keep it, the medicine of punishment is not only superfluous but harmful, and so ceases to be medicine at all. Those wicked sons who, not out of hatred of other people's sins but out of zeal for their own quarrels, try to draw away altogether, or at least to divide, weak brothers ensnared by the glamour of their name: swollen with pride, crammed with insolence, treacherously slanderous and turbulently seditious, they put on the cloak of rigorous severity so as not to seem lacking in the light of truth, and they twist into sacrilegious schism and pretexts for cutting people off what Holy Scripture commands (with due regard for sincere love and the unity of peace) for correcting a brother's faults by a moderate cure" (Augustine, Against the Letter of Parmenian 3.1). His advice to the godly and peaceable is to correct with mercy what they can, and to bear patiently what they can't, mourning and grieving over it in love until God either reforms or corrects it, or at the harvest uproots the weeds and scatters the chaff (ibid. 3.2).
Let all the godly take care to arm themselves with these weapons, so that, while they think themselves vigorous and ardent defenders of righteousness, they don't desert the kingdom of heaven, which is the only kingdom of righteousness. Since God has willed that the communion of his Church be maintained in this outward society, anyone who breaks its bond out of hatred of the ungodly sets off down a slope on which he is in great danger of cutting himself off from the communion of saints. Let them reflect that in a large body there are many who may escape their notice and yet are truly righteous and innocent in the Lord's sight. Let them reflect that of those who seem diseased, many are far from taking pleasure in their faults or flattering themselves about them, and, roused again and again by a serious fear of the Lord, are striving after greater integrity. Let them reflect that they have no right to pass judgment on someone for a single act, since the holiest sometimes fall most grievously. Let them reflect that in the ministry of the word and the sharing of the sacraments, the power to gather the Church is too great to be robbed of all its effect by the faults of a few ungodly people. Lastly, let them reflect that in assessing the Church, God's judgment carries more weight than ours.
17. The holiness of the Church: real, but still in progress
Since they also argue that the Church is called holy for good reason, we need to consider what that holiness consists in, lest by refusing to recognise any church that isn't completely perfect, we leave no church at all. It is true, as Paul says, that "Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her, that he might sanctify her, having cleansed her by the washing of water with the word, so that he might present the church to himself in splendour, without spot or wrinkle or any such thing, that she might be holy and without blemish" (Eph. 5:25-27). Yet it is equally true that the Lord is daily smoothing out her wrinkles and wiping away her spots. It follows that her holiness isn't yet complete. This, then, is the holiness of the Church: it makes progress every day but isn't yet perfect; it advances daily but hasn't yet reached the goal, as will be explained more fully elsewhere.
So when the prophets foretell, "Jerusalem shall be holy, and strangers shall never again pass through it," and, "it shall be called the Way of Holiness; the unclean shall not pass over it" (Joel 3:17; Isa. 35:8), we shouldn't take it to mean that no blemish remains in the members of the Church, but only that they aspire with their whole heart to holiness and perfect purity, and that the purity they haven't yet fully attained is therefore credited to them by God's kindness.
And although the signs of such holiness among people are all too rare, we must understand that since the world began the Lord has never been without his Church, and never will be until the final consummation of all things. For although at the very outset the whole human race was corrupted and defiled by Adam's sin, yet from this polluted mass he always sanctifies some vessels for honour, so that no age is left without experience of his mercy. He has declared this with sure promises, such as these: "I have made a covenant with my chosen one; I have sworn to David my servant: 'I will establish your offspring for ever, and build your throne for all generations'" (Ps. 89:3-4). "The Lord has chosen Zion; he has desired it for his dwelling place: 'This is my resting place for ever; here I will dwell'" (Ps. 132:13-14). "Thus says the Lord, who gives the sun for light by day and the fixed order of the moon and the stars for light by night, who stirs up the sea so that its waves roar, the Lord of hosts is his name: 'If this fixed order departs from before me, declares the Lord, then shall the offspring of Israel cease from being a nation before me for ever'" (Jer. 31:35-36).
18. The prophets did not separate from a corrupt Israel
Christ himself, his apostles and nearly all the prophets have given us examples on this point. Isaiah, Jeremiah, Joel, Habakkuk and others describe in fearful terms the diseases of the church at Jerusalem. Corruption had spread so far among the people, the rulers and the priests that Isaiah doesn't hesitate to compare Jerusalem to Sodom and Gomorrah (Isa. 1:10). Religion was partly despised, partly adulterated, and as for morals, we read everywhere of theft, robbery, treachery, murder and similar crimes. Yet the prophets didn't for that reason form new churches for themselves or set up new altars for separate sacrifices. Whatever their fellow countrymen were like, they reflected that the Lord had entrusted his word to that people and instituted the ceremonies by which he was then worshipped, and so they lifted up pure hands to him even in the company of the ungodly. Certainly, if they had thought they were contracting any defilement by doing so, they would have died a hundred deaths rather than let themselves be dragged there. Nothing kept them from separating except the desire to preserve unity. If the holy prophets didn't feel bound to withdraw from the Church because of the many and grievous crimes, not of one or two individuals but of almost the whole people, we claim far too much for ourselves if we presume to withdraw at once from the communion of the Church because not everyone's life measures up to our judgment, or even to the Christian profession.
19. Christ and the apostles did the same; the two points to hold
And what sort of age was that of Christ and the apostles? Yet neither the desperate ungodliness of the Pharisees nor the loose and dissolute morals that prevailed everywhere kept them from sharing the same sacred rites with the people and meeting in one common temple for the public exercises of religion. Why? Simply because they knew that those who took part in these rites with a pure conscience were in no way defiled by the company of the wicked. If anyone is little moved by prophets and apostles, let him at least defer to the authority of Christ.
Cyprian, then, puts it well: "Even though weeds or unclean vessels are seen in the Church, that is no reason for us to withdraw from the Church. We must only labour to be wheat ourselves; we must make every effort, as far as we can, to be vessels of gold or silver. But to break the earthen vessels belongs to the Lord alone, to whom a rod of iron has been given. Let no one claim for himself what belongs to the Son alone, and think himself able to winnow the threshing floor, clear away the chaff and separate out all the weeds by human judgment. What depraved zeal thus takes upon itself is proud obstinacy and sacrilegious presumption" (Cyprian, Letters 3.5).
Let these two points, then, be regarded as settled. First, there is no excuse for anyone who voluntarily abandons the outward communion of a church in which the word of God is preached and the sacraments are administered. Second, whatever the faults of a few or of many, nothing prevents us from duly professing our faith there in the ordinances God has instituted, because a godly conscience isn't harmed by the unworthiness of anyone else, whether pastor or private person, and sacred rites are no less pure and wholesome to a holy and upright person for being handled at the same time by the impure.
20. Forgiveness of sins: our entry into the Church
Their peevishness and pride go further still. Refusing to recognise any church that isn't free of the slightest blemish, they take offence at sound teachers for urging believers to make progress, and so teaching them to groan under the burden of sin their whole lives long and to flee to God for pardon. They claim that this draws believers away from perfection. I grant that we mustn't work feebly or half-heartedly at urging perfection, much less give up urging it. But I hold that it is a device of the devil to fill our minds with the confident belief that we've already attained it while we're still on the road.
That's why, in the Creed, the forgiveness of sins is fittingly placed right after the Church: no one obtains forgiveness except those who are citizens and members of the household of the Church, as we read in the prophet: "the people who dwell there will be forgiven their iniquity" (Isa. 33:24). The first place, then, should be given to the building of the heavenly Jerusalem, in which God is then pleased to wipe away the guilt of all who take refuge there. I say the Church must be built first, not because there can be any church without forgiveness of sins, but because the Lord has promised his mercy only within the communion of saints.
Our first entry into the Church and the kingdom of God, then, is by the forgiveness of sins, without which we have no covenant or union with God. For so he speaks through the prophet: "I will make for them a covenant on that day with the beasts of the field, the birds of the heavens, and the creeping things of the ground. And I will abolish the bow, the sword, and war from the land, and I will make you lie down in safety. And I will betroth you to me for ever. I will betroth you to me in righteousness and in justice, in steadfast love and in mercy" (Hos. 2:18-19). We see how the Lord reconciles us to himself by his mercy. So too in another passage, where he foretells that the people he had scattered in his anger will be gathered again: "I will cleanse them from all the guilt of their sin against me" (Jer. 33:8). That's why we are brought into the fellowship of the Church through the sign of washing: to teach us that we have no entrance into God's family unless our impurities have first been washed away by his goodness.
21. Forgiveness keeps us in the Church as well as bringing us in
Nor is it only once, at the outset, that the Lord chooses us and admits us into the Church by forgiving our sins; by the same means he also keeps and protects us there. What good would it do us to receive a pardon that was afterwards of no further use? All the godly can testify that the Lord's mercy would be empty and deceptive if it were granted only once, for there's no one who isn't aware, throughout his whole life, of many weaknesses that need God's mercy. And it's certainly not without reason that the Lord promises this gift especially to his own household, nor in vain that he commands the same message of reconciliation to be delivered to them daily. Since we carry the remnants of sin about with us all our lives, we couldn't remain in the Church for a single moment unless we were sustained by God's unbroken grace in forgiving our sins. On the other hand, the Lord has called his people to eternal salvation, and so they should consider that pardon for their sins is always ready for them. Let us hold firmly, then, that if we've been admitted and grafted into the body of the Church, the forgiveness of sins has been given us and is given us daily, by God's generosity, through the mediation of Christ's merits and the sanctifying work of the Spirit.
22. The keys given to the Church for this purpose
It is to impart this blessing to us that the keys have been given to the Church (Matt. 16:19; 18:18). When Christ commissioned the apostles and gave them the power of forgiving sins, he didn't intend only that they should loose the sins of those who would be converted from ungodliness to faith in Christ, and do it once for all; he intended, besides, that they should carry out this office continually among believers. Paul teaches this when he says that the message of reconciliation has been entrusted to the ministers of the Church, so that they may again and again, in Christ's name, urge the people to be reconciled to God (2 Cor. 5:20). So, in the communion of saints, our sins are continually forgiven through the ministry of the Church, when presbyters or bishops, to whom this office has been entrusted, strengthen godly consciences in the hope of pardon and forgiveness by the promises of the gospel, both in public and in private, as the case requires. For many, because of their weakness, need individual reassurance, and Paul declares that he testified to the grace of Christ not only in the public assembly but from house to house, reminding each person individually of the teaching of salvation (Acts 20:20-21).
Three things are to be noted here. First, whatever holiness God's children have, it is always on this condition: as long as they live in a mortal body, they cannot stand before God without the forgiveness of sins. Second, this benefit belongs so peculiarly to the Church that we can't enjoy it unless we remain in her communion. Third, it is dispensed to us by the Church's ministers and pastors, whether in the preaching of the gospel or in the administration of the sacraments, and it is here above all that the power of the keys, which the Lord has given to the company of the faithful, is displayed. So let each of us count it our duty to seek forgiveness of sins only where the Lord has placed it. Of the public reconciliation that belongs to discipline I'll speak in its proper place.
23. The Novatian error revived by some Anabaptists, refuted from the Lord's Prayer
But since those frenzied spirits I've mentioned try to rob the Church of this, her only anchor of salvation, consciences need to be more firmly fortified against so deadly an opinion. In ancient times the Novatians troubled the churches with this teaching, and in our own day some of the Anabaptists, not unlike the Novatians, have fallen into the same delirious dreams. They claim that in baptism God's people are reborn to a pure and angelic life, untouched by any fleshly defilement. If anyone sins after baptism, they leave him nothing but God's unrelenting judgment. In short, they offer no hope of pardon to a sinner who has fallen after receiving grace, because they admit no forgiveness of sins except that by which we are first regenerated.
No falsehood is more clearly refuted by Scripture. Yet since these people manage to deceive others (just as Novatus had a great many followers in his day), let's briefly show how madly they rave, to their own ruin and that of others.
In the first place, since by the Lord's command the saints repeat this prayer every day, "Forgive us our debts" (Matt. 6:12), they confess that they are debtors. Nor do they ask in vain, for the Lord has told them to ask only for what he intends to give. Indeed, while he has declared that the whole prayer will be heard by his Father, he has sealed this particular absolution with a special promise (Matt. 6:14). What more could we want? The Lord requires of his saints a confession of sins throughout their lives, without ceasing, and promises pardon. How presumptuous, then, to declare them exempt from sin, or, when they've stumbled, to shut them out from grace altogether! Again, whom does he command us to forgive seventy times seven times? Isn't it our brothers (Matt. 18:22)? And why has he commanded it, if not so that we may imitate his own clemency? He pardons, then, not once or twice only, but as often as, aware of our faults, we are struck with alarm and call on him with sighs.
24. Examples from the patriarchs and David
To begin, as it were, at the very beginning of the Church: the patriarchs had been circumcised, admitted into the covenant, and no doubt taught righteousness and integrity by their father's care, when they conspired to murder their brother. It was a crime the most hardened robbers would have shrunk from. In the end, softened by Judah's protests, they sold him instead, which was itself an intolerable cruelty. Simeon and Levi took a wicked revenge on the men of Shechem, one their own father condemned. Reuben, with shameful lust, defiled his father's bed. Judah, seeking a prostitute, sinned against the law of nature with his own daughter-in-law (Gen. 37:18, 28; 34:25; 35:22; 38:16). Yet far from being struck out of the chosen people, they were raised up to be its heads.
And what of David? Seated on the throne of justice, how wickedly he made way for blind lust by shedding innocent blood! He had already been regenerated, and as one of the regenerate had received the Lord's special approval. Yet he committed a crime that would have horrified even the pagans, and still he obtained pardon (2 Sam. 11:4, 15; 12:13).
And not to dwell on particular examples, all the promises of divine mercy found in the Law and the Prophets are so many proofs that the Lord is ready to forgive his people's offences. Why else does Moses promise a time to come when the people who had fallen into rebellion would return to the Lord? "Then the Lord your God will restore your fortunes and have mercy on you, and he will gather you again from all the peoples where the Lord your God has scattered you" (Deut. 30:3).
25. The prophets' promises, Solomon's prayer, and the daily sacrifice
But I don't want to start a list that could never be finished. The prophetic books are full of similar promises, offering mercy to a people covered with countless sins. What crime is worse than rebellion? It is called a divorce between God and his Church, and yet even this is overcome by his goodness. "If a man divorces his wife and she goes from him and becomes another man's wife, will he return to her? Would not that land be greatly polluted? You have played the whore with many lovers; and would you return to me? declares the Lord." "Return, faithless Israel, declares the Lord. I will not look on you in anger, for I am merciful, declares the Lord; I will not be angry for ever" (Jer. 3:1, 12). And surely he could feel no differently who declares, "I have no pleasure in the death of anyone who dies... so turn, and live" (Ezek. 18:23, 32).
So when Solomon dedicated the temple, one of the purposes for which it was set apart was that prayers offered for the pardon of sins might be heard there: "If they sin against you (for there is no one who does not sin), and you are angry with them and give them to an enemy, so that they are carried away captive to the land of the enemy, far off or near, yet if they turn their heart in the land to which they have been carried captive, and repent and plead with you in the land of their captors, saying, 'We have sinned and have acted perversely and wickedly,' if they repent with all their heart and with all their soul in the land of their enemies who carried them captive, and pray to you towards their land, which you gave to their fathers, the city that you have chosen, and the house that I have built for your name, then hear in heaven your dwelling place their prayer and their plea, and maintain their cause and forgive your people who have sinned against you, and all their transgressions that they have committed against you" (1 Kings 8:46-50). Nor was it for nothing that God appointed in the Law a daily sacrifice for sins. Had he not foreseen that his people would continually suffer from the disease of sin, he would never have provided these remedies.
26. Christ's coming did not reduce God's mercy but enlarged it
Did the coming of Christ, in which the fullness of grace was revealed, take this privilege of praying for pardon away from believers? If they sinned against the Lord, were they to obtain no mercy at all? What would that be but to say that Christ came for the destruction of his people rather than their salvation, if the divine forbearance in pardoning sin, constantly available to the saints under the Old Testament, is now declared to have been withdrawn? But if we believe the Scriptures when they plainly proclaim that only in Christ have the grace and loving-kindness of the Lord fully appeared, the riches of his mercy been poured out, and reconciliation between God and humanity been accomplished (Titus 2:11; 3:4; 2 Tim. 1:9-10), let us not doubt that our heavenly Father's clemency, far from being cut off or reduced, now overflows more abundantly than ever.
Nor is evidence lacking. Peter had heard our Saviour declare that whoever would not confess him before men would be denied before the angels of God (Mark 8:38); yet he denied him three times in one night, and with curses, and still he isn't refused pardon. Those among the Thessalonians who were living idle, disorderly lives are rebuked, but still invited to repentance (2 Thess. 3:6). Not even Simon Magus is driven to despair; rather he is told to hope, since Peter urges him to turn to prayer (Acts 8:22).
27. Whole churches restored, and the order of the Creed
What are we to say of the fact that whole churches were at times caught up in the grossest sins, and yet Paul, instead of giving them up to destruction, mercifully rescued them? The defection of the Galatians was no small fault; the Corinthians were even less excusable, since the sins among them were more numerous and no less serious. Yet neither church is shut out from the Lord's mercy. Indeed, the very people who had sinned more than others in impurity and sexual immorality are expressly invited to repent (2 Cor. 12:21). The Lord's covenant stands, and will always stand, inviolable: the covenant he solemnly made with Christ, the true Solomon, and with his members, in these words: "If his children forsake my law and do not walk according to my rules, if they violate my statutes and do not keep my commandments, then I will punish their transgression with the rod and their iniquity with stripes, but I will not remove from him my steadfast love" (Ps. 89:30-33). In short, the very order of the Creed reminds us that the forgiveness of sins always resides in the Church of Christ, since the forgiveness of sins is added right after the Church has, so to speak, been established.
28. Sins committed knowingly are not beyond pardon
Some who are a little more discerning, seeing that the teaching of Novatus is so clearly refuted by Scripture, don't make every sin unpardonable, but only deliberate transgression of the Law, into which a person falls knowingly and willingly. Those who speak this way allow pardon only for sins committed in ignorance. But since the Lord in the Law ordered some sacrifices to be offered to atone for the deliberate sins of believers, and others to cover sins of ignorance (Lev. 4), how perverse it is to deny any atonement for deliberate sin! Nothing seems plainer to me than that the one sacrifice of Christ avails to forgive the deliberate sins of believers, as the Lord attested by those fleshly sacrifices, which served as its emblems.
Besides, how can David, so well instructed in the Law, be excused on the grounds of ignorance? Did David, who was punishing murder and adultery in others every day, not know how grave those crimes were? Did the patriarchs think fratricide lawful? Had the Corinthians made so little progress as to imagine that God was pleased with sensuality, impurity, sexual immorality, hatred and strife? Was Peter, after being so carefully warned, ignorant of how serious it was to deny his Master with an oath? Let us not, then, out of malice shut the door on God's mercy when he has displayed it so kindly.
29. The ancient severity of public penance
I'm well aware that ancient writers took the sins forgiven to believers every day to mean the lighter faults that creep in through the weakness of the flesh, and that they thought the formal penance then required for graver crimes could no more be repeated than baptism. This view shouldn't be read as though they wanted to drive into despair those who had fallen after their first repentance, or to make light of those lesser faults as if they counted for nothing before God. They knew that the saints often stumble through unbelief, that careless oaths sometimes escape them, that they sometimes boil over with anger and even break out into open abuse, and that they struggle with other evils that are no small offence to the Lord. They called these faults "lighter" only to distinguish them from public crimes, which came under the Church's notice and caused great scandal.
The great difficulty they made over pardoning those who had committed something that called for church censure wasn't because they thought it hard to obtain pardon from the Lord. Rather, by this severity they meant to deter others from rushing headlong into crimes that, by their seriousness, would cut them off from the communion of the Church. Still, the word of the Lord, which ought to be our only rule here, certainly prescribes greater moderation, since it teaches that the rigour of discipline mustn't be pressed so far as to overwhelm with sorrow the very person whose good it is especially meant to serve (2 Cor. 2:7), as I've already discussed at greater length.
Chapter 2
A Comparison Between the False Church and the True
1. Where falsehood rules the citadel of religion, the Church dies
I've explained how much weight the ministry of word and sacraments should carry with us, and how far our reverence for it should go, as the permanent mark by which the Church is recognised. We've seen, first, that wherever it exists whole and unimpaired, no faults of conduct and no defects should stop us from calling that body a church; and second, that minor errors in this ministry shouldn't make us regard it as unlawful. We've also seen that the errors deserving such pardon are those that don't damage the fundamental doctrine of religion or suppress the articles on which all believers should agree, and, with regard to the sacraments, defects that neither destroy nor impair the lawful institution of their Author.
But as soon as falsehood has broken into the citadel of religion, as soon as the sum of necessary doctrine is overturned and the use of the sacraments destroyed, the death of the Church certainly follows, just as a person's life ends when the throat is cut or the heart mortally wounded. Paul's words show this clearly when he says that the Church is "built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Christ Jesus himself being the cornerstone" (Eph. 2:20). If the Church is founded on the teaching of the apostles and prophets, which tells believers to place their salvation in Christ alone, how can the Church go on standing once that teaching is destroyed? The Church must fall whenever the sum of religion, which alone can hold it up, has given way. Again, if the true Church is "a pillar and buttress of the truth" (1 Tim. 3:15), there is certainly no Church where lies and falsehood have seized control.
2. The state of things under the Papacy, and the appeal to succession
Since this is how matters stand under the Papacy, we can see how much of the Church survives there. In place of the ministry of the word, a perverse government made up of lies holds sway, partly extinguishing, partly smothering the pure light. In place of the Lord's Supper the foulest sacrilege has come in. The worship of God is disfigured by a whole mass of intolerable superstitions. Doctrine, without which Christianity cannot exist, is entirely buried and thrown out, and the public assemblies are schools of idolatry and ungodliness. So in refusing to take part in such deadly wickedness, we run no risk of being cut off from the Church of Christ. The communion of the Church wasn't instituted as a chain to bind us to idolatry, ungodliness, ignorance of God and other evils, but to keep us in the fear of God and obedience to the truth.
They do boast loudly of their Church, of course, as if there were no other in the world. Then, as though that settled the matter, they declare that all who withdraw from obedience to the Church as they portray it are schismatics, and all who dare to whisper against its teaching are heretics. But what arguments do they offer to prove they possess the true Church? They appeal to ancient records from Italy, France and Spain, claiming descent from those holy men who founded and raised up churches by sound teaching, confirmed that teaching and built the Church with their blood. They claim that the Church, consecrated in this way by spiritual gifts and the blood of martyrs, was preserved from ruin by an unbroken succession of bishops. And they make much of the importance that Irenaeus, Tertullian, Origen, Augustine and others attached to that succession.
Anyone willing to consider the matter with me for a moment will see without difficulty how flimsy, indeed how plainly ridiculous, these claims are. I'd urge our opponents to pay serious attention too, if I had any hope of doing them good by teaching them. But since they've abandoned all regard for the truth and aim only at pursuing their own ends by any means they can, I'll make just a few observations to help good people and lovers of truth to free themselves from their quibbles.
First, I ask them why they don't cite Africa, Egypt and all Asia. The answer is that in all those regions the sacred succession, on which they rest their boast of continuous churches, was broken. So they fall back on the claim that they have the true Church because, ever since it began, it has never lacked bishops, who succeeded one another in an unbroken line. But what if I set Greece before them? I ask them again: why do they say the Church perished among the Greeks, where there was never any break in the succession of bishops, the very succession they hold to be the sole guardian and preserver of the Church? They call the Greeks schismatics. Why? Because by breaking away from the Apostolic See they forfeited their privilege. Really? Don't those who break away from Christ deserve to forfeit it far more? It follows, then, that the plea of succession is empty unless later generations keep the truth of Christ that their fathers handed down to them, safe and uncorrupted, and continue in it.
3. The Jews made the same boast; succession without faithfulness is worthless
The plea Rome makes today, then, is exactly the one the Jews seem to have made when the Lord's prophets charged them with blindness, ungodliness and idolatry. Just as the Jews proudly boasted of their temple, ceremonies and priesthood, by which they confidently thought the Church should be measured, so Rome offers us, in place of the Church, certain outward masks, which are often quite unconnected with the Church and without which the Church can perfectly well exist. We need no other argument to refute them than the one Jeremiah used against the foolish confidence of the Jews: "Do not trust in these deceptive words: 'This is the temple of the Lord, the temple of the Lord, the temple of the Lord'" (Jer. 7:4).
The Lord recognises nothing as his own except where his word is heard and faithfully kept. So although the glory of God was enthroned in the sanctuary between the cherubim (Ezek. 10:4), and he had promised to make his settled dwelling there, yet when the priests corrupted his worship with debased superstitions, he moved elsewhere and left the place bereft of holiness. If that temple, which seemed consecrated as God's permanent home, could be abandoned by him and become profane, Rome has no grounds for claiming that God is so bound to persons and places, and so tied to outward observances, that he must stay with those who have only the name and appearance of a church.
This is the very question Paul discusses in Romans 9 to 11. Weak consciences were badly shaken when those who seemed to be God's people not only rejected but even persecuted the teaching of the gospel. So after setting out his doctrine, Paul removes this difficulty by denying that those Jews, enemies of the truth, were the Church, even though they lacked nothing that might otherwise be wanted for the outward form of the Church. His reason for denying it is that they did not embrace Christ. In Galatians, comparing Ishmael with Isaac, he says still more plainly that many hold a place in the Church to whom the inheritance doesn't belong, because they are not the children of the free woman. From this he goes on to contrast the two Jerusalems: just as the Law was given on Mount Sinai but the gospel came forth from Jerusalem, so many who were born and raised in slavery confidently boast that they are children of God and of the Church, and, degenerate as they are, proudly look down on God's true children (Gal. 4:22-31). When we hear, likewise, that it was once declared from heaven, "Cast out the slave woman and her son," let us rely on that unbreakable decree and boldly despise their empty boasts. If they pride themselves on outward profession, Ishmael was circumcised too. If they rest on antiquity, he was the firstborn. Yet we see that he was rejected. If you ask why, Paul gives the reason: only those born of the pure and lawful seed of doctrine are counted as children (Rom. 9:6-8).
On this ground God declares that he wasn't bound to ungodly priests, even though he had made a covenant with their father Levi to be his messenger, or interpreter (Mal. 2:4). In fact he turns back on them the false boast they used to throw at the prophets, that the dignity of the priesthood deserved special honour. He readily grants it, and argues with them on the ground that he is ready to keep the covenant, whereas they, by failing to keep it on their side, deserve to be rejected. Here, then, is what succession is worth when it isn't joined to imitation and a matching life: as soon as later generations are shown to have abandoned their origins, they lose all their honour. Unless, of course, we're prepared to say that because Caiaphas succeeded many godly priests (indeed, the line from Aaron to him was unbroken), that accursed council deserved the name of Church! Even in earthly governments no one would tolerate calling the tyranny of Caligula, Nero, Elagabalus and the like the true state of the commonwealth, simply because they followed men like Brutus, Scipio and Camillus. In the government of the Church above all, nothing is more absurd than to ignore doctrine and locate succession in persons.
Nothing, in fact, was further from the minds of the holy teachers they wrongly thrust at us than to maintain that churches exist by hereditary right wherever bishop has followed bishop. Rather, since it was undisputed in their day that no change had been made in doctrine from the beginning, they took it as a sufficient refutation of all the new errors that these contradicted the teaching held constantly and with one consent from the apostles onward. So our opponents have no further grounds for making a show of the name "Church," which we hold in due reverence. When it comes to definition, they're not merely, as the saying goes, in hot water; they're stuck in their own mire, because they put a vile prostitute in place of the holy bride of Christ.
So that this substitution doesn't deceive us, let's note, among other warnings, this one from Augustine. Speaking of the Church he says: "Sometimes she herself is obscured and, as it were, clouded over by a multitude of offences; sometimes, in a time of calm, she appears quiet and free; sometimes she is overwhelmed and tossed by the waves of tribulation and trial" (Augustine, Letter to Vincentius 48). As examples he mentions that the strongest pillars of the Church often bravely endured exile for the faith, or lay hidden throughout the world.
4. Christ's test: his sheep hear his voice
This is how Rome assails us today, frightening the unwary with the name of Church while being the deadly enemies of Christ. So although they display a temple, a priesthood and other such masks, the empty glitter with which they dazzle simple eyes shouldn't move us in the least to admit that there is a church where the word of God is absent. The Lord gave us an unfailing test when he said, "Everyone who is of the truth listens to my voice" (John 18:37). And again: "I am the good shepherd. I know my own and my own know me." "My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me." A little earlier he had said that when the shepherd "has brought out all his own, he goes before them, and the sheep follow him, for they know his voice. A stranger they will not follow, but they will flee from him, for they do not know the voice of strangers" (John 10:14, 27, 4-5).
Why, then, do we of our own accord make such a foolish judgment about the Church, when Christ has marked it out by a sign in which there is nothing ambiguous at all: a sign seen everywhere, whose presence infallibly shows that the Church is there, and whose absence shows the absence of everything that properly bears the name? Paul declares that the Church is founded not on human judgments or on the priesthood but on the teaching of the apostles and prophets (Eph. 2:20). Indeed, Jerusalem is to be told apart from Babylon, and the Church of Christ from a conspiracy of Satan, by the very test our Saviour applied: "Whoever is of God hears the words of God. The reason why you do not hear them is that you are not of God" (John 8:47). In short, since the Church is Christ's kingdom, and he reigns only by his word, can there be any doubt that it's a lie to present Christ's kingdom without his sceptre, that is, without his holy word?
5. The charge of heresy and schism answered
They accuse us of heresy and schism because we preach a different doctrine, don't submit to their laws, and meet separately from them for prayer, baptism, the administration of the Supper and other sacred rites. It's a very serious accusation, but it doesn't need a long and laboured defence.
The names "heretic" and "schismatic" are applied to those who destroy the Church's communion by separating from it. That communion is held together by two bonds: agreement in sound doctrine and brotherly love. So Augustine distinguishes heretics from schismatics thus: heretics corrupt the purity of the faith with false teachings, while schismatics sometimes break the bond of fellowship even while holding the same faith (Augustine, Questions on the Gospels). But the thing to notice is that this bond of love depends so completely on unity of faith that it has in it its beginning, its end and, in short, its only rule. Let's remember, then, that whenever church unity is commended to us, what is required is that, as our minds agree in Christ, our wills should also be joined in mutual goodwill in Christ. That's why Paul, in urging unity on us, takes as his foundation that there is "one Lord, one faith, one baptism" (Eph. 4:5). And when he tells us to be "of the same mind... in full accord," he immediately adds, "Have this mind among yourselves, which is yours in Christ Jesus" (Phil. 2:2, 5), indicating that where the word of the Lord is absent, there is no union of believers but a faction of the ungodly.
6. Cyprian's witness, and why we left
Cyprian too, following Paul, traces the source of the Church's concord to the one episcopate of Christ, and then adds: "There is one Church, which by its fruitfulness spreads ever more widely into a multitude, just as there are many rays of the sun but one light, many branches of a tree but one trunk founded on its clinging root. When many streams flow from one spring, though they seem to spread into a multitude from the abundance of the supply, the unity remains at the source. Pluck a ray from the body of the sun, and its unity allows no division. Break a branch from the tree, and the broken branch cannot sprout. Cut a stream off from its spring, and it dries up. So too the Church, flooded with the Lord's light, spreads its rays across the whole world, yet it is one light that is shed everywhere" (Cyprian, On the Unity of the Church). Words couldn't express more elegantly the inseparable bond that all Christ's members have with one another. We see how constantly he calls us back to the head. So he declares that heresies and schisms arise because people don't return to the source of truth, don't seek the head, and don't keep the teaching of the heavenly Master.
Let them go on shouting, then, that we're heretics for having withdrawn from their Church, when the only cause of our estrangement is that they can't tolerate a pure profession of the truth. I say nothing of the fact that they drove us out with anathemas and curses. That fact alone is more than enough to excuse us, unless they also want to make schismatics of the apostles, with whom we share a common cause. Christ, I say, warned his apostles, "They will put you out of the synagogues" (John 16:2), and the synagogues he meant were then regarded as lawful churches. Since it is certain that we were cast out, and we are ready to show that it was done for Christ's name, the cause should be looked into before any verdict is given for us or against us. I'm willing, though, to leave that to them if they like. For me it is enough that we had to withdraw from them in order to draw near to Christ.
7. The parallel with ancient Israel
The standing we should give to all the churches that have fallen under the tyranny of the Roman idol will be clearer if we compare them with the ancient Church of Israel as the prophets describe it. As long as the Jews and Israelites kept to the laws of the covenant, a true Church existed among them; that is, by God's kindness they enjoyed the benefits of a church. True doctrine was contained in the law, and its ministry was entrusted to the prophets and priests. They were initiated into religion by the sign of circumcision, and trained and strengthened in the faith by the other sacraments. There's no doubt that the titles with which the Lord honoured his Church applied to their community. When they abandoned the Lord's law and sank into idolatry and superstition, they partly lost that privilege. For who would dare deny the title of Church to those with whom the Lord had entrusted the preaching of his word and the observance of his mysteries? And yet who would dare give the name of Church, without qualification, to an assembly in which the word of God is openly trampled underfoot with impunity, and in which his ministry, the Church's chief support and very soul, has been destroyed?
8. The stages of Israel's and Judah's decline
"What, then?" someone will say. "Was there not a scrap of the Church left to the Jews from the time they fell into idolatry?" The answer is easy. First, I say that there were several stages in the falling away itself, for we can't treat the lapses by which Judah and Israel turned from the pure worship of God as identical. When Jeroboam made the calves against God's express prohibition and dedicated an unlawful place of worship, he corrupted religion entirely (1 Kings 12:28-33). The people of Judah became degenerate in their morals and superstitious in their opinions before they made any improper change in the outward form of religion. Although they had taken up many perverse ceremonies under Rehoboam, the teaching of the law, the priesthood and the rites God had instituted continued at Jerusalem, so that the godly still had the Church in a tolerable state there. Among the Israelites, matters that had certainly not been reformed up to the time of Ahab then grew worse. His successors down to the fall of the kingdom were partly like him, and partly (when they wanted to be somewhat better) followed Jeroboam's example; all without exception were wicked idolaters. In Judah there were changes from time to time, some kings corrupting God's worship with false and superstitious inventions, others attempting to reform it, until at last the priests themselves polluted God's temple with profane and abominable rites.
9. Why we cannot join in Rome's worship
Now let the Papists deny, if they can, however much they try to play down their faults, that the state of religion among them is as debased and corrupt as it was in the kingdom of Israel under Jeroboam. Their idolatry is grosser, and their doctrine not a whit purer; if anything, it is more impure still. God, and indeed anyone with a moderate degree of judgment, will bear me out, and the thing is too obvious for me to need to enlarge on it.
When they try to force us into communion with their Church, they make two demands. First, that we join in their prayers, their sacrifices and all their ceremonies. Second, that whatever honour, power and jurisdiction Christ has given to his Church we must ascribe to theirs.
As to the first, I grant that all the prophets at Jerusalem, when things were very corrupt there, neither offered sacrifice separately nor held separate meetings for prayer. They had God's command to assemble at Solomon's temple, and they knew that the Levitical priests, whom the Lord had set over sacred things and who had not yet been removed, were still entitled to that office, however unworthy of the honour they might be. But the key point in the whole question is that the prophets weren't forced into any superstitious worship; in fact they took part in nothing that God hadn't instituted. Where is the resemblance with the Papists? We can scarcely attend any of their gatherings without defiling ourselves with open idolatry. Their chief bond of communion is undoubtedly the Mass, which we abhor as the greatest sacrilege. Whether we're right or rash in this will be seen elsewhere (chapter 18). For now it's enough to show that our situation differs from that of the prophets, who, when they were present at the sacred rites of the ungodly, weren't required to witness or use any ceremonies except those God had instituted.
If we want an example that matches in every respect, let's take it from the kingdom of Israel. Under Jeroboam's arrangements circumcision remained, sacrifices were offered, the law was held sacred, and the God they had received from their fathers was worshipped. But because of invented and forbidden forms of worship, God disapproved and condemned everything done there. Show me one prophet or godly person who ever worshipped or sacrificed at Bethel. They knew they couldn't do it without defiling themselves with some form of sacrilege. We hold, therefore, that the godly should not carry their commitment to the communion of the Church so far as to be bound to follow it when it has sunk into profane and polluted rites.
10. Why we cannot grant their assemblies the authority of the Church
On the second point our objections are stronger still. When we speak of the Church in the particular sense of the Church whose judgment we must revere, whose authority we must acknowledge, whose warnings we must obey, whose censures we must fear, and whose communion we must faithfully keep in every respect, we can't grant that they are a church without binding ourselves to submission and obedience. Still, we're willing to grant them what the prophets granted the Jews and Israelites of their own day, when things were in a similar or even better state. We see how the prophets constantly denounce their assemblies as profane gatherings, which it would be no more lawful to join in than to deny God (Isa. 1:13-14).
And certainly, if those were churches, it follows that Elijah, Micaiah and others in Israel, and Isaiah, Jeremiah, Hosea and their like in Judah, men whom the prophets, priests and people of their day hated and cursed more than the uncircumcised, were strangers to the Church of God. If those were churches, then the Church was no longer the pillar of the truth but the prop of falsehood, not the tabernacle of the living God but a storehouse of idols. The prophets were therefore bound to withhold their consent from those assemblies, since consenting would have been nothing but an ungodly conspiracy against God.
For the same reason, anyone who acknowledges the assemblies of the present day, defiled as they are by idolatry, superstition and ungodly teaching, as churches in full communion, with which a Christian must keep fellowship even to the point of agreeing with their doctrine, will be gravely mistaken. If they are churches, the power of the keys belongs to them; yet the keys are inseparably bound to the word, which they have driven out. Again, if they are churches, they can claim Christ's promise, "Whatever you bind..." (Matt. 16:19); yet they expel from their communion all who sincerely profess to be Christ's servants. Either Christ's promise is empty, or in this respect at least they are not churches. In short, in place of the ministry of the word they have schools of ungodliness and sewers of every kind of error. So in this sense they are either not churches, or no mark will remain by which the lawful assemblies of the faithful can be distinguished from the gatherings of Turks.
11. Yet traces of the Church remain under the Papacy
Still, just as in ancient times certain special privileges of the Church remained among the Jews, so today we don't deny the Papists those traces of the Church that the Lord has allowed to survive among them amid the ruin. Once the Lord had made his covenant with the Jews, it was preserved not so much by them as by its own strength, which enabled it to withstand their ungodliness. Such is the certainty and constancy of God's goodness that his covenant continued there, and his faithfulness couldn't be wiped out by their treachery. Nor could circumcision be so profaned by their impure hands as to stop being a true sign and sacrament of his covenant. That's why the Lord called the children born to them his own (Ezek. 16:20-21), though, apart from his special blessing, they in no way belonged to him.
In the same way, having entrusted his covenant to France, Italy, Germany, Spain and England, when those countries were oppressed by the tyranny of Antichrist, the Lord, so that his covenant might remain unbroken, first preserved baptism there as a witness to the covenant: baptism, which, consecrated by his own lips, keeps its power despite human wickedness. Second, he saw to it by his providence that other remnants survived too, so that the Church wouldn't perish entirely. Just as, when buildings are demolished, the foundations and ruins are often left standing, so he didn't allow Antichrist either to overthrow his Church from its foundations or to level it to the ground. To punish the ingratitude of those who had despised his word, he allowed a terrible shaking and dismembering to take place; but he willed that amid the devastation the building should remain, even if half in ruins.
12. Churches under the Papacy, but not a lawful Church: summary
So while we refuse simply to grant the name of Church to the Papists, we don't deny that there are churches among them. The question we raise concerns only the true and lawful constitution of the Church, which involves communion in the sacred rites that are signs of profession, and above all in doctrine.
Daniel and Paul foretold that Antichrist would sit in the temple of God (Dan. 9:27; 2 Thess. 2:4), and we regard the Roman pontiff as the leader and standard-bearer of that wicked and abominable kingdom. The fact that he places his seat in the temple of God indicates that his kingdom would not be such as to wipe out the name either of Christ or of his Church. It's clear, then, that we don't at all deny that churches remain under his tyranny. But they are churches he has profaned by sacrilegious ungodliness, oppressed by cruel domination, and corrupted, indeed almost killed, with evil and deadly doctrines like poisoned drinks: churches where Christ lies half-buried, the gospel is suppressed, godliness is driven out and the worship of God almost abolished; where, in short, everything is in such disorder that it looks more like Babylon than the holy city of God.
In a word, I call them churches in so far as the Lord wonderfully preserves there some remnants of his people, however miserably torn and scattered, and in so far as some tokens of the Church still remain, above all those whose power neither the devil's cunning nor human wickedness can destroy. But since, on the other hand, the marks we must chiefly look to in this discussion have been erased, I say that neither the body as a whole nor any single assembly within it has the form of a lawful church.
Chapter 3
The Teachers and Ministers of the Church: Their Election and Office
1. Why God governs his Church through human ministers
We must now speak of the order by which the Lord has willed his Church to be governed. It is right that he alone should rule and reign in the Church, should preside and stand out in it, and that its government should be carried on and administered by his word alone. Yet since he doesn't live among us in visible presence, declaring his will to us with his own lips, he uses (as I've said) the ministry of human beings, making them, as it were, his deputies. He doesn't transfer his right and honour to them; he simply does his own work through their lips, as a craftsman uses a tool.
I'm obliged to repeat what I set out earlier (chapter 1, section 5). God could have done this himself, without any help or instrument, or he could have done it through angels. But there are several reasons why he prefers to use human beings.
First, in this way he shows his condescension towards us, employing people to act as his ambassadors in the world, to interpret his secret will, in short, to represent his own person. So he shows by experience that he doesn't call us his temples for nothing, since he gives answers to human beings through a human mouth as if from a sanctuary.
Second, it is an excellent and very useful training in humility when he accustoms us to obey his word as preached by people like ourselves, and sometimes by people of less worth than ourselves. If he spoke from heaven himself, it would be no wonder if everyone received his sacred oracles at once with reverent ears and minds. Who wouldn't dread his power when it was present? Who wouldn't fall flat at the first sight of his great majesty? Who wouldn't be overwhelmed by that boundless splendour? But when a frail human being, sprung from the dust, speaks in God's name, we give the best proof of our godliness and obedience by listening teachably to his servant, though he is in no way our superior. That's why he hides the treasure of his heavenly wisdom in fragile clay jars (2 Cor. 4:7): to have a surer test of how much we value it.
Third, nothing was better suited to fostering mutual love than to bind people together by this tie, appointing one of them as pastor to teach the rest, who are told to be learners and to receive the common doctrine from a single mouth. If everyone were self-sufficient and needed no one else's help (such is the pride of the human mind), each would despise all the others and be despised in turn. So the Lord has bound his Church by what he foresaw would be the strongest bond of unity, when he entrusted the doctrine of eternal life and salvation to human beings, so that through their hands he might pass it on to others.
Paul had this in mind when he wrote to the Ephesians: "There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope that belongs to your call; one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is over all and through all and in all. But grace was given to each one of us according to the measure of Christ's gift. Therefore it says, 'When he ascended on high he led a host of captives, and he gave gifts to men.' (In saying, 'He ascended,' what does it mean but that he had also descended into the lower regions, the earth? He who descended is the one who also ascended far above all the heavens, that he might fill all things.) And he gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers, to equip the saints for the work of ministry, for building up the body of Christ, until we all attain to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to mature manhood, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ, so that we may no longer be children, tossed to and fro by the waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine, by human cunning, by craftiness in deceitful schemes. Rather, speaking the truth in love, we are to grow up in every way into him who is the head, into Christ, from whom the whole body, joined and held together by every joint with which it is equipped, when each part is working properly, makes the body grow so that it builds itself up in love" (Eph. 4:4-16).
2. The ministry is the chief bond holding the Church together
With these words Paul shows that the human ministry God uses in governing the Church is a principal bond holding believers together in one body. He also indicates that the Church can't be kept safe unless it is upheld by the safeguards to which the Lord has been pleased to entrust its safety. Christ "ascended far above all the heavens, that he might fill all things" (Eph. 4:10). This is how he fills them: through the ministers to whom he has entrusted this office, and to whom he has given grace to carry it out, he dispenses and distributes his gifts to the Church, and so shows himself in a sense actually present, putting forth the power of his Spirit in this institution of his so that it isn't empty or fruitless. In this way the saints are renewed and the body of Christ is built up; in this way we grow up in every respect into him who is the head, and are united with one another; in this way we are all brought into the unity of Christ, provided prophecy flourishes among us, we receive his apostles, and we don't despise the teaching delivered to us.
Whoever, then, tries to abolish the order and form of government we are speaking of, or belittles it as of minor importance, is plotting the devastation, or rather the ruin and destruction, of the Church. Neither the light and heat of the sun nor food and drink are as necessary to sustain and nourish this present life as the apostolic and pastoral office is to preserve the Church on earth.
3. The dignity and necessity of the ministry
That's why, as I noted earlier, God has repeatedly commended the dignity of this office by the titles he gives it, so that we would hold it in the highest esteem as among the most excellent of our blessings. He declares that in raising up teachers he confers a special benefit on people, when he has his prophet exclaim, "How beautiful upon the mountains are the feet of him who brings good news, who publishes peace" (Isa. 52:7), and when he calls the apostles the light of the world and the salt of the earth (Matt. 5:13-14). The office couldn't be praised more highly than when he said, "The one who hears you hears me, and the one who rejects you rejects me" (Luke 10:16). But the most striking passage of all is in 2 Corinthians, where Paul treats the question as his set subject. He argues that there is nothing in the Church more noble and glorious than the ministry of the gospel, since it is the ministry of the Spirit, of righteousness and of eternal life (2 Cor. 3:6-9). These and similar passages should keep this way of governing and sustaining the Church through ministers, which the Lord has ratified for ever, from seeming worthless to us and finally falling into disuse through contempt.
How necessary it is, he has shown not only by words but by examples. When he was pleased to shed the light of his truth more brightly on Cornelius, he sent an angel from heaven to have Peter fetched to him (Acts 10:3-6). When he was pleased to call Paul to know him and to graft him into the Church, he didn't instruct him with his own voice but sent him to a man from whom he would receive both the doctrine of salvation and the sanctification of baptism (Acts 9:6-20). It's no accident that the angel, God's own messenger, refrains from declaring God's will and instead tells Cornelius to send for a man to declare it; or that Christ, the only Master of believers, puts Paul under a man's teaching, the very Paul he meant to catch up to the third heaven and honour with a wonderful revelation of things that cannot be told (2 Cor. 12:2-4). Who, then, would dare despise or dismiss as unnecessary a ministry whose usefulness God has chosen to confirm by such evidence?
4. The offices: apostles, prophets and evangelists were temporary; pastors and teachers are permanent
Those who govern the Church according to Christ's institution are named by Paul as, first, apostles; second, prophets; third, evangelists; fourth, pastors; and last, teachers (Eph. 4:11). Of these only the last two hold an ordinary office in the Church. The Lord raised up the other three at the beginning of his kingdom, and still raises them up from time to time when the needs of the age require it.
The nature of the apostolic office is clear from the command, "Go into all the world and proclaim the gospel to the whole creation" (Mark 16:15). No fixed boundaries are set for them; the whole world is assigned them to be brought into obedience to Christ, so that by spreading the gospel as widely as they could, they might set up his kingdom everywhere. So when Paul wants to vindicate his apostleship, he doesn't say he had won some one city for Christ, but that he had spread the gospel far and wide, not building on another's foundation but planting churches where his Lord's name had never been heard (Rom. 15:19-20). The apostles, then, were sent out to bring the world back from its revolt to true obedience to God, and to establish his kingdom everywhere by the preaching of the gospel; or, if you prefer, they were the Church's first architects, laying its foundations throughout the world.
By "prophets" Paul means not all interpreters of God's will, but those who excelled by special revelation. There are none such now, or they are less evident. By "evangelists" I understand those who were lower in rank than the apostles but next to them in office, and who even acted in their place: men like Luke, Timothy, Titus and others, and perhaps also the seventy disciples whom our Saviour appointed next after the apostles (Luke 10:1).
On this interpretation, which seems to me to fit both Paul's words and his meaning, those three offices were not instituted to be permanent in the Church, but only to last as long as churches had to be founded where none existed before, or at least had to be brought over from Moses to Christ. I don't deny that God afterwards raised up apostles, or at least evangelists in their place, from time to time, as he has done in our own day. Such men were needed to bring the Church back from the revolt of Antichrist. I still call the office extraordinary, because it has no place in churches that are properly established.
Next come pastors and teachers, whom the Church can never do without. The difference between them, I think, is this: teachers have no charge of discipline, of administering the sacraments, or of admonition and exhortation, but only of interpreting Scripture, so that pure and sound doctrine may be maintained among believers. The pastoral office includes all of these.
5. Pastors correspond to apostles, teachers to prophets
We now understand which offices in the government of the Church were temporary and which were instituted to last for ever. If we class evangelists with apostles, we'll have two pairs of offices that correspond to each other: our teachers resemble the ancient prophets, and our pastors resemble the apostles. The prophetic office was more excellent because of the special gift of revelation that went with it, but the office of teacher was much the same in nature and had exactly the same purpose.
Likewise, the Twelve whom the Lord chose to proclaim the new preaching of the gospel to the world (Luke 6:13) excelled the rest in rank and dignity. By the nature of the case and the meaning of the word, all church officers might properly be called apostles, since they are all sent by the Lord and are his messengers. But because it was so important that a sure attestation be given to the mission of those who brought a new and extraordinary message, it was right that the Twelve (to whom Paul was later added) should be distinguished from others by a title of their own. Paul does give the same name to Andronicus and Junia, who he says were "well known to the apostles" (Rom. 16:7); but when he speaks precisely, he restricts the term to that first order, and that is Scripture's usual practice. Still, pastors have the same function as apostles, except that each is given the government of a particular church. Let's now look at that function more closely.
6. The pastor's office: to preach the word and administer the sacraments
When our Lord sent out the apostles, he commissioned them (as I've just said) to preach the gospel and to baptise believers for the forgiveness of sins. He had already commanded them to distribute the sacred symbols of his body and blood, following his example (Matt. 28:19; Luke 22:19). This is the sacred, inviolable and perpetual law laid on those who take the apostles' place: they are commissioned to preach the gospel and administer the sacraments. From this we conclude that those who neglect both have no right to claim the apostolic office.
What about pastors? Paul speaks not only of himself but of all pastors when he says, "This is how one should regard us, as servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God" (1 Cor. 4:1). Elsewhere he describes a bishop as one who "must hold firm to the trustworthy word as taught, so that he may be able to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to rebuke those who contradict it" (Titus 1:9). From these and similar passages found everywhere, we can infer that the two chief parts of the pastor's office are to preach the gospel and to administer the sacraments.
But teaching isn't only a matter of public addresses; it extends to private admonition too. So Paul calls the Ephesians to witness: "I did not shrink from declaring to you anything that was profitable, and teaching you in public and from house to house, testifying both to Jews and to Greeks of repentance towards God and of faith in our Lord Jesus Christ." A little later he says, "Remember that for three years I did not cease night or day to admonish every one with tears" (Acts 20:20-21, 31).
My purpose here isn't to list all the qualities of a good pastor, but only to show what those who call themselves pastors profess: that in presiding over the Church they hold no idle dignity, but must train the people in true godliness by the teaching of Christ, administer the sacred mysteries, and maintain and exercise proper discipline. To those set as watchmen in the Church the Lord declares, "If I say to the wicked, 'You shall surely die,' and you give him no warning, nor speak to warn the wicked from his wicked way, in order to save his life, that wicked person shall die for his iniquity, but his blood I will require at your hand" (Ezek. 3:18). What Paul says of himself applies to all pastors: "If I preach the gospel, that gives me no ground for boasting. For necessity is laid upon me. Woe to me if I do not preach the gospel!" (1 Cor. 9:16). In short, what the apostles did for the whole world, every pastor should do for the flock entrusted to him.
7. Each pastor bound to his own church
In assigning each pastor his own church, we don't deny that a pastor attached to one church may help others, whether some disturbance has arisen that needs his presence or his advice is sought on some difficult question. But because this arrangement is necessary to keep the peace of the Church, each is given his own task, so that things don't fall into disorder, with everyone running here and there without any definite calling, crowding together in one place, and leaving churches empty on a whim, more concerned for their own convenience than for building up the Church. As far as possible, this arrangement should be generally kept, so that each person stays content within his own bounds and doesn't encroach on another's.
Nor is this a human invention; it's God's ordinance. We read that Paul and Barnabas appointed elders in every church at Lystra, Iconium and Antioch (Acts 14:21-23), and Paul himself tells Titus to appoint elders in every town (Titus 1:5). Similarly he mentions the bishops of the Philippians, and Archippus, the bishop of the Colossians (Phil. 1:1; Col. 4:17). And in Acts we have his famous address to the elders of the church at Ephesus (Acts 20:28).
Let everyone who takes on the government and care of one church know, then, that he is bound by this law of divine calling. That doesn't mean he is tied to the soil (as the lawyers say), enslaved and fixed so that he can't move a foot even if the public good requires it and the thing is done properly and in order. But someone called to one place shouldn't think of moving, or seek to be released, because he judges it to his own advantage. And if it's expedient for someone to be transferred elsewhere, he shouldn't attempt it on his own private initiative but wait for public authority.
8. Bishops, presbyters and pastors are one office; elders who govern
In using the names bishop, presbyter and pastor interchangeably for those who govern churches, I've followed the authority of Scripture, which uses the words as synonyms. It gives the name "bishop" to all who carry out the ministry of the word. So Paul, after telling Titus to appoint elders in every town, adds immediately, "For an overseer [bishop] must be above reproach" (Titus 1:5, 7). Elsewhere he greets several bishops in a single church (Phil. 1:1). And in Acts, he calls the elders of Ephesus, whom he is said to have summoned, "overseers" in the course of his address (Acts 20:17, 28).
We should note that so far I've listed only the offices that consist in the ministry of the word, and Paul mentions no others in the passage from Ephesians 4 quoted above. But in Romans and 1 Corinthians he lists other offices: miracles, gifts of healing, interpretation, administration, care of the poor (Rom. 12:7-8; 1 Cor. 12:28). I'll say nothing about those that were temporary, since they're not worth dwelling on. But two are permanent: government and the care of the poor.
By these "governors" I understand elders chosen from among the people to join the bishops in pronouncing censures and exercising discipline. No other meaning can be given to the phrase "the one who leads, with zeal" (Rom. 12:8). From the beginning, then, each church had its council, made up of godly, serious and respected men, in whom the power of correcting faults was vested. I'll speak of this power later. Experience shows, moreover, that this arrangement wasn't confined to a single age, and so we must regard the office of government as necessary for every age.
9. Deacons: two kinds
The care of the poor was entrusted to deacons, and Paul mentions two kinds in Romans: "the one who contributes, in generosity... the one who does acts of mercy, with cheerfulness" (Rom. 12:8). Since he is clearly speaking of public offices of the Church, there must have been two distinct kinds. Unless I'm mistaken, in the first clause he means deacons who administered alms, and in the second those who had devoted themselves to caring for the poor and the sick. Such were the widows he mentions in his letter to Timothy (1 Tim. 5:9-10). For there was no public office women could hold except that of devoting themselves to the service of the poor. If we accept this (and it certainly should be accepted), there will be two kinds of deacons: one serving the Church by managing the affairs of the poor, the other by caring for the poor themselves.
Although the Greek word diakonia has a broader meaning, Scripture gives the name "deacon" specifically to those whom the Church appoints to distribute alms and care for the poor, making them, as it were, stewards of the poor's common fund. Luke describes their origin, institution and office (Acts 6:1-6). When the Greek-speaking believers complained that their widows were being neglected in the daily distribution, the apostles, explaining that they couldn't carry out both duties, preaching the word and serving tables, asked the congregation to choose seven men of good reputation to whom the task could be entrusted. We ought to have the same kind of deacons as the apostolic Church had, following her example.
10. No one may take a public office in the Church without a call
Since in the sacred assembly "all things should be done decently and in order" (1 Cor. 14:40), there is nothing in which this should be more carefully observed than in establishing its government, because disorder is nowhere more dangerous. So, to prevent restless and turbulent people from pushing themselves forward to teach or rule (as was in fact going to happen), it was expressly provided that no one should take up a public office in the Church without a call (Heb. 5:4; Jer. 17:16). Anyone, then, who wants to be regarded as a true minister of the Church must first be properly called, and second must answer to that call, that is, take up and carry out the office assigned to him.
We see this often in Paul, who, when he wants to vindicate his apostleship, almost always appeals to his call together with his faithfulness in carrying out the office. If so great a minister of Christ doesn't dare claim the authority to be heard in the Church except as one appointed to it by his Lord's command and faithfully performing what was entrusted to him, what effrontery it is for anyone lacking either or both of these to demand such honour for himself! But since I've already touched on the need to carry out the office, let's now deal only with the call.
11. The outward call and the inward call
The subject falls under four heads: who are to be appointed ministers, in what manner, by whom, and with what rite or ceremony of admission.
I'm speaking of the outward and formal call, which concerns the public order of the Church. I say nothing of the secret call of which every minister is conscious before God, but to which the Church is no witness: the good testimony of our own heart that we take up the office offered to us not from ambition or greed or any other selfish desire, but from a sincere fear of God and a desire to build up the Church. That is certainly necessary for each of us, as I've said, if we want our ministry to be approved by God. Still, a person may have been properly called by the Church even though he accepted with a bad conscience, provided his wickedness isn't evident.
It's also common to say that private persons are called to the ministry when they appear fit and capable of carrying it out, since learning combined with godliness and the other gifts of a good pastor is a kind of preparation for the office. For those whom the Lord has destined for this great office he first equips with the armour needed to carry it out, so that they don't come to it empty-handed and unprepared. That's why Paul, in 1 Corinthians, when dealing with the offices, first lists the gifts in which those who held them ought to excel (1 Cor. 12:7-11). But since this is the first of the four heads I mentioned, let's turn to it now.
12. Who should be chosen, and in what spirit
Paul deals at length with what kind of people should be chosen as bishops in two passages (Titus 1:5-9; 1 Tim. 3:1-7). The substance is that no one should be chosen unless he is sound in doctrine and holy in life, and not notorious for any fault that would destroy his authority and bring disgrace on the ministry. The description of deacons and elders is entirely similar (see chapter 4, sections 10-13). We must always take care that those chosen aren't unfit for, or unequal to, the burden laid on them; in other words, that they are furnished with what they'll need to fulfil their office. So our Saviour, when about to send out his apostles, equipped them with the weapons and tools they could not do without (Luke 21:15; 24:49; Acts 1:8). And Paul, after describing a good and genuine bishop, warns Timothy not to defile himself by choosing an unsuitable person for the office (1 Tim. 5:22).
By "in what manner" I don't mean the rite of choosing, but only the reverent fear that must be observed in an election. Hence the fasting and prayer that Luke tells us believers used when they chose elders (Acts 14:23). Understanding that this was the most serious business they could undertake, they didn't dare proceed without the greatest reverence and care. Above all they were earnest in prayer, asking God for the spirit of wisdom and discernment.
13. By whom ministers are chosen: the apostles were chosen by Christ alone
The third head is by whom ministers are to be chosen. No firm rule can be drawn from the appointment of the apostles, which differed somewhat from the ordinary call of others. Since theirs was an extraordinary ministry, it had to be marked out by some more distinctive sign, so those who were to carry it out had to be called and appointed by the Lord's own mouth. It was not by any human election, therefore, but at the sole command of God and Christ that they took up the work. That's why, when the apostles wanted to put someone in Judas's place, they didn't dare nominate one man definitely, but put forward two, so that the Lord might declare by lot which of them he wanted (Acts 1:23-26).
This is how we should understand Paul's declaration that he was an apostle "not from men nor through man, but through Jesus Christ and God the Father" (Gal. 1:1). The first part, "not from men," he had in common with all godly ministers of the word, since no one could rightly carry out the office unless called by God. The second was peculiar to him. In glorying in it, he claims not only what belongs to a true and lawful pastor but also the badges of his apostleship. Some among the Galatians, trying to undermine his authority, were making him out to be an ordinary disciple, a substitute for the original apostles. So, to keep the dignity of his ministry intact against these attacks, he felt it necessary to show that he was in no way inferior to the other apostles. He therefore affirms that he was chosen not by human judgment, like an ordinary bishop, but by the mouth and clear command of the Lord himself.
14. Ordinary ministers are appointed by human beings, and even Paul was set apart by the Church
But no sober person will deny that the regular form of lawful calling is for bishops to be appointed by human beings, since there are many passages of Scripture to that effect. Nor, as I've said, does Paul's protest that he was sent neither from men nor through man contradict this, since he isn't speaking there of the ordinary election of ministers but claiming for himself what was peculiar to the apostles. And yet the Lord, while choosing Paul by special privilege, still placed him under the discipline of a church call. Luke tells us: "While they were worshipping the Lord and fasting, the Holy Spirit said, 'Set apart for me Barnabas and Saul for the work to which I have called them'" (Acts 13:2). Why this setting apart and laying on of hands after the Holy Spirit had already testified to their election, except to preserve the church order of appointing ministers through human beings? God couldn't have given a clearer proof that he approves this order than by having Paul set apart by the Church after he had already declared that he had appointed him apostle to the Gentiles. We see the same thing in the election of Matthias. Because the apostolic office was so important that they didn't dare appoint anyone to it on their own judgment, they put forward two on whom the lot might fall, so that the choice would have sure testimony from heaven while the Church's order was not disregarded.
15. Elected with the consent of the people, under the oversight of other pastors
The next question is whether a minister should be chosen by the whole church, or only by fellow ministers and the elders who have charge of discipline, or whether he may be appointed on the authority of one individual.
Those who give this right to one individual cite Paul's words to Titus: "This is why I left you in Crete, so that you might put what remained into order, and appoint elders in every town" (Titus 1:5); and to Timothy: "Do not be hasty in the laying on of hands" (1 Tim. 5:22). But they are mistaken if they think that Timothy at Ephesus and Titus in Crete reigned like kings, disposing of everything as they pleased. They presided only in the sense of giving the people good and sound counsel beforehand, not by doing whatever they liked on their own with everyone else shut out.
So that this doesn't look like an invention of mine, I'll make it plain by a parallel case. Luke tells us that Barnabas and Paul appointed elders in the churches, but he also indicates the method when he says it was done by vote: the word he uses, cheirotonēsantes, means appointing by a show of hands (Acts 14:23). So the two of them presided over the appointment, but the whole body, as was the Greek custom in elections, declared by raising their hands whom they wanted. In the same way Roman historians often say that the consul who held the assembly "elected" the new magistrates, simply because he received the votes and presided over the people at the election. It is certainly not credible that Paul granted Timothy and Titus more than he took for himself, and we see that his custom was to appoint bishops by the votes of the people. We must therefore interpret those passages in a way that doesn't infringe the common right and liberty of the Church.
Cyprian is right, then, to insist, as a matter of divine authority, that a minister be chosen in the presence of the people, before the eyes of all, and approved as worthy and fit by public judgment and testimony (Cyprian, Letters 1.3). Indeed, we see that by the Lord's command the practice in appointing the Levitical priests was to bring them before the people before consecrating them. Nor was Matthias enrolled among the apostles, nor the seven deacons chosen, in any other way than in the sight and with the approval of the people (Acts 1:15-26; 6:2-6). "These examples," says Cyprian, "show that the ordination of a minister ought not to take place except with the knowledge of the people standing by, so that the ordination might be just and lawful which had been examined by the testimony of all."
We see, then, that ministers are lawfully called according to God's word when those who appear suitable are elected with the consent and approval of the people. Other pastors, however, should preside over the election, so that the general body doesn't go wrong through fickleness, factional passion or disorder.
16. The rite of ordination: the laying on of hands
It remains to consider the form of ordination, which I put last among the parts of the call (see chapter 4, sections 14-15). It is certain that when the apostles appointed anyone to the ministry, they used no other ceremony than the laying on of hands. I think this form came from the Jewish custom of presenting to God, by the laying on of hands, whatever they wanted to be blessed and consecrated. So Jacob, about to bless Ephraim and Manasseh, placed his hands on their heads (Gen. 48:14). Our Lord did the same when he prayed over the little children (Matt. 19:15). With the same purpose, I imagine, the Jews laid hands on their sacrifices as the law commanded. So by the laying on of hands the apostles signified that they were offering to God the person they were admitting to the ministry, though they also did the same over those on whom they conferred the visible gifts of the Spirit (Acts 8:17; 19:6).
However that may be, it was the regular form whenever they called anyone to the sacred ministry. In this way they consecrated pastors and teachers; in this way they consecrated deacons. Although there's no specific command about the laying on of hands, since we see that the apostles observed it consistently, their careful observance should count for us as a command (see chapter 14, section 20; chapter 19, section 31). And it is certainly useful that by such a sign the dignity of the ministry should be commended to the people, and that the one ordained should be reminded that he is no longer his own but is bound in service to God and the Church. Besides, it will not be an empty sign if it is restored to its true origin. If the Spirit of God has instituted nothing in the Church in vain, we'll find that this ceremony of his appointment isn't useless, provided it isn't superstitiously abused.
Finally, we should note that it was not the whole people but only the pastors who laid hands on ministers. Whether several always laid on hands together is uncertain. It's clear that in the case of the deacons it was done by the apostles, and in the case of Paul and Barnabas by a few others (Acts 6:6; 13:3). But elsewhere Paul says that he laid hands on Timothy himself, with no one else mentioned: "I remind you to fan into flame the gift of God, which is in you through the laying on of my hands" (2 Tim. 1:6). As for the phrase in the first letter about the laying on of hands "by the council of elders" (1 Tim. 4:14), I don't take Paul to be speaking of the body of elders. I understand the expression to mean the ordination itself, as if he said: see to it that the gift you received through the laying on of hands, when I made you a presbyter, isn't wasted.
Chapter 4
The State of the Early Church and the Form of Government Used Before the Papacy
1. Why we look at the early Church, and its three orders
So far I've set out the order of church government as it is given to us in the pure word of God, along with the ministerial offices Christ instituted (chapter 1, sections 5-6; chapter 3). To make the whole subject clearer and more familiar, and to fix it better in our minds, it will help to look at the form of the early Church, since this gives us a kind of visible picture of the divine institution.
The bishops of those times did publish many canons that seem to say more than Scripture says. Yet they were so careful to build their whole arrangement on God's word, the only standard, that it's easy to see they scarcely departed from it at any point. Even if something is lacking in those regulations, they sincerely wanted to preserve the divine institution and didn't stray far from it, so it will be of real benefit to explain briefly what they practised.
We've said that Scripture sets before us three classes of ministers, and the early Church likewise divided all its ministers into three orders. From the order of presbyters, some were chosen to be pastors and teachers, while the rest were given charge of the oversight of conduct and discipline. To the deacons belonged the care of the poor and the distribution of alms. "Readers" and "acolytes" were not names of distinct offices. They were names for those whom the ancients called the clergy, whom they trained from their youth in certain duties of service to the Church, so that they might understand better what they were destined for and come better prepared for their work, as I'll shortly show at greater length. So Jerome, setting out five orders in the Church, lists bishops, presbyters, deacons, believers and catechumens, and gives no proper place to the other clergy and monks (Jerome on Isaiah 9).
2. The bishop as president among the presbyters
All those to whom the task of teaching was entrusted they called presbyters. In each city these presbyters chose one of their number and gave him the special title of bishop, to prevent the dissension that so often arises from equality. The bishop, however, wasn't so far above his colleagues in honour and dignity as to rule over them. His role in the council of presbyters was that of a president in any assembly: to bring matters forward, gather opinions, take the lead in consulting, advising and exhorting, guide the whole proceedings by his authority, and carry out what was decided by common consent. The ancients themselves admit that this practice was introduced by human arrangement, to suit the needs of the time.
So Jerome, commenting on Titus 1, says: "A bishop is the same as a presbyter. Before the devil stirred up divisions in religion, and people were saying, 'I am of Paul,' 'I am of Cephas,' the churches were governed by the common council of presbyters. Afterwards, to root out the seeds of dissension, the whole oversight was handed to one person. So just as presbyters know that by the custom of the Church they are subject to the one who presides, bishops should know that they are greater than presbyters more by custom than by the Lord's appointment, and ought to rule the Church together for the common good."
Elsewhere he shows how old the custom was (Jerome, Letter to Evangelus). He says that at Alexandria, from Mark the Evangelist down to Heraclas and Dionysius, the presbyters always placed one of their own number in a higher rank and gave him the name of bishop.
Each city, then, had a college of presbyters made up of pastors and teachers. All of them performed for the people the task of teaching, exhorting and correcting that Paul assigns to bishops (Titus 1:9). To leave a succession behind them, they made it their business to train the younger men who had devoted themselves to the sacred warfare. Each city was assigned a surrounding district, which supplied it with presbyters and was treated as part of that church. Each presbyter, as I've said, was under one bishop merely for the sake of order and peace, and the bishop, though he excelled the others in dignity, was himself subject to the meeting of his brothers. But if the district under his bishopric was too large for him to handle all the bishop's duties, presbyters were placed at certain points in it to act as his deputies in lesser matters. These were called chorepiscopi (rural bishops), because they represented the bishops across the province.
3. Bishops and presbyters were bound to preach and administer the sacraments
In the office we're now discussing, bishop and presbyters alike were bound to give themselves to the administration of word and sacraments. Only at Alexandria, because Arius had troubled the Church there, was it ordered that no presbyter should address the people, as Socrates reports (Tripartite History 9), and Jerome makes no secret of his displeasure at the rule (Jerome, Letter to Evagrius). It would have been thought monstrous for someone to call himself a bishop and not show himself a true bishop by his conduct. Such was the strictness of those times that all ministers were required to fulfil their office as the Lord demands.
Nor am I speaking only of one age. Even in Gregory's time, when the Church had almost fallen, or at least had greatly declined from its ancient purity, no bishop would have been tolerated who refrained from preaching. In his twenty-fourth letter he says: "The priest dies when no sound is heard from him, for he calls down the wrath of the unseen Judge if he walks without the sound of preaching." Elsewhere: "When Paul testifies that he is innocent of the blood of all (Acts 20:26), his words charge us who are called priests, put us on trial and show us guilty, since to the sins of our own we add the deaths of others, for we commit murder as often as we watch them going daily to destruction while we remain lukewarm and silent" (Gregory, Homilies on Ezekiel). He calls himself and others "silent" when they were less diligent in their work than they should have been. If he didn't spare even those who did their duty only in part, what would he have done to those who neglected it entirely? For a long time, then, it was regarded in the Church as the first duty of a bishop to feed the people with God's word, or to build up the Church, publicly and privately, with sound doctrine.
4. Archbishops and patriarchs: a rare arrangement for the sake of order
As for the fact that each province had an archbishop among its bishops (see chapter 7, section 15), and that at the Council of Nicaea patriarchs were appointed above the archbishops in rank and dignity: this was designed to preserve discipline, though it should be noted, in treating the subject here, that the practice was very rare. The chief reason for these ranks was that if anything arose in a church which a few couldn't easily resolve, it could be referred to a provincial synod. If the importance or difficulty of the case called for wider discussion, patriarchs were brought in along with synods, and from them there was no appeal except to a general council.
Some gave this arrangement the name "hierarchy." In my view the name is improper, and it is certainly not one Scripture uses. The Holy Spirit meant to make sure that no one should dream of primacy or domination in the government of the Church. But if we set the word aside and look at the thing itself, we'll find that the ancient bishops had no wish to frame a form of church government different from the one God prescribed in his word.
5. Deacons in the early Church
The deacons' role then was no different from what it had been under the apostles (chapter 3, section 6). They received the daily offerings of the faithful and the Church's yearly revenues, to apply them to their proper uses: partly to supporting ministers and partly to supporting the poor. They did this under the bishop's oversight, to whom they gave an annual account of their stewardship.
Although the canons uniformly make the bishop the manager of all the Church's goods, this doesn't mean he took that task on himself alone. It means he decided which people the deacon should admit to the Church's public support, and to whom and in what portions the remainder should be given, and he was entitled to check whether the deacon performed his duty faithfully. So in the canons ascribed to the apostles it says: "We command that the bishop have the affairs of the Church under his control. For if the souls of people, which are more precious, have been entrusted to him, much more should he have charge of money matters, so that under his control everything may be given to the poor through the presbyters and deacons, and the ministry may be carried out reverently and with due care." The Council of Antioch (canon 35) decreed that bishops who meddled with the Church's funds without the knowledge of the presbyters and deacons should be restrained.
There's no need to discuss this further, since many of Gregory's letters make it plain that even in his day, when church regulations were otherwise badly corrupted, deacons were still the stewards of the poor under the bishops. Subdeacons were probably attached to deacons at first, to help them in managing the care of the poor, but the distinction was gradually lost. Archdeacons began to be appointed when the size of the revenues called for a newer and more exact system of administration, though Jerome mentions that the office already existed in his day. Archdeacons were responsible for the accounts of revenues, property and furnishings, and for the daily offerings. So Gregory tells the archdeacon Solitanus that the blame lies with him if any of the Church's goods perish through his fraud or neglect.
Deacons were also assigned the reading of the word to the people and the call to prayer, and were permitted to give the cup in the Lord's Supper. This was done to honour their office, so that they would carry it out with greater reverence, reminded by such signs that what they were handling was no secular stewardship but a spiritual service dedicated to God.
6. The Church's goods were the patrimony of the poor
From this we can also judge the use and nature of the distribution of church property. In the decrees of synods and in the ancient writers you'll find everywhere that whatever the Church possessed, whether in land or in money, was the patrimony of the poor. So the saying kept sounding in the ears of bishops and deacons: Remember that you are not handling your own property but what is meant for the needs of the poor; if you dishonestly hide or squander it, you will be guilty of blood. They were told to distribute it to those to whom it was owed, with the greatest fear and reverence, as in God's sight, and without favouritism. Hence the solemn appeals in Chrysostom, Ambrose, Augustine and other such bishops, in which they declare their integrity before the people.
It is just in itself, and was sanctioned by divine law, that those who give their labour to the Church should be supported from the Church's common resources. Some presbyters in that age had given their own inheritance to God and had voluntarily become poor. So the distribution was arranged so that ministers were provided for and the poor were not neglected. Meanwhile it was ensured that the ministers themselves, who ought to be an example of frugality to others, didn't have so much that it could be abused for luxury or refinement, but only what they needed to meet their wants. "For clergy who can be supported from their own inheritance," says Jerome, "commit sacrilege if they accept what belongs to the poor, and by such misuse eat and drink judgment on themselves" (Jerome, Letter to Nepotian).
7. The four-fold division of church revenues
At first the administration was free and voluntary, when bishops and deacons were faithful of their own accord, and integrity of conscience and purity of life took the place of laws. Afterwards, when the greed and corrupt desires of some produced bad examples, canons were drawn up to correct these evils. They divided the Church's revenues into four parts, assigning one to the clergy, another to the poor, another to the repair of churches and other buildings, and a fourth to the poor, whether strangers or natives.
Other canons attribute this last part to the bishop, but it comes to the same thing as the division I've described. They don't mean that it was his property, to devour alone or squander as he pleased, but that it enabled him to show the hospitality Paul requires of that office (1 Tim. 3:2). This is how Gelasius and Gregory understand it. The only reason Gelasius gives why the bishop may claim anything for himself is so that he can give it to captives and strangers. Gregory speaks still more plainly: "It is the custom of the Apostolic See," he says, "to instruct a newly ordained bishop to divide all the revenues into four portions: one for the bishop and his household, for hospitality and maintenance; another for the clergy; a third for the poor; a fourth for the repair of churches."
A bishop therefore could not lawfully take for his own use more than was enough for moderate and frugal food and clothing. When anyone began to indulge in luxury or in ostentation and show, he was at once reprimanded by his colleagues, and if he refused to obey, was stripped of his honours.
8. Church ornaments sold to feed the poor
The money spent on adorning churches was at first very small, and even afterwards, when the Church had become somewhat wealthier, they kept moderation in this. Even so, whatever money was gathered was reserved for the poor whenever a greater need arose.
So when a famine struck the province of Jerusalem and the need couldn't be met in any other way, Cyril took the vessels and robes and sold them to support the poor. In the same way Acacius, bishop of Amida, when a great multitude of Persians were nearly dying of hunger, gathered his clergy and made this noble speech: "Our God has no need of cups or plates, for he neither eats nor drinks" (Tripartite History 5, 11.16). He melted down the church plate so that he could provide food and pay the ransom of those wretched people. Jerome, in a passage attacking the excessive splendour of churches, tells how Exuperius, bishop of Toulouse, carried the Lord's body in a wicker basket and his blood in a glass, yet let no poor person go hungry (Jerome, Letter to Nepotian).
Ambrose tells the same of himself that I've just told of Acacius. When the Arians attacked him for breaking up sacred vessels to ransom captives, he made this admirable defence: "He who sent the apostles without gold also gathered churches without gold. The Church has gold not to keep but to give away, and to help in time of need. What need is there to hoard what does no good? Don't we know how much gold and silver the Assyrians carried off from the Lord's temple? Isn't it better for a priest to melt it down to support the poor, if there's no other means, than for a sacrilegious enemy to carry it away? Wouldn't the Lord say, 'Why did you let so many poor people die of hunger, when you certainly had gold to help them? Why were so many captives carried off and not ransomed? Why were so many killed by the enemy? It would have been better to preserve living vessels than metal ones.' You would have no answer to these charges. What could you say? 'I was afraid the temple of God would lack ornament.' He would answer, 'The sacraments need no gold, and things that are not bought with gold are not made pleasing by gold. The ornament of the sacraments is the ransom of captives'" (Ambrose, On Duties 2.28).
In a word, we see the exact truth of what he says elsewhere: whatever the Church then possessed was the revenue of the needy. And again: "A bishop has nothing but what belongs to the poor" (Ambrose, Letters 5.31, 33).
9. The lesser "orders" were a training ground, not offices
We've now reviewed the ministerial offices of the ancient Church. The others that church writers mention were rather exercises and preparations than distinct offices. These holy men, to leave a nursery for the Church behind them, took in young men who, with their parents' consent and authority, devoted themselves to the spiritual warfare under their care and training. They formed them from their early years so that they wouldn't enter the work as ignorant novices. Everyone who received this training was given the general name of "clerks."
I wish some more fitting name had been given them, since the name arose from error, or at least from a wrong attitude: Peter applies the Greek word klēros (that is, the Lord's inheritance) to the whole Church (1 Pet. 5:3). Yet the institution itself was thoroughly sacred and wholesome. Those who wanted to give themselves and their labour to the Church were brought up under the bishop's care, so that no one would serve in the Church without good prior training: without having taken in sound doctrine in his early years, formed habits of seriousness and stricter morals under stricter discipline, been withdrawn from ordinary business, and grown used to spiritual cares and studies.
Just as recruits are trained by mock battles for real and serious warfare, there was an elementary training in which they practised the duties of the clergy before actually being appointed. First they were entrusted with opening and closing the church and were called doorkeepers (ostiarii). Next the name acolytes was given to those who assisted the bishop in household service and attended him constantly, first as a mark of respect and second so that no suspicion might arise, since he was never to go anywhere without company and a witness. Then, so that they might gradually become known to the people and win their regard, and at the same time learn to bear everyone's gaze and to speak before all, so as not to be overcome with shame when they came forward to teach as presbyters, they were given the task of reading in the lectern (the Psalms were assigned to them). In this way they advanced step by step, proving their care in each exercise, until they were appointed subdeacons. All I mean by this is that these were the elementary exercises of recruits, not functions counted among the true ministries of the Church.
10. The call of ministers in the early Church: persons, reverence and the people's consent
In the first and second heads of the calling of ministers (the persons to be elected and the religious care to be shown in the choice), the early Church followed Paul's instruction and the apostles' examples. They met to elect pastors with the greatest reverence and with earnest prayer to God. They also had a form of examination to test the life and teaching of the candidates against Paul's standard (1 Tim. 3:2). Here they sometimes went wrong through excessive strictness, requiring more of a bishop than Paul requires, and especially, as time went on, requiring celibacy. In other respects their practice matched Paul's description.
On our third head, however, who had the right to appoint ministers, they didn't always keep the same rule. In earlier times no one was admitted to the ranks of the clergy without the consent of the whole people. Cyprian therefore makes a lengthy apology for having appointed Aurelius a reader without consulting the church, because although it was done against custom, it wasn't done without reason. He begins: "Dear brothers, in ordaining clergy we are accustomed to consult you beforehand and weigh the character and merits of each by common counsel" (Cyprian, Letters 2.5).
But since in these lesser exercises (readers and acolytes) there was no great danger, as they were appointed to a long probation and unimportant duties, the people's consent stopped being asked. Later, in the other orders too, with the exception of the bishopric, the people usually left the choice and decision to the bishop and presbyters, who determined who was fit and worthy; unless, perhaps, new presbyters were being appointed to parishes, in which case the express consent of the local inhabitants had to be given.
It's not surprising that the people weren't very eager to defend their right in this matter. No subdeacon was appointed who hadn't given long proof of his conduct in clerical duties, under the strict discipline then in use. Once he had proved himself at that level he was appointed deacon, and then, if he conducted himself faithfully, he reached the honour of presbyter. So no one was promoted whose conduct hadn't truly been tested for many years under the eye of the people. There were also many canons for punishing their faults, so that the Church, if she didn't neglect the remedies, wasn't burdened with bad presbyters or deacons. In the case of presbyters, in fact, the consent of the citizens was always required, as the canon attributed to Anacletus attests (Decretum, Distinction 67). Finally, all ordinations took place at set times of the year, so that no one could creep in secretly without the faithful's consent or be promoted too easily without witnesses.
11. The people's role in electing bishops
In the election of bishops, the people kept their right for a long time to prevent anyone from being forced on them who wasn't acceptable to all. So the Council of Antioch forbade installing anyone against the will of the people, and Leo I carefully confirmed this. Hence these statements: "Let the man be elected whom the clergy and people, or the majority, ask for." Again: "Let the one who is to preside over all be elected by all" (Leo, Letters 90.2). A man appointed unknown and untested must be forced on them by violence. And again: "Let the man be elected who is chosen by the clergy and called by the people, and let him be consecrated by the bishops of the province with the judgment of the metropolitan."
The holy fathers were so careful that this liberty of the people should never be diminished that when a general council met at Constantinople to ordain Nectarius, they refused to do it without the approval of all the clergy and people, as their letter to the Roman synod testifies. Accordingly, when a bishop named his own successor, the act wasn't ratified without consulting the whole people. Of this we have not only an example but the very form, in Augustine's nomination of Eradius (Augustine, Letters 110). And Theodoret, after relating that Peter was the successor nominated by Athanasius, adds at once that the priestly order confirmed it, and the magistrates, leading citizens and whole people approved by acclamation (Theodoret, Ecclesiastical History 4.20).
12. Limits on the crowd
The Council of Laodicea (canon 18) did decree, and I admit on the best grounds, that elections shouldn't be left to crowds. It hardly ever happens that so many heads settle any matter well with one consent. The saying generally holds true: "The fickle crowd is torn by opposing wishes."
At first, therefore, the clergy alone made a selection and presented the person they'd selected to the magistrate, the senate and the leading citizens. After deliberation these signed their approval of the election if it seemed right, and if not, chose another whom they preferred. The matter was then laid before the multitude. Though not bound by these earlier proceedings, the people were less able to act tumultuously. Or, if the matter began with the multitude, it was only so that it might be known whom they most wanted; after hearing the people's wishes, the clergy then made the election. So the clergy weren't free to appoint whom they pleased, nor were they obliged to yield to the people's foolish desires.
Leo sets down this order when he says: "The wishes of the citizens, the testimony of the people, the choice of the honourable, the election of the clergy are to be awaited" (Leo, Letters 87). Again: "Let the testimony of the honourable, the signatures of the clergy, the consent of the magistracy and people be obtained; otherwise (he says) it must on no account be done." The decree of the Council of Laodicea intends nothing more than that the clergy and rulers shouldn't let themselves be swept away by the rash multitude, but should restrain its foolish desires, whenever there was need, by their prudence and gravity.
13. This mode of election lasted a long time
This way of electing was still in force in Gregory's time, and probably continued much longer. Many of his surviving letters clearly prove it. Whenever a new bishop was to be elected, his custom was to write to the clergy, the magistrates and the people, and sometimes also to the governor, depending on the form of government. If, because of the unsettled state of the Church, he gave oversight of the election to a neighbouring bishop, he always required a formal decision confirmed by everyone's signatures. When Constantius was elected bishop of Milan, and many Milanese had fled to Genoa because of barbarian raids, he held that the election would not be lawful unless they too were called together and gave their consent (Gregory, Letters 2.69).
Indeed, it is not yet five hundred years since Pope Nicholas fixed the election of the Roman pontiff in this way: first, the cardinals should go before; next, they should join to themselves the other clergy; and lastly, the election should be ratified by the consent of the people. At the end he quotes the decree of Leo I mentioned above and orders it to be enforced in future. If the malice of the wicked were so strong that the clergy had to leave the city in order to hold a pure election, he still orders that some of the people be present at the same time.
The emperor's vote, as far as we can tell, was required only in two churches, Rome and Constantinople, the two seats of empire. When Valentinian sent Ambrose to Milan with authority to oversee the election of a new bishop, it was an extraordinary step, taken because of the violent factions raging among the citizens. But at Rome the emperor's authority in electing the bishop was so great that Gregory says he was appointed to govern the Church by the emperor's order (Gregory, Letters 1.5), though he had been called by the people in due form. The custom was that when the magistrates, clergy and people nominated someone, he was presented at once to the emperor, who either ratified the election by approving or annulled it by disapproving.
Nothing in the decretals collected by Gratian contradicts this practice. All they say is that it must never be tolerated for canonical election to be abolished and a king to appoint a bishop at will, and that someone promoted by violent authority was not to be consecrated by the metropolitans. It is one thing to rob the Church of her right and hand it over entirely to the whim of a single individual; it is quite another to grant a king or emperor the honour of confirming a lawful election by his authority.
14. The form of ordination in the ancient Church
It remains to treat the form by which the ministers of the ancient Church were installed in their office after election. The Latins called it ordination or consecration; the Greeks used cheirotonia, sometimes also cheirothesia, though cheirotonia properly refers to the kind of election in which votes are shown by raised hands.
A decree of the Council of Nicaea is extant to the effect that the metropolitans, with all the bishops of the province, were to meet to ordain the one chosen. If some were prevented by distance, illness or any other necessary cause, at least three should meet, and those absent should signify their consent by letter. This canon fell out of use but was renewed by several later councils. All, or at least all who had no excuse, were required to attend, so that a stricter examination might be made of the life and teaching of the person to be ordained, for the thing was never done without examination.
From Cyprian's words it appears that in old times the bishops were not called in after the election but were present at the election itself, to act as moderators and prevent disorder by the crowd. After saying that the people have the power either to choose worthy priests or to refuse unworthy ones, he adds at once: "For this reason we must carefully observe and keep the divine and apostolic tradition (which is observed by us also, and by nearly all the provinces), that for the proper performance of ordinations all the nearest bishops of the province should meet with the people over whom the new bishop is to be ordained, and the bishop should be chosen in the presence of the people." But because the bishops were sometimes slow to assemble and there was a risk that some would abuse the delay for intrigue, it was thought sufficient for them to come after the choice had been made and, after due investigation, consecrate the one who had been approved.
15. How the form gradually changed
Although this was done everywhere without exception, a different custom gradually gained ground: those who were elected would go to the metropolitan to be ordained. This arose more from ambition and the corruption of the ancient custom than from any good reason. Not long after, as the authority of the Roman See grew, an even worse custom was introduced: applying to Rome for the consecration of the bishops of almost all Italy. We can see this in Gregory's letters (Letters 2.69, 76). The ancient right was kept only by a few cities which had not given way so easily, such as Milan. Perhaps only metropolitan sees kept their privilege, since to consecrate an archbishop it was the practice for all the bishops of the province to meet in the metropolitan city.
The form used was the laying on of hands (chapter 19, sections 28, 31). I don't read of any other ceremonies, except that in public meetings bishops wore some dress that set them apart from the other presbyters. Presbyters and deacons were also ordained by the laying on of hands, but each bishop ordained his own presbyters together with the college of presbyters. Though they all performed the same act, because the bishop presided and the ordination was done, as it were, under his auspices, it was said to be his. Hence ancient writers often say that a presbyter differs from a bishop in nothing except the power of ordaining.
Chapter 5
The Ancient Form of Government Corrupted by the Tyranny of the Papacy
1. Who is made a bishop under the Papacy
It's time to set before the reader the order of church government observed by the Roman See and all its satellites, the whole "hierarchy" they have perpetually on their lips, and to compare it with the description I've given of the early Church. The contrast will show what sort of church those have who think the mere title enough to outweigh, or rather crush, us.
The best place to begin is the call: who is called to the ministry, with what character, and on what grounds. After that we'll consider how faithfully they carry out their office. Bishops come first; I wish they could claim first place in this discussion for their honour! But the subject doesn't let me touch it even lightly without exposing their disgrace. Still, I must remember what kind of book I'm writing, one meant for plain teaching, and not let my discourse stray beyond its limits.
Let any of them who haven't lost all sense of shame tell me what kind of bishops are regularly elected today. Any examination of doctrine is thought old-fashioned. If any attention is paid to learning at all, they choose a lawyer who knows better how to plead in court than to preach in church. This much is certain: for a hundred years scarcely one in a hundred has been elected who had any acquaintance with sacred doctrine. I don't spare earlier ages because they were much better, but because the question here concerns only the Church of the present day. If we inquire into morals, we'll find few or almost none whom the ancient canons wouldn't have judged unworthy. If a man wasn't a drunkard, he was a fornicator; if he was free of that vice, he was a gambler or a hunter or loose in some other way. And these are only the lighter faults that the ancient canons counted as barring a man from the episcopate. The most absurd thing of all is that boys scarcely ten years old are made bishops with the Pope's permission. Such is their shamelessness and stupidity that they have no fear even of this last monstrous wrong, which is shocking even to natural feeling. It's plain what kind of elections these must be, when such reckless carelessness reigns.
2. The people's right taken away: no lawful election remains
In elections the whole right has been taken from the people. Vows, assent, signatures and everything of that sort have disappeared, and all the power has been given to the canons alone. First they confer the episcopal office on whomever they like; then they bring him out before the people, but to be worshipped, not examined. Yet Leo protests that no reason permits this and calls it a violent imposition (Leo, Letters 90.2). Cyprian, after declaring it a matter of divine authority that no election take place without the people's consent, shows that any different procedure conflicts with God's word. Many council decrees most strictly forbid it to be done otherwise, and order that if it is, the election be void. If this is true, there is today throughout the Papacy no canonical election in line with either divine or church law. Even if there were no other evil in this, what excuse can they give for robbing the Church of her right?
They say the corruption of the times required it: since hatred and faction swayed the people and magistrates in choosing bishops more than right and sound judgment, the decision had to be confined to a few. Grant that this was a last remedy in desperate circumstances. When the cure proved more harmful than the disease, why was no remedy provided for the new evil? They say the rules the canons must follow are strictly laid down. But can we doubt that even in ancient times the people, meeting to elect a bishop, knew they were bound by the most sacred laws, when they saw a rule prescribed by God's word? That one sentence in which God describes the true character of a bishop ought justly to carry more weight than ten thousand canons. Yet, carried away by the worst passions, the people paid no regard to law or fairness. So today, though excellent laws have been made, they remain buried in writing.
Meanwhile the general and approved practice, carried on almost systematically, is that drunkards, fornicators and gamblers are promoted to this honour. That's the least of it: bishoprics are the rewards of adulterers and pimps, and when they are given to hunters and falconers, things are at their best. To excuse such conduct in any way would be wicked beyond measure. The people had an excellent rule given them by God's word: a bishop must be "above reproach... able to teach, not violent but gentle, not quarrelsome" (1 Tim. 3:2-3). Why, then, was the power of election transferred from the people to these men? Because amid the tumults and factions of the crowd the word of God went unheard. And why, on the other hand, is it not now transferred away from these men, who not only violate every law but, having thrown off shame, mix and confound things human and divine with lust, greed and ambition?
3. How the people's right was lost, and what princes did with it
It isn't true, though, that this was devised as a remedy. We read that in old times riots often broke out in cities over the election of bishops, yet no one ever thought of depriving the citizens of their right, because they had other ways of preventing the fault or correcting it once committed. Let me state what really happened. When the people began to be careless in making their choice and left the business, as less suited to them, to the presbyters, the presbyters took advantage of the opportunity to seize a domination, which they afterwards established by issuing new canons. Ordination today is nothing but a mockery: the so-called examination they put on is so empty and trivial that it lacks even the appearance of one.
So when rulers, by agreements with the Roman pontiffs, obtained for themselves the right to nominate bishops, the Church suffered no new injury, because the canons were simply deprived of an election they had seized without any right or acquired by stealth. Still, nothing is more disgraceful than bishops being sent from royal courts to take possession of churches, and godly princes would do well to give up this corruption. It is an ungodly plundering of the Church whenever a people has a bishop forced on it whom it hasn't asked for or at least freely approved. But the disorderly practice that long existed in churches gave rulers the occasion to take the presentation of bishops for themselves. They wanted the benefice to belong to them rather than to people who had no better right to it and abused it just as badly.
4. Presbyters and deacons ordained for the wrong purpose
This is the famous call on account of which bishops boast that they are successors of the apostles. They claim, moreover, that they alone can properly appoint presbyters. But here they most shamefully corrupt the ancient institution, because by their ordination they appoint not presbyters to guide and feed the people but priests to offer sacrifice. Likewise when they consecrate deacons, they pay no regard to the deacon's true and proper work, and ordain them only for certain ceremonies concerning the cup and the paten.
The Council of Chalcedon, by contrast, decreed that there should be no "absolute ordinations," that is, ordinations without assigning the ordained person a place where he would carry out his office. This decree is very useful for two reasons: first, so that churches aren't burdened with needless expense and idle men don't receive what should be given to the poor; and second, so that those ordained will realise they aren't promoted merely to an honorary position but entrusted with a duty they're solemnly bound to carry out. But the Roman authorities, who think nothing in religion matters except their bellies, treat the "title" required by the council as simply an income sufficient for support, whether from the man's own property or from the priesthood. So when they ordain presbyters or deacons, they don't care where they are to serve; they confer the order provided the ordained are rich enough to support themselves.
Who can admit that the "title" the council's decree requires is merely a yearly income for living on? And when more recent canons made bishops liable for the support of those they ordained without a proper title, to curb too easy ordination, a way was devised around the penalty: the ordained person promises to be content with whatever title is named, and so is barred from suing for support. I say nothing of the thousand frauds committed here, as when some falsely claim empty titles to benefices from which they can't get a penny, and others by secret agreement get a temporary appointment which they promise to hand back immediately, and sometimes don't. There are more tricks of the same sort.
5. Their trials and ceremonies are empty shows
Even if these grosser abuses were removed, it would still be absurd to appoint a presbyter without assigning him a place. When they ordain, it is only to sacrifice. But the lawful ordination of a presbyter is to the government of the Church, while deacons are called to the care of alms. Many pompous ceremonies are used to cover the act, so that mere show may inspire reverence in simple people. But what effect can such appearances have on sensible people, when underneath them there is nothing solid or true? They use ceremonies either borrowed from Judaism or invented by themselves, and it would be better if they kept away from them. Of the examination (it's hardly worth mentioning the shadow of one that they keep), of the people's consent, and of the other necessary things, there is no mention. By "shadow" I mean those ridiculous gestures staged in a silly, lifeless imitation of antiquity.
Bishops have their deputies who, before ordination, inquire into the candidates' doctrine. But what sort of inquiry is it? Do they ask whether they can read their Missals, or decline a common noun from the lesson, or conjugate a verb, or give the meaning of a single word? They don't even need to give the sense of one sentence. And even candidates who lack these elementary skills aren't turned away, provided they bring the recommendation of money or influence. Of the same kind is the question put three times in an unintelligible voice when the candidates are brought to the altar: "Are they worthy of the honour?" Someone who has never seen them, but has his part in the play so that no form is missing, answers, "They are worthy." (In the French edition Calvin adds that it may be some servant who doesn't understand Latin, playing his part as in a farce.) What can you charge these venerable fathers with except that, in such sacrilegious play-acting, they shamelessly laugh at God and man? But since they've long been in possession of the thing, they think they now have legal title to it. Anyone who dares open his mouth against these plain and flagrant wrongs is hauled off to a capital trial, like someone who in old times revealed the mysteries of Ceres. Would they act like this if they believed in a God?
6. Benefices: the sale and trade in church offices
Then there is the conferring of benefices, which used to be joined with ordination but is now completely separate. Do they behave any better there? They have many excuses, for it isn't only bishops who confer the office of priest (and even where bishops are called "collators" they don't always have the full right); others hold the right of presentation, and the bishops keep only the honorary title of conferring. To these are added nominations from universities, resignations (simple or by exchange), commendatory letters, pre-emptive grants and the like. But they all behave in such a way that none can reproach another.
I maintain that in the Papacy today scarcely one benefice in a hundred is conferred without simony, as the ancients defined it. I don't say that all buy for a fixed sum; but show me one in twenty who doesn't reach the priesthood by some shady means. Some owe their promotion to kinship or marriage ties, some to their parents' influence, some win favour by fawning. In short, the purpose for which offices are given is that provision be made, not for churches, but for those who receive them. That's why they call them "benefices," a name that shows they view them as nothing more than the gifts by which princes buy the favour of their soldiers or reward their service. I say nothing of the fact that these rewards are given to barbers, cooks, grooms and such dregs.
Today no cases in the law courts make more noise than those concerning priestly offices, so that you could regard them as game thrown to dogs to be hunted. Is it tolerable even to hear the name "pastors" given to people who have forced their way into a church as into enemy territory, who have driven others out by courtroom brawls, who have bought it for a price, who have worked for it by sordid flattery, who have received it while still lisping boys, like an inheritance from uncles and relatives? Sometimes even illegitimate sons get it from their fathers.
7. One man put over five or six churches
Was the licence of the people, however corrupt and lawless, ever carried to such a height? Even more monstrous is that one man (I won't say what kind, but certainly one who can't govern himself) is put in charge of five or six churches. In princes' courts today you can see youths who are three times abbots, twice bishops and once archbishops. Everywhere there are canons loaded with five, six or seven benefices, of none of which they take any care except to draw the income.
I won't point out that God's word cries out against this; it has long ceased to carry any weight with them. I won't point out that many councils threaten the severest punishment for this dishonest practice; these too they boldly scorn whenever it suits them. But I say it is monstrous wickedness, completely opposed to God, to nature and to church order, that one thief should lie brooding over several churches, and that the name of pastor should be given to someone who, even if he wished, couldn't be present with his flock. Yet such is their impudence that they cloak these abominations with the name of "church" to exempt them from all blame. Indeed, if you like, in these wrongs lies that holy succession by which, as they boast, the Church is kept from perishing.
8. Monks do not belong among the presbyters
Let's now look at the second test of a lawful pastor: how faithfully he carries out his office. The priests elected there are partly called monks and partly seculars. The former kind was unknown to the early Church. Holding such a place in the Church is so contrary to the monastic profession that in old times, when people were chosen from monasteries for church office, they stopped being monks. So Gregory, though there were many abuses in his time, wouldn't allow the offices to be mixed (Gregory, Letters 3.11). He insisted that those appointed abbots give up the clerical office, because no one can properly be monk and cleric at the same time, the one standing in the way of the other.
If I ask how a man can fulfil his office well who is declared unfit by the canons, what will they answer? They'll cite those abortive decrees of Innocent and Boniface by which monks are admitted to the honour and power of the priesthood while remaining in their monasteries. But is it reasonable that any unlearned ass, as soon as he has seized the Roman See, can overturn all antiquity with one little word? I'll deal with that matter later. For now it's enough that in the purer times of the Church it was thought a great absurdity for a monk to hold the office of priest. Jerome declares that he doesn't perform the priest's office while living among monks, and ranks himself among the people to be governed by the priests.
But even granting them this, what duty do they perform? Some of the mendicants preach; all the other monks sing or mutter masses in their cells, as if either our Saviour had intended, or the nature of the office allowed, presbyters to be made for such a purpose. Scripture plainly testifies that it's a presbyter's duty to rule his own church (Acts 20:28). Isn't it ungodly profanation to turn it to another purpose, indeed to change God's sacred institution altogether? When they are ordained, they are expressly forbidden to do what God commands all presbyters. For this is their cant: "Let a monk, content with his cell, not presume to administer the sacraments or hold any other public office." Let them deny, if they can, that it is open mockery of God to appoint someone a presbyter in order that he abstain from his proper office, and to give him the name when he can't have the thing.
9. Beneficiaries and hired mass-priests
I come to the seculars. Some of these are, as they say, "beneficiaries," that is, they hold offices that maintain them; others hire out their services day by day to sing or say masses, and live on the stipends they collect. Benefices either carry the care of souls, like bishoprics and parish charges, or are stipends for soft-living men who earn their keep by chanting, such as prebends, canonries, parsonages, deaneries, chaplaincies and the like. Things are now so turned upside down that the offices of abbot and prior are given not only to secular priests but even to boys, by privilege, that is, by common and usual custom.
As for the hired men who seek their food from day to day, what else could they do than what they actually do, which is to prostitute themselves in a base and shameful way for gain, especially given the vast crowd of them that fills the world today? They dare not beg openly, or think they'd gain little that way, so they go about like hungry dogs, extorting by a kind of barking importunity from the unwilling what they can stuff into their hungry bellies. If I tried to describe how disgraceful it is to the Church that the honour and office of presbyter should come to this, I'd never finish. My readers must not expect me to fully portray this shameful degradation.
I say briefly that if it is a presbyter's office (and both God's word, 1 Cor. 4:1, and the ancient canons require it) to feed the Church and administer Christ's spiritual kingdom, then all those priests who have no work or income except from trading in masses not only fail in their office but have no lawful office to fulfil. They have no place to teach and no people to govern. In short, nothing is left them but an altar on which to sacrifice Christ, which is to sacrifice not to God but to demons, as I'll show later (chapter 18, sections 3, 9, 14).
10. Canons, deans and chaplains are not true presbyters
I'm not touching here on faults of individuals, but only the internal disease at the root of the institution itself. I'll add a sentence that will sound strange in their ears, but since it is true it ought to be said: canons, deans, chaplains, provosts and all who are maintained in idle priestly offices must be viewed in the same light. What service can they render the Church? The preaching of the word, the care of discipline and the administration of the sacraments they have shaken off as burdens too heavy to bear. What remains, then, for which they can claim to be true presbyters? Only chanting and pompous ceremonies. But what has that to do with the matter?
If they plead custom, use or long prescription, I appeal in reply to the definition by which our Saviour has described true presbyters and shown the qualities of those to be regarded as presbyters. If they can't bear the hard law of submitting to Christ's rule, let them at least allow the case to be decided by the authority of the early Church. Their position will not be one bit improved when judged by the ancient canons. Those who have degenerated into canons ought to be presbyters, as they once were, to rule the Church together with the bishop and be, as it were, his colleagues in pastoral work. What they call chapter deaneries have nothing to do with the true government of the Church, much less chaplaincies and similar worthless names. How, then, are they all to be regarded? Certainly both Christ's word and the practice of the early Church exclude them from the honour of presbyters.
They insist that they are presbyters. But when we unmask them, we find their whole profession utterly alien to the presbyter's office as the apostles described it and as it was carried out in the early Church. All such offices, then, under whatever titles, since they are novelties and are certainly supported neither by God's institution nor by ancient practice, ought to have no place in a description of that spiritual government which the Church received and which was consecrated by the Lord's own mouth. Or, if they want it put in ruder and coarser terms: since chaplains, canons, deans, provosts and such idle bellies don't touch with one finger a single particle of the work necessarily required of presbyters, they must not be allowed falsely to usurp the honour and so violate Christ's holy institution.
11. Bishops and parish rectors who abandon their churches
There still remain bishops and parish rectors, and I wish they would contend for the maintenance of their office. I would gladly grant that theirs is a godly and excellent office if they carried it out. But when they desert the churches entrusted to them and, throwing the care onto others, still want to be regarded as pastors, they are acting as if the pastor's job were to do nothing.
If some moneylender who never leaves the city gave himself out as a ploughman or vine-dresser, or a soldier who had spent all his time in the field or camp and never seen a book or a courtroom passed himself off as a lawyer, who could tolerate the absurdity? Those who want to be called and thought lawful pastors of the Church, and are unwilling to be so, act far more absurdly. How few even appear to superintend their churches! Many spend their lives devouring the revenues of churches they never visit even to inspect. Some go once a year themselves, or send a steward, to see that nothing is lost in the leasing. When the corruption first crept in, those who wanted this kind of holiday pleaded privilege, but now it is a rare thing for anyone to live in his church. They look on churches merely as farms, over which they put vicars as bailiffs or farmhands. But it is contrary to common sense to call someone a shepherd who has never seen a sheep of his flock.
12. Gregory and Bernard complained of the beginnings
It appears that in Gregory's time some seeds of this corruption already existed, as the rulers of churches had begun to grow more careless in teaching. He complains bitterly: "The world is full of priests, and yet labourers in the harvest are rare, for we take on the office of the priesthood, but we don't do the work of the office" (Gregory, Homilies 17). Again: "Having no love in their hearts, they want to be thought lords, and don't at all acknowledge themselves to be fathers. They change a post of humility into a height of dominion." And again: "But we, O pastors, what are we doing, we who receive the wages but are not labourers? We have fallen away to outside business; we take on one thing and perform another; we leave the ministry of the word, and, to our punishment as I see it, are called bishops, holding the honour of the name, not the power."
If he used such bitter language against those who were only a little less diligent in their office, what would he have said had he seen that very few bishops, if any, and scarcely one in a hundred of the other clergy, mount the pulpit once in their entire lives? Men have reached such a degree of folly that preaching a sermon to the people is thought beneath the episcopal dignity. In Bernard's time things had become worse still. We see how bitterly he attacks the whole order, and yet there is reason to believe matters were then in much better shape than now.
13. The boast of apostolic succession answered
Anyone who carefully examines the whole form of church government as it now exists in the Papacy will find no kind of plunder in which robbers act more freely, without law or measure. Everything is so unlike, indeed so opposed, to Christ's institution, has so far fallen from the ancient customs and practices of the Church, and is so contrary to nature and reason, that no greater injury can be done to Christ than to use his name to defend this disorderly rule.
"We," they say, "are the pillars of the Church, the priests of religion, the vicars of Christ, the heads of the faithful, because apostolic authority has come to us by succession." They keep puffing themselves up with such nonsense as if they were talking to blocks of wood. Whenever they make such boasts, I ask in my turn: what do they have in common with the apostles? We aren't talking about some hereditary honour that can come to people while they sleep, but about the office of preaching, which they so carefully avoid.
Likewise, when we maintain that their kingdom is the tyranny of Antichrist, they immediately object that their venerable hierarchy has often been praised by great and holy men. As if the holy fathers, when they commended the church hierarchy or spiritual government handed down to them by the apostles, ever dreamed of that shapeless and dismal chaos, where bishoprics are mostly held by ignorant asses who don't know even the first elementary points of the faith, or sometimes by boys just out of the nursery; or, if some are more learned (a rare case), they treat the episcopal office as nothing but a title of magnificence and splendour; where the rectors of churches think no more of feeding the flock than a cobbler thinks of ploughing; where everything is thrown into a confusion worse than Babel's, so that no genuine trace of fatherly government is left to be seen.
14. Their conduct would earn deposition under the ancient canons
If we turn to conduct, where is the light of the world that Christ requires, where is the salt of the earth, where is the holiness that might serve as a permanent check on others? Today there is no order of men more notorious for luxury, softness, daintiness and every kind of licence. In no order are there teachers more skilled in deceit, fraud, treachery and betrayal. Nowhere is there more skill and boldness in mischief, to say nothing of ostentation, pride, greed and cruelty. The world is so disgusted at bearing these things that there is no danger of my seeming to exaggerate.
One thing I'll say that even they won't be able to deny: among the bishops there is scarcely one, and among the parish clergy not one in a hundred, who, if his conduct were judged by the ancient canons, would not deserve to be excommunicated or at least removed from office. I seem to say something almost incredible, so completely has that ancient discipline, which required strict scrutiny of the clergy's morals, fallen out of use; but that is how things really are. Let those who serve under the banner and auspices of the Roman See go and boast of their priestly order. It is certain that what they have comes neither from Christ, nor from his apostles, nor from the fathers, nor from the early Church.
15. There is no true diaconate in the Papacy
Now let the deacons come forward and show us their most sacred distribution of church goods (see chapter 19, section 32). Their deacons aren't chosen for that purpose at all. The only charge laid on them is to serve at the altar, read the Gospel, or chant and do I don't know what other trivial things. Nothing is said about alms, nothing about caring for the poor, nothing at all about the work they once did. I'm speaking of the institution itself; if we look at what they actually do, theirs is really no office at all, only a step to the priesthood.
In one thing those who hold the deacon's place at the Mass show an empty image of antiquity: they receive the offerings before the consecration. The ancient practice was that before the communion of the Supper the faithful kissed one another and offered alms at the altar, declaring their love first by a sign and then by an act of kindness. The deacon, who was steward of the poor, received what was given in order to distribute it. Now no more of these alms reaches the poor than if they were cast into the sea. They deceive the Church, then, by this lying diaconate. In this they certainly have nothing resembling the apostolic institution or the ancient practice.
They have moved the very distribution of goods elsewhere, and arranged it so that nothing more disorderly can be imagined. As robbers divide the plunder after murdering their victims, so these men, after extinguishing the light of God's word as if they had murdered the Church, have imagined that whatever had been dedicated to godly uses was left as prey and plunder. So they have divided it up, each seizing as much as he could for himself.
16. The Church's goods plundered
All those ancient arrangements I've explained are not only upset but altogether disguised and wiped out. The chief part of the plunder has gone to bishops and city presbyters, who, having enriched themselves in this way, were turned into canons. That the division was a mere scramble is evident from the fact that even to this day they are still disputing over the shares. Be that as it may, the outcome has been that out of all the Church's goods not a penny goes to the poor, to whom at least half belonged. The canons expressly assign a fourth to them, and destine another fourth for the bishops, for hospitality and other kindly services.
I say nothing about what the clergy ought to do with their share, or the use to which they should put it, for I've shown clearly that what is set aside for churches, buildings and other expenses ought in time of need to be given to the poor. If they had one spark of the fear of God in their hearts, could they bear the thought that all their food and clothing come from theft, indeed from sacrilege? But since they're little moved by God's judgment, they should at least reflect that those whom they try to persuade that their church's orders are as beautiful and well arranged as they like to boast are people with sense and reason. Let them answer briefly: is the diaconate a licence to rob and steal? If they deny this, they'll be forced to admit that no diaconate remains among them, since the whole administration of their church resources has been openly turned into sacrilegious plunder.
17. The plea that splendour honours the Church, and the answer
Here they offer a very fair-sounding excuse, saying that the dignity of the Church is rightly upheld by this magnificence. Some of their party are even so shameless as to boast openly that only in this way are fulfilled the prophecies in which the ancient prophets describe the splendour of Christ's kingdom, with the priestly order shown in royal dress. It wasn't for nothing, they say, that God made these promises to his Church: "May all kings fall down before him, all nations serve him!" (Ps. 72:11). "Awake, awake, put on your strength, O Zion; put on your beautiful garments, O Jerusalem, the holy city" (Isa. 52:1). "All those from Sheba shall come. They shall bring gold and frankincense, and shall bring good news, the praises of the Lord. All the flocks of Kedar shall be gathered to you" (Isa. 60:6-7).
I'd fear seeming childish if I spent long refuting this dishonesty, so I don't want to waste words. I'll ask only this: if some Jew misapplied these passages, what answer would they give? They'd rebuke his stupidity in making a carnal and worldly application of things said spiritually about Christ's spiritual kingdom. We know that under the images of earthly things the prophets have painted for us the heavenly glory that ought to shine in the Church. In the blessings these words literally express, the Church never had less than under the apostles, and yet everyone agrees that the power of Christ's kingdom was then at its most flourishing.
What do those passages mean, then? That everything precious, lofty and illustrious should be made subject to the Lord. As for the statement specifically about kings, that they would bow to Christ, throw down their crowns at his feet and dedicate their resources to the Church: when was this more truly and fully shown than when Theodosius, setting aside the purple and laying down the signs of empire, humbled himself before God and the Church in public repentance like one of the people? Or when he and other godly princes made it their study and care to preserve pure doctrine in the Church and to cherish and protect sound teachers? That priests didn't then wallow in surplus wealth is declared well enough by this one sentence of the Council of Aquileia, over which Ambrose presided: "Poverty in the priests of the Lord is glorious." It is certain that the bishops of that time had resources by which they could have made the Church's glory conspicuous, if they had thought these the Church's true ornaments. But knowing that nothing was more contrary to the duty of pastors than to pride themselves on rich food, splendid clothes, large retinues and magnificent houses, they cultivated and followed the humility and modesty, indeed the very poverty, that Christ has consecrated among his servants.
18. Lavish church decoration at the expense of the poor
To avoid wearying you, let me sum up again, showing how far the present distribution, or rather squandering, of church goods differs from the true diaconate, which God's word recommends and the early Church observed (Book 1, chapter 11, sections 7, 13; Book 3, chapter 20, section 30; chapter 4, section 8 above). Money spent on adorning churches is wrongly spent unless it is accompanied by the moderation which the very nature of sacred things requires, and which the apostles and other holy fathers prescribed by precept and example. Is anything like this seen in churches today? Whatever fits, I won't say with that ancient frugality, but with decent moderation, is rejected. Nothing pleases but what smacks of luxury and the corruption of the times.
Meanwhile, they are so far from taking proper care of living temples that they'd let thousands of the poor perish before breaking up the smallest cup or dish to relieve their need. So that I don't judge too harshly by my own authority, I'd ask the godly reader only to consider what Exuperius of Toulouse, whom we've mentioned, or Acacius, or Ambrose, or anyone like-minded would say if they rose from the dead. While the needs of the poor are so great, they certainly wouldn't approve of their funds being carried off as surplus; and even if there were no poor, the uses to which the money is put are harmful in many respects and useful in none.
But I don't appeal to human beings. These goods have been dedicated to Christ and ought to be distributed as he pleases. It's useless for them to call what they've squandered against his commands expenditure "for Christ." To tell the truth, the Church's ordinary revenue isn't much reduced by these expenses. No bishoprics are so rich, no abbacies so productive, no benefices so many and large, as to satisfy the gluttony of priests. But while they spare themselves, they get the people by superstition to spend on building temples, setting up statues, buying plate and providing costly vestments what should have been given to the poor. In this way the daily alms are swallowed up in this abyss.
19. Conclusion: the true diaconate is completely overturned
As for the revenue they draw from lands and property, what can I say beyond what I've already said and what everyone sees? We see with what kind of faithfulness the greatest part is managed by those called bishops and abbots. What madness to look for church order here! Is it fitting that those whose lives ought to be a singular example of frugality, modesty, self-control and humility should rival princes in the number of their attendants, the splendour of their houses and the daintiness of their dress and feasting? Can anything be more contrary to the duty of men whom God's eternal and inviolable command forbids to long for shameful gain and tells to be content with simple food, than to lay hands not only on villages and castles but also to invade the largest provinces, and even seize the empire itself?
If they despise the word of God, what answer will they give to the ancient council canons, which decree that a bishop shall have a small dwelling not far from the church, a frugal table and plain furniture (Council of Carthage, canons 14-15)? What answer will they give to the declaration of the Council of Aquileia, in which poverty in the Lord's priests is pronounced glorious? As for Jerome's advice to Nepotian to make the poor and strangers familiar with his table and to have Christ as a guest with him, they would perhaps reject it as too severe. What he adds immediately it would shame them to acknowledge: that a bishop's glory is to provide for the sustenance of the poor, and that the disgrace of all priests is to study their own riches. This they can't admit without covering themselves with disgrace.
But there's no need to press them so hard here, since all I wanted was to show that the lawful order of deacons was abolished long ago, and that they can no longer pride themselves on it in commending their church. This, I think, has been fully established.
Chapter 6
The Primacy of the Roman See
1. What the claim is, and why it matters to them
So far we've looked at the church offices that existed in the government of the early Church. Over time they were corrupted, and then more and more debased, until in the Papal Church they keep only the name and are in fact mere masks. The contrast lets the godly reader judge what kind of church it is that we're accused of schism for leaving.
But the head and crown of the whole matter, the primacy of the Roman See, from which they undertake to prove that the catholic Church is found only with them, we haven't yet touched. That's because it didn't originate in Christ's institution or the practice of the early Church, as the other parts did. Those, we showed, were ancient in origin and only later degenerated, even taking on an entirely new shape. Yet they work hard to persuade the world that the chief and only bond of church unity is to cling to the Roman See and stay subject to it.
The prop they lean on most heavily, when they want to deprive us of the Church and claim it for themselves, is that they hold the head on which the Church's unity depends and without which it must be torn apart and fall to pieces. For they regard the Church as a kind of mutilated trunk if it isn't subject to the Roman See as its head. So when they debate their hierarchy, they always start from the axiom: the Roman pontiff, as vicar of Christ the Head of the Church, presides in his place over the universal Church, and the Church isn't rightly constituted unless that See holds primacy over all others. We must therefore examine this claim, so as to leave out nothing that bears on the proper government of the Church.
2. The argument from the Jewish high priest
The question can be put like this: for the true order of the "hierarchy," as they call it, or of church order, is it necessary that one See surpass the others in dignity and power, so as to be head of the whole body? We lay unjust laws on the Church if we impose this necessity on her without any warrant from God's word. So if our opponents want to prove what they maintain, they must first show that this arrangement was instituted by Christ.
For this purpose they point to the office of high priest under the law and the supreme jurisdiction God set up at Jerusalem. The answer is easy, and there are several answers for anyone who isn't satisfied with one.
First, there's no reason to extend to the whole world what was useful for one nation. The two cases are quite different. Because the Jews were hemmed in on every side by idolaters, God fixed the seat of his worship in the central region of the earth, so that they wouldn't be pulled apart by a variety of religions. There he appointed one priest to whom they could all look, to keep them better united. But now that true religion is spread over the whole globe, who can't see how absurd it is to give the government of East and West to one individual? It's as if someone argued that the whole world should be governed by one governor because a single district doesn't have several.
There is another reason why that institution shouldn't be made a precedent. Everyone knows the high priest was a type of Christ. Now that the priesthood has been transferred, that right must be transferred with it. To whom? Certainly not to the Pope, as he impudently boasts when he claims the title, but to Christ, who alone holds the office without a vicar or successor and gives the honour to no one else. For this priesthood consists not only in teaching but in the atonement Christ made by his death and the intercession he now makes with the Father (Heb. 7:11).
3. The arguments from the New Testament: "You are Peter" and "Feed my lambs"
That example, which we can see was temporary, they have no right to impose on us as a perpetual law. In the New Testament they have nothing to offer in support of their view except that one person was told, "You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church" (Matt. 16:18), and again, "Simon, son of John, do you love me?... Feed my lambs" (John 21:15).
To give these proofs any strength, they must first show that the person ordered to feed Christ's flock is given power over all churches, and that binding and loosing is nothing other than presiding over the whole world. But Peter himself, having received a command from the Lord, urges all other elders to feed the Church (1 Pet. 5:2). So we're entitled to infer that by Christ's words nothing more was given to Peter than to the others, or that the right Peter received he shared equally with the others.
But we needn't argue in the dark. Elsewhere we have a clear explanation from Christ himself of what binding and loosing means: it is to retain and forgive sins (John 20:23). The manner of loosing and binding is explained throughout Scripture, especially in the passage where Paul declares that the ministers of the gospel are commissioned to reconcile people to God and at the same time to exercise discipline over those who reject the benefit (2 Cor. 5:18-20; 10:6).
4. The keys were given to all, as Cyprian and Augustine saw
I've touched elsewhere on how badly they twist the passages about binding and loosing, and I'll explain it more fully shortly. For now it's enough to see what they can extract from our Saviour's celebrated answer to Peter. He promised him the keys of the kingdom of heaven and said that whatever he bound on earth would be bound in heaven (Matt. 16:19).
The moment we agree on the meaning of the keys and the manner of binding, all dispute will end. The Pope will happily give up the task the apostles were assigned, since it is full of labour and toil, gets in the way of his luxuries and brings no gain. Heaven is opened to us by the teaching of the gospel, and so it is called, by an apt metaphor, the keys. And the only way people are bound and loosed is this: they are loosed when they are reconciled to God by faith, and bound more firmly by unbelief. If this were all the Pope claimed for himself, I believe no one would envy him or raise the question. But because this laborious and very unprofitable succession doesn't suit the Pope at all, the dispute arises at once over what it was that Christ promised Peter.
From the very nature of the case, I conclude that nothing more is meant than the dignity inseparable from the burden of the apostolic office. Granting the definition I've given (and it can't be rejected without effrontery), nothing is given to Peter here that he didn't share with his colleagues. Any other view would wrong not only their persons but the very majesty of the teaching.
They object. But what is gained by dashing against this stone? The most they can show is that, as the preaching of the same gospel was commanded to all the apostles, so the power of binding and loosing was given to them in common. Christ, they say, made Peter prince of the whole Church when he promised to give him the keys. But what he promised to one here, he elsewhere hands over to all the rest. If the same right promised to one is given to all, in what way is that one superior to his colleagues? He is superior, they say, in that he receives by himself what the others receive only in common. What if I answered, with Cyprian and Augustine, that Christ did this not to prefer one to the others but to commend the unity of his Church?
Cyprian says: "In the person of one man he gave the keys to all, to signify the unity of all. The rest were therefore what Peter was, admitted to an equal share of honour and power, but the beginning starts from unity, so that the Church of Christ may be shown to be one" (Cyprian, On the Unity of the Church). Augustine says: "If the mystery of the Church had not been in Peter, our Lord would not have said to him, 'I will give you the keys.' For if this was said to Peter, the Church doesn't have them; but if the Church has them, then Peter, in receiving the keys, represented the whole Church" (Augustine, Homilies on John 50). Again: "All were asked, but Peter alone answers, 'You are the Christ'; and it is to him that it is said, 'I will give you the keys,' as if he alone had received the power of loosing and binding, whereas he both spoke for all and received in common with all, being as it were the representative of unity. One received for all, because there is unity in all" (Homilies 124).
5. "On this rock": honour of rank is not power
Nowhere, though, do we read that any other apostle was told, "You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church" (Matt. 16:18). As if Christ there said anything else about Peter than what Paul and Peter himself say of all Christians (Eph. 2:20; 1 Pet. 2:5). The first describes Christ as the chief cornerstone on which all who grow into a holy temple in the Lord are built; the other describes us as living stones founded on that elect and precious stone, and so joined and fitted together, united to our God and to each other.
Peter is above the others, they say, because the name was given to him specially. I gladly grant Peter the honour of being placed among the first in the building of the Church, or, if they prefer, of being the first among the faithful. But I won't allow them to infer from this that he has primacy over the others. What kind of inference is it? Peter excels others in fervent zeal, in teaching, in boldness; therefore he has power over them. We could argue with greater plausibility that Andrew ranks before Peter, because he came first in time and brought Peter to Christ (John 1:40-42); but I pass that by. Let Peter have the pre-eminence. There is still a great difference between honour of rank and the possession of power. We see that the apostles usually left it to Peter to address the assembly, and in a way to take the lead in reporting, exhorting and admonishing, but we nowhere read anything about power.
6. The rock is Peter's confession of Christ
Though we haven't yet come to that part of the discussion, I'll just observe how futilely they argue who try to build up a governing power over the whole Church out of the mere name Peter. The old quibble they first used to give it a colour, that the Church is founded on Peter because it says "on this rock," doesn't deserve notice, let alone refutation.
Some of the fathers did explain it that way, and Rome holds that up as its shield. But when the whole of Scripture is against that explanation, why is their authority set against God's? Indeed, why do we argue about the meaning of these words as if it were obscure or ambiguous, when nothing could be clearer? Peter had confessed, in his own name and that of his brothers, that Christ is the Son of God (Matt. 16:16). On this rock Christ builds his Church, because it is the only foundation, as Paul says: "no one can lay a foundation other than that which is laid, which is Jesus Christ" (1 Cor. 3:11).
I'm not rejecting the fathers' authority here for lack of passages from them to prove my point, if I wanted to cite them. But as I've said, I don't want to weary my readers by debating so clear a matter, especially since our writers dealt with it fully long ago.
7. How Peter actually behaves among the apostles
In fact, no one can settle this question better than Scripture, if we compare all the passages that show what office and power Peter held among the apostles, how he acted among them and how they received him (Acts 15:7). Run through all of them, and the most you'll find is that Peter was one of the twelve, their equal and colleague, not their master.
He does bring matters before the council when something has to be done, and advises on what is needed. But at the same time he listens to the others, not only giving them a chance to speak but letting them decide; and when they have decided, he follows and obeys. When he writes to pastors, he doesn't command with the authority of a superior but makes them his colleagues and advises them courteously, as equals do (1 Pet. 5:1). When he is accused of having gone in to the Gentiles, though the accusation is groundless, he answers it and clears himself (Acts 11:3). When his colleagues send him with John to Samaria, he doesn't refuse (Acts 8:14). By sending him, the apostles show that they don't regard him as a superior; by obeying and undertaking the mission entrusted to him, he confesses that he is one of them and has no authority over them.
Even if none of this were so, the letter to the Galatians alone would remove all doubt, since nearly two chapters of it are devoted to proving that, in the honour of the apostleship, Paul is Peter's equal (Gal. 1:18; 2:8). He says he went to Peter not to acknowledge subjection but only to make their agreement in doctrine plain to all; that Peter himself asked for no such acknowledgment but gave him the right hand of fellowship, so that they might be fellow workers in the vineyard; that no less grace was given to him among the Gentiles than to Peter among the Jews; and finally that when Peter wasn't acting with strict integrity, Paul rebuked him, and Peter submitted to the rebuke (Gal. 2:11). All this makes it plain that either there was equality between Paul and Peter, or at least that Peter had no more authority over the others than they had over him. Paul argues this point expressly, as I've said, so that no one would rank Peter or John above him in the apostleship, since they were colleagues, not masters.
8. A special case is not a universal rule
Suppose I granted them what they ask about Peter, that he was chief of the apostles and surpassed the others in dignity. There would still be no ground for making a universal rule out of a particular example, or twisting a single fact into a permanent law, since the two things are very different. One man was chief among the apostles precisely because they were few. If one man presides over twelve, does it follow that one should preside over a hundred thousand? That twelve should have one among them to direct everything is nothing strange. Nature allows it and the human mind requires it that in any meeting, though all are equal in power, there should be one as a kind of moderator to whom the others look. There's no senate without a consul, no bench of judges without a president, no college without a head, no company without a master. So it would be no absurdity to admit that the apostles gave Peter such a primacy. But an arrangement that works among a few shouldn't be transferred at once to the whole world, which no one man can govern.
They say that it is observed that there is one supreme head in nature as a whole as well as in each of its parts, and they like to draw proof of this from cranes and bees, which always put themselves under the guidance of one leader, not several. I admit their examples. But do bees fly together from all over the world to choose one queen? Each queen is content with her own hive. Among cranes, each flock has its own leader. What can they prove from this except that each church ought to have its own bishop?
They refer us to the example of states, quoting Homer, "a rule of many is not good," and other passages from pagan writers in praise of monarchy. The answer is easy. Homer's Ulysses and others don't praise monarchy as though one person should govern the whole world. They mean that one kingdom doesn't admit two kings, and that power, as one poet puts it (Lucan 1), cannot bear a partner.
9. Christ is the only Head of the Church
Let it be as they like (though it is quite absurd), and suppose it were good and useful for the whole world to be under one monarchy. I still won't grant that the same should hold in the government of the Church. Her only Head is Christ, under whose rule we are all united to one another according to the order and form of government he himself has prescribed. They offer Christ a gross insult, then, when on this pretext they want one man to preside over the whole Church, since the Church can never be without a head, "even Christ, from whom the whole body, joined and held together by every joint with which it is equipped, when each part is working properly, makes the body grow so that it builds itself up in love" (Eph. 4:15-16).
See how all people, without exception, are placed in the body, while the honour and name of Head are left to Christ alone. See how each member is assigned a certain measure, a limited and finite function, while both the fullness of grace and the supreme power of government reside only in Christ.
I know the quibble they usually raise: that Christ is properly called the only Head because he alone reigns by his own authority and in his own name, but that nothing prevents what they call a second, ministerial head from being under him and acting as his deputy. This quibble can't help them until they first show that this office was ordained by Christ. For the apostle teaches that the whole service is spread through the members, while the power flows from one heavenly Head. Or, to put it more plainly: since Scripture testifies that Christ is Head and claims this honour for himself alone, it must not be transferred to anyone else except the one whom Christ himself has made his deputy. But not only is there no passage to that effect; many passages refute it.
10. Paul describes the Church and mentions no single head
Paul sometimes paints a living picture of the Church, yet makes no mention of a single head. On the contrary, we can infer from his description that such a head is foreign to Christ's institution. Christ, by his ascension, took his visible presence away from us, and yet he ascended "that he might fill all things." So he is now present in the Church, and always will be. When Paul wants to show the way in which Christ makes himself present, he points us to the ministerial offices that Christ uses: "grace was given to each one of us according to the measure of Christ's gift"; "he gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers" (Eph. 4:7, 10-11).
Why doesn't he say that one person presided over all to act as Christ's deputy? The passage particularly called for it, and it ought on no account to have been left out if it were true. Christ, he says, is present with us. How? Through the ministry of men whom he appointed over the government of the Church. Why not rather through a ministerial head appointed as his deputy? Paul speaks of unity, but it is a unity in God and in the faith of Christ. He attributes to human beings nothing but a common ministry and a particular manner of working to each. Why, in commending unity, does he not, after saying, "There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope that belongs to your call, one Lord, one faith, one baptism" (Eph. 4:4-5), go on immediately to add, "one Supreme Pontiff to keep the Church in unity"? Nothing could have been said more fittingly, if that had really been the case.
Let that passage be carefully weighed, and there will be no doubt that Paul meant to give a full picture of the holy church government to which later generations gave the name of hierarchy. Not only does he place no monarchy among the ministers; he intimates that there is none. And there is no doubt that he meant to express the way believers are joined to Christ the Head. He not only makes no mention of a ministerial head but assigns a particular working to each of the members according to the measure of grace given to each. Nor is there any room for subtle philosophical comparisons between the heavenly and the earthly hierarchy. It is not safe to be wise beyond measure about the former, and in setting up the latter the only pattern we should follow is the one our Lord himself has drawn in his own word.
11. Even if Peter had been the head, it would not follow that the Pope is
I now make them another concession, which they'll never get from sensible people: that the primacy of the Church was fixed in Peter in order to continue for ever by unbroken succession. How will they prove that his See was fixed at Rome, so that whoever becomes bishop of that city presides over the whole world? By what authority do they attach this dignity to a particular place, when it was given without any mention of place?
Peter, they say, lived and died at Rome. What did Christ himself do? Didn't he carry out his bishopric while he lived and complete the office of priest by dying at Jerusalem? The Prince of pastors, the chief Shepherd, the Head of the Church, couldn't win honour for a place, but Peter, so far his inferior, could? Isn't this worse than childish trifling? Christ gave the honour of primacy to Peter; Peter had his See at Rome; therefore he fixed the seat of the primacy there. By that reasoning the Israelites of old would have had to put the seat of primacy in the wilderness, where Moses, the chief teacher and prince of the prophets, carried out his ministry and died.
12. If it followed Peter's seat, the primacy would belong to Antioch
Let's see how admirably they argue. Peter, they say, held the first place among the apostles, so the church in which he sat should have the privilege. But where did he first sit? At Antioch, they say. So the church of Antioch rightly claims the primacy. They acknowledge that Antioch was once first, but say that Peter, by moving away, carried the honour with him to Rome. A letter is extant under the name of Pope Marcellus to the presbyters of Antioch, in which he says: "The See of Peter was at first with you, and was afterwards, by the Lord's command, moved here." So the church of Antioch, once first, gave way to the See of Rome.
But by what oracle did that good man learn that the Lord had so ordered? If the matter is to be settled in proper form, they must say whether they hold the privilege to be personal, or real, or mixed. It must be one of the three. If they say personal, it has nothing to do with place. If real, then once given to a place it isn't lost by the death or departure of the person. It remains that they must hold it to be mixed; then the consideration of place alone isn't enough unless the person also corresponds. Let them choose whichever they like, and I will immediately infer, and easily prove, that Rome has no ground to claim the primacy.
13. The absurdity of their reasoning
Still, grant it. Let the primacy have been transferred from Antioch to Rome, as they vainly claim. Why didn't Antioch keep second place? If Rome has first place simply because Peter had his See there at the end of his life, to which place should second go sooner than to the place where he first had his See? How is it that Alexandria takes precedence over Antioch? How can the church of a disciple outrank the See of Peter?
If honour is due to a church according to the dignity of its founder, what shall we say of other churches? Paul names three who seemed to be pillars: James, Peter and John (Gal. 2:9). If the Roman See is given first place in honour of Peter, don't the churches of Ephesus and Jerusalem, where John and James were settled, deserve second and third places? But in ancient times Jerusalem held the last place among the patriarchates, and Ephesus couldn't secure even the lowest corner. Other churches that Paul founded and over which the apostles presided have also passed away. The See of Mark, who was only one of the disciples, has obtained honour. Let them either confess that this arrangement was topsy-turvy, or concede that it is not always true that each church deserves the degree of honour its founder had.
14. Peter was not bishop of Rome for twenty-five years
I see no reason to credit their claim that Peter occupied the Roman See at all. Certainly Eusebius's statement that he presided there for twenty-five years is easily refuted. From Galatians 1 and 2 it appears that he was at Jerusalem about twenty years after Christ's death, and afterwards came to Antioch. How long he stayed there is uncertain: Gregory counts seven years, Eusebius twenty-five. But from our Saviour's death to the end of Nero's reign (under whom they say Peter was put to death) there are only thirty-seven years, since our Lord suffered in the eighteenth year of Tiberius. If you subtract the twenty years that Peter, as Paul testifies, spent at Jerusalem, at most seventeen remain, and these must be divided between his two bishoprics. If he lived long at Antioch, his See at Rome must have been short.
This can be shown even more clearly. Paul wrote to the Romans while on his way to Jerusalem, where he was arrested and taken to Rome (Rom. 15:15-16). The letter was therefore probably written about four years before his arrival at Rome. Yet there is no mention of Peter, as there certainly would have been if he had been ruling that church. Indeed, at the end of the letter, where Paul lists a long series of people he tells them to greet, and where we might suppose he includes everyone he knew, he says nothing at all about Peter. For people of sound judgment there is no need for a long, subtle demonstration. The nature of the case and the whole subject of the letter proclaim that Paul wouldn't have passed over Peter if he had been at Rome.
15. Paul in Rome never mentions Peter
Paul is afterwards brought as a prisoner to Rome. Luke relates that he was received by the brothers there, but says nothing of Peter. From Rome Paul writes to many churches. He even sends greetings from certain individuals, but doesn't hint by a single word that Peter was there at the time. Who will believe he would have said nothing about him if he had been present? In the letter to the Philippians, after saying that he has no one who cares for the Lord's work so faithfully as Timothy, he complains that "they all seek their own interests" (Phil. 2:21). And to Timothy he makes a still more serious complaint: that no one stood by him at his first defence, but all deserted him (2 Tim. 4:16). Where, then, was Peter? If they say he was at Rome, how disgraceful is the charge Paul brings against him, of being a deserter of the gospel! For Paul is speaking of believers, since he adds, "May it not be charged against them."
At what time, then, and for how long, did Peter hold that See? The general opinion of the authors is that he governed that church until his death. But they don't agree on who his successor was: some say Linus, others Clement. And they tell many absurd fables about a debate between Peter and Simon Magus. Augustine himself, writing about superstition, doesn't hide that, through a rashly held opinion, it had become the custom at Rome to fast on the day on which Peter carried off the palm from Simon Magus (Augustine, Letters 36). In short, the affairs of that period are so tangled by the variety of opinions that nothing we read about it should be believed rashly.
From the agreement of the authors, I don't dispute that Peter died there, but that he was bishop there, particularly for a long period, I can't believe. I don't attach great importance to the point, however, since Paul testifies that Peter's apostleship belonged especially to the Jews and his own especially to us. So, to keep firmly established among us the agreement they made between themselves, or rather the arrangement of the Holy Spirit, we ought to pay more regard to Paul's apostleship than to Peter's, since the Holy Spirit, in assigning them different provinces, destined Peter for the Jews and Paul for us. Let the Romanists seek their primacy somewhere other than in God's word, which gives no foundation for it at all.
16. Why the early Church honoured Rome
Let us now turn to the early Church, so that it may also appear that our opponents boast of its support no less falsely and rashly than of the witness of God's word. They lay it down as an axiom that the unity of the Church can't be maintained unless there is one supreme head on earth whom all the members must obey, and that our Lord therefore gave the primacy to Peter and then, by right of succession, to the See of Rome, to stay there to the end. They assert that this has been observed from the beginning.
Since they twist many passages, I'll begin by saying that I don't deny that the early Christians consistently showed high honour to the Roman Church and spoke of it with respect. This, I think, was due chiefly to three causes.
First, the opinion that prevailed (I don't know how) that this Church was founded and set in order by Peter's ministry had a great effect in winning it influence and authority. So in the East it was honoured with the title "the Apostolic See." Second, because the seat of the empire was there, it was reasonable to expect that the people most distinguished for learning, prudence, skill and experience would be there more than elsewhere. Account was rightly taken of this, so that the celebrity of the city and the far more excellent gifts of God might not seem to be despised. A third cause was added: when the churches of the East, of Greece and of Africa were kept in constant turmoil by differences of opinion, the Church of Rome was calmer and less troubled. So godly and holy bishops, driven out of their sees, often fled to Rome as to a refuge or harbour. The people of the West are less sharp and changeable in mind than those of Asia or Africa, and so less eager for innovations. It therefore gave the Roman Church very great authority that in those uncertain times it was not as unsettled as others and held more firmly to the doctrine once delivered, as I'll explain better shortly. For these three reasons, I say, it was held in no ordinary esteem and received many distinguished testimonies from ancient writers.
17. The early writers did not teach a primacy of Rome
Our opponents want to build a primacy and supreme authority over the other churches on this, and as I've said, they go badly wrong. To make this clearer, I'll briefly show what the early writers thought about this unity that they press so hard.
Jerome, writing to Nepotian, after listing many examples of unity, comes down at last to the church hierarchy. He says: "Every bishop of a church, every archpresbyter, every archdeacon, and the whole ecclesiastical order, depends on its own rulers." Here a Roman presbyter is speaking and commending unity in church order. Why doesn't he mention that all the churches are bound together by one Head as a common bond? Nothing would have been more to the point, and it can't be said he left it out through forgetfulness; there was nothing he would more gladly have mentioned if the fact had allowed. He therefore undoubtedly acknowledges that the true method of unity is the one Cyprian admirably describes in these words:
"The episcopate is one, a part of which is held in its entirety by each bishop; and the Church is one, which by increasing fruitfulness extends more widely into a multitude. As there are many rays of the sun but one light, many branches of a tree but one trunk upheld by its clinging root, and as very many streams flow from one spring, and though the numbers seem spread out by the largeness of the overflowing supply, yet unity is preserved whole in the source, so the Church, flooded with the Lord's light, sends her rays over the whole globe, and yet it is one light that is everywhere diffused, without dividing the unity of the body. She stretches her branches over the whole globe and sends forth flowing streams; still the head is one, and the source one" (Cyprian, On the Unity of the Church). Afterwards he says: "The bride of Christ cannot be an adulteress; she knows one house, and with chaste modesty keeps the sanctity of one bed."
See how he makes the bishopric of Christ alone universal, as including under it the whole Church. See how he says that a part of it is held in its entirety by all who carry out the episcopal office under this Head. Where is the primacy of the Roman See, if the whole bishopric resides in Christ alone and a part of it is held in its entirety by each?
My purpose in these remarks is to show the reader, in passing, that the axiom of an earthly unity in the hierarchy, which the Romanists assume as confessed and beyond doubt, was entirely unknown to the early Church.
Chapter 7
The Beginning and Rise of the Roman Papacy, Until It Reached a Height That Destroyed the Church's Liberty and Overthrew All True Order
1. Nicaea and the early councils: one of the chief bishops, not head of all
As to the antiquity of the Roman See's primacy, nothing in favour of it is older than the decree of the Council of Nicaea, which gives the Bishop of Rome the first place among the patriarchs and tells him to look after the churches near the city. In dividing authority between him and the other patriarchs and fixing each one's limits, the council certainly doesn't appoint him head of all, only one of the chief.
Vitus and Vincentius attended on behalf of Julius, who then governed the Roman Church, and they were given the fourth place. I ask: if Julius had been recognised as head of the Church, would his delegates have been put fourth? Would Athanasius have presided at a council where the representative of the supreme order ought to have been most prominent?
At the Council of Ephesus, Celestine, then bishop of Rome, used a clever device to protect his See's dignity. When he sent his delegates, he made Cyril of Alexandria, who would otherwise have presided, his own deputy. Why that commission, except to link his name with the first See? His delegates sit in a lower place, are asked their opinion along with the others and sign in their turn, while his name is coupled with that of the patriarch of Alexandria.
What of the second Council of Ephesus, where Leo's delegates were present but Dioscorus, patriarch of Alexandria, presided as of right? They'll object that it wasn't an orthodox council, since it condemned the venerable Flavian, acquitted Eutyches and approved his heresy. Yet when the council met and the bishops divided the seats among themselves, the Roman Church's delegates sat among the others as in a holy and lawful council. They didn't contend for first place but yielded it to another. They would never have done this if they'd thought it theirs by right. The Roman bishops were never ashamed to stir up the greatest strife over honours, and for no other reason to trouble and harass the Church with many destructive contests. But because Leo saw it would be too outrageous to demand first place for his delegates, he left it alone.
2. Chalcedon was a special case
Next came the Council of Chalcedon, where, by the emperor's concession, the Roman Church's delegates held first place. But Leo himself admits this was an extraordinary privilege. When he asked it of the emperor Marcian and the empress Pulcheria, he didn't claim it was due to him; he only argued that the Eastern bishops who had presided at Ephesus had thrown everything into confusion and misused their power. Since a serious moderator was needed, and it wasn't likely that those who had once been so unstable and unruly would be fit for the task, he asked that, because of the fault and unfitness of the others, the role of directing be transferred to him.
What is asked as a special privilege, outside the usual order, is certainly not owed by common law. When the only plea is that a new president is needed because the previous ones behaved badly, it is plain that the thing asked had not been done before and ought not to be made permanent, being done only because of present danger. The Roman pontiff held first place at Chalcedon, then, not because it was due to his See, but because the council needed a serious and capable moderator, while those who ought to have presided disqualified themselves by their intemperance and passion.
Leo's successor confirmed this by his conduct. When he sent his delegates to the fifth council, that of Constantinople, held long afterwards, he didn't quarrel over the first seat but readily allowed Mennas, patriarch of Constantinople, to preside. Likewise at the Council of Carthage, which Augustine attended, we see that not the legates of the Roman See but Aurelius, the archbishop of the place, presided, although the authority of the Roman pontiff was then in question. Even in Italy itself a universal council was held, at Aquileia, at which the Roman bishop wasn't present. Ambrose, then in high favour with the emperor, presided, and the Roman pontiff isn't mentioned. Because of Ambrose's standing, the See of Milan was then more distinguished than Rome's.
3. The titles of pride crept in later
As for the bare title of "primate" and the other titles of pride the pontiff now boasts of, it isn't hard to see how they crept in. Cyprian often mentions Cornelius and calls him by no name but brother, fellow bishop or colleague. When he writes to Stephen, Cornelius's successor, he not only makes him equal to himself and the rest, but addresses him sharply, charging him at one time with presumption and at another with ignorance.
After Cyprian we have the judgment of the whole African Church. The Council of Carthage ordered that no one should be called chief of the priests or first bishop, but only bishop of the first See. Anyone who examines the older records will find that the Roman pontiff was then content with the common title of brother. Certainly, as long as the Church kept its true and pure form, all these names of pride that the Roman See later began to boast of were unheard of; no one knew what was meant by supreme pontiff and sole head of the Church on earth. If the Roman bishop had presumed to take any such title, there were upright men who would at once have checked his folly.
Jerome, being a Roman presbyter, was not slow to proclaim the dignity of his church, as far as facts and the times allowed, and yet we see how he keeps it in due subordination: "If authority is wanted, the world is greater than a city. Why do you hold up to me the custom of one city? Why defend a few, among whom pride has arisen against the laws of the Church? Wherever the bishop is, whether at Rome, or Gubbio, or Constantinople, or Reggio, he has the same merit and the same priesthood. The power of wealth and the lowliness of poverty don't make a bishop higher or lower" (Jerome, Letter to Evagrius).
4. Gregory against the title "universal bishop"
The controversy over the title "universal bishop" arose in Gregory's time, occasioned by the ambition of John of Constantinople, who wanted to make himself universal, something no one had ever tried. In that controversy Gregory doesn't claim he is being deprived of a right belonging to him. He insists strongly that the title is profane, indeed blasphemous, indeed the forerunner of Antichrist: "The whole Church falls from its state if he who is called universal falls" (Gregory, Letters 4.76). Again: "It is very hard to bear patiently that one who is our brother and fellow bishop should alone be called bishop while all the others are despised. But what else does this pride of his suggest but that the days of Antichrist are already near? For he is imitating the one who, despising the company of angels, tried to climb to the summit of greatness."
He says elsewhere to Eulogius of Alexandria and Anastasius of Antioch: "None of my predecessors ever wanted to use this profane term. For if one patriarch is called universal, it detracts from the name of patriarch in the others. But far be it from any Christian mind to want to claim for itself what would in the slightest degree diminish the honour of its brothers" (4.80). "To consent to that impious term is nothing less than to lose the faith" (4.83). "What we owe to preserving the unity of the faith is one thing; what we owe to suppressing pride is another. I speak with confidence, for everyone who calls himself, or wants to be called, universal priest is by his pride a forerunner of Antichrist, because he acts proudly in setting himself above the others" (7.154).
When Gregory writes that this honour was offered to Leo at the Council of Chalcedon, he says something with no appearance of truth; nothing of the kind is found in the council's acts. Leo himself, who in many letters attacks the decree made there in honour of the See of Constantinople, would certainly not have omitted this most plausible argument if it were true that he had refused what was offered him. Gregory is mistaken in saying that Chalcedon conferred the title on the Roman See, not to mention how ridiculous it is to say it came from that holy council and yet call it wicked, profane, nefarious, proud and blasphemous, indeed devised by the devil and announced by the herald of Antichrist. He adds that his predecessor refused it, so that by what was given to one person, all priests would not lose their due honour. In another place he says: "No one ever wanted to be called by such a name; no one claimed this rash title for himself, lest by seizing the honour of supremacy in the pontificate he should seem to deny it to all his brothers" (4.82).
5. How the Roman See gained influence: exiles and appeals
I come now to jurisdiction, which the Roman pontiff claims as a certain fact over all churches. I know there were great disputes about this in ancient times, for there was never a time when the Roman See didn't aim at authority over other churches. It's worth briefly investigating the means by which she gradually gained some influence. I'm not speaking of the unlimited power she seized at a fairly recent date; I'll deal with that in its place. But it is worth showing how she formerly raised herself so as to claim some authority over other churches.
When the Eastern churches were troubled and torn by the Arian factions under the emperors Constantius and Constans, sons of Constantine the Great, and Athanasius, the chief defender of orthodoxy, had been driven from his see, the calamity forced him to come to Rome, so that by the authority of that See he might check his enemies' rage and strengthen the orthodox in their distress. He was honourably received by Julius, then bishop, who persuaded the Western bishops to take up his cause. So when the orthodox badly needed outside help and saw their chief protection lay in the Roman See, they gladly gave it all the authority they could. At most, though, this meant that its communion was highly valued and it was thought disgraceful to be excommunicated by it.
Dishonest bad men later added much to its authority, because when they wanted to escape lawful tribunals, they took refuge at Rome. If a presbyter was condemned by his bishop, or a bishop by his provincial synod, he appealed to Rome. The Roman bishops received these appeals more eagerly than they should have, because it seemed a kind of extraordinary power to step into matters so remote from them. So when Eutyches was condemned by Flavian, bishop of Constantinople, he complained to Leo that the sentence was unjust. Leo, nothing loath, took up a bad cause with more presumption than discretion and attacked Flavian bitterly for condemning an innocent man without proper investigation. The result of Leo's ambition was that for a time Eutyches's impiety was strengthened.
The same thing certainly happened repeatedly in Africa: whenever any scoundrel had been condemned by his own judge, he fled to Rome and brought many slanderous charges against his own people. The Roman See was always ready to step in. This dishonesty forced the African bishops to decree that no one should appeal across the sea, on pain of excommunication.
6. The Roman bishop's authority to ordain: confined to his own patriarchate
However that may be, let's consider what right or authority the Roman See then possessed. Church power may be reduced to four heads: the ordination of bishops, the calling of councils, the hearing of appeals (or jurisdiction), and the giving of warnings or censures.
All the ancient councils require that bishops be ordained by their own metropolitans; they nowhere require application to the Roman bishop, except in his own patriarchate. Gradually, though, it became customary for all Italian bishops to go to Rome for consecration, except the metropolitans, who wouldn't allow themselves to be brought into subjection in this way. When a metropolitan was to be ordained, the Roman bishop sent one of his presbyters merely to attend, not to preside. We have an example in Gregory, in the consecration of Constantius of Milan after the death of Laurence (Gregory, Letters 2.68, 70). I don't think this was a very ancient custom. At first, as a mark of respect and goodwill, they sent delegates to one another to witness ordinations and attest their fellowship. What was done voluntarily afterwards began to be treated as necessary. In any case, it's certain that anciently the Roman bishop had no power to ordain except within the bounds of his own patriarchate, that is, as a canon of Nicaea puts it, in the "suburban" churches.
To ordination was added the sending of a synodical letter, but this implied no authority. The patriarchs were accustomed, immediately after consecration, to attest their faith in a formal document declaring that they agreed with the holy and orthodox councils. In rendering an account of their faith they mutually approved one another. If the Roman bishop had received this confession from others without giving it, he would have been acknowledged as superior in that. But since he had to give as well as receive, and be subject to the common law, this was a sign of equality, not lordship. We have an example in a letter of Gregory to Anastasius and Cyriac of Constantinople, and in another to all the patriarchs together (Gregory, Letters 1.24, 25; 6.169).
7. Admonitions and censures went both ways
Next come admonitions or censures. The Roman bishops anciently used these towards others, and received them in their turn. Irenaeus sharply rebuked Victor for rashly troubling the Church with a harmful schism over a matter of no importance, and Victor submitted without objection. Holy bishops then felt free, as brothers, to warn and rebuke the Roman prelate when he went wrong. He in turn reminded others of their duty when the case called for it, and reprimanded them for their faults.
When Cyprian urges Stephen to admonish the bishops of France, he doesn't base it on Stephen's larger power but on the common right that priests have in regard to one another (Cyprian, Letters 3.13). If Stephen had then presided over France, wouldn't Cyprian have said, "Rein them in, for they are yours"? But his language is very different: "The brotherly fellowship that binds us together requires that we admonish one another." And we see with what sharpness of language a man otherwise of mild temper attacks Stephen himself when he thinks him guilty of insolence. So it doesn't yet appear that in this respect the Roman bishop had any jurisdiction over those outside his province.
8. Calling councils belonged to the emperor
As for calling councils, it was the duty of every metropolitan to assemble a provincial synod at fixed times. Here the Roman bishop had no jurisdiction, while only the emperor could summon a general council. If any bishop had tried to do so, not only would those outside his province not have obeyed the summons, but an uproar would have arisen at once. That is why the emperor gave notice to all alike to attend.
Socrates does relate that Julius complained to the Eastern bishops for not calling him to the Council of Antioch, since the canons forbade anything to be decided without the Roman bishop's knowledge. But who doesn't see that this is to be understood of decrees binding the whole Church? And it's no surprise if, out of respect for the antiquity and size of the city and the dignity of the see, no universal decree about religion was made in the Roman bishop's absence, provided he didn't refuse to attend. But what has this to do with ruling the whole Church? We don't deny that he was one of the principal bishops; we only refuse to admit what the Romanists now contend for, that he had power over all.
9. Appeals to Rome rejected by France and Africa; forged documents
The fourth remaining kind of power is that of hearing appeals. The supreme power clearly belongs to the one to whose tribunal appeals are made. Many had repeatedly appealed to the Roman pontiff. He too had tried to bring cases under his cognisance, but whenever he went beyond his own bounds he was always rebuffed. I say nothing of the East and Greece, but it's certain that the bishops of France stoutly resisted when he seemed to claim authority over them.
In Africa the matter was long disputed. At the Council of Milevum, which Augustine attended, those who carried appeals overseas were excommunicated. The Roman pontiff tried to get the decree changed and sent delegates to show that the privilege of hearing appeals had been given him by the Council of Nicaea. The delegates produced council records drawn from their own church's archive. The African bishops resisted, maintaining that the Roman bishop should not be trusted in his own cause. They said they would send to Constantinople and other Greek cities, where less suspect copies could be had. It was found that nothing like what the Romanists claimed was in the records, and so the decree abolishing the Roman pontiff's supreme jurisdiction was confirmed.
This episode shows the Roman pontiff's remarkable effrontery. He had fraudulently substituted the Council of Sardica for that of Nicaea and was shamefully caught in an obvious falsehood. Still greater and more shameless was the wickedness of those who added a forged letter to the council's acts, in which a certain bishop of Carthage condemns the arrogance of his predecessor Aurelius for promising to withdraw from obedience to the Apostolic See, and, surrendering himself and his church, humbly begs pardon. These are the fine records of antiquity on which the majesty of the Roman See rests; under the pretext of antiquity they deal in falsehoods so childish that even a blind man could feel them. "Aurelius," it says, "swollen with devilish daring and obstinacy, rebelled against Christ and St Peter, and so deserved to be anathematised." What does Augustine say about that? What do the many fathers present at Milevum say? But why refute at length so absurd a document, which even Romanists, if they have any modesty left, can't look at without deep shame?
Gratian, whether from malice or ignorance I don't know, after quoting the decree that those who carry appeals overseas are to be deprived of communion, adds the exception "unless, perhaps, they have appealed to the Roman See." What can you make of creatures so devoid of common sense that they list as an exception to the law the very thing for which, as everyone sees, the law was made? In condemning appeals overseas the council was simply forbidding appeal to Rome, yet this worthy interpreter exempts Rome from the common law.
10. The case of Caecilian shows what Rome's jurisdiction really was
To settle the question at once, one story will show what kind of jurisdiction the Roman bishop had. Donatus of Casae Nigrae had accused Caecilian, bishop of Carthage. Caecilian was condemned without a hearing, since he knew the bishops had conspired against him and refused to appear. The case was brought before the emperor Constantine, who, wanting it settled by a church decision, gave it to Miltiades, the Roman bishop, appointing as his colleagues some bishops from Italy, France and Spain.
If hearing appeals in church cases belonged to the ordinary jurisdiction of the Roman See, why did he allow others to be joined with him at the emperor's pleasure? Why did he take up the decision more on the emperor's command than by virtue of his own office? But let's see what happened next (Augustine, Letters 162, and elsewhere). Caecilian prevails. Donatus is defeated in his slanderous suit and appeals. Constantine hands the decision of the appeal to the bishop of Arles, who sits as judge to give sentence after the Roman pontiff. If the Roman See has supreme power not subject to appeal, why does Miltiades allow himself to be so insulted as to have the bishop of Arles preferred to him? And who is the emperor who does this? Constantine, who they boast made it his constant study, and used all the resources of the empire, to enlarge that See's dignity.
We see, then, how far the Roman pontiff was in every way from that supreme dominion which he claims was given him by Christ over all churches, and which he falsely alleges he held in every age with the consent of the whole world.
11. Forged decretals and Leo's vicars
I know how many letters, rescripts and edicts there are in which the pontiffs ascribe to themselves everything and confidently claim it. But everyone with a little intelligence and learning knows that most of them are so absurd in themselves that it's easy to spot at first glance the forge they came from. Does any sensible, sober person think Anacletus wrote that famous interpretation that appears in Gratian under his name, that "Cephas" means "head"? The Romanists of today use against us numerous follies of this kind which Gratian heaped together without judgment. The smoke with which, in former days of ignorance, they fooled the ignorant, they still try to sell in today's light. I don't want to take much trouble refuting things whose extreme absurdity refutes them.
I admit that genuine letters of ancient pontiffs exist in which they make grand claims for the reach of their see. Some of Leo's are like this: as he had learning and eloquence, he was also excessively eager for glory and dominion. But the real question is whether the churches believed his testimony when he praised himself in this way. It appears that many were offended by his ambition and also resisted his greed.
In one place he appoints the bishop of Thessalonica his vicar throughout Greece and neighbouring regions (Leo, Letters 85); elsewhere he gives the same office to the bishop of Arles, or someone else, for France (Letters 83). Likewise he appointed Hormisdas, bishop of Seville, his vicar throughout Spain. But he always makes this reservation, that in giving such commissions the ancient privileges of the metropolitans were to stay safe and whole. These appointments were made on the condition that no bishop be hindered in his ordinary jurisdiction, no metropolitan in taking cognisance of appeals, no provincial council in setting up churches. What was this but to disclaim all jurisdiction and step in only to settle quarrels, so far as the law and nature of church fellowship allow?
12. Gregory's time: more influence, still not dominion
In Gregory's time that ancient rule changed greatly. The empire was convulsed and torn; France and Spain were suffering from many disasters; Illyricum was laid waste, Italy harassed and Africa almost destroyed by unbroken calamities. So that during these upheavals the integrity of the faith might survive, or at least not perish entirely, the bishops everywhere attached themselves more closely to the Roman pontiff. In this way the see's dignity, and also its power, increased greatly, though I don't attach much weight to the means by which this came about. It is certain that it was then greater than in earlier ages. Yet it was very different from the unbridled dominion of one man ruling others as he pleased.
Still, the reverence given to the Roman See was such that by its authority it could guide and restrain those whom their own colleagues could not keep to their duty. Gregory takes care to testify, again and again, that he was no less faithful in preserving the rights of others than in insisting that his own be preserved: "I do not, from ambition, take away from anyone's right, but I desire to honour my brothers in all things" (Gregory, Letters 2.68). There is no sentence in his writings in which he boasts more proudly of the extent of his primacy than this: "I do not know what bishop is not subject to the Roman See, when he is found at fault." But he adds at once: "Where faults do not call for interference, all are equal according to the rule of humility." He claims the right to correct those who have sinned; if all do their duty, he puts himself on a level with them.
He did claim this right, and those who wished agreed to it, while those who didn't like it were free to object with impunity; it is known that most did. We may add that he is speaking there of the bishop of Constantinople, who, when condemned by a provincial synod, rejected the whole judgment. His colleagues had informed the emperor of his stubbornness, and the emperor gave the matter to Gregory. We see, then, that Gregory doesn't interfere with ordinary jurisdiction at all, and that, in acting as a backstop to others, he acts entirely at the emperor's command.
13. Even this influence weighed on Gregory
At this time, then, the whole power of the Roman bishop consisted in opposing stubborn and unmanageable spirits where some extraordinary remedy was needed, and this in order to help other bishops, not to interfere with them. So he claims no more power over others than he elsewhere grants others over himself, when he says he's ready to be corrected and amended by all (Gregory, Letters 2.37). In another place, though he orders the bishop of Aquileia to come to Rome to plead his cause in a doctrinal dispute with others, he does so not on his own authority but in obedience to the emperor's command. He doesn't say that he himself will be the only judge; he promises to call a synod to settle the whole matter.
Though the moderation was still such that the Roman See's power had limits it wasn't allowed to cross, and the Roman bishop was no more above others than under them, it appears how dissatisfied Gregory was with this state of things. He complains again and again that under the cover of the episcopate he was dragged back into the world and was more tangled in earthly cares than when he lived as a layman; that in that honourable office he was crushed by the tumult of secular business. Elsewhere he says: "So many burdensome occupations press on me that my mind cannot rise at all to things above. I am shaken by the many waves of cases, and when they are calmed, I am troubled by the storms of a tumultuous life, so that I may truly say, 'I have come into the depths of the sea, and the flood has overwhelmed me.'"
From this I infer what he would have said had he lived in our times. If he didn't fulfil the pastor's duty perfectly, at least he did it. He declined the administration of civil power and acknowledged that he, like others, was subject to the emperor. He didn't meddle with the management of other churches unless forced by necessity. And still he thought himself in a labyrinth, because he couldn't give himself entirely to the duty of a bishop.
14. Constantinople and Rome: the order of sees followed the order of the empire
At that time, as I've said, the bishop of Constantinople was disputing the primacy with the bishop of Rome. After the seat of empire was fixed at Constantinople, the majesty of the empire seemed to demand that that church should hold the next place of honour after Rome's. And certainly, from the beginning, nothing had done more to give Rome the primacy than that it was then the capital of the empire.
In Gratian (Distinction 80) there is a rescript under the name of Pope Lucius to the effect that the only way the cities where metropolitans and primates should preside were distinguished was by the civil government that had previously existed there. There is a similar rescript under the name of Pope Clement, saying that patriarchs were appointed in the cities that had previously had the chief priests of the pagan cults. Though that is absurd, it was borrowed from something true. It's certain that, to keep change to a minimum, provinces were divided according to the existing state of affairs, and primates and metropolitans were placed in the cities that surpassed the rest in honour and power.
So the Council of Turin decreed that the cities in each province that were first in civil government should be the first sees of bishops, and that if the honour of civil government moved from one city to another, the right of the metropolis should move there too. But the Roman pontiff Innocent, seeing that the ancient dignity of the city had been declining ever since the seat of empire was moved to Constantinople, and fearing for his see, enacted the opposite, denying that metropolitan churches must change as imperial capital cities change. But the authority of a synod is rightly preferred to one man's opinion, and Innocent himself is to be suspected, being a party to the case. Whatever the truth, his warning itself shows that the original rule was for metropolitans to be distributed according to the order of the empire.
15. Leo's protest against Constantinople's rank
In keeping with this ancient custom, the first Council of Constantinople decreed that the bishop of that city should rank next after the Roman pontiff, because it was a "new Rome." Long afterwards, when a similar decree was made at Chalcedon, Leo protested fiercely. Not only did he allow himself to disregard what six hundred bishops or more had decreed, he even assailed them with bitter reproaches for taking honour from other sees by what they had presumed to confer on the Church of Constantinople.
What could have driven the man to disturb the world over so small a matter but sheer ambition? He says that what the Council of Nicaea had once sanctioned ought to be inviolable, as if the Christian faith were in danger if one church were preferred to another, or as if separate patriarchates had been set up on any grounds other than practical arrangement. We know that arrangement changes with the times, indeed requires various changes. It is futile for Leo to claim that the See of Constantinople ought not to receive the honour that Nicaea gave to Alexandria. Common sense says that this was one of those decrees that could be repealed as times changed.
And what shall we say of the fact that none of the Eastern churches, though chiefly affected, objected? Proterius, who had been appointed at Alexandria in place of Dioscorus, was certainly present; other patriarchs whose honour was reduced were present. It was for them to object, not for Leo, whose rank remained untouched. Since they were all silent, and many consented, while the Roman bishop alone resisted, it is easy to judge what moved him: he foresaw what happened not long afterwards, that when the glory of old Rome declined, Constantinople, not content with second place, would dispute the primacy with her. Yet his protests weren't successful enough to prevent the council's decree from being ratified. His successors, seeing themselves defeated, quietly dropped the quarrel and let the bishop of Constantinople be counted as the second patriarch.
16. John of Constantinople and Gregory's refusal of the title
Soon afterwards John, who presided over the church of Constantinople in Gregory's time, went so far as to call himself universal patriarch. Gregory, not to fail his See in a most excellent cause, constantly opposed him. It was impossible to tolerate John's pride and madness in wanting to make the limits of his bishopric equal to the limits of the empire. What Gregory denies to another, he doesn't claim for himself, but detests the title in anyone's mouth as wicked, impious and nefarious. He is even offended with Eulogius, bishop of Alexandria, who had honoured him with it: "Look at the address of the letter you sent me. Although I forbade you, you took care to write a word of proud meaning, calling me 'Universal Pope.' What I ask is that your holiness go no further, because whatever is given to another beyond what reason demands is taken from you. I do not count as honour that by which I see the honour of my brothers reduced. For my honour is the honour of the whole Church and the full prerogative of my brothers. If your holiness calls me Universal Pope, you deny yourself to be what you acknowledge me to be as a whole" (Gregory, Letters 8.30).
Gregory's cause was good and honourable. But John, backed by the favour of the emperor Maurice, couldn't be dissuaded from his purpose, and Cyriac, his successor, never allowed anyone to speak to him about it.
17. Phocas and Boniface; Pepin and Zachary
At length Phocas, who had murdered Maurice and seized his throne, was more friendly to the Romans (for what reason I don't know, or rather because he'd been crowned king there without opposition). He granted to Boniface III what Gregory by no means asked: that Rome should be the head of all the churches. In this way the controversy ended.
Even so, this kindness of the emperor to the Romans would have counted for little had other circumstances not followed. Soon afterwards Greece and all Asia were cut off from the Roman pontiff's communion, while the respect he received from France amounted to obedience only so far as France pleased. France was first brought under subjection when Pepin got possession of the throne. Zachary, the Roman pontiff, had helped him in his treachery and robbery when he expelled the lawful sovereign and seized a kingdom that lay exposed like prey, and Zachary was rewarded by having the Roman See's jurisdiction established over the churches of France. As robbers divide the common plunder, those two worthies arranged that Pepin would have the worldly and civil power by robbing the true prince, while Zachary would become head of all the bishops and have the spiritual power. This, though weak at first (as new power usually is), was afterwards confirmed by Charlemagne's authority for a very similar reason, since he too was indebted to the Roman pontiff, whose zeal had won him the honour of the empire.
There is reason to believe that the churches had been greatly changed before this, but it is certain that the ancient form of the Church was then completely wiped out in Gaul and Germany. Brief commentaries on those times are still extant among the archives of the Parliament of Paris, mentioning the agreements both of Pepin and of Charlemagne with the Roman pontiff. From this we may infer that the ancient state of things was changed then.
18. The tyranny established; Bernard's lament
From that time, while everything everywhere was growing worse, the tyranny of the Roman bishop was established and kept increasing, partly through the bishops' ignorance and partly through their sluggishness. While he claimed everything for himself and exalted himself more and more without measure, against law and right, the bishops didn't exert themselves as they should have to curb his pretensions. Even if they had lacked no spirit, they lacked true doctrine and experience, and so were not fit for so great an effort.
We see how great and monstrous was the profanation of everything sacred and the breakdown of the whole church order at Rome in Bernard's age. He complains (On Consideration, to Eugenius) that the ambitious, the greedy, the demon-possessed, the sacrilegious, fornicators, incestuous people and similar scoundrels flocked from all over the world to Rome to gain or keep church honours by apostolic authority; that fraud, trickery and violence prevailed. The way cases were then judged he describes as execrable, as disgraceful not only to the Church but to the law courts. He exclaims that the Church is full of the ambitious and that no one is more afraid to commit crimes than robbers in their den dividing the spoils of a traveller.
"Few look to the mouth of the lawgiver," he says, "but all to his hands. Not without reason, for it is their hands that do all the Pope's business. What sort of thing is it when those who say to you, 'Well done, well done,' are bought with the spoils of the Church? The life of the poor is scattered in the streets of the rich; silver glitters in the mud; people run together from every side; it isn't the poorer who picks it up, but the stronger, or perhaps the one who runs fastest. But that custom, or rather that death, doesn't come from you; I wish it might end with you. While these things go on, you, a pastor, come out wearing much costly clothing. If I may presume to say it, this is more the pasture of demons than of sheep. Peter, no doubt, did this; Paul played at this! Your court has been more used to receiving good men than to making them. The bad don't gain much there, but the good become corrupted."
When he goes on to describe the abuses of appeals, no godly person can read it without horror. Finally, speaking of the Roman See's unbridled greed in seizing jurisdiction, he concludes (On Consideration 3): "I voice the murmur and common complaint of the churches. Their cry is that they are maimed and dismembered. There are none, or very few, who do not lament or fear this plague. Do you ask what plague? Abbots are encroached on by bishops, bishops by archbishops, and so on. It is strange if this can be excused. By acting this way you prove that you have the fullness of power, but not the fullness of righteousness. You do it because you can; whether you also ought to is the question. You are appointed to preserve, not to envy, the honour and rank of each." I have quoted these few passages from many, partly so my readers may see how grievously the Church had then fallen, and partly so they may see with what grief and lamentation all godly people watched this calamity.
19. What today's Papacy claims is far beyond even those times
Even if we granted the Roman pontiff of today the eminence and range of jurisdiction his see had in the middle period, as in the time of Leo and Gregory, what would that be compared with the Papacy as it now exists? I'm not speaking of worldly dominion or civil power, which I'll explain in its place (chapter 11, sections 8-14). But what resemblance is there between the spiritual government they boast of and the state of those times?
The only definition they give of the Pope is that he is the supreme head of the Church on earth and the universal bishop of the whole globe. The pontiffs themselves, speaking of their authority, declare with great loftiness that the power of command belongs to them, that the necessity of obedience falls on others, that all their decrees are to be regarded as confirmed by the divine voice of Peter, that provincial synods lack authority because the Pope is not present, that they can ordain the clergy of any church and summon to their See anyone ordained elsewhere. Countless things of this kind are in Gratian's jumble, which I don't mention, to avoid wearying my readers. The sum is that the Roman pontiff holds the supreme cognisance of all church matters, whether in defining doctrine, making laws, appointing discipline or giving sentences. It would also be tedious and unnecessary to review the privileges they claim in what they call "reservations."
But the most intolerable thing of all is that they leave no judicial authority in the world to restrain and curb them when they abuse their immense power without restraint. "No one," they say, "may alter the judgment of this See, because of the primacy of the Roman Church." Again: "The judge shall not be judged, either by the emperor, or by kings, or by the clergy, or by the people." It is surely domineering enough for one man to appoint himself judge of all while refusing to submit to the judgment of anyone. But what if he tyrannises the people of God? If he scatters and lays waste Christ's kingdom? If he throws the whole Church into turmoil? If he turns the pastoral office into robbery? Even if he were the most depraved of all, he insists that no one can call him to account. The pontiffs' language is: "God has been pleased to end the cases of other men by men, but the prelate of this See he has reserved, unquestioned, for his own judgment." Again: "The deeds of subjects are judged by us; ours by God alone."
20. Forged authorities and the axioms that follow
So that such decrees would carry more weight, they falsely put the names of ancient pontiffs on them, as though things had been so arranged from the beginning, whereas it is absolutely certain that whatever gives the pontiff more than we've said the ancient councils gave him is new and of recent fabrication. They have carried their effrontery so far as to publish a rescript under the name of Anastasius, patriarch of Constantinople, testifying that ancient regulations ordered that nothing be done in the remotest provinces without first being referred to the Roman See. Besides its extreme folly, who could believe that such a tribute to the Roman See came from an opponent and rival of its honour and dignity? But no doubt it was necessary for those Antichrists to reach such a pitch of madness and blindness, so that their wickedness would be plain to all sound-minded people who simply open their eyes.
The decretal letters collected by Gregory IX, and also the Clementines and Martin's Extravagants, breathe an even plainer and more bombastic savagery, like the tyranny of barbarian kings. Yet these are the oracles by which the Romanists would have their Papacy judged. From them have sprung the famous axioms that carry the force of oracles throughout the Papacy today: that the Pope cannot err; that the Pope is above councils; that the Pope is the universal bishop of all churches and the chief Head of the Church on earth. I say nothing of the still greater absurdities babbled by foolish canonists in their schools, absurdities that Roman theologians not only accept but applaud, flattering their idol.
21. Gregory himself refutes these claims
I won't press them on the strictest terms. Against their great insolence some might quote what Cyprian said to the bishops at the council he chaired: "None of us sets himself up as bishop of bishops, or forces his colleagues to obey by the tyranny of terror." Some might object what was decreed long after at Carthage: "Let no one be called prince of priests or first bishop." They might gather many proofs from history, canons from councils, and many passages from ancient writers that put the Roman pontiff in his proper place. But I leave these out so as not to seem to press them too hard.
Still, let these worthy defenders of the Roman See tell me with what face they can defend the title "universal bishop" when they see it so often condemned by Gregory. If his testimony counts, then in making their pontiff universal they declare him to be Antichrist. The title "head" wasn't any more acceptable to him. Gregory says: "Peter was the chief member in the body; John, Andrew and James were heads of particular communities. All, however, are members of the Church under one head. Indeed the saints before the law, the saints under the law, the saints under grace, all making up the Lord's body, are constituted members; none of them ever wanted to be called universal" (Gregory, Letters 4.83).
When the pontiff claims the power of command, he agrees little with what Gregory says elsewhere. Eulogius, bishop of Alexandria, had said he'd received an order from him, and Gregory replies: "I beg you to take this word 'order' out of my hearing, for I know who I am and who you are: in rank you are my brothers, in character my fathers. I did not order, therefore, but took care to suggest what seemed useful" (7.80). When the Pope extends his jurisdiction without limit, he does great and heinous wrong not only to other bishops but to each single church, tearing and dismembering them to build his see on their ruins. When he exempts himself from all tribunals and wants to reign as a tyrant, holding his own whim as his only law, the thing is too insulting and too foreign to church order to be submitted to on any account. It is abhorrent not only to godly feeling but even to common sense.
22. The Papacy now is a hundred times worse than in Gregory's and Bernard's day
So as not to be forced to discuss each point singly, I appeal again to those who today want to be thought the best and most faithful defenders of the Roman See: are they not ashamed to defend the present state of the Papacy, which is clearly a hundred times more corrupt than it was in the days of Gregory and Bernard, though even then these holy men were so displeased with it?
Gregory complains everywhere (Letters 1.5, 7, 25 and elsewhere) that he was pulled apart by outside occupations; that under the cover of the episcopate he was taken back into the world and was subject to more worldly cares than he remembered having had as a layman; that he was so crushed by the trouble of secular affairs that he couldn't lift his mind to things above; that he was tossed by so many waves of cases and afflicted by the storms of a tumultuous life that he might well say, "I have come into the depths of the sea." It is certain that amid these worldly occupations he could still teach the people in sermons, admonish in private and correct those who needed it, order the Church, give counsel to his colleagues and urge them to their duty. There was even some time left for writing. And yet he mourns it as his calamity that he was plunged into the deepest sea.
If the administration then was a sea, what shall we say of the Papacy now? What resemblance is there between the two periods? Now there are no sermons, no care for discipline, no zeal for churches, no spiritual function, nothing in short but the world. And yet this labyrinth is praised as if nothing could be found better ordered and arranged. What complaints Bernard pours out, what groans he utters, when he sees the vices of his own age! What would he have done on seeing this iron age of ours, or something even worse than iron? How dishonest, then, not only to defend stubbornly as holy and divine what all the saints have always with one voice disapproved, but to abuse their testimony in favour of the Papacy, which, it is plain, was altogether unknown to them.
I admit that in Bernard's time everything was so corrupt as to be not unlike our own. But it shows a complete lack of shame to seek any excuse from the middle period, that of Leo, Gregory and the like. It is just as if someone defended the monarchy of the Caesars by praising the ancient state of the Roman republic, that is, borrowed the praises of liberty to praise tyranny.
23. The decisive answer: there is no Church and no bishop at Rome
Finally, even if all these things were granted, an entirely new question arises when we deny that there is a Church at Rome in which such privileges can reside, and deny that there is a bishop there to uphold their dignity. Suppose all these things are true (though we have already forced the opposite from them): that Peter was made head of the universal Church by Christ's words; that he deposited the honour thus conferred on him in the Roman See; that this was endorsed by the authority of the ancient Church and confirmed by long use; that supreme power was always, by common consent, handed to the Roman pontiff; that while he was judge of all causes and all people he was subject to no one's judgment. Let even more be conceded if they like. I answer in one word that none of this helps if there is no Church and no bishop at Rome.
They must concede to me that she is not a mother of churches who is not herself a church, and that he can't be chief of bishops who is not himself a bishop. Do they want the Apostolic See at Rome? Let them give me a true and lawful apostleship. Do they want a supreme pontiff? Let them give me a bishop. But how? Where will they show me any semblance of a church? No doubt they talk about one and have it always in their mouths. But surely the Church is recognised by certain marks, and "bishopric" is the name of an office. I am not now speaking of the people but of the government, which ought always to be visible in the Church.
Where, then, is a ministry such as Christ's institution requires? Let's remember what was said earlier about the duty of presbyters and bishops. If we bring the office of cardinals to that test, we'll acknowledge that they are anything but presbyters. And I'd like to know what single quality of a bishop the Pope himself has. The first point in a bishop's office is to teach the people God's word; the second, next to it, is to administer the sacraments; the third is to admonish and exhort, to correct those at fault and restrain the people by holy discipline. Which of these does he do? Indeed, which of them does he even pretend to do? Let them say, then, on what ground they want him regarded as a bishop who doesn't even in appearance touch any part of the duty with his little finger.
24. A bishop is not like a king: the Pope is the opposite of a bishop
It is not with a bishop as with a king. A king, though he doesn't carry out the proper duty of a king, still keeps the title and the honour. But in deciding who is a bishop, regard is had to Christ's command, which ought always to be given effect in the Church. Let the Romanists untie this knot. I deny that their pontiff is prince of bishops, since he is no bishop. They must prove this allegation of mine false if they would make good theirs.
What do I maintain, then? That he has nothing proper to a bishop but is in all things the opposite of a bishop. But where shall I begin? With doctrine or with morals? What shall I say, or what pass over in silence, or where shall I end? This I maintain: though the world is now flooded with perverse and ungodly doctrines, full of every kind of superstition, blinded by error and sunk in idolatry, there is not one of these doctrines that has not come from the Papacy or at least been confirmed by it.
There is no other reason why the pontiffs rage so against the reviving gospel, why they strain every nerve to crush it and urge all kings and princes to cruelty, than that they see their whole dominion tottering and collapsing the moment Christ's gospel prevails. Leo was cruel and Clement bloodthirsty, Paul is savage. But in attacking the truth they are not so much driven by natural temper as by the conviction that they have no other way of keeping their power. Seeing that they can't be safe unless they put Christ to flight, they labour in this cause as if fighting for their altars and hearths, for their own lives and those of their followers.
What then? Shall we recognise the Apostolic See where we see nothing but horrible apostasy? Shall he be Christ's vicar who, by his furious efforts to persecute the gospel, plainly declares himself to be Antichrist? Shall he be Peter's successor who goes about with fire and sword tearing down everything Peter built? Shall he be Head of the Church who, after cutting the Church off from Christ, her only true Head, tears and mangles her members? Rome was once the mother of all the churches, but since she became the seat of Antichrist she has ceased to be what she was.
25. Why the Pope is Antichrist
To some we seem slanderous and impudent when we call the Roman pontiff Antichrist. But those who think so don't see that they are charging Paul with intemperance, whom we follow and indeed whose very words we speak. So that no one will object that we twist Paul's words against the Roman pontiff and they mean something else, I'll briefly show that they can only be understood of the Papacy.
Paul says that Antichrist would sit in the temple of God (2 Thess. 2:4). In another passage the Spirit, portraying him in the person of Antiochus, says that his reign would be marked by great swelling words of vanity (Dan. 7:25; 11:36). From this we infer that his tyranny is exercised more over souls than over bodies, a tyranny set up against the spiritual kingdom of Christ. Then, his nature is such that he doesn't abolish the name of Christ or of the Church, but rather uses Christ's name as a pretext and hides under the name of Church as under a mask.
Although all the heresies and schisms that have existed from the beginning belong to Antichrist's kingdom, when Paul foretells that the falling away would come, he indicates by this description that the seat of abomination will be set up when a kind of general defection comes upon the Church, though many members of the Church scattered here and there should remain in the true unity of the faith. When he adds that in his own time the mystery of lawlessness, which was afterwards to be openly revealed, had already begun to work secretly, we understand that this calamity was neither to be brought in by one man nor to end in one man (see Calvin on 2 Thess. 2:3; Dan. 7:9).
Furthermore, the mark by which Paul distinguishes Antichrist is that he would rob God of his honour and take it to himself. This is the main feature we should follow in searching for Antichrist, especially when pride of this kind goes on to open devastation of the Church. Since it is certain that the Roman pontiff has shamelessly transferred to himself the most peculiar properties of God and Christ, there can be no doubt that he is the leader and standard-bearer of an ungodly and abominable kingdom.
26. The honour of a place does not outlast the thing itself
Let the Romanists go on and set antiquity against us, as if, amid such a total change in every respect, the honour of the See could continue where there is no See. Eusebius says that God, to make way for his vengeance, moved the Church that was at Jerusalem to Pella (Eusebius 3.5). What we are told was done once may have been done repeatedly. It is too absurd and ridiculous to tie the honour of the primacy to a particular spot, so that the person who is in fact Christ's bitterest enemy, the chief adversary of the gospel, the greatest devastator and ruiner of the Church, the cruellest slayer and murderer of the saints, should nevertheless be regarded as Christ's vicar, Peter's successor and the first priest of the Church, merely because he occupies what was formerly the first of all sees.
I don't say how great the difference is between the Pope's chancery and well-ordered church government, though this one fact could settle the question. No sensible person will locate the episcopate in lead seals and bulls, much less in that machinery of petitions and restrictions in which the Pope's spiritual government is supposed to consist. It has been neatly said that the vaunted Roman Church was long ago turned into a secular court, the only thing now to be seen at Rome. I am not here speaking of the vices of individuals, but demonstrating that the Papacy itself is diametrically opposed to the church order.
27. The character of the popes: what they actually believe
If we come to individuals, it's well known what kind of vicars of Christ we shall find. No doubt Julius and Leo and Clement and Paul will be pillars of the Christian faith, the foremost interpreters of religion, though they knew nothing more of Christ than they'd learned in Lucian's school. But why name three or four popes, as if there were any doubt what religion the pontiffs, with their college of cardinals and their scholars, hold in our day?
The first article of the secret theology in fashion among them is that there is no God. The second is that everything written and taught about Christ is lies and deception. A third is that the doctrine of a future life and a final resurrection is a mere fable. Not all think this, and few say it; I confess that. Yet it is long since this began to be the ordinary religion of pontiffs. (Erasmus, in a letter to Steuchus, wrote: "It may be that in Germany there are people who don't refrain from blasphemy against God, but they are severely punished. But at Rome I have heard with my own ears men belching out horrible blasphemies against Christ and his apostles in front of many others besides myself, and doing it with impunity!") And though this is notorious to everyone who knows Rome, Roman theologians never cease to boast that our Saviour has by special privilege made sure the Pope can't err, because it was said to Peter, "I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail" (Luke 22:32). What do they gain by such effrontery except to let the whole world understand that they have reached the extreme of wickedness, neither fearing God nor respecting man?
28. John XXII and the claim that the pope cannot err
Let's suppose the wickedness of the pontiffs I've mentioned is not known, since they have not published it in sermons or writings but revealed it only at table, in their chambers, or at least within the walls of their court. But if they want to confirm the privilege they claim, they must strike John XXII from their list of pontiffs. He publicly maintained that the soul is mortal and dies with the body until the day of resurrection (the contemporary John Gerson attests that he openly denied the soul's immortality). To show that the whole See, with its chief supports, utterly fell then, none of the cardinals opposed his madness; only the faculty of Paris urged the king to insist on a retraction. The king forbade his subjects communion with him unless he recanted at once, and published his prohibition in the usual way by a herald. Compelled by this, he renounced his error.
This example spares me the need to argue further with my opponents when they say that the Roman See and its pontiffs cannot err in the faith because it was said to Peter, "I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail." By this shameful lapse he certainly fell from the faith and became a notable proof to later ages that not all who succeed Peter in the episcopate are Peters. The matter is really too childish to need an answer anyway. If they insist on applying everything said to Peter to Peter's successors, it follows that they are all Satans, because our Lord once said to Peter, "Get behind me, Satan! You are a hindrance to me" (Matt. 16:23). It is as easy for us to throw back the one saying as for them to cite the other.
29. The See does not make the man
I take no pleasure in this absurd way of arguing, and so I return to the point where I strayed. To fix Christ and the Holy Spirit and the Church to a particular spot, so that everyone who presides there, even if he were a devil, must still be considered Christ's vicar and head of the Church because that spot was formerly Peter's See, is not only ungodly and insulting to Christ but absurd and contrary to common sense.
For a long time the Roman pontiffs have been either altogether devoid of religion or its greatest enemies. The see they occupy therefore no more makes them vicars of Christ than it turns an idol into God when it is set up in the temple of God (2 Thess. 2:4). And if morals are asked about, let the popes answer for themselves: what is there in them that could make them recognised as bishops? First, the manner of life at Rome, which they not only overlook and keep silent about but tacitly approve, is utterly unworthy of bishops, whose duty is to curb the people's licence by strict discipline.
I won't be so harsh as to charge them with the faults of others. But when they themselves, with their households, with almost the whole college of cardinals and the whole body of their clergy, are so given to wickedness, obscenity, uncleanness, injustice and crimes of every kind that they look more like monsters than men, in this they show that they are anything but bishops. They needn't fear I'll expose their shame further. It is painful to wade through such filthy mud, and I must spare modest ears. But I think I have amply shown what I set out to: that though Rome was formerly the first of churches, she doesn't deserve in our day to be counted as even the least of her members.
30. Cardinals: a rank that rose with its head
As for those they call cardinals, I don't know how they rose so suddenly to such a height. In Gregory's age the name was applied only to bishops. Whenever he mentions cardinals, he assigns them not only to the Roman Church but to every other church, so that, in short, a "cardinal priest" is nothing but a bishop. I don't find the name in writers of an earlier age. I do see that they were inferior to bishops, whom they now far outrank.
There is a well-known passage in Augustine: "Although in terms of honour which custom has fixed in the Church, the office of bishop is greater than that of presbyter, yet in many things Augustine is inferior to Jerome" (Augustine, Letters 82). Here he certainly isn't distinguishing a presbyter of the Roman Church from other presbyters, but ranking them all alike below bishops. And this was so strictly observed that at the Council of Carthage, when two delegates of the Roman See were present, one a bishop and the other a presbyter, the presbyter was put in the lowest place. Not to dwell too long on ancient times, we have an account of a council held at Rome under Gregory in which the presbyters sit in the lowest place and sign by themselves, while the deacons don't sign at all. Indeed, they had no office then except to be present under the bishop and help him in administering word and sacraments.
So much has their lot changed that they have become companions of kings and emperors. There can be no doubt that they grew gradually along with their head until they reached their present peak of dignity. I thought it right to say this in passing so that my readers may see how very different the Roman See as it now exists is from the ancient See under which it tries to hide and defend itself.
Whatever they were formerly, since they have no true and lawful office in the Church, they retain only a colour and an empty mask. Indeed, since they are in all respects the opposite of true ministers, what Gregory so often writes must necessarily have befallen them: "Weeping, I say it; groaning, I declare it: when the priestly order has fallen within, it cannot long stand without" (Gregory, Letters 4.55, 56; 5.7). Or rather, what Malachi says of such people must be fulfilled in them: "You have turned aside from the way. You have caused many to stumble by your instruction. You have corrupted the covenant of Levi, says the Lord of hosts, and so I have made you despised and abased before all the people" (Mal. 2:8-9).
I now leave all the godly to judge what the supreme peak of the Roman hierarchy must be, to which the Papists, with wicked effrontery, don't hesitate to subject God's very word, that word which should be venerable and holy on earth and in heaven, to men and angels.
Chapter 8
The Church's Power in Articles of Faith, and the Papal Church's Unbridled Licence in Destroying the Purity of Doctrine
1. The three kinds of church power, and their purpose
We come now to the third division of this book: the power of the Church, whether it lies in individual bishops or in councils, provincial or general. I speak only of the spiritual power proper to the Church, which consists in doctrine, in jurisdiction, or in making laws. In regard to doctrine, there are two parts: the authority to deliver doctrines, and the authority to interpret them.
Before taking up each in turn, I want to remind the godly reader that whatever is taught about the Church's power must be aimed at the purpose for which Paul says it was given: for building up, not for tearing down (2 Cor. 10:8; 13:10). Those who use it lawfully count themselves nothing more than servants of Christ and, in Christ, servants of the people.
The only way ministers can build up the Church is by working to uphold Christ's authority, and that cannot remain intact unless what he received from the Father is left to him: to be the Church's only Master. It was said of no one else but him, "Listen to him" (Matt. 17:5). Church power, therefore, mustn't be dangerously inflated. It must be kept within fixed limits so it isn't dragged this way and that at the whim of human beings. To that end it will help to see how Prophets and Apostles describe it. If we grant human beings unreservedly all the power they care to claim, it's easy to see how quickly it will turn into a tyranny entirely foreign to the Church of Christ.
2. Authority belongs to the office and the word, not to the person: Moses and the priests
We must remember, then, that whatever authority and dignity the Holy Spirit in Scripture gives to priests, prophets, apostles or the apostles' successors is given wholly not to the men themselves but to the ministry to which they are appointed; or, to put it more plainly, to the word whose ministry they have been appointed to carry out. If we went through the whole of Scripture in order, we would find that they were never given authority to teach or to answer questions except in the name and word of the Lord. Whenever they are called to office, they are told to bring nothing of their own but to speak by the Lord's mouth. Nor does he bring them forward to be heard by the people before he has instructed them what to say, lest they speak anything but his own word.
Moses, the prince of all the prophets, was to be heard before others (Exod. 3:4; Deut. 17:9), but first he was given his orders, so that he couldn't speak at all except from the Lord. So when the people accepted his teaching, they are said to have believed the Lord and his servant Moses (Exod. 14:31). It was provided, under the severest penalties, that the priests' authority should not be despised (Deut. 17:12). But the Lord at the same time shows on what terms they were to be heard, when he says that he made his covenant with Levi so that the law of truth would be in his mouth (Mal. 2:4-6). A little later he adds: "For the lips of a priest should guard knowledge, and people should seek instruction from his mouth, for he is the messenger of the Lord of hosts." If the priest wants to be heard, therefore, let him show himself to be God's messenger; that is, let him faithfully deliver the commands he has received from his Maker. When the manner of hearing is dealt with, it is expressly said: "according to the instructions that they give you" (Deut. 17:11).
3. The prophets
Ezekiel describes the power given to the prophets in general in a fine passage: "Son of man, I have made you a watchman for the house of Israel. Whenever you hear a word from my mouth, you shall give them warning from me" (Ezek. 3:17). Isn't the one told to hear at the Lord's mouth forbidden to invent anything of himself? And what does it mean to give a warning from the Lord, except to speak in such a way that he can confidently declare that the word he delivers is not his own but the Lord's?
Jeremiah says the same thing in different words: "Let the prophet who has a dream tell the dream, but let him who has my word speak my word faithfully" (Jer. 23:28). God is clearly declaring a law for everyone here, a law that allows no one to teach more than he has been commanded. He goes on to call "chaff" whatever hasn't come from him alone. So none of the prophets opened his mouth without the Lord's word going before. Hence we meet so often the expressions "the word of the Lord," "the burden of the Lord," "thus says the Lord," "the mouth of the Lord has spoken it."
And rightly so, for Isaiah cries out that his lips are unclean (Isa. 6:5), and Jeremiah confesses that he doesn't know how to speak because he is a child (Jer. 1:6). What could come from the unclean lips of the one and the childish lips of the other, if they spoke their own language, except what was unclean or childish? But their lips were holy and pure once they began to be organs of the Holy Spirit. After being bound so strictly to deliver nothing but what they received, the prophets are given great power and splendid titles. When the Lord declares, "See, I have set you this day over nations and over kingdoms, to pluck up and to break down, to destroy and to overthrow, to build and to plant," he gives the reason at the same time: "Behold, I have put my words in your mouth" (Jer. 1:9-10).
4. The apostles, and Christ himself
If you look to the apostles, they are commended with many distinguished titles: light of the world and salt of the earth, to be heard in Christ's place, whatever they bound or loosed on earth being bound or loosed in heaven (Matt. 5:13-14; Luke 10:16; John 20:23). But they declare for themselves what authority their office gave them: if they are apostles, they must not speak what pleases them but faithfully deliver the commands of the one who sent them. The words in which Christ defined their mission are clear enough: "Go therefore and make disciples of all nations... teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you" (Matt. 28:19-20).
And so that no one could refuse this law, he took it on himself too: "My teaching is not mine, but his who sent me" (John 7:16). He who was always the Father's only and eternal counsellor, who was appointed by the Father as Lord and Master of all, nonetheless, because he carried out the ministry of teaching, set by his own example the rule that all ministers must follow in teaching. The Church's power, then, is not unlimited. It is subject to the word of the Lord and, so to speak, enclosed within it.
5. Christ the only Master: how God has taught in different ways
The rule that has always held in the Church from the beginning, and ought to hold today, is that God's servants may teach only what they have learned from him. Yet the ways they have learned have varied with the times, and the way things are now differs greatly from the former way.
First, if it is true, as Christ says, that "no one knows the Father except the Son and anyone to whom the Son chooses to reveal him" (Matt. 11:27), then those who wanted to attain the knowledge of God always had to be guided by that eternal wisdom. How could they have grasped God's mysteries in their minds, or declared them to others, except by the teaching of the One to whom alone the Father's secrets are known? The only way holy people in ancient times knew God, then, was by seeing him in the Son as in a mirror. By this I mean that God never revealed himself to people by any means other than his Son, that is, his own only wisdom, light and truth. From this fountain Adam, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob and the others drew all the heavenly teaching they had. From the same fountain all the prophets also drew all the heavenly oracles they published.
This wisdom did not always show itself in one way. With the patriarchs he used secret revelations, but to confirm them he also used signs, so that they could not doubt that it was God speaking to them. What the patriarchs received they passed on to later generations, for God, in entrusting it to them, bound them to hand it on, while their children and descendants knew by God's inward teaching that what they heard was from heaven and not from earth.
6. The written word: the Law, Prophets, Psalms and histories
When God determined to give his Church a more glorious form, he was pleased to commit his word to writing, so that the priests could look there for what they were to teach the people, and every doctrine delivered could be tested against it (Mal. 2:7). After the giving of the Law, then, when the priests are told to teach from the Lord's mouth, the meaning is that they are not to teach anything foreign or alien to the kind of doctrine God had summed up in the Law, and it was unlawful for them to add to it or take from it.
Next came the prophets, through whom God published new oracles added to the Law, though not so new that they didn't flow from the Law and look back to it. As far as doctrine goes, they were only interpreters of the Law, adding nothing to it but predictions of future events. With that exception, all they delivered was pure exposition of the Law. But since the Lord wanted doctrine to exist in a clearer and fuller form, to better satisfy weak consciences, he also commanded the prophecies to be committed to writing and counted as part of his word. To these were added historical accounts, which are also the work of prophets but written under the Holy Spirit's direction. I include the Psalms among the prophecies, since what we say of the prophecies applies equally to them.
The whole body, therefore, made up of the Law, the Prophets, the Psalms and the Histories, was the word of the Lord to his ancient people. By it as a standard, priests and teachers before Christ's coming were bound to test their teaching, and they were not allowed to turn aside to the right or the left, because their whole office was confined to this: to give the people answers from God's mouth. This is gathered from a celebrated passage of Malachi, which tells them to remember the Law and give heed to it until the preaching of the gospel (Mal. 4:4). He thus holds people back from all foreign doctrines and doesn't allow them to depart in the least from the path Moses had faithfully marked out. And the reason David praises the Law so magnificently and says so many good things of it (Psalms 19 and 119) was so that the Jews would not long for any outside help, all perfection being contained in it.
7. Christ is God's last and complete word
When the Wisdom of God was at last made manifest in the flesh, he fully unfolded to us everything the human mind can grasp or ought to think about the heavenly Father. Now that Christ, the Sun of Righteousness, has risen, we have the full radiance of divine truth, like the brightness of noon, whereas the light was dim before. It was no ordinary blessing the author of Hebrews meant to announce when he wrote: "Long ago, at many times and in many ways, God spoke to our fathers by the prophets, but in these last days he has spoken to us by his Son" (Heb. 1:1-2). He is indicating, indeed openly declaring, that God will not from now on, as formerly, speak through this person and that; that he will not add prophecy to prophecy or revelation to revelation; but that he has so completed all parts of teaching in the Son that it is to be taken as his last and eternal testimony.
That is why the whole period of the new dispensation, from the time Christ appeared to us with the preaching of his gospel until the day of judgment, is called the last hour, the last times, the last days. So that, content with the perfection of Christ's teaching, we may learn not to invent new doctrine for ourselves or accept any devised by others. The Father had good reason, then, to appoint the Son as our teacher with a special prerogative, commanding that he, and no human being, be heard. When he said, "Listen to him" (Matt. 17:5), he commended Christ's office to us in few words, but words of more weight and force than people commonly suppose. It is as if he withdrew us from all human teaching and confined us to Christ alone, telling us to seek the whole doctrine of salvation from him alone, to depend on him alone, to cling to him alone; in short (as the words say), to listen only to his voice.
And what can now be expected or desired from any human being, when the very Word of life has appeared before us and explained himself so plainly? Every mouth should be stopped once he has spoken, in whom, by the Father's good pleasure, "are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge" (Col. 2:3). He has spoken as the Wisdom of God should speak, who is in no way lacking, and as the Messiah should, from whom the revelation of all things was expected (John 4:25). In other words, he has spoken in such a way as to leave nothing for others to say after him.
8. Nothing may be taught in the Church except what is in the Prophets and Apostles
Let this, then, be a sure axiom: no word of God is to be given a place in the Church except what is contained, first, in the Law and the Prophets, and second, in the writings of the Apostles; and the only right method of teaching in the Church is according to the prescription and rule of his word. From this we also infer that nothing else was permitted to the apostles than had formerly been permitted to the prophets: namely, to expound the ancient Scriptures and show that the things delivered there are fulfilled in Christ. Even this they could not do except from the Lord; that is, unless the Spirit of Christ went before them and in a manner dictated their words.
For Christ defined the terms of their mission in this way when he commanded them to go and teach, not what they had made up at random, but whatever he had commanded (Matt. 28:20). Nothing could be plainer than his words in another passage: "You are not to be called rabbi, for you have one teacher... you have one instructor, the Christ" (Matt. 23:8, 10). To impress this more deeply on their minds, he repeats it twice in the same place. And because in their ignorance they couldn't take in the things they had heard and learned from their Master's lips, the Spirit of truth is promised to guide them into all truth (John 14:26; 16:13). The limit here deserves careful attention. The task he assigns to the Holy Spirit is to bring to remembrance what his own lips had previously taught.
9. No one, not even the whole Church, may go beyond this
Peter, fully instructed by his Master about the extent of what was permitted him, leaves nothing more to himself or to others than to pass on the doctrine delivered by God: "Whoever speaks, [let him speak] as one who speaks oracles of God" (1 Pet. 4:11). That is, not hesitantly, as people do whose convictions are incomplete, but with the full confidence that becomes a servant of God who has a sure message. What is this but to banish all the inventions of the human mind, whoever devised them, so that the pure word of God may be taught and learned in the Church of the faithful; to throw out the decrees, or rather fictions, of men, whatever their rank, so that God's decrees alone may stand firm?
These are "the weapons of our warfare," which "are not of the flesh but have divine power to destroy strongholds. We destroy arguments and every lofty opinion raised against the knowledge of God, and take every thought captive to obey Christ" (2 Cor. 10:4-5). Here is the supreme power with which the Church's pastors, by whatever name they are called, should be invested: to dare everything boldly for God's word, making all the virtue, glory, wisdom and rank of the world yield and obey its majesty; to command everyone, from the highest to the lowest, trusting in its power to build up the house of Christ and overthrow the house of Satan; to feed the sheep and drive away the wolves; to instruct and encourage the teachable, to accuse, rebuke and subdue the rebellious and insolent; to bind and loose; and in short, if need be, to flash lightning and thunder; but all in the word of God.
As I have noted, there is this difference between the apostles and their successors: the apostles were sure and authentic scribes of the Holy Spirit, and so their writings are to be regarded as the oracles of God, whereas their successors have no other office than to teach what is delivered and sealed in Holy Scripture. We conclude, therefore, that it is not now the business of faithful ministers to coin some new doctrine, but simply to hold to the doctrine to which all, without exception, are made subject.
In saying this, I mean to show what is required not only of each individual but of the whole Church. As to individuals, Paul had certainly been appointed an apostle to the Corinthians, and yet he declares he has no dominion over their faith (2 Cor. 1:24). Who will presume to claim a dominion that the apostle says he himself was not entitled to? If he had allowed such freedom in teaching that every pastor could rightly demand unquestioning faith in whatever he delivered, he would never have laid down for the Corinthians the rule that while two or three prophets speak, the others should weigh what is said, and that if a revelation comes to someone sitting by, the first should be silent (1 Cor. 14:29-30). So he spared no one, but subjected everyone's authority to the censure of God's word.
But it will be said that with respect to the whole Church the case is different. I answer that Paul meets this objection too in another place, when he says that faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ (Rom. 10:17). In other words, if faith depends on God's word alone, if it looks to it alone and rests on it alone, what room is left for any word of man? Whoever knows what faith is can never hesitate here, for faith must have strength enough to stand fearless and unconquerable against Satan, the schemes of hell and the whole world. That strength can be found only in God's word. Then the reason we should have in view here is universal: God deprives man of the power to produce any new doctrine so that he alone may be our master in spiritual teaching, as he alone is true and can neither lie nor deceive. This reason applies no less to the whole Church than to each individual believer.
10. What Rome teaches instead
If the Church's power as described here is set beside the power that spiritual tyrants, falsely calling themselves bishops and religious prelates, have exercised for several ages among God's people, there is no more agreement than between Christ and Belial. It isn't my intention to unfold here the shameful way they've used their tyranny. I'll only state the doctrine they maintain today, first in writing and then by fire and sword.
They take it for granted that a universal council is a true representation of the Church, and, laying that down as unquestionable, they hold that such councils are under the immediate guidance of the Holy Spirit and therefore cannot err. But since they rule councils, indeed create them, they in fact claim for themselves whatever they say is due to councils. They will have our faith stand or fall at their pleasure, so that whatever they've decided one way or the other must be firmly lodged in our minds; what they approve we must approve without doubt, and what they condemn we must hold to be rightly condemned. Meanwhile, at their own whim and in contempt of God's word, they coin doctrines and demand our assent, declaring that no one can be a Christian unless he assents to all their dogmas, positive and negative, if not with explicit then with implicit faith, because it belongs to the Church to frame new articles of faith.
11. The promises of Christ's presence belong to every believer
First let us hear by what arguments they prove that this authority was given to the Church, and then we'll see how far their claims about the Church help them. The Church, they say, has the glorious promise that she'll never be abandoned by Christ her bridegroom, but will be guided by his Spirit into all truth. But many of the promises they usually cite were given no less to individual believers than to the whole Church.
The Lord did speak to the twelve apostles when he said, "I am with you always, to the end of the age" (Matt. 28:20), and again, "I will ask the Father, and he will give you another Helper, to be with you for ever, even the Spirit of truth" (John 14:16-17). But he made these promises not only to the twelve but to each of them separately, and likewise to the other disciples he already had or would later receive. When they interpret these promises, so full of comfort, as if they were given not to any particular Christian but to the whole Church together, what else is that but to rob Christians of the confidence they ought to draw from them to cheer them on their way?
I don't deny that the whole body of the faithful is furnished with a great variety of gifts, and has a far larger and richer treasure of heavenly wisdom than each Christian apart. I don't mean this was said of believers in general as if all possessed the spirit of wisdom and knowledge in equal degree. But we mustn't let Christ's adversaries defend a bad cause by twisting Scripture from its proper meaning. Setting that aside, I simply hold what is true: the Lord is always present with his people and guides them by his Spirit. He is the Spirit not of error, ignorance, falsehood or darkness but of sure revelation, wisdom, truth and light, from whom they can learn without deception the things given to them (1 Cor. 2:12), that is, "what is the hope to which he has called you, what are the riches of his glorious inheritance in the saints" (Eph. 1:18).
But while believers, even the most richly gifted, receive in this present life only the first fruits and a foretaste of the Spirit, the best they can do, aware of their weakness, is to keep carefully within the limits of God's word, lest by following their own judgment too far they stray from the right path, left without that Spirit by whose teaching alone truth is told from falsehood. All of them confess with Paul that they "have not already obtained this" (Phil. 3:12). So they aim at progress every day rather than boast of perfection.
12. The Church is not already perfect: "without spot or wrinkle" and "pillar of the truth"
It will be objected that whatever is said of part of the saints belongs in full to the Church. Although there is some appearance of truth in this, I deny that it is true. God does measure out the gifts of his Spirit to each of the members so that nothing necessary for the whole body is lacking, since the gifts are given for the common good. But the Church's riches are always such that much is lacking from that supreme perfection our opponents boast of. Still, the Church isn't left destitute in any respect, and always has as much as is sufficient, for the Lord knows what her needs require. But to keep her in humility and godly modesty, he gives her no more than he knows to be good for her.
I know it's usual to object that Christ has cleansed the Church "by the washing of water with the word, so that he might present the church to himself in splendour, without spot or wrinkle" (Eph. 5:26-27), and that she is therefore called "the pillar and buttress of the truth" (1 Tim. 3:15). But the first passage shows what Christ does daily in the Church more than what he has already completed. If he daily sanctifies all his people, purifies and refines them and wipes away their stains, it is certain that they still have some spots and wrinkles, and that their sanctification is in some measure incomplete. How vain and fabulous it is to suppose that the Church, all of whose members are somewhat stained and impure, is completely holy and spotless in every part! It is true that the Church is sanctified by Christ, but here only the beginning of her sanctification is seen; the end and full completion will come when Christ, the Holy of Holies, truly and completely fills her with his holiness. It is true also that her spots and wrinkles have been wiped away, but in such a way that the process continues every day until Christ at his coming removes every remaining defect. Unless we admit this, we shall be forced to hold with the Pelagians that believers' righteousness is perfected in this life, and, like the Cathari and Donatists, to tolerate no weakness in the Church. (Our opponents themselves count all such people as heretics.)
The other passage, as we saw earlier (chapter 1, section 10), has a very different meaning from what they give it. When Paul was instructing Timothy and training him for the office of a true bishop, he says he did it so that Timothy might know how to behave in the household of God. To make him give himself to the work with greater seriousness and zeal, he adds that the Church is the pillar and buttress of the truth. What else do these words mean than that God's truth is preserved in the Church, and preserved by the instrumentality of preaching? As he says elsewhere, Christ "gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the shepherds and teachers... so that we may no longer be children, tossed to and fro by the waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine, by human cunning, by craftiness in deceitful schemes. Rather, speaking the truth in love, we are to grow up in every way into him who is the head, into Christ" (Eph. 4:11, 14-15). The reason the truth, instead of being extinguished in the world, remains unimpaired is that it has the Church as its faithful guardian, by whose help and ministry it is maintained. But if this guardianship consists in the ministry of the prophets and apostles, it follows that everything depends on this: that the word of the Lord is faithfully kept and maintained in its purity.
13. The real point: the Church's authority is joined to the word, not apart from it
So that my readers may better understand the hinge on which the question chiefly turns, I'll briefly explain what our opponents demand and what we resist. When they deny that the Church can err, their meaning and aim is this: since the Church is governed by the Spirit of God, she can walk safely without the word; in whatever direction she moves, she can think and say nothing but the truth; and so if she determines anything without or beside God's word, it must be regarded in no other light than as a divine oracle.
If we grant the first point, that the Church cannot err in things necessary to salvation, our meaning is that she cannot err because she has completely set aside her own wisdom and submits to the teaching of the Holy Spirit through God's word. Here, then, is the difference. They put the Church's authority outside God's word; we attach it to the word and don't allow it to be separated from it.
And is it strange if the bride and pupil of Christ is so subject to her Lord and Master that she hangs carefully and constantly on his lips? In every well-ordered household the wife obeys her husband's command; in every well-run school only the master's teaching is heard. So let the Church not be wise in herself, nor think anything of herself, but let her consider her wisdom at an end when he stops speaking. In this way she will distrust all the inventions of her own reason; and when she leans on God's word, she won't waver in doubt or hesitation but rest in full assurance and unwavering steadiness. Trusting the generous promises she has received, she'll have the means to maintain her faith nobly, never doubting that the Holy Spirit is always with her to be the perfect guide of her path. At the same time, she'll remember the use God wants us to make of his Spirit: "When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth" (John 16:13). How? "He will bring to your remembrance all that I have said to you" (John 14:26). He declares, then, that nothing more is to be expected from his Spirit than the enlightening of our minds to perceive the truth of his teaching.
So Chrysostom observes shrewdly: "Many boast of the Holy Spirit, but with those who speak their own words it is a false pretence. As Christ said he did not speak on his own authority (John 12:50; 14:10), because he spoke according to the Law and the Prophets, so if anything contrary to the Gospel is pressed on us in the name of the Holy Spirit, let us not believe it. For as Christ is the fulfilment of the Law and the Prophets, so the Spirit is the fulfilment of the Gospel" (Chrysostom, sermon on the Holy Spirit). We can easily see how wrongly our opponents act in boasting of the Holy Spirit for no other end than to lend his name to strange doctrines foreign to God's word, whereas he himself wants to be inseparably joined to God's word, and Christ declares the same thing of him when he promises him to the Church.
So it is indeed. The soberness that our Lord once prescribed for his Church he wants observed for ever. He forbade anything to be added to his word or taken from it (Deut. 4:2; 12:32). This is the inviolable decree of God and the Holy Spirit, a decree our opponents try to annul when they pretend the Church is guided by the Spirit without the word.
14. The claim that the Church must supply what Scripture lacks
Here again they mutter that the Church had to add something to the apostles' writings, or that the apostles themselves had to supply orally what they'd taught less clearly, since Christ said to them, "I still have many things to say to you, but you cannot bear them now" (John 16:12); and that these are the points received without writing, merely by use and custom. What effrontery! I admit that the disciples were ignorant and almost unteachable when our Lord spoke to them in this way. But were they still in this state when they committed his teaching to writing, so that they afterwards had to supply orally what through ignorance they'd left unwritten? If they were guided into all truth by the Spirit of truth when they published their writings, what prevented them from embracing a full knowledge of the gospel and recording it there?
But let's grant them what they ask, provided they point out which things had to be revealed without writing. If they dare to try, I'll answer them in Augustine's words: "When the Lord is silent, who of us can say, 'This is it,' or 'That is it'? Or if we presume to say it, how do we prove it?" (Augustine, Tractates on John 96). But why argue needlessly? Every child knows that the writings of the apostles, which these people represent as mutilated and incomplete, contain the outcome of the revelation the Lord then promised them.
15. Matthew 18:17, "tell it to the church"
"What?" they say. "Didn't Christ declare that nothing the Church teaches and decides can be contradicted, when he ordered that anyone who dares to contradict should be treated as a Gentile and a tax collector?" (Matt. 18:17). First, there is no mention of doctrine here but of the Church's authority to censure, for correction is being affirmed, so that no one who had been admonished or reprimanded might resist her judgment.
But, to say nothing of this, it is very strange that these people are so lost to all sense of shame that they aren't afraid to plume themselves on this declaration. What will they make of it but this: that the consent of the Church, a consent never given except to God's word, is not to be despised? "The Church is to be heard," they say. Who denies it, since she decides nothing but according to God's word? If they demand more than this, let them know that Christ's words give them no support.
I shouldn't seem contentious when I insist so strongly that we can't grant the Church any new doctrine, that is, allow her to teach and deliver oracles beyond what the Lord has revealed in his word. Sensible people see how great the danger is if so much authority is once granted to men. They see also how wide a door is opened to the mockery and cavils of the ungodly if we admit that Christians are to receive human opinions as if they were oracles. We may add that our Saviour, speaking according to the circumstances of his time, gave the name "church" to the Sanhedrin, so that the disciples would afterwards learn to revere the sacred assemblies of the Church. It would follow from the Romanist reading that single cities and districts would have equal freedom to coin dogmas.
16. Infant baptism and the Nicene Creed
The examples they bring don't help them. They say that infant baptism rests not so much on a plain command of Scripture as on a decree of the Church. It would be a miserable refuge if, in defending infant baptism, we had to run to the bare authority of the Church; but it will be made plain enough elsewhere (chapter 16) that the case is quite different.
Likewise, when they object that we nowhere find in Scripture what was declared at the Council of Nicaea, that the Son is "of one substance" with the Father (see Augustine, Letters 178), they do the fathers a grave injustice, as if they had rashly condemned Arius for not swearing to their words, though he professed the whole of the doctrine contained in the writings of the Apostles and Prophets. I admit that the expression is not in Scripture. But since it is declared there so often that there is one God, and Christ is so often called true and eternal God, one with the Father, what do the Nicene fathers do in affirming that he is of one essence except simply declare the true meaning of Scripture?
Theodoret relates that Constantine opened their meeting with these words: "In discussing divine matters, the teaching of the Holy Spirit stands on record. The Gospels and apostolic writings, together with the oracles of the prophets, fully show us the mind of God. Therefore, laying aside discord, let us take the solution of our questions from the words of the Spirit" (Theodoret, Ecclesiastical History 1.5). No one opposed this sound advice. No one objected that the Church could add something of her own, or that the Spirit hadn't revealed everything to the apostles, or at least that they hadn't handed it on to later generations, and so forth. If the point our opponents insist on is true, then first, Constantine was wrong in robbing the Church of her power; and second, when no bishop stood up to defend it, their silence was a kind of treachery and made them traitors to church law. But since Theodoret reports that they readily embraced what the emperor said, it is evident that this new dogma was then entirely unknown.
Chapter 9
Councils and Their Authority
1. Two things to say before beginning
Even if I granted everything our opponents ask about the Church, it wouldn't help them much. Whatever is said of the Church they immediately transfer to councils, which they claim represent her. In fact, when they argue so stubbornly for the Church's power, their only aim is to hand everything they extract over to the Roman Pontiff and his circle. Before I take up the question, two points need to be made briefly.
First, if I am stricter on this subject than they would like, it isn't because I value ancient councils less than I should. I honour them from the heart and want everyone to hold them in proper respect. But there must be a limit, and nothing may be allowed that takes away from Christ. It is Christ's right to preside over every council and to share that honour with no one. And he presides only when he governs the whole assembly by his word and Spirit.
Second, if I give councils less than my opponents demand, it isn't because I fear that councils favour their cause and oppose ours. The Lord's word gives us abundant means to prove our teaching and to overthrow the whole papacy, so we have no great need of other help. And if the case required it, the ancient councils would supply a good deal of what we need on both fronts.
2. What it means to meet in Christ's name
Turning to the subject itself, the most notable promise Scripture makes about assemblies is our Saviour's: "Where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them" (Matt. 18:20). But that applies just as much to any small gathering as to a universal council. The weight of the matter lies in the condition attached: Christ will be in the midst of a council provided it meets in his name. So our opponents can name councils of thousands of bishops, and it will do them little good. They won't persuade us that such bodies are guided by the Holy Spirit until they make it believable that they gather in Christ's name. Wicked and dishonest men can conspire against Christ just as easily as good and honest bishops can meet in his name, and many decrees that have come from councils prove it. I'll come to that shortly. For now my answer is brief: the promise is made only to those who assemble in his name.
How, then, do we define such an assembly? I deny that those meet in Christ's name who disregard his command not to add anything to the word of God or take anything from it (Deut. 4:2; Rev. 22:18), who decide everything at their own pleasure, and who, not content with Scripture, the only rule of perfect wisdom, invent some novelty out of their own heads. Our Saviour has certainly not promised to be present at every council of whatever kind. He has given a particular mark by which true and lawful councils can be told from the rest, and we must never lose sight of that distinction. The covenant God made long ago with the Levitical priests was that they would teach from his mouth (Mal. 2:7). He always required the same of the prophets, and it was the rule laid down for the apostles. On those who break this covenant God bestows neither the honour of the priesthood nor any authority. Let my opponents resolve this difficulty if they want to bind my faith to human decrees that have no warrant from God's word.
3. The truth doesn't depend on pastors: the Old Testament prophets
They suppose that truth can't remain in the Church unless it is found among her pastors, and that the Church can't exist unless she is displayed in general councils. That is far from the truth if the prophets have given us an accurate picture of their own times. In Isaiah's day there was a Church at Jerusalem, which the Lord hadn't yet abandoned. Yet this is what he says of her pastors: "His watchmen are blind; they are all without knowledge; they are all silent dogs; they cannot bark; dreaming, lying down, loving to slumber. The dogs have a mighty appetite; they never have enough. But they are shepherds who have no understanding; they have all turned to their own way" (Isa. 56:10-11). Hosea speaks in the same vein: "The prophet is a watchman for my God over Ephraim, yet a fowler's snare is on all his ways, and hostility in the house of his God" (Hos. 9:8). By tying them ironically to God, he shows that their priestly pretensions were empty.
There was a Church in Jeremiah's time too. Hear what he says of its pastors: "From prophet to priest, everyone deals falsely" (Jer. 6:13). And again: "The prophets are prophesying lies in my name. I did not send them, nor did I command them or speak to them" (Jer. 14:14). To avoid piling up quotations, read the whole of chapters 23 and 40 as well. Ezekiel attacks them in no milder terms: "The conspiracy of her prophets in her midst is like a roaring lion tearing its prey; they have devoured human lives." "Her priests have done violence to my law and have profaned my holy things" (Ezek. 22:25-26). There is more to the same effect. Complaints of this kind run all through the prophets, and nothing recurs more often.
4. The New Testament says the same evil will come again
Perhaps this great evil was found among the Jews but our age is free of it. I wish that were so, but the Holy Spirit said otherwise. Peter's words are plain: "But false prophets also arose among the people, just as there will be false teachers among you, who will secretly bring in destructive heresies" (2 Pet. 2:1). Notice that he foretells the danger coming not from ordinary believers but from men who take pride in the title of pastors and teachers. How often, too, did Christ and his apostles warn that the Church's greatest dangers would come from pastors (Matt. 24:11, 24)? Paul declares openly that Antichrist would take his seat in the temple of God (2 Thess. 2:4), which tells us that the terrible calamity he was speaking of would come only from men who sit in the Church as pastors. In another place he shows that the arrival of this evil was close at hand. Addressing the elders of Ephesus, he says, "I know that after my departure fierce wolves will come in among you, not sparing the flock; and from among your own selves will arise men speaking twisted things, to draw away the disciples after them" (Acts 20:29-30).
If pastors could degenerate so far in so short a time, how much corruption could a long run of years bring in among them? And without filling my pages with details, the examples of almost every age remind us that truth isn't always cherished in the hearts of pastors, and that the Church's safety doesn't depend on their condition. It is right that those appointed to guard the Church's peace and safety should be her leaders and guardians. But it is one thing to do what you owe and quite another to owe what you don't do.
5. Not everyone who is called a pastor is one
I don't want anyone to think I'm eager to overthrow the authority of pastors recklessly and across the board. All I'm urging is discernment: we shouldn't assume as a matter of course that everyone who calls himself a pastor is one. The Pope and his whole crew of bishops, for no other reason than that they bear the name, throw off obedience to God's word and turn everything upside down as they please. Meanwhile they insist that they can't lack the light of truth, that God's Spirit lives in them permanently, and that the Church exists in them and dies with them. It is as if the Lord no longer executed his judgments or punished the world's wickedness today the way he punished the ingratitude of his ancient people, by striking pastors with confusion and blindness (Zech. 12:4).
These foolish men don't see that they are echoing the ancient enemies of God's word. Jeremiah's opponents set themselves against the truth in just the same way: "Come, let us make plots against Jeremiah, for the law shall not perish from the priest, nor counsel from the wise, nor the word from the prophet" (Jer. 18:18).
6. Why a council of pastors is not the Church: Israel's priests and Ahab's prophets
This makes it easy to answer their claim about general councils. It can't be denied that the Jews had a true Church under the prophets. But if a general council had been made up of the priests of that time, what would the Church have looked like? We hear the Lord denounce not one or two of them but the whole order: "The priests will be appalled and the prophets astounded" (Jer. 4:9). "Instruction shall perish from the priest, and counsel from the elders" (Ezek. 7:26). "Therefore it shall be night to you, without vision, and darkness to you, without divination. The sun shall go down on the prophets, and the day shall be black over them" (Mic. 3:6). If all such men had been gathered in one place, what spirit would have presided over their meeting?
We have a striking case in the council Ahab convened (1 Kings 22:6, 22). Four hundred prophets were present. But because they had come together with no other aim than to flatter the ungodly king, the Lord sent Satan to be a lying spirit in all their mouths. The truth was condemned by unanimous vote. Micaiah was judged a heretic, struck and thrown into prison. The same was done to Jeremiah and to the other prophets.
7. The council that condemned Christ
But one memorable example may serve for all. Consider the council that the priests and Pharisees assembled at Jerusalem against Christ (John 11:47). As far as outward appearance goes, what was missing? If there had been no Church at Jerusalem then, Christ would never have taken part in its sacrifices and other ceremonies. A solemn meeting is held, the high priest presides, the whole priestly order takes its seats, and yet Christ is condemned and his teaching driven out. That outrage shows the Church wasn't included in that council at all.
"But nothing like this can happen with us." Who told us so? To be so secure in a matter this serious is to invite the charge of laziness. When the Spirit announces through Paul, in plain terms, that a falling away will come, one that can't come until pastors first forsake God (2 Thess. 2:3), why do we walk blindfolded to our own ruin? We cannot, then, accept that the Church consists in an assembly of pastors. The Lord has nowhere promised that they would always be good, and he has sometimes foretold that they would be wicked. When he warns us of danger, it is so that we will be more careful.
8. How to weigh a council's decrees
"So," you will say, "do the definitions of councils carry no authority?" Of course they do. I'm not arguing that every council should be condemned and all their acts struck out in one sweep. "But you are putting them all under a higher standard, and leaving everyone free to accept or reject their decrees as they please." Not at all. When a council's decree is produced, I would first ask when it was held, on what occasion, with what intention, and who attended. Then I would bring the matter it discussed to the standard of Scripture. And I would do this in such a way that the council's decision keeps its weight and counts as a prior judgment, without being exempted from the test I've described.
I wish everyone had followed the method Augustine lays down in his third book against Maximinus, when he wanted to silence that heretic's quibbles about councils: "I ought not to cite the Council of Nicaea against you, nor you the Council of Ariminum against me, as if either settled the question. I am not bound by the authority of the latter, nor you by that of the former. Let case contend with case, cause with cause, reason with reason, on the authority of the Scriptures, an authority that belongs to neither of us in particular but is common to us both." That way councils are given their due respect, and the highest place still goes to Scripture, with everything brought to it as a test.
So the ancient councils of Nicaea, Constantinople, the first of Ephesus, Chalcedon and others like them, which were held to refute errors, we gladly accept and revere as sacred in matters of the faith. They contain nothing but the pure and genuine interpretation of Scripture, which the holy Fathers adopted with spiritual wisdom to crush the enemies of religion who had arisen at that time. In some later councils too we see a true zeal for religion, and clear marks of ability, learning and good sense. But since things usually go from bad to worse, it's easy to see in the more recent councils how far the Church gradually fell from the purity of that golden age. I don't doubt that even in the more corrupt periods there were better bishops in the councils. But what the Roman senators once complained about in their own decrees happened to them as well: opinions were counted, not weighed, and the better men had to give way to the greater number. Many ungodly judgments were certainly produced. There's no need to collect examples here, both because it would be tedious and because others have done it so carefully that little remains to be added.
9. When councils contradict each other, Scripture must decide
Why should I review the quarrels of council with council? And nobody should whisper to me that when councils disagree, one of them must not be a lawful council. How would we find that out? Only, if I'm not mistaken, by judging from Scripture that its decrees aren't sound. That alone is the sure rule of discernment.
About nine hundred years ago, the Council of Constantinople, called by the Emperor Leo, ordered that the images set up in churches be thrown down and broken in pieces. Shortly afterwards the Council of Nicaea, convened by Irene out of dislike for the earlier one, decreed that images be restored. Which of the two shall we acknowledge as lawful? The latter has generally prevailed and won images a place in churches. But Augustine maintains that this could not be done without the greatest danger of idolatry, and Epiphanius, at a later date, speaks much more harshly (Letter to John of Jerusalem and Against Heresies, Book 3). He calls it an unspeakable abomination to see images in a Christian church. Could men who spoke like that approve of that council if they were alive today? If the historians are right, and we can trust their accounts, that council sanctioned not only the images themselves but the worship of them. Plainly the decree came from Satan. Didn't the council's members show, by twisting and corrupting Scripture, that they held it in contempt? I've made this clear earlier in the work (Book 1, chapter 11, section 14).
Whatever the case, we will never be able to tell apart the councils that contradict and oppose one another, and there have been many, unless we weigh them all in that balance for men and angels, the word of God. That is why we accept the Council of Chalcedon and reject the second Council of Ephesus: the latter approved the impiety of Eutyches and the former condemned it. The judgment of those holy men rested on the Scriptures, and in following it we ask that the same word of God that enlightened them would now enlighten us. Let the Romanists go on, in their usual way, boasting that the Holy Spirit is fixed and tied to their councils.
10. Even the best councils fell short: the example of Nicaea
Even the ancient and purer councils leave something to be desired. Sometimes the learned and prudent men who attended were distracted by the business before them and overlooked much else. Sometimes, absorbed in graver and weightier matters, they let smaller ones pass. Sometimes, being human, they were simply misled by ignorance, or carried away by some excess of feeling.
The last of these seems the hardest to avoid, and there is a striking example in the Council of Nicaea, which has been unanimously received, as it deserves, with the greatest veneration. The chief article of our faith was in danger there. Arius, its enemy, was present and ready to take on all comers, and it was vital that those who had come to oppose him stand together. Yet, feeling secure amid all these dangers, and almost forgetting their dignity, modesty and courtesy, they dropped the matter before them as if they had met to please Arius. They began to give way to quarrels among themselves and turned the pen that should have been used against Arius against each other. Shameful accusations were heard, pamphlets flew back and forth, and they would never have stopped until they had stabbed each other with these mutual wounds, had not the Emperor Constantine stepped in. He said that investigating their lives was beyond his competence, and he checked their intemperance with flattery rather than rebuke.
If this was so at Nicaea, in how many respects is it likely that later councils erred? The point hardly needs a long demonstration. Anyone who reads their proceedings will find many weaknesses, to put it no more strongly.
11. Leo and Gregory on the fallibility of councils
Even Leo, the Roman Pontiff, doesn't hesitate to accuse the Council of Chalcedon, which he admits was orthodox in doctrine, of ambition and reckless haste. He doesn't deny that it was lawful, but he openly maintains that it might have erred.
Some may think I'm wasting effort pointing out errors of this kind, since my opponents admit that councils can err in matters not necessary to salvation. But the effort isn't wasted. Although they concede the point in words, because they have to, they then press on us the rulings of all councils, on every subject without distinction, as oracles of the Holy Spirit. That demands more than they claimed at the outset. What is that but to maintain that councils cannot err, or that if they do, it's unlawful for us to see the truth or to withhold our agreement from their errors?
All I mean to draw from this is that even when councils were otherwise godly and holy, and governed by the Holy Spirit, he still let them share the common lot of humanity, so that we wouldn't put too much trust in men. This is a better view than that of Gregory of Nazianzus, who says in a letter (Ep. 55) that he never saw any council end well. By saying that all without exception ended badly, he leaves them very little authority. There's no need to speak separately of provincial councils, since it's easy to judge from general councils how much weight they should have in framing articles of faith and deciding what teaching is to be accepted.
12. "Obey your leaders": the last refuge, and why it fails
When our Romanists see every rational ground slipping away beneath them, they retreat to one last miserable shelter. However dull in understanding and counsel their leaders may be, and however depraved in heart and will, the Lord's word still stands, which commands us to obey those who rule over us (Heb. 13:17). Is that so? What if I deny that men who act like this are the rulers the text means? They shouldn't claim for themselves more than Joshua had, who was both the Lord's prophet and an excellent pastor. Listen to how the Lord installed him: "This Book of the Law shall not depart from your mouth, but you shall meditate on it day and night, so that you may be careful to do according to all that is written in it. For then you will make your way prosperous, and then you will have good success" (Josh. 1:8). Our spiritual rulers, then, will be those who turn neither to the right nor to the left from the law of the Lord.
If the teaching of all pastors were to be received without question, why does the Lord warn us so often and so earnestly not to listen to false prophets? "Thus says the LORD of hosts: Do not listen to the words of the prophets who prophesy to you, filling you with vain hopes. They speak visions of their own minds, not from the mouth of the LORD" (Jer. 23:16). Again: "Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep's clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves" (Matt. 7:15). John would urge us in vain to test the spirits to see whether they are from God (1 John 4:1). Not even angels are exempt from this testing (Gal. 1:8), still less Satan with his lies. And what does "If the blind lead the blind, both will fall into a pit" (Matt. 15:14) mean, if not that there is a great difference among pastors, and that we are not to listen to all of them indiscriminately?
So they have no ground for frightening us with their titles in order to draw us into sharing their blindness. On the contrary, we see that the Lord has taken particular care to keep us from being led away by the errors of others, whatever mask they hide behind. If our Saviour's answer is true, blind guides, whether high priests, prelates or pontiffs, can do nothing more than hurry us over the same cliff as themselves. Let no names of councils, pastors or bishops, which can be used falsely as well as truly, keep us from heeding the evidence of both words and deeds, and from testing all spirits by the divine word to see whether they are from God.
13. The proper role of councils in interpreting Scripture
Having shown that the Church was given no power to set up new doctrine, let us now consider the power attributed to her in interpreting Scripture. We readily admit that when some teaching is in dispute, there is no better or surer remedy than for a council of true bishops to meet and examine the controverted point. A decision of that kind, agreed by the pastors of the churches together after calling on the Spirit of Christ, carries much more weight than if each pastor adopted a view for himself and delivered it to his own people, or if a few individuals met privately and decided.
Second, when bishops are gathered in one place, they can deliberate more conveniently in common, settling both the doctrine and the manner of teaching it, so that diversity doesn't cause offence. Third, Paul himself prescribes this method of deciding doctrine. When he gives a single church the power to judge, he shows what the procedure should be in weightier cases, namely that the churches together should take common cognisance of them.
And a godly instinct itself tells us that if someone troubles the Church with some novelty in doctrine, and the matter goes so far that there's danger of greater division, the churches should first meet, examine the question, and finally, after proper discussion, decide according to Scripture. That settles doubt among the people and stops the mouths of wicked and restless men, so that the matter goes no further. So when Arius arose, the Council of Nicaea was called, and by its authority both crushed that ungodly man's attempts and restored peace to the churches he had troubled, and affirmed the eternal divinity of Christ against his sacrilegious teaching. Later, when Eunomius and Macedonius stirred up fresh disturbances, their madness was met with the same remedy by the Council of Constantinople, and the Council of Ephesus defeated the impiety of Nestorius. From the first, this was the usual means of preserving unity in the Church whenever Satan began his schemes.
But we must remember that not every age and place is blessed with an Athanasius, a Basil, a Cyril and the like, the defenders of sound doctrine whom the Lord raised up in those days. Consider what happened at the second Council of Ephesus, when the Eutychian heresy prevailed. Flavian, of holy memory, with some godly men, was driven into exile, and many similar crimes were committed, because instead of the Spirit of the Lord, Dioscorus, a factious man of very bad character, presided. "But the Church wasn't there." I grant it. I always maintain that the truth doesn't perish in the Church even when one council suppresses it, but is wonderfully preserved by the Lord to rise again and prevail in his own time. What I deny is that every interpretation of Scripture is true and certain simply because it received the votes of a council.
14. The real aim: calling everything a council decides an "interpretation of Scripture"
The Romanists, however, have another purpose in saying that the power of interpreting Scripture belongs to councils without any challenge. They use it as a pretext for giving the name of Scripture's interpretation to everything councils decide. Of purgatory, the intercession of saints, auricular confession and the like, not one syllable can be found in Scripture. But since all these have been approved by the Church's authority, or more accurately, accepted through opinion and practice, every one of them must be held as an interpretation of Scripture.
And not only that: whatever a council has decided against Scripture is to be called an interpretation too. Christ tells all to drink from the cup he holds out in the Supper (Matt. 26:27). The Council of Constance forbade giving it to the people and decreed that the priest alone should drink. This is directly contrary to Christ's institution, yet they want it regarded as his interpretation. Paul calls the forbidding of marriage a teaching of demons (1 Tim. 4:1-3), and the Spirit says elsewhere that "marriage should be honoured by all" (Heb. 13:4). Yet having forbidden their priests to marry, they insist this is a true and genuine interpretation of Scripture, though nothing could be more alien to it. If anyone dares to open his lips against it, he will be judged a heretic, since the Church's decision is beyond challenge and it is unlawful to doubt the accuracy of her interpretation. Why attack such effrontery? To point at it is to condemn it.
I deliberately leave aside their teaching on the power to approve Scripture. To subject the oracles of God to human censure in this way, and to hold that they are validated because they please men, is a blasphemy not worth mentioning. I have already touched on it in any case (Book 1, chapter 7, and chapter 8, section 9). But I will put one question to them. If Scripture's authority rests on the Church's approval, will they quote a council's decree to that effect? I believe they can't. Then why did Arius allow himself to be defeated at Nicaea by passages from John's Gospel? On their reasoning he was free to reject them, since no general council had previously approved them.
They appeal to an old list, which they call the Canon, and say it originated in a decision of the Church. But again I ask: in what council was that Canon published? Here they have to be silent. And I'd like to know what they take that Canon to be, for I see that the ancients were far from agreed about it. If Jerome is to be believed (Preface to the books of Solomon), Maccabees, Tobit, Ecclesiasticus and the like must be ranked among the Apocrypha, and that they will not tolerate on any account.
Chapter 10
The Power of Making Laws: How the Pope and His Followers Tyrannise and Destroy Souls
1. The Church's second power, and what is at stake
We come now to the second part of the power the papacy claims for itself: the power to make laws. From it has come a flood of human traditions, each one a deadly snare for wretched souls. Their authors have been no more careful than the scribes and Pharisees, who loaded burdens on other people's shoulders that they wouldn't lift with a finger (Matthew 23:4; Luke 11:46). I've already shown elsewhere (Book 3, chapter 4, sections 4-7) what a cruel slaughter they commit through their doctrine of auricular confession. Other laws don't look so violent, but even the ones that seem most bearable press tyrannically on the conscience. I'll say nothing here about how they corrupt the worship of God, or how they rob God, the only Lawgiver, of his right.
The question before us is this: may the Church bind consciences with laws? Civil order isn't in question. We are asking only how God is to be worshipped according to the rule he has himself laid down, and how our spiritual liberty before God can stay unharmed. In ordinary speech, "human traditions" means all the decrees about God's worship that people have issued without the authority of his word. That is what we are fighting. We are not fighting the holy and useful regulations of the Church that serve discipline, decency or peace. Our aim is to curb the boundless and barbarous empire exercised over souls by those who want to be taken for pastors of the Church and who are in fact its cruellest murderers.
They say their laws are spiritual, that they concern the soul, and that they are necessary for eternal life. But that is exactly how Christ's kingdom is invaded and the freedom he gave to believers' consciences is crushed. I say nothing of the greater impiety of those who claim that obeying these laws wins forgiveness of sins, righteousness and salvation, and who make the whole sum of religion and godliness consist in them. My point is simpler: no necessity should be laid on consciences in matters where Christ has made them free. Unless they are free, they cannot have peace with God, as we showed earlier (Book 3, chapter 19). They must acknowledge Christ as their only King and Deliverer, and be ruled by the one law of liberty, the gospel, if they want to keep the grace they have received in him. They can be subject to no bondage and bound by no chains.
2. The weight of these laws
The architects of these constitutions like to imagine that they are laws of liberty, a pleasant yoke and a light burden. Anyone can see that this is false. They don't feel the burden themselves. Having thrown off the fear of God, they calmly ignore their own laws along with God's. But people who care about their salvation are far from feeling free while they're tangled in these snares.
Look at how carefully Paul acted. He wouldn't fasten a single restraint on anyone, and with good reason: he could see how deep a wound would be dealt to the conscience if things the Lord had left free were made compulsory. By contrast, it's almost impossible to count the regulations these men have enforced under penalty of eternal death and demanded with the greatest severity as necessary for salvation. Many of them are extremely hard to keep, and taken together they are impossible, there are so many. How can people under such a mountain of difficulty avoid being tormented with anxiety and filled with terror? So my target here is regulations of this kind: those made to bind the conscience inwardly before God, imposing religious duties as if they commanded things necessary for salvation.
3. What conscience is, and why it matters here
Many people find this question confusing because they don't distinguish carefully enough between the outward court and the court of conscience. The difficulty grows when we read Paul telling us to obey magistrates "not only because of wrath but also for conscience' sake" (Romans 13:5). It seems to follow that civil laws bind the conscience. If that were so, nothing I said about spiritual government in the last chapter, or am about to say in this one, would stand. To resolve it we must first understand what conscience is, and the definition comes from the word itself.
When people grasp things with their minds, we say they "know", and so we speak of knowledge. When, besides this, they have a sense of divine judgment, like a witness that won't let them hide their sins but drags them as accused persons before the judge's seat, that sense is called conscience. It holds a kind of middle position between God and humanity. It won't let us suppress what we know in ourselves, but pursues us until it convicts us. This is what Paul means when he says that conscience bears witness, "their thoughts meanwhile accusing or else excusing them" (Romans 2:15). Bare knowledge could stay shut up inside a person, so this sense, which brings us before God's judgment-seat, has been set over us like a sentry to watch and search out all our secrets so that nothing stays buried in darkness. Hence the old proverb that conscience is a thousand witnesses.
For the same reason Peter speaks of "the pledge of a good conscience toward God" (1 Peter 3:21), meaning the peace of mind we have when, persuaded of Christ's grace, we come boldly into God's presence. And the letter to the Hebrews says we have "no more consciousness of sins" (Hebrews 10:2): we are released and acquitted, so sin no longer accuses us.
4. Conscience looks to God, works look to people
So works have to do with people, but conscience has to do with God. A good conscience is simply inward integrity of heart. That is Paul's meaning when he says that "the goal of this charge is love that comes from a pure heart and a good conscience and a sincere faith" (1 Timothy 1:5). A little later in the same chapter he shows how different it is from mere intellect, saying that some "have rejected" a good conscience "and suffered shipwreck in regard to the faith" (1 Timothy 1:19). By this he shows that conscience is a living inclination to worship God, a sincere desire to live in godliness and holiness.
Sometimes the word is extended to people as well, as when Paul says, "I always take pains to have a clear conscience toward God and man" (Acts 24:16). But that is because the fruits of a good conscience flow out and reach other people too. Strictly speaking, conscience concerns God alone.
So a law binds the conscience when it binds a person simply in itself, without reference to other people. For example, God commands us not only to keep our minds chaste and free from lust, but also forbids every kind of obscenity in speech and all outward lewdness. My conscience is bound to keep that law even if there were not another human being in the world. Someone who lives intemperately doesn't merely set a bad example to his brothers and sisters. He stands convicted in his conscience before God.
Things that are indifferent in themselves follow a different rule. We ought to abstain from them when they cause offence, but our conscience remains free. Paul says of meat offered to idols, "If someone says to you, 'This has been offered in sacrifice,' then do not eat it, for the sake of the one who informed you, and for the sake of conscience": "I do not mean your conscience, but his" (1 Corinthians 10:28-29). A believer who has been warned and still eats would sin. But however necessary abstaining may be for the sake of a brother, as the Lord requires, conscience keeps its liberty. We can see how a law may bind the outward act and still leave the conscience free.
5. Human laws and Paul's command to obey rulers
Back to human laws. If they are imposed to create a religious obligation, as though keeping them were necessary in itself, we say that the restraint they place on the conscience is unlawful. Our consciences have to do with God, not with people. That is the old distinction between the earthly court and the court of conscience. Even when the whole world was wrapped in the thickest darkness, this small ray of light stayed alight: conscience stands above all human judgments. The principle was acknowledged in words and later violated in practice, but God wanted a witness to liberty to exist even then, exempting the conscience from human tyranny.
We still haven't dealt with the difficulty from Paul's words. If we must obey rulers not only from fear of punishment but for conscience' sake, it seems their laws rule the conscience, and if that's true of civil laws, it must be true of church laws too. My answer is that we first need to distinguish the general from the particular. Individual laws don't reach the conscience, but we are bound by the general command of God that tells us to submit to the authorities. That is exactly Paul's point: magistrates are to be honoured because they have been appointed by God (Romans 13:1). He doesn't say that their laws extend to the inner government of the soul. Everywhere else he proclaims that the worship of God and the spiritual rule of righteous living are above all human decrees.
There is a second point that follows from this. Human laws, whether made by magistrates or by the Church, have to be kept (I mean laws that are just and good), but they don't bind the conscience in themselves. The necessity of keeping them lies in the general purpose, not in the particular things commanded. The case is entirely different with laws that prescribe a new way of worshipping God and bring necessity into matters that are free.
6. The papacy's laws and its claim to be our lawgiver
These are exactly what the papacy today calls ecclesiastical constitutions, and presents as part of the true and necessary worship of God. Since there are countless numbers of them, they form countless fetters to bind and ensnare the soul. I touched on this subject when I expounded the law (Book 3, chapter 4, section 6), but this is the proper place for a full treatment, so I'll give as careful a summary as I can. I'll set aside the question of the tyranny by which false bishops claim the right to teach whatever they please, since I've dealt with it enough already, and concentrate on their claim to make laws.
Their excuse for burdening consciences with new laws is that the Lord has appointed them spiritual legislators and given them the government of the Church. So they hold that everything they order has to be obeyed by Christian people, and that anyone who breaks their commands is doubly disobedient, a rebel against both God and the Church. If they were true bishops, I would grant them some authority here: not what they demand, but what is needed for ordering the Church's polity properly. As they are anything but what they want to seem, they can't claim even the smallest authority without overreaching. Still, as I've shown this elsewhere, let's grant for the moment that whatever power true bishops have rightly belongs to them. I still deny that they have been set over believers as legislators, to prescribe a rule of life on their own authority or bind the people entrusted to them by their decrees. I mean they have no right to insist that whatever they invent without the authority of God's word must be kept by the Church as necessary. The apostles knew nothing of such power, and our Lord himself repeatedly denied it to the Church's ministers. I wonder how anyone has dared to seize it, and still dares to defend it, with no apostolic precedent and against God's plain prohibition.
7. God alone is our Lawgiver
The Lord has included everything that belongs to a perfect rule of life in his law, and left nothing for people to add to its summary. He did this first because all right conduct consists in ordering our actions by his will as the standard, so that he alone should be regarded as master and guide of our lives. Second, he did it to show that there is nothing he requires of us more than obedience.
That's why James says, "The one who speaks against a brother or sister or judges a brother or sister speaks against the law and judges the law." And then: "There is only one lawgiver and judge, the one who is able to save and to destroy" (James 4:11-12). God claims it as his own peculiar privilege to rule us by his laws. Isaiah had said the same thing, a little less plainly: "The Lord is our judge, the Lord is our lawgiver, the Lord is our king; he will save us" (Isaiah 33:22). Both passages show that the power of life and death belongs to the one who has power over the soul. No human being may take this to himself. God, who alone can save and destroy, must be acknowledged as the only King of souls, the one who is, in Isaiah's words, our King and Judge and Lawgiver and Saviour.
So Peter, reminding pastors of their duty, urges them to shepherd the flock without "domineering over those in your charge" (1 Peter 5:2-3), meaning the heritage of believers. If we see that it's wrong to transfer to human beings what God declares belongs to him alone, we'll see that this cuts off completely all the power claimed by those who take it on themselves to order anything in the Church without the authority of God's word.
8. The two reasons God keeps this for himself, and the test they give us
The whole question depends on this: God being the only lawgiver, it's unlawful for anyone to claim that honour. So it's worth fixing in mind the two reasons for which God claims it exclusively. The first is that his will is for us the perfect rule of all righteousness and holiness, so that in knowing it we have a perfect rule of life. The second is that when the question is how he should be worshipped, the one we ought to obey, and on whose will we must depend, alone has authority over our souls.
With these two reasons in view, it's easy to decide which human regulations are contrary to the Lord's word. They are all those devised as part of the true worship of God, and the keeping of which is bound on the conscience as a matter of necessary obligation. Let's remember to weigh all human laws in this balance, if we want a sure test that won't let us go astray.
Paul uses the first reason in Colossians, against false apostles who were trying to lay new burdens on the churches. He uses the second more often in Galatians, in a similar case. In Colossians he maintains that the teaching of the true worship of God isn't to be sought from human beings, because the Lord has taught us faithfully and fully how he is to be worshipped. To show this, he says in the first chapter that the gospel contains all wisdom, so that everyone may be presented mature in Christ. At the beginning of chapter 2 he says that all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge are hidden in Christ, and concludes that believers should beware of being carried away from Christ's flock by philosophy and empty deceit, according to human tradition (Colossians 2:3-8). Near the end of the chapter he condemns even more firmly all self-made worship, that is, all the forms of worship that people invent or take over from others, and every precept anyone presumes to hand down on his own authority about the worship of God. We hold, then, that all regulations are impious if the worship of God is supposed to consist in keeping them. The passages in Galatians where Paul insists that no fetters are to be fastened on the conscience, which must be ruled by God alone, are plain enough, especially chapter 5. It's enough to refer to them.
9. Papal ceremonies and discipline: why we oppose both
Let me make the matter plainer by applying it to our own times. The regulations called ecclesiastical, with which the pope and his followers burden the Church, we hold to be harmful and impious, while our opponents defend them as holy and healthy. They come in two kinds: some concern ceremonies and rites, others discipline. Do we have good reason to oppose both? We have a better reason than we would like.
First, their own authors openly say that the very essence of the worship of God is contained in them. Why else do they bring forward their ceremonies, if not so that God may be worshipped by them? This isn't merely the mistake of an ignorant crowd. It has the approval of those who hold the office of teachers. I'm not speaking of the gross abominations by which they've corrupted all godliness. But they wouldn't regard it as so terrible a crime to go wrong in some tiny tradition if they hadn't made the worship of God subordinate to their inventions. Paul declares it intolerable that the lawful worship of God should be made subject to human will. So where do we go wrong if we can't tolerate it today? Especially when we're being told to worship God "according to the elementary principles of the world", something Paul says is opposed to Christ (Colossians 2:20)?
On the other side, everyone knows how they lay consciences under a strict necessity of obeying whatever they command. In protesting against this we make common cause with Paul, who will in no way allow believers' consciences to be brought under human bondage.
10. How their traditions nullify God's commandment
The worst of it is that once religion begins to be made up of these empty inventions, the perversion is quickly followed by the shocking wickedness that our Lord charged against the Pharisees, of making void the commandment of God through their traditions (Matthew 15:3, 6). I don't want to argue this in my own words. Let our present legislators win the case if they can clear themselves of Christ's accusation. How can they, when they treat it as far worse to let a year pass without auricular confession than to spend it in the greatest wickedness? Far worse to have let a bit of meat touch the tongue on a Friday than to have defiled the whole body daily with fornication? Far worse to have done honest work on a day consecrated to some saint than to have used all one's members for the worst of crimes? Far worse for a priest to be joined to one woman in lawful marriage than to be involved in a thousand adulteries? Far worse to have failed to complete a vowed pilgrimage than to have broken faith in every promise? Far worse not to have poured out money on the monstrous, excessive and useless luxury of churches than to have refused the poor in their greatest need? Far worse to have walked past an idol without honouring it than to have treated the whole human race with contempt? Far worse not to have mumbled long meaningless formulas at set times than never to have framed one proper prayer?
What does it mean to make God's word void by tradition, if this isn't it? They recommend God's commandments coldly and perfunctorily, yet they press obedience to their own regulations with great zeal, as if the whole power of godliness lay in them. They excuse breaches of the divine law with trivial penances, yet visit the smallest violation of one of their decrees with imprisonment, exile, fire or sword. They are neither severe nor unbending toward despisers of God, but they persecute to the extreme, with unrelenting hatred, those who despise themselves. And they train the simple people they hold in bondage so well that these would sooner see the whole law of God overturned than one iota of what they call the precepts of the Church broken.
There's a grievous fault in this at the start: one person despises, judges and rejects his neighbour over trivial matters, matters which, by God's judgment, are free. But as if that were a small evil, these "weak and worthless elementary principles", as Paul calls them in Galatians (4:9), are valued above the heavenly oracles of God. A man practically acquitted of adultery is judged over his food, and the one who is allowed his fornication is forbidden to marry. That, in the end, is all that this double-dealing obedience achieves: it turns away from God exactly as far as it turns toward human beings.
11. Useless observances, and the pull back to Judaism
There are two other serious faults we find in these regulations. First, much of what they prescribe is useless and sometimes absurd. Second, the sheer mass of it oppresses devout consciences and carries them back to a sort of Judaism, so that they cling to shadows and can't come to Christ.
I know it will hardly be believed that these things are useless and absurd, by worldly wisdom that finds them so attractive that the Church seems entirely disfigured without them. But that is exactly what Paul says: they "have indeed an appearance of wisdom in promoting self-made religion and asceticism and severity to the body" (Colossians 2:23). That is a most healthy warning, and we should never lose sight of it. Human traditions, he says, deceive by an appearance of wisdom. Where does the appearance come from? First, because they're made by people, the human mind recognises something of its own in them, and when it recognises it, it embraces it more willingly than anything better that suits its vanity less. Second, because they seem to train people in humility while keeping their minds crawling on the ground under a yoke, and that gives them another recommendation. Finally, because they appear to curb the will of the flesh and subdue it by strict abstinence, they seem wisely devised.
What does Paul say to all this? Does he tear off these masks so that simple people won't be fooled by a false pretext? He thinks it enough, as a refutation, to say that they are human devices, and passes over all the rest as worthless. Because he knew that all invented worship is condemned in the Church, and is the more suspect to believers the more pleasing it is to the human mind; because he knew that the false show of outward humility differs so widely from true humility that it can easily be told apart; and because he knew that this discipline is worth no more than "bodily training" (1 Timothy 4:8), he wanted the very things that recommend human traditions to the ignorant to be taken by believers as their refutation.
12. The glare of ceremonies
It's the same today. Not only the uneducated crowd but everyone in proportion to how puffed up he is with worldly wisdom is wonderfully taken by the glitter of ceremonies. Hypocrites and silly women think nothing could be imagined better or more beautiful. But those who examine them thoroughly and weigh them more truly by the rule of godliness know two things: that they are useless trifles, and that they are tricks that deceive the eyes of spectators with empty show. I'm speaking of the ceremonies the Roman teachers insist are great mysteries, and that we know by experience to be mere mockery.
It's no wonder their authors have gone so far in deceiving themselves and others with such frivolities. They took their model partly from the dreams of the pagans, and partly, like apes, rashly imitated the old rites of the law of Moses, which have no more to do with us than the sacrifice of animals. If there were no other proof, no sane person would expect any good from such a mismatched hodgepodge. The facts themselves show that very many ceremonies have no use except to stupefy the people rather than teach them. In the same way, hypocrites make much of the new canons that distort discipline rather than preserve it, but a closer look shows they are only the shadow and fleeting ghost of discipline.
13. The sheer number, and how it always grows
The second fault is the multitude. Who can fail to see that ceremonies, heaped one on another, have grown so numerous that the Christian Church cannot bear them? So there's a strange mixture of Judaism in them, while other observances prove a deadly snare to godly minds.
Augustine complained that in his day, while God's commandments were neglected, custom was so powerful that someone who touched the ground barefoot during the week after Easter was censured more severely than someone who drowned his wits in wine. He complained that the Church, which God in mercy meant to be free, was so burdened that the condition of the Jews was more bearable (Augustine, Letter 119). If that holy man had lived in our day, how he would have lamented the bondage we now have! The number is ten times greater, and every iota is demanded a hundred times more strictly than then.
This is how it usually goes. Once perverse lawmakers have seized authority, they never stop commanding and forbidding until they reach the extreme of harshness. Paul put this neatly: "If with Christ you died to the elemental spirits of the world, why, as if you were still alive in the world, do you submit to regulations: 'Do not handle, Do not taste, Do not touch'?" (Colossians 2:20-21). The word he uses for "taste" can mean both eating and touching; here it's surely taken in the first sense so that there's no needless repetition. He describes the progress of false teachers beautifully. Superstition begins by forbidding not only eating but even a gentle chewing. When it has won that, it forbids even tasting. When that too is yielded, it decides it's unlawful even to touch with a finger.
14. Christ's few sacraments, and the "weak brothers" excuse
We rightly condemn this tyranny, in which wretched consciences are strangely tormented by endless edicts and by the excessive strictness with which they're enforced. I've dealt with the canons concerning discipline elsewhere (above, section 12; also chapter 12). What can I say of ceremonies, whose effect has been that we have almost buried Christ and gone back to Jewish figures? "Our Lord Christ," says Augustine, "bound together the society of his new people by sacraments, very few in number, most excellent in meaning, and easiest to keep" (Letter 118). It would be hard to say how far this simplicity is from the multitude and variety of rites in which the Church is tangled today.
I know the excuse some clever people make for this perversity. They say there are many among us as unlearned as any among the people of Israel, and that this tutoring was brought in for their sake. The strong may do without it, but they shouldn't neglect it, since it helps the weak. My answer is that we know well enough what is owed to the weakness of others, but the way to look after the weak is not to bury them under a heap of ceremonies. God had a reason for distinguishing us from his ancient people: he trained them like children with signs and figures, and trains us more simply, without so much outward show. Paul says, "the heir, as long as he is a child... is under guardians and managers" (Galatians 4:1-2). That was the Jews' condition under the law. But we are like adults, freed from guardians and trustees, and have no need of childish lessons. God surely foresaw what kind of people he would have in his Church and how they should be governed, and he made the distinction between us and the Jews in the way I've described. So it is a foolish way of caring for the ignorant to set up again the Judaism that Christ has abolished.
Christ expressed this contrast between the old people and the new when he told the Samaritan woman, "The hour is coming, and is now here, when the true worshippers will worship the Father in spirit and truth" (John 4:23). That had always been so in a sense, but the new worshippers differ from the old in this: under Moses the spiritual worship of God was shadowed and, as it were, tangled up in many ceremonies, whereas those have now been abolished and worship is simpler. People who confuse this distinction overturn the order Christ set up and approved.
You'll ask: are the more ignorant to be given no ceremonies at all to help their ignorance? I don't say that. I think such help is very useful to them. My point is only that the measure should be one that illustrates Christ and doesn't obscure him. That is why a few ceremonies, by no means burdensome, were divinely appointed, so that they might show a present Christ. The Jews were given a larger number so that they might be images of an absent Christ. (By "absent" I don't mean absent in power, but in the manner in which he was shown.) To keep due moderation, then, we need to hold on to that smallness of number, ease of observance, and richness of meaning that comes from clarity. It's useless to say that this isn't being done. Everyone can see it.
15. Works of human invention, and ceremonies that teach nothing
I say nothing of the harmful notions with which people's minds are filled: that these are sacrifices by which God is appeased, sins are expiated, and righteousness and salvation are won. It may be argued that good things in themselves aren't spoiled by errors of this kind, since similar errors can attach to acts that God himself commanded. But nothing is more unbecoming than that works devised by human will should be held in such esteem as to be thought worthy of eternal life.
The works God commands receive a reward because the Lawgiver himself accepts them as marks of obedience. They don't get their value from their own worth or merit, but because God values our obedience to him so highly. (I'm speaking of that perfection of works which God commands but people don't achieve. Even the works of the law are accepted only by God's free kindness, since our obedience is weak and defective. But we aren't discussing here how far works count apart from Christ, so I'll leave that.) What I repeat, because it belongs to this subject, is that whatever praise works have, they have in respect of obedience, which alone God regards. He testifies to that through the prophet: "In the day that I brought them out of the land of Egypt, I did not speak to your fathers or command them concerning burnt offerings and sacrifices. But this command I gave them: 'Obey my voice'" (Jeremiah 7:22-23). Of invented works he says elsewhere, "Why do you spend your money for that which is not bread?" (Isaiah 55:2), and again, "In vain do they worship me, teaching as doctrines the commandments of men" (Matthew 15:9). So they can't excuse themselves from the charge of letting wretched people look for a righteousness in these outward trifles, one they could present to God and stand on before the heavenly tribunal.
It's also a fault richly deserving blame that they put on meaningless ceremonies like stage plays or magical incantations. All ceremonies are corrupt and harmful if they don't direct people to Christ, and the ceremonies of the papacy are cut off from doctrine, so they confine people to signs without any meaning. Finally, since the belly is a resourceful inventor, it's clear that many ceremonies were devised by greedy priests as bait for catching money. Whatever their origin, they're so prostituted to dirty profit that a great part of them would have to be scrapped to stop a profane and sacrilegious trade from going on in the Church.
16. A general test for all human traditions
Though it may look as if I'm not giving the general doctrine of human constitutions but fitting my argument wholly to our own age, nothing I've said fails to apply to every age. Whenever people start the superstitious practice of worshipping God with their own inventions, all the laws made for this purpose quickly degenerate into these gross abuses. The curse God pronounces, of striking with stupor and blindness those who worship him with human doctrines, is not confined to one time but holds for all. The unvarying result of this blindness is that people who despise God's many warnings and entangle themselves in these deadly fetters leave no kind of absurdity untried.
If you want to know simply, apart from circumstances, what marks the human traditions that the Church must reject and all the godly condemn, the definition we gave earlier is clear and certain. They include all laws made by people, without the authority of God's word, either to prescribe the manner of divine worship or to lay a religious obligation on the conscience as though they commanded things necessary for salvation. If one or both of these are joined by other evils, such as obscuring the clarity of the gospel by their number, giving no edification, being idle and frivolous pursuits rather than true exercises of piety, being set up for sordid gain, being hard to keep, or being tainted with harmful superstitions, we have the means of measuring how much mischief they cause.
17. "The Church is guided by the Spirit": the first answer
I know what they'll answer: that these traditions aren't from them but from God. The Church, they say, is guided by the Holy Spirit so that it can't err, and the Spirit's authority lives in them. If that is conceded, it follows that their traditions are revelations of the Holy Spirit and can't be disregarded without impiety and contempt of God. And so that they won't seem to have tried anything without high authority, they want us to believe that a large part of their practices comes from the apostles. In their view the apostles show in one case what they did in others: when the apostles met in council and announced to the Gentiles, as the council's opinion, that they should "abstain from the things polluted by idols, and from sexual immorality, and from what has been strangled, and from blood" (Acts 15:20, 29).
We have already explained how they falsely take the name of Church to exalt themselves (chapter 8, sections 10-13). If we strip off all masks and glosses in this case, which should be our first concern and is also in our highest interest, and consider what kind of Church Christ wants, so that we can form ourselves by it as a standard, it will quickly appear that it is no mark of the Church to ignore the limits of God's word and run wild in making new laws.
Doesn't the law once given to the Church stand for ever? "Everything that I command you, you shall be careful to do. You shall not add to it or take from it" (Deuteronomy 12:32). And elsewhere: "Do not add to his words, lest he rebuke you and you be found a liar" (Proverbs 30:6). They can't deny that this was said to the Church, so what are they proclaiming but their own stubbornness when, despite such prohibitions, they profess to add to God's teaching and presume to mix their own with it? Far be it from us to agree to the falsehood by which they insult the Church. The name of Church is falsely claimed wherever people contend for that reckless human licence that can't stay within the boundaries set by God's word, but breaks out insolently and resorts to its own inventions. In this passage nothing is tangled, obscure or ambiguous: the whole Church is forbidden to add to or take from God's word, as regards his worship and the precepts of salvation.
"But that was said only of the Law, which the Prophets and the whole gospel dispensation then followed!" I admit it, but I add that these were fulfilments of the Law rather than additions or subtractions. If the Lord doesn't allow anything to be added to or taken from the ministry of Moses, wrapped up as it was in many folds of obscurity, until he furnished clearer teaching through the prophets and finally through his beloved Son, why should we not suppose that we are much more strictly forbidden to add anything to the Law, the Prophets, the Psalms and the Gospel? The Lord can't forget himself, and long ago he declared that nothing offends him so much as being worshipped by human inventions.
Hence those famous declarations of the prophets, which ought to ring in our ears continually: "I did not speak to your fathers or command them in the day that I brought them out of the land of Egypt concerning burnt offerings or sacrifices. But this command I gave them: 'Obey my voice, and I will be your God, and you shall be my people; and walk in all the way that I command you'" (Jeremiah 7:22-23). "I solemnly warned your fathers when I brought them up out of the land of Egypt, warning them persistently, even to this day, saying, 'Obey my voice'" (Jeremiah 11:7). The best known of all is this: "Has the Lord as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices as in obeying the voice of the Lord? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to listen than the fat of rams. For rebellion is as the sin of divination, and presumption is as iniquity and idolatry" (1 Samuel 15:22-23). It's easy to prove, then, that whenever human inventions of this kind are defended by the Church's authority, they can't be cleared of the charge of impiety, and the name of Church is falsely claimed.
18. We honour the Church by obeying its Lord; the traditions are not apostolic
So we speak freely against the tyranny of human traditions that is arrogantly forced on us in the Church's name. We aren't mocking the Church, as our opponents unjustly say to stir up ill feeling. We give her the praise of obedience, and she acknowledges none greater. It's they who injure the Church, by presenting her as rebellious toward her Lord, as though she went further than God's word allows. And they combine shamelessness with malice when they keep shouting about the power of the Church while hiding both the command the Lord gave her and the obedience she owes to it. If our wish is, as it should be, to agree with the Church, it matters more to consider and remember the instruction the Lord has given to us and to the Church alike: to obey him with one heart. We will certainly agree best with the Church when we show ourselves obedient to the Lord in everything.
To trace the origin of the traditions that have burdened the Church to the apostles is plain imposture, since the whole substance of the apostles' teaching is that conscience must not be burdened with new observances nor God's worship contaminated by our inventions. And if any credit is to be given to ancient histories and records, what they attribute to the apostles was not only unknown to them but never even heard of by them. Nor can they pretend that most of their decrees, though never written down, were received by use and practice, being things the apostles couldn't grasp while Christ was in the world but learned after his ascension by the Holy Spirit's revelation. I've explained that passage elsewhere (chapter 8, section 14). In regard to this question, they make themselves truly ridiculous. All those mysteries that were so long undiscovered by the apostles are plainly either Jewish or pagan customs, the first long ago given among the Jews, the second spread among all the nations, or else absurd gestures and empty ceremonies, which stupid priests without sense or learning can perform properly, and which children and street performers can do so well that it seems you couldn't find fitter priests for such sacrifices.
Even without records, sensible people would judge from the nature of the case that such a mass of rites and observances didn't rush into the Church all at once but crept in gradually. The venerable bishops nearest to the apostles in time introduced some things about order and discipline. But those who came after them, and those after them again, lacked judgment and had too much curiosity and greed, each latecomer vying in foolish rivalry with his predecessors so as not to be outdone in inventing novelties. And since there was a danger that these inventions, from which they expected praise from posterity, might soon go out of use, they insisted all the more strictly on observing them. This false zeal produced a great part of the rites that these men present as apostolic. History bears witness to it.
19. The Lord's Supper as an example
I won't be tedious by listing everything. One example will do. Under the apostles the Lord's Supper was administered with great simplicity. Their immediate successors added some things to the dignity of the ordinance, which are not to be disapproved. Afterwards came foolish imitators who kept patching fragments together and left us the priestly vestments we see at the mass, the altar ornaments, the gestures and the whole hodgepodge of useless observances.
They object that in ancient times it was believed that what was done with the consent of the whole Church came from the apostles, and they cite Augustine. I'll give the explanation in Augustine's own words: "The things we observe all over the world we may understand to have been appointed either by the apostles themselves or by general councils, whose authority in the Church is most useful, such as the annual solemn celebration of our Lord's passion, resurrection and ascension into heaven, and of the coming of the Holy Spirit, and anything else observed by the whole Church wherever it exists" (Letter 118). In naming so few examples, anyone can see that he meant to trace the observances of his day to authors worthy of trust and respect, and that they were few and sober, serving to maintain the Church's order. How different from our Roman teachers, who insist that not a single trivial ceremony of theirs fails to be apostolic!
20. Holy water
Here is another example. Ask them where they got their holy water, and they'll answer at once: from the apostles. As if I didn't know which Roman bishop history credits with inventing it, who, if he had brought the apostles into his council, would surely never have corrupted baptism with a foreign and ill-timed symbol. I don't even think it likely that the origin of that consecration is as ancient as the record claims. Augustine says that in his day some churches rejected the formal imitation of Christ's washing of feet, in case the rite should seem to belong to baptism (Letter 118). That shows there was then no washing at all that resembled baptism.
However that may be, I will never admit that the apostolic Spirit gave rise to a daily sign by which baptism, brought back to memory, is in a way repeated. It doesn't matter to me that Augustine elsewhere ascribes other things to the apostles. He has nothing better than conjecture, and that isn't enough to judge a matter of such weight. Finally, even if we grant that the things he mentions come from the apostolic age, there's a great difference between setting up some exercise of piety that believers may use with a free conscience or leave aside if they find it unhelpful, and enacting a law that binds the conscience. Whoever the originator is, since we see the serious abuses that have followed, nothing prevents us from abolishing these things without any slur on him, since he never recommended them in a way that laid on us a fixed and unbreakable obligation to keep them.
21. The Jerusalem council did not make a new law
It doesn't help their tyranny much to cite the example of the apostles. They say the apostles and elders of the early Church passed a decree without any authority from Christ, commanding all the Gentiles to abstain from meat offered to idols, from things strangled and from blood (Acts 15:20). If that was lawful for them, why shouldn't their successors be allowed to copy them as often as the need arises? If only they would always imitate the apostles, in this and in other matters! I'm ready to prove on good grounds that nothing new was instituted or decreed by the apostles here.
When Peter says in that council that God is being tested if a yoke is placed on the disciples' necks, he would undermine his own argument if he then allowed a yoke to be put on them. But it is put on them if the apostles, on their own authority, forbid the Gentiles to touch meat offered to idols, things strangled and blood. The difficulty remains that they do seem to forbid these things. It's easily removed by looking more closely at the decree's meaning. The first and most important point is that the Gentiles were to keep their liberty, which was not to be disturbed, and they were not to be troubled with the observances of the Law. So far, the decree is entirely on our side. The qualification that follows is not a new law enacted by the apostles. It is the divine and eternal command of God against violating charity, and it takes nothing from that liberty. It only reminds the Gentiles how to accommodate themselves to their brothers and not misuse their liberty to give offence. The second point, then, is that the Gentiles are to use a harmless liberty, giving no offence to the brothers. Still, the apostles do specify something: they show, as the time required, which things would offend their brothers, so that the Gentiles could avoid them. But they add nothing new of their own to God's eternal law forbidding the offence of the brothers.
22. Giving up freedom out of charity is not a new law
Suppose faithful pastors, in charge of churches not yet well established, tell their flocks not to eat meat on Friday until the weak among whom they live grow stronger, or not to work on a holy day, or something similar. When superstition is set aside, these matters are indifferent in themselves, yet where they give offence to the brothers they can't be done without sin. There are times when believers can't set this example before weak brothers without badly wounding their consciences. Only a slanderer would say that a new law is being made by people who are plainly just guarding against the scandals that their Master has expressly forbidden.
Nothing more than this can be said of the apostles. Their only aim in removing grounds of offence was to enforce the divine law that prohibits offence. It was as if they said: the Lord has commanded you not to hurt a weak brother, but you can't eat meat offered to idols, things strangled and blood without offending weak brothers, so we require you, in the Lord's name, not to eat so as to offend. The best witness that the apostles had this in view is Paul, who writes in line with the council's opinion: "Therefore, as to the eating of food offered to idols, we know that 'an idol has no real existence,' and that 'there is no God but one.'" "However, not all possess this knowledge. But some, through former association with idols, eat food as really offered to an idol, and their conscience, being weak, is defiled." "But take care that this right of yours does not somehow become a stumbling block to the weak" (1 Corinthians 8:4-9). Anyone who weighs this properly won't be taken in by the gloss they use as a cloak for their tyranny, that the apostles began by their decree to infringe the Church's liberty.
And so that they can't escape without admitting the accuracy of this explanation, let them tell me by what authority they dared to repeal this very decree. It was, evidently, because the danger of those offences and quarrels the apostles wanted to prevent no longer existed, and they knew that a law is to be judged by its purpose. Since the law was passed with charity in view, it prescribes nothing except as charity requires. In admitting that breaking this law is nothing but a violation of charity, don't they acknowledge at the same time that it wasn't some added supplement to God's law, but a genuine and simple application of it to the times and customs for which it was meant?
23. "We must put up with it": why this cannot be endured
Even though such laws are a hundred times unjust and harmful to us, they still say we must listen to them without exception. What is asked of us, they say, isn't agreement with errors but only submission to the strict commands of those set over us, commands we aren't free to refuse (1 Peter 2:18). But here too the Lord comes to the help of his word and frees us from this bondage by asserting the liberty he bought for us with his sacred blood, whose benefit he has more than once confirmed in his word. What is demanded of us is not, as they maliciously pretend, to endure some heavy bodily oppression. It is to be tortured in our consciences and brought into slavery, in other words, to be robbed of the benefits of Christ's blood.
Even setting that aside as though it were beside the point, do we think it a small matter that the Lord is deprived of his kingdom, which he so strictly claims for himself? He is deprived of it every time he is worshipped with laws of human invention, since he wants to be the sole legislator of his worship. And so that no one thinks this unimportant, let's hear how the Lord himself rates it: "Because this people draw near with their mouth and honour me with their lips, while their hearts are far from me, and their fear of me is a commandment taught by men, therefore, behold, I will again do wonderful things with this people, with wonder upon wonder; and the wisdom of their wise men shall perish, and the discernment of their discerning men shall be hidden" (Isaiah 29:13-14). And again, "In vain do they worship me, teaching as doctrines the commandments of men" (Matthew 15:9).
When the children of Israel defiled themselves with every kind of idolatry, the cause of the whole evil is traced to the impure mixture that came from neglecting God's commandments and devising new forms of worship. The sacred history tells how the new settlers brought by the king of Assyria from Babylon to live in Samaria were torn apart by lions because they did not know "the law of the god of the land" (2 Kings 17:24-34). Even if they had done nothing wrong in ceremonies, their empty show couldn't have pleased God. Meanwhile he kept punishing them for violating his worship by bringing in inventions foreign to his word. When they were frightened by the punishment, they took up the rites prescribed in the Law, but since they still did not worship God purely, the text says twice over that they feared the Lord and did not fear him. From this we learn that part of the reverence we owe him is to worship him simply as he commands, without mixing in our own inventions. In the same way godly kings are repeatedly praised for acting according to all his commands and turning aside neither to the right nor to the left (2 Kings 22:1-2).
I go further. Even where no open impiety appears in invented worship, the Spirit strictly condemns it, because it is a departure from God's command. The altar of Ahaz, modelled on one from Damascus (2 Kings 16:10), might have looked like an added ornament for the temple, since his intention was to offer sacrifices there to God alone, and to do it more splendidly than at the old altar. Yet we see how the Spirit hates the bold attempt, for no other reason than that human inventions in God's worship are impure corruptions. And the more clearly God's will has been shown to us, the less excusable our presumption is when we try anything of our own. So the guilt of Manasseh is made heavier by his building a new altar in Jerusalem, of which the Lord had said, "In Jerusalem I will put my name" (2 Kings 21:4-7), because the authority of God was by that act openly rejected.
24. Why God hates worship made to human specification
Many wonder why God threatens so sternly to bring astonishment on those who worship him with the commandments of men, and declares such worship vain. But if they considered what it means, in religion, which is heavenly wisdom, to depend on God alone, they'd also see that the Lord has weighty grounds for hating this perverse service offered at the whim of human will. Obeying such laws in worship has a show of humility, but those who do it are anything but humble, since they are prescribing to God the very laws they keep. That is why Paul wants us to be so careful not to be deceived by the traditions of men and by what he calls "self-made religion", that is, worship invented by people without God's sanction.
It really is so: we must be fools in our own wisdom and in all human wisdom, in order to let him alone be wise. Those who try to win his approval with paltry observances of human devising, and as it were force on him against his will a crooked obedience that is actually given to men, do exactly the opposite. This has been the course for many centuries, within our own memory, and still today in places where the creature's power is greater than the Creator's, and where religion (if it deserves the name) is polluted with more and more absurd superstitions than paganism ever had. What could human sense produce but things fleshly and foolish, tasting of their makers?
25. Samuel, Manoah and Gideon
The defenders of superstition appeal to Samuel, who sacrificed at Ramah, and pleased God even though he acted against the Law (1 Samuel 7:17). The answer is easy. He did not set up a second altar in opposition to the one true altar. The place for the ark of the covenant hadn't yet been fixed, so he sacrificed in the town where he lived, as the most convenient place. It was never the intention of the holy prophet to innovate in sacred things, where the Lord had so strictly forbidden adding or subtracting.
I take Manoah's case to have been extraordinary and special. Though a private man, he offered sacrifice to God, and not without approval, because he did it not on a rash impulse of his own but by divine inspiration (Judges 13:19). How much God detests all human devices in his worship is shown in the case of a man no less than Manoah, Gideon, whose ephod brought ruin not only on him and his family but on the whole people (Judges 8:27). In short, every added invention by which people want to worship God is nothing but a pollution of true holiness.
26. "Do what the Pharisees tell you"
Why then, they ask, did Christ say that the intolerable burdens laid by the scribes and Pharisees were to be borne (Matthew 23:3)? On the contrary, why did he say elsewhere that we must beware of the leaven of the Pharisees (Matthew 16:6)? Matthew himself explains leaven as whatever human teaching is mixed with the pure word of God. What could be plainer than that we're told to avoid and beware of their whole teaching? It follows with certainty that in the other passage our Lord never meant his people's consciences to be harassed by the mere traditions of the Pharisees. The words, unless twisted, don't say that.
Our Lord, starting to attack the Pharisees' conduct, first teaches his hearers that even if they saw nothing worth following in the Pharisees' lives, they should still do what they taught by word when they sat in the seat of Moses, that is, when they expounded the Law. All he meant was to guard ordinary people against being led by their teachers' bad example into despising the teaching. But since some people are not moved by reason at all and always demand authority, I'll quote Augustine, who says exactly the same thing:
"The Lord's sheepfold has persons set over it, of whom some are faithful, others hirelings. Those who are faithful are true shepherds, but learn that hirelings are necessary too. For many in the Church, pursuing earthly advantages, preach Christ, and the voice of Christ is heard through them, and the sheep follow not a hireling but the shepherd by means of a hireling. Learn that hirelings were pointed out by the Lord himself. 'The scribes and the Pharisees,' he says, 'sit on Moses' seat; so do and observe whatever they tell you, but not what they do.' What is this but to say: hear the voice of the shepherd through hirelings? Sitting in the chair, they teach the Law of God, and so God teaches through them. But if they choose to teach their own, do not listen, do not do it." (Augustine, Tractate 46 on John)
27. Lawful church order: decency and order
Many unlearned people, hearing that it is impious to bind the conscience and vain to worship God with human traditions, put one blot on all the laws by which the Church's order is established. That mistake needs heading off. The danger of error is real, because it's not easy at first glance to see how widely the two things differ. But I'll make the matter so clear in a few words that no one need be misled by the resemblance.
First, understand that in every human society some form of government is needed to secure public peace and maintain harmony. In transacting business some form must always be observed, which public decency, and indeed humanity itself, require us not to ignore. This must apply especially in churches, which are best sustained by a well-ordered constitution and cannot have harmony without it. So if we want to provide for the Church's welfare, we must always attend carefully to Paul's instruction that all things be done "decently and in order" (1 Corinthians 14:40).
People are so different in their ways, so varied in mind, so opposed in judgment and temperament, that no government is firm enough without certain laws, and no rite can be observed without a fixed form. So far from condemning laws that serve this end, we hold that removing them would cripple the Church and disfigure and scatter it entirely. Paul's instruction that all things be done decently and in order can't be kept unless order and decency are secured by the addition of regulations, as a kind of bonds. But with these regulations we must always keep to one exception: they must not be thought necessary for salvation, nor lay the conscience under a religious obligation, nor be compared to the worship of God or put in place of godliness.
28. The test: decency and order
So we have an excellent and sure mark for telling the impious regulations (which, as we said, overturn true religion and subvert conscience) from the Church's legitimate observances. We need only remember that one or both of two things are always intended: that in the sacred gathering of believers all things may be done decently and with fitting dignity, and that human society may be kept in order by certain bonds, so to speak, of moderation and humanity. When a law is understood to be made for the sake of public decency, there's no room for the superstition of those who measure the worship of God by human inventions. And when a law is known to be meant for common use, the false idea of its obligation and necessity, which so alarms the conscience when traditions are held necessary for salvation, falls away, since all that is sought is to maintain charity through a shared practice.
It may help to explain more clearly what Paul means by decency and what is included in order. The purpose of decency is partly that rites which produce reverence in sacred things may stir us to godliness, and partly that the modesty and gravity that should be seen in all honourable actions may be especially evident here. In order, the first thing is that those who preside know the law and rule of right government, and that those who are governed are accustomed to obedience and good discipline. The second is that the Church's affairs be arranged so as to provide for peace and tranquillity.
29. Examples of true decency
So we won't call "decency" something that merely provides empty pleasure, like the theatrical display the papists put on in their public services, where there is nothing but a mask of useless splendour and fruitless luxury. We call decency that which suits the reverence due to sacred mysteries, forms a fit exercise of piety, or at least gives an ornament suited to the occasion, and is not without fruit, reminding believers of the great modesty, seriousness and reverence with which sacred things should be handled. Ceremonies, to be exercises of piety, must lead us directly to Christ. In the same way, order doesn't consist in pointless pomp that gives only fleeting splendour, but in an arrangement that removes all confusion, boorishness, stubbornness, and all turbulence and dissension.
We have examples of the first class in 1 Corinthians 11, where Paul says that common meals must not be mixed with the Lord's sacred Supper and that women must not appear in public with heads uncovered (1 Corinthians 11:5, 21). There are many other things we do daily, such as praying on our knees and with head uncovered, administering the Lord's sacraments not carelessly but with some dignity, and observing some solemnity in burying our dead. In the other class are the hours set aside for public prayer, preaching and solemn services; quiet and silence during the sermon; fixed places; the singing of hymns; days set apart for celebrating the Lord's Supper; Paul's prohibition of women teaching in the church; and similar matters. We may add especially those things that preserve discipline, such as catechising, church censures, excommunication, fasting and so on. All the ecclesiastical regulations we admit to be holy and healthy can thus be reduced to two heads: one concerning rites and ceremonies, the other concerning discipline and peace.
30. Human and divine: the bending of the knee
There is a danger on one side that false bishops will take a pretext from this for their impious and tyrannical laws, and a danger on the other that some, too easily alarmed by those evils, will leave no place for any laws, however holy. So let me say that I approve only those human regulations that are founded on God's authority, drawn from Scripture, and therefore entirely divine.
Take the bending of the knee in public prayer. Is this a human tradition that anyone is free to reject or neglect? I say it is human, and also divine. It is from God, as part of that decency whose care and observance the apostle recommends. And it is from people, as it specifically determines what was indicated in general rather than explained in detail. From this one example we can judge what to think of the whole class. The whole sum of righteousness, every part of divine worship and everything necessary for salvation, the Lord has faithfully comprehended and clearly set out in his sacred oracles, so that in these he alone is the Master to be heard. But in outward discipline and ceremonies he hasn't been pleased to prescribe every detail we should observe. He foresaw that this depended on the nature of the times, and that one form would not suit all ages. In these matters we must have recourse to the general rules he has given, and use them to test whatever the Church's need may require to be commanded for order and decency.
Finally, since he hasn't given an express command, because these matters are not necessary for salvation and should be adapted, for the Church's edification, to the changing circumstances of each age and nation, it is right, as the Church's interest may require, to change and repeal the old forms as well as introduce new ones. I admit that we shouldn't innovate rashly, constantly or for trivial reasons. Charity is the best judge of what tends to harm or to build up. If we let her be our guide, all will be safe.
31. How to keep such regulations
Things appointed by this rule are to be observed by the Christian people with a free conscience and without superstition, but also with a devout and ready willingness to obey. They are not to be held in contempt, passed over with careless indifference, still less openly broken in pride and defiance. You'll ask what liberty of conscience there is in such careful observance. In fact, this liberty shows up best when we hold that these are not fixed and perpetual obligations to which we are bound, but outward helps for human weakness, which we don't all need but all use, because we are bound to nurture mutual charity.
We can see this in the examples above. Is religion placed in a woman's head covering, so that it's unlawful for her to go out with her head uncovered? Is her silence fixed by a decree that can't be broken without terrible wickedness? Is there any mystery in bending the knee, or in burying a dead body, that can't be left out without a crime? Not at all. If a woman has to hurry so quickly to help a neighbour that she has no time to cover her head, she doesn't sin by running out uncovered. There are times when it is as fitting for her to speak as at other times to be silent. Nothing forbids someone who can't bend his knees because of illness to pray standing. It's better to bury a dead man quickly than, for lack of grave-clothes or because the mourners aren't there, to wait until he rots unburied.
Even so, in these matters the custom and institutions of the country, in short humanity and the rules of modesty itself, declare what should be done or avoided. If a mistake is made here through carelessness or forgetfulness, no crime has been committed. If it is done from contempt, such stubbornness is to be disapproved.
In the same way, it makes no difference what the days and hours are, what the buildings are like, or which psalms are sung on each day. But there should be certain days and fixed hours, and a place suited to receive everyone, if any care is taken for the preservation of peace. What a seedbed of quarrels confusion in these matters would be if everyone were allowed to change at will what belongs to the common order! Not everyone will be satisfied with the same course if matters on this debatable ground are left to individual decision. And if anyone here becomes clamorous and wants to be wiser than he should, let him consider how he will justify his awkwardness to the Lord. Paul's answer should satisfy us: "If anyone is inclined to be contentious, we have no such practice, nor do the churches of God" (1 Corinthians 11:16).
32. Cautions in using church regulations
We must take the greatest care that no error creeps in to taint or spoil this pure use. We will succeed if whatever observances we use are plainly useful and very few in number, and especially if the teaching of a faithful pastor is added to keep out mistaken opinions. The result is that in all these matters each person keeps his freedom and yet voluntarily subjects it to a kind of necessity, so far as the decency we've spoken of or charity requires.
Next, so that in keeping these things we don't fall into any superstition or rigidly demand too much from others, let's not imagine that the worship of God is improved by a multitude of ceremonies. Let no church despise another because of a difference in outward discipline. Finally, instead of laying down any perpetual law for ourselves, let us refer the whole purpose and use of observances to the Church's edification. When it requires, let us allow without offence not only that something be changed, but that even observances formerly in use be reversed. Our own age is proof that the nature of the times allows certain rites, not otherwise impious or unbecoming, to be abolished as circumstances demand. The ignorance and blindness of earlier times was such, and churches clung so stubbornly and with such mistaken ideas to ceremonies, that they can hardly be purified from monstrous superstitions without removing many ceremonies that were once established not without reason and that in themselves are not chargeable with any impiety.
Chapter 11
The Church's Jurisdiction, and Its Abuse in the Papacy
1. Why the Church needs spiritual jurisdiction, and the first sense of the keys
The third part of ecclesiastical power, and when things are properly ordered the principal one, is jurisdiction. All the Church's jurisdiction concerns discipline, which I'll deal with shortly. No city or village can exist without a magistrate and a system of government, and in the same way the Church of God needs a kind of spiritual government. I've said this before, but I have to repeat it. This government is entirely distinct from civil government. It doesn't obstruct or weaken civil government; it does a great deal to support and promote it. So the power of jurisdiction is, in a word, simply the order provided to keep the Church's spiritual life in good shape. For this purpose, tribunals were set up in the Church from the beginning, to take notice of conduct, to deal with vices, and to exercise the office of the keys.
Paul mentions this order in 1 Corinthians under the name of "governments" (1 Cor. 12:28), and again in Romans when he speaks of the one who "leads with diligence" (Rom. 12:8). He isn't addressing magistrates here, since none of them were Christians then. He means those who were joined with the pastors in the spiritual governing of the Church. In his letter to Timothy he also mentions two kinds of elders: those who labour in the word, and those who don't preach but still rule well (1 Tim. 5:17). There's no doubt he means by the second group those appointed to oversee conduct and to administer the keys.
The power I'm speaking of rests entirely on the keys Christ gave the Church in Matthew 18. There he commands that those who despise private admonition be sharply rebuked in public, and if they persist in their stubbornness, be put out of the fellowship of believers. But admonitions and corrections can't be carried out without looking into the matter, and so some kind of process and order is unavoidable. If we don't want to empty the promise of the keys of its meaning, and do away with excommunication, solemn warnings and everything of that kind, we have to grant the Church some jurisdiction.
Notice that I'm not talking here about the general authority of teaching, as in Matthew 21 and John 20. My point is that the authority once held by the Sanhedrin has been transferred to the flock of Christ. Until then the power of government had belonged to the Jews. Christ establishes it in his Church, as far as the Church is a pure institution, and he attaches a heavy sanction to it. It had to be so, because otherwise the judgment of a poor and despised Church would be brushed aside by rash and arrogant people.
So that this doesn't confuse the reader, since Christ uses almost the same words in two places that differ considerably in what they mean, I need to explain. There are two passages about binding and loosing. The first is Matthew 16, where Christ promises to give Peter the keys of the kingdom of heaven and immediately adds, "Whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven" (Matt. 16:19). This has exactly the same meaning as the words in John, where Christ is about to send the disciples out to preach and, after breathing on them, says, "If you forgive anyone's sins, they are forgiven; if you retain anyone's sins, they are retained" (John 20:23).
My interpretation is not clever, forced or twisted. It's the plain, natural, obvious one: this command about forgiving and retaining sins, and the promise to Peter about binding and loosing, refer to nothing other than the ministry of the word. When the Lord entrusted that ministry to the apostles, he gave them this power of binding and loosing along with it. What is the heart of the gospel, if not that all of us are slaves of sin and death, and are freed and released by the redemption that is in Christ Jesus, while those who don't receive and acknowledge Christ as their deliverer and redeemer are condemned to eternal chains?
When the Lord gave the apostles this message to carry to all nations, he honoured it with this striking testimony to prove that it was his own message and came from him. It was a marvellous confirmation, both for the apostles themselves and for all who would hear them. The apostles needed lasting and complete assurance about their preaching. They would carry it out with endless labour, anxiety, harassment and danger, and finally seal it with their blood. To know that it wasn't empty or in vain, but full of power, they needed to be convinced, in the middle of all their fears and difficulties, that they were doing God's work. They needed to know that God was on their side even if the whole world opposed them, and that although Christ, the author of their teaching, was no longer physically present on earth, he was in heaven confirming the truth of what he had given them.
Their hearers, for their part, needed to be fully certain that the doctrine of the gospel was not the word of the apostles but of God himself, not a voice rising from the earth but one coming down from heaven. The forgiveness of sins, the promise of eternal life and the message of salvation can't be in the power of any human being. So Christ testified that in preaching the gospel the apostles act only as servants. It was he who spoke and promised everything through their mouths as his instruments. The forgiveness of sins they announced was therefore God's own promise, and the condemnation they pronounced was God's own sure judgment.
This testimony was given for all ages and stands firm, making everyone secure that the word of the gospel, whoever preaches it, is the very word of God, issued at the supreme tribunal, written in the book of life, and fixed and ratified in heaven. We can now see that the power of the keys is simply the preaching of the gospel, and as far as human beings are concerned, it's not so much a power as a ministry. Strictly speaking, Christ didn't give this power to people. He gave it to his word, and he made people its ministers.
2. The second sense: binding and loosing in discipline
The other passage on binding and loosing is in Matthew 18, where Christ says, "If they refuse to listen to them, tell it to the church; and if they refuse to listen even to the church, treat them as you would a pagan or a tax collector. Truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven" (Matt. 18:17-18). This passage isn't quite the same as the first and has to be understood a little differently, though the two are closely related.
They're alike in that both are general statements: the power of binding and loosing is always the same (it works through the word of God), with the same command and the same promise. They differ in that the first refers especially to the preaching the ministers of the word carry out, while the second refers to the discipline of excommunication entrusted to the Church. The Church binds the person she excommunicates, not by plunging them into eternal ruin and despair, but by condemning their life and conduct and warning them that unless they repent they stand condemned. She looses the person she receives back into communion, because she makes them a sharer in the unity she has in Christ Jesus.
So no one should stubbornly despise the judgment of the Church, or treat it lightly that the faithful have condemned them. The Lord testifies that this judgment of believers is nothing other than the announcement of his own sentence, and that what they do on earth is ratified in heaven. They have the word of God, by which they condemn the stubborn, and the word by which they welcome the penitent back into favour. They can't err or disagree with God's judgment, because they judge only by God's law, which is not an uncertain or merely human opinion but the holy will of God, an oracle from heaven.
These two passages, which I think I've explained briefly, plainly and truthfully, are the ones the Roman party twists, with no discrimination at all, to establish confession, excommunication, jurisdiction, the right to make laws and indulgences all at once. The first passage they use to prop up the primacy of the Roman See. They are so familiar with the keys, having taken it on themselves to fit them with locks and doors, that you'd think they had spent their whole lives at the locksmith's trade.
3. Spiritual and civil power are different, and the difference is permanent
Some people imagine that all of this was temporary, designed for a time when magistrates were still strangers to our faith. They go wrong by not seeing the difference between ecclesiastical and civil power. The Church has no right of the sword to punish or restrain, no power to compel, no prison or other penalty of the kind a magistrate normally inflicts. And the aim isn't to punish the sinner against their will, but to obtain a confession of repentance through willing correction. The two powers are very different. The Church takes nothing to herself that belongs to the magistrate, and the magistrate can't do what the Church does.
An example makes this clearer. Suppose someone gets drunk. In a well-governed city the penalty is imprisonment. If they commit sexual immorality, the penalty will be the same or more severe. That satisfies the laws, the magistrates and the external court. But the offender may well show no sign of repentance and simply grumble and resent it. Does the Church have nothing to do here? Such a person can't be admitted to the Lord's Supper without dishonouring Christ and his holy ordinance. Reason demands that someone whose bad example has caused offence in the Church should remove that offence by a formal declaration of repentance.
The argument of those who hold the opposite view is weak. They say Christ gave this office to the Church at a time when there were no magistrates to carry it out. But often the magistrate is negligent, and sometimes needs correcting himself, as Emperor Theodosius did. Besides, the same could be said of the whole ministry of the word. On that reasoning, pastors should stop rebuking open wickedness, stop reproving and accusing, since Christian magistrates ought to deal with these things by law and the sword. In truth, just as the magistrate should purge the Church of scandals by physical punishment and restraint, so the minister should in turn help the magistrate reduce the number of offenders. They should work together, each a help to the other and not a hindrance.
4. The Church's jurisdiction is permanent, and the early Christian emperors left it in place
If we look more carefully at Christ's words, it's clear that the state and order of the Church described there is permanent, not temporary. It would be absurd for those who refuse our admonitions to be handed over to the magistrate, yet that would be necessary if the magistrate were to take the Church's place. Why would the promise, "Truly I tell you, whatever you bind on earth," be limited to a year or two? Christ also made no new law here. He followed the practice always observed in the Church of his ancient people, which shows that the Church can never do without the spiritual jurisdiction she has had from the beginning.
The agreement of all ages confirms this. When emperors and magistrates began to take the Christian name, spiritual jurisdiction wasn't immediately abolished. It was simply arranged so as not to damage civil jurisdiction or be mixed up with it. That was right. A godly magistrate won't want to exempt himself from the subjection common to all God's children, and a chief part of that is to submit to the Church, which judges by the word of God. It is far from his duty to abolish that judgment. As Ambrose says, "What more honourable title can an emperor have than to be called a son of the Church? A good emperor is within the Church, not above the Church" (Ambrose, Letter 32 to Valentinian).
So those who strip the Church of this power in order to glorify the magistrate not only distort Christ's meaning with a false interpretation, they also pass a serious condemnation on the many holy bishops since the apostles' day, accusing them of wrongly taking over the honour and office of the civil magistrate.
5. What discipline was for in the early Church
We should also see what ecclesiastical discipline was truly used for in the ancient Church, and how serious the abuses were that crept in. That way we'll know what from ancient practice to abolish and what to restore, if we want to overthrow the kingdom of Antichrist and set up Christ's true kingdom again.
The aim is first to prevent scandals, and when they occur, to remove them. Two things must be kept in view in how it's done. First, this spiritual power must be wholly distinct from the power of the sword. Second, it must not be exercised at the will of one individual but by a lawful assembly (1 Cor. 5:4). Both were observed in the Church's purer times. The holy bishops didn't use fines, imprisonment or other civil penalties. As was fitting, they used only the word of God. The Church's most severe punishment, her last thunderbolt, so to speak, is excommunication, and it's used only when necessary. It needs no violence or physical force, but is content with the power of God's word.
In short, the ancient Church's jurisdiction was simply a practical expression of what Paul teaches about the spiritual power of pastors: "The weapons we fight with are not the weapons of the world. On the contrary, they have divine power to demolish strongholds. We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ. And we will be ready to punish every act of disobedience" (2 Cor. 10:4-6).
This is accomplished through the preaching of doctrine. And so that doctrine isn't held in contempt, those who profess to belong to the household of faith must be judged by the doctrine taught. That can't happen unless the ministry includes the right to summon those who need private admonition or sharp rebuke, and the right to keep from the Lord's Supper those who can't be admitted without profaning it. So when Paul asks elsewhere, "What business is it of mine to judge those outside the church?" (1 Cor. 5:12), he makes church members answerable to censure for the correction of their faults, and implies that there are tribunals from which no believer is exempt.
6. The power belonged to a council, and how it was gradually taken over
As I've said, this power didn't belong to one person to use as he pleased. It belonged to the assembly of elders, which was in the Church what a council is in a city. When Cyprian speaks of those who exercised it in his day, he usually joins the whole clergy with the bishop. Elsewhere he shows that although the clergy presided, the people weren't shut out from the hearing. He writes: "From the beginning of my bishopric I determined to do nothing without the advice of the clergy, and nothing without the consent of the people." But the common and usual way of exercising this jurisdiction was through the council of presbyters, who, as I said, were of two kinds: some for teaching, others only as overseers of conduct.
This arrangement gradually decayed. By Ambrose's time the clergy alone judged church cases, and he complained of it: "The ancient synagogue, and afterwards the Church, had elders, without whose advice nothing was done. This has fallen out of use, I don't know through whose fault, unless it's the laziness, or rather the pride, of the teachers, who want it to appear that they alone are somebody" (Ambrose on 1 Tim. 5). You can see how annoyed this holy man was that the better arrangement had even partly slipped, though what existed then was at least tolerable. What would he have said if he had seen the shapeless ruins we have now, with no trace of the old building left?
First, against all right and law, the bishop took for himself what had been given to the whole Church. It's as if a consul had driven out the senate and seized the whole empire. A bishop may rank above the others, but the authority of the assembly is greater than that of any one man. It was a gross injustice when one man moved the common power over to himself, opened the way for tyrannical licence, robbed the Church of what was hers, and suppressed and discarded the council that the Spirit of Christ had ordained.
7. Bishops then passed it to officials, and discipline became a worldly court
Evil always breeds evil. The bishops came to despise this jurisdiction as beneath their attention and handed it to others, hence the appointment of "officials" to act in their place. I'm not speaking now of the character of these people. I'm only saying that they are no different from civil judges. Yet it's called spiritual jurisdiction, though all the litigation is about worldly affairs. Even apart from other evils, how can they call a quarrelsome law court a church court? But, they say, there are admonitions, there is excommunication. That is how God is mocked.
Does some poor man owe a sum of money? He's summoned. If he appears, he's found liable, and if he doesn't pay, he's warned. After a second warning comes excommunication. If he doesn't appear, he's warned to appear; if he delays, he's warned again, and soon excommunicated. I ask you, is there any resemblance between this and Christ's institution, or ancient custom, or church procedure?
Vices are condemned there too, they say. But fornication, indecency, drunkenness and similar sins they not only tolerate but, by a kind of silent approval, encourage and confirm, among the people and among the clergy alike. They summon a few out of many, either to avoid seeming to turn a blind eye entirely, or to fine them. I say nothing of the theft, extortion, embezzlement and sacrilege that go on there, or of the sort of people usually appointed to the office. It's enough, and more than enough, to say that when the Romanists boast of their spiritual jurisdiction, we're ready to show that nothing is more contrary to the procedure Christ instituted, and that it resembles ancient practice no more than darkness resembles light.
8. Summary: Christ shut his ministers out from worldly rule
I haven't said everything that could be said here, and what I have said is only a quick survey. But I trust it's enough to leave no one in doubt that the spiritual power the Pope prides himself on, along with all his supporters, is an impious contradiction of God's word and an unjust tyranny over his people. By spiritual power I mean three things together: their boldness in inventing new doctrines that led the poor people away from the pure word of God, the wicked traditions with which they trapped them, and the pseudo-ecclesiastical jurisdiction they exercise through deputies and officials. If we let Christ reign among us, that whole domination must immediately fall.
The right of the sword, which they also claim, doesn't bear on consciences and so isn't to be examined in this place. But it's worth noticing that they are always true to form, resembling nothing less than what they want to be seen as, namely pastors of the Church. I'm not speaking of the faults of particular men, but of the common corruption, and so of the destructive nature of the whole order, which is thought to be maimed unless it's distinguished by wealth and arrogant titles.
If we look for Christ's authority on this, there's no doubt he meant to bar the ministers of his word from civil rule and worldly power when he said, "The kings of the Gentiles lord it over them, and those who exercise authority over them call themselves Benefactors. But you are not to be like that" (Luke 22:25-26; compare Matt. 20:25-26). He shows not only that the office of pastor is different from the office of prince, but that the two are so far apart that they can't be combined in one person.
Moses did hold both (Exod. 18:16). But that was, first, the result of a rare miracle, and second, temporary, until matters could be better arranged. Once the Lord prescribed a settled form, the civil government was left to Moses and he was told to hand the priesthood over to his brother. That's right, because it's more than human nature can manage for one man to carry both burdens. The Church has carefully observed this in every age. As long as any true appearance of a church remained, no bishop ever thought of seizing the sword. In Ambrose's time it was a common saying that emperors longed for the priesthood more than priests longed for imperial power. And the other saying he adds was fixed in everyone's mind: palaces belong to the emperor, churches to the priest.
9. The Roman claims that this display honours Christ and doesn't distract from the work
But once a way was found for bishops to keep the title, honour and wealth of their office without its burden and care, left entirely idle, the right of the sword was handed to them, or rather they seized it themselves. What excuse will they offer for this effrontery? Was it a bishop's business to involve himself in judging cases and governing states and provinces, taking on work so foreign to his calling? A bishop's own office demands so much time and labour that even if he gives himself to it completely, with no other distractions, he's scarcely equal to it.
Yet they have the nerve to boast that this is how the dignity of Christ's kingdom is properly upheld, and that they're not drawn away from their own calling. Take the first claim. If it's a fine ornament for the sacred office that its holders be raised so high that they frighten the greatest monarchs, they have grounds to complain to Christ, who has seriously cut back their honour. What could be more insulting, on their view, than "The kings of the Gentiles lord it over them... but you are not to be like that" (Luke 22:25-26)? And yet he lays no harder law on his servants than he first laid on himself: "Who appointed me a judge or an arbiter between you?" (Luke 12:14). He flatly refuses the office of judging, and he wouldn't have done that if it had suited his office. Will his servants not accept the lowly position he accepted himself?
As for the second claim, I wish they would prove by experience as easily as they assert it. The apostles judged it wrong to neglect the word of God in order to wait on tables (Acts 6:2). Just so, these men, however unwilling to be taught, are forced to admit that one person can't be both a good bishop and a good prince. If the apostles, with such remarkable gifts and capable of far more and weightier tasks than anyone since, confessed they couldn't serve both the ministry of the word and the tables without collapsing under the load, how can these men, who are nothing beside the apostles, be a hundred times more diligent? The very attempt is shameless, arrogant presumption. Still, we see it done, and we see with what result: they have abandoned their own work and gone over to another camp.
10. How this tyranny grew from small beginnings
There's no doubt this great growth came from slender beginnings. They couldn't reach this height in one step. At one time they raised themselves secretly, by craft and cunning, before anyone saw what was happening. At another, when the opportunity came, they extracted some increase of power from princes by threats and intimidation. At another, when princes were inclined to be generous, they took advantage of their foolish and thoughtless good nature.
In ancient times, godly people with a dispute would leave the decision to the bishop to avoid a lawsuit, since they had no doubt of his integrity. As Augustine somewhere says, the ancient bishops were often very unhappy to be dragged into such matters, but they put up with the burden unwillingly to keep the parties from rushing to some contentious court. These voluntary arbitrations, quite different from legal combat, have been turned by these men into regular jurisdiction. Cities and districts, under pressure from various difficulties, sought the protection of the bishops and threw themselves on their care, and by a strange trick the bishops turned from protectors into masters. That a good part was seized by factional violence can't be denied.
The princes who freely granted jurisdiction to bishops were moved by various motives. Their generosity had some appearance of piety, but this misplaced liberality didn't serve the Church's best interests. They corrupted her ancient and true discipline, or to tell the truth, abolished it completely. Bishops who abuse the goodness of princes for their own benefit prove by this one example that they were not true bishops at all. If they'd had one spark of the apostolic spirit, they would have answered in the words of Paul, "The weapons we fight with are not the weapons of the world" (2 Cor. 10:4). Instead, swept along by blind greed, they ruined themselves, their successors and the Church.
11. The Pope claims both swords, and Bernard answers him
At length the Roman Pontiff, not satisfied with modest territories, laid hands first on kingdoms and then on the empire. To keep what he took by sheer robbery, he claims at one moment that he holds it by divine right, at another he points to a donation from Constantine, at another to some other title. My first answer is Bernard's: "Suppose he can claim it on some ground or other; it is not by apostolic right. Peter couldn't give what he didn't have, but what he had he gave to his successors, namely care of the churches. When our Lord and Master says he wasn't appointed judge between two people, the servant and disciple shouldn't think it unbecoming not to be judge of everyone" (Bernard, On Consideration 2).
Bernard is speaking of civil judgments, because he goes on: "Your power, then, is over sins, not over property, since it was for the first and not the second that you received the keys of the kingdom of heaven. Which seems the higher dignity to you, forgiving sins or dividing lands? There's no comparison. These low earthly matters have the kings and princes of the earth as their judges. Why do you invade other people's territory?" And again, addressing Pope Eugenius: "You have been set above others. For what? Not to rule over them, I take it. So let us remember, however highly we think of ourselves, that a ministry is laid on us, not a lordship given to us. Learn that you need a slender staff, not a sceptre, to do the work of a prophet." Again: "It is plain that the apostles are forbidden to exercise dominion. Go, then, and dare to usurp for yourself either apostleship with dominion, or dominion with apostleship." And immediately after: "This is the apostolic form: dominion is forbidden, ministry is commanded."
Bernard says this, and says it in a way that shows everyone he's telling the truth. Even without a word from him the matter is plain. Yet the Roman Pontiff wasn't ashamed to decree at the Council of Arles that the supreme right of both swords belonged to him by divine right.
12. The so-called Donation of Constantine
The Donation of Constantine is a claim that anyone moderately familiar with the history of the time knows is both fabulous and absurd. But leaving history aside, Gregory alone is a fully sufficient witness against it. Whenever he speaks of the emperor, he calls him "my most serene lord" and himself his unworthy servant. In another place he says, "Let our Lord not be too quickly offended with priests in respect of worldly power, but out of excellent consideration for the one whose servants they are, let him show them due respect even while ruling them." We see how he wants to be counted among the people under a common subjection. He isn't pleading someone else's case here but his own. And again: "I trust in almighty God that he will give long life to godly rulers, and place us under your hand according to his mercy."
I don't bring these up to discuss the Donation exhaustively, only to show my readers in passing how childishly the Romanists lie when they try to claim an earthly empire for their Pontiff. All the more shameless is Augustine Steuchus, who in so desperate a cause was willing to lend his labour and his tongue to the Roman Pontiff. Valla, as a learned and sharp man could easily do, had completely refuted the fable. Since he knew little of church affairs, he hadn't said everything relevant. Steuchus rushes in and scatters worthless quibbles, trying to bury the clear light. He argues his master's case no more convincingly than a wit might who, under cover of defending it, actually argued Valla's side. But it's a cause worthy of the Pope to hire such defenders, and worthy too of hired ranters whom the hope of gain can deceive, as it did Eugubinus.
13. When and how the popes rose to imperial power
If someone asks when this fictitious empire began to appear, it's not yet five hundred years since the Roman Pontiffs were subject to the emperors and no pope was elected without the emperor's authority. The occasion for upsetting this order was given to Gregory VII by Henry IV, a rash and reckless man of little prudence, great audacity and loose life. He had all the bishoprics of Germany in his court, partly for sale and partly open to plunder. Hildebrand, who had been provoked by him, seized this plausible pretext to assert his claim. His cause looked good and godly and so was greeted with great favour, while Henry, because of his insolent rule, was widely hated by the princes.
Eventually Hildebrand, who took the name Gregory VII and was an impure and wicked man, revealed his sinister intentions. Many who had joined his conspiracy then deserted him. But he gained this much: his successors were able not only to shake off the yoke without penalty but also to bring the emperors under their own control. Many later emperors were more like Henry than like Julius Caesar. It wasn't hard to overcome them while they sat at home, idle and complacent, instead of doing what was most necessary, which was to use every legitimate means to restrain the greed of the popes. That is how much colour there is for the grand Donation of Constantine, by which the Pope claims the western empire was given him.
14. How they seized Rome and other lands
Meanwhile the popes never stopped invading the dominions of others, by fraud, treachery or arms. Rome itself, which was then free, they brought under their power about a hundred and thirty years ago. In the end they gained the dominion they now hold, and to keep or enlarge it, for two hundred years now (they had begun before they took the city), they have so troubled the Christian world that they've almost destroyed it.
In Gregory's time, the guardians of church property seized lands they considered the Church's and, in the manner of the treasury, fixed their seals to mark the claim. Gregory called a council of bishops, bitterly denounced this profane custom, and asked whether they would anathematise any churchman who tried on his own to take some possession by posting a title, and likewise any bishop who ordered it done or failed to punish it when done without his order. All pronounced the anathema.
If it was a crime deserving anathema for a churchman to claim property by posting a title, then what anathemas can adequately punish the popes of the last two hundred years, who have thought of nothing but war and bloodshed, the destruction of armies, the plunder of cities, the ruin of nations and the devastation of kingdoms, all to get hold of other people's property? It's obvious that the very last thing they aim at is the glory of Christ. If they voluntarily gave up every scrap of secular power they hold, there would be no danger to God's glory, to sound doctrine, or to the Church's safety. But they're driven blindly and headlong by a lust for power, thinking nothing can be safe unless they rule, "harshly and brutally," as the prophet says (Ezek. 34:4).
15. The claim to immunity from civil courts, and the early bishops' moderation
Tied to jurisdiction is the immunity the Roman clergy claim. They think it beneath them to answer before a civil judge in personal cases, and they see the Church's liberty and dignity as consisting in exemption from ordinary courts and laws. But the ancient bishops, who were otherwise firm defenders of the Church's rights, didn't think it any injury to themselves or their order to act as subjects. Godly emperors also summoned clergy to their courts whenever necessary, and met no opposition. Constantine, writing to the people of Nicomedia, says: "If any of the bishops rashly stirs up trouble, his boldness will be restrained by the servant of God, that is, by my officers" (Theodoret 1.20). Valentinian says, "Good bishops cast no slur on the emperor's power, but sincerely keep the commandments of God, the great King, and obey our laws" (Theodoret 4.8). This was clearly what everyone thought at the time.
Church matters were indeed brought before the bishop's court. For example, when a clergyman had offended, but not against the civil laws, he was charged only under the church canons, and instead of being summoned to the civil court he had the bishop as his judge in that case. Likewise, when a question of faith, or anything properly belonging to the Church, was at issue, it was left to the Church to decide. That is how Ambrose's words are to be understood: "Your father of august memory not only answered in words but enacted by law that in a matter of faith the judge should be one who is neither unequal in office nor incompetent by the nature of his jurisdiction" (Ambrose, Letter 32). And again: "If we look to the Scriptures or to ancient examples, who can deny that in a matter of faith, a matter of faith, I say, bishops are accustomed to judge Christian emperors, not emperors to judge bishops?" And again: "I would have come to your court, O emperor, if the bishops or the people had allowed me; they say a matter of faith should be discussed in the Church before the people."
Ambrose holds that a spiritual cause, one touching religion, shouldn't be brought before the civil court where worldly disputes are tried, and everyone rightly praises his firmness on this. Yet even with a good case he goes so far as to say that if it comes to force and violence, he will yield: "I will not desert the post entrusted to me, but if forced, I will not resist; prayers and tears are our weapons" (On Handing Over the Basilicas).
Notice the unusual moderation of this holy man, his mix of prudence, courage and boldness. Justina, the emperor's mother, couldn't win him over to the Arian side and tried to drive him from the government of the Church. That would have happened if he had gone to the palace when summoned to plead his cause. So he argued that the emperor was not fit to decide such a controversy. Both the necessity of the times and the nature of the matter demanded this. He thought it better to die than to consent to hand such an example down to posterity. Yet if violence was used, he didn't think of resisting, for he said it isn't a bishop's place to defend the faith and the Church's rights by arms. In every other kind of case, he declared himself ready to do whatever the emperor commanded: "If he asks for tribute, we don't refuse it. The lands of the Church pay tribute. If he asks for the lands, he has the power to take them; none of us stands in the way."
Gregory speaks the same way: "I am not ignorant of the mind of my most serene lord. He isn't in the habit of interfering in priestly cases, lest he somehow burden himself with our sins." Gregory doesn't exclude the emperor from judging priests altogether. He says only that there are certain causes the emperor should leave to the church court.
16. What the early bishops aimed at in resisting civil encroachment
All these holy men sought by this exception was to stop irreligious princes from hindering the Church in her duty through their tyrannical whims and violence. They didn't object when princes used their authority in church affairs, provided this was done to preserve the Church's order and not disturb it, to establish discipline and not destroy it. The Church doesn't have, and shouldn't want, the power of compulsion (I mean civil coercion). So it falls to godly kings and princes to uphold religion by laws, edicts and judgments.
In just this way, when Emperor Maurice commanded certain bishops to receive neighbouring colleagues who had been driven out by the barbarians, Gregory confirmed the order and urged them to obey. When the same emperor urged Gregory himself to restore good relations with John, bishop of Constantinople, Gregory tried to show he wasn't to blame. But far from boasting of immunity from the secular court, he promised to comply as far as conscience allowed, and he said that Maurice had acted as a religious prince should in giving these commands to priests.
Chapter 12
The Discipline of the Church, and Its Chief Use in Censures and Excommunication
1. Why the Church needs discipline
I've put off the subject of the Church's discipline until now, and I need to explain it briefly so that we can move on to other matters. Discipline depends largely on the power of the keys and on spiritual jurisdiction. To make this easier to follow, let's divide the Church into two main groups, clergy and people. I use the word "clergy" in its ordinary sense for those who hold a public ministry in the Church. I'll speak first of the common discipline that everyone should submit to, and then of the clergy, who have a discipline of their own on top of it.
Some people dislike discipline so much that they dislike the very word, so I'll say this to them. No society can be kept in good order without it, and neither can a household, even a modest one. How much more necessary it is in the Church, whose condition ought to be the best ordered of all. The saving teaching of Christ is the life of the Church, and discipline is her sinews, because it keeps the members of the body joined together, each in its place. So anyone who wants discipline abolished, or who stands in the way of restoring it, whether deliberately or through carelessness, is working toward the complete devastation of the Church. What will happen if everyone is allowed to do as they please? That is exactly what will happen if the preaching of the gospel isn't joined by private admonition, correction, and the other means that keep doctrine from going slack.
Discipline, then, is a bridle that restrains and tames those who fight against the teaching of Christ. It is a spur that wakes the indifferent. Sometimes it is a father's rod, used to chastise in mercy, with the gentleness of Christ's Spirit, those who have fallen more seriously. We can already see the beginnings of a terrible devastation in the Church, caused by a total lack of care and method in managing the people. Necessity itself cries out for a remedy, and the only remedy is the one Christ commands and the godly have always used.
2. The steps of discipline
The first foundation of discipline is private admonition. If anyone isn't doing their duty willingly, or behaves arrogantly, or lives in a way that isn't quite honourable, or does something blameworthy, they must be willing to be admonished, and every believer must make it their business to admonish a brother or sister when the situation calls for it. This is where pastors and elders especially must be vigilant. Their duty isn't only to preach to the people but to exhort and admonish them from house to house whenever general teaching hasn't done enough. Paul shows this when he says he taught "publicly and from house to house" and declares himself "innocent of the blood of all" because he hadn't shrunk from declaring "the whole counsel of God" (Acts 20:20, 26-27). Doctrine gains real force and authority when the minister not only expounds publicly to all what they owe to Christ, but also has the right and the means to require it of those he sees dragging their feet or ignoring his teaching.
If someone perversely rejects these admonitions, or shows by persisting in their faults that they despise them, Christ's instruction is that after a second admonition before witnesses, they are to be brought before the Church. That means the council of elders, who admonish them more sharply there with public authority, so that if they respect the Church they may submit and obey (Matt. 18:15-17). If even this doesn't win them over and they persist in their wrongdoing, then, as someone who despises the Church, they are to be shut out from the fellowship of believers.
3. Private and public sins
Our Saviour isn't speaking only of secret faults in that passage, so we have to attend to the difference between private sins and public or openly known ones. Of the first, Christ says to each individual, "go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone" (Matt. 18:15). Of open sins, Paul says to Timothy, "As for those who persist in sin, rebuke them in the presence of all, so that the rest may fear" (1 Tim. 5:20). Christ had begun with the words "if your brother sins against you," and unless you want to be picky, you can only take that to mean the sin is known to you and to no one else. The command Paul gave Timothy, to rebuke publicly those who sin publicly, he followed himself with Peter (Gal. 2:14). When Peter's sin gave public offence, Paul didn't take him aside; he confronted him in front of the whole Church. So the right course is this. Secret faults are corrected by the steps Christ lays out. Open sins that cause public scandal go straight to solemn correction by the Church.
4. Lesser faults and flagrant wrongs
There is a second distinction to keep in view. Some sins are simply faults, while others are crimes and flagrant wickedness. Correcting the second kind takes more than admonition or rebuke; it takes a sharper remedy. Paul shows this when he doesn't merely rebuke the incestuous man in Corinth in words but punishes him with excommunication as soon as he hears of the crime (1 Cor. 5:3-5).
Now we can begin to see more clearly how the Church's spiritual jurisdiction, which deals with sin according to the word of the Lord, is at once the best support of sound doctrine, the best foundation of order, and the best bond of unity. When the Church expels from her fellowship open adulterers, fornicators, thieves, robbers, troublemakers, perjurers, false witnesses, and others like them, she isn't claiming any unreasonable power for herself. She is using a jurisdiction she has received from the Lord. The same goes for the stubborn, who, when properly admonished for lesser faults, treat God and his tribunal with contempt.
And so that no one will despise the Church's judgment, or think it a small thing to be condemned by the votes of the faithful, the Lord has declared that it is nothing other than the announcement of his own sentence, and that what they do on earth is ratified in heaven. They act by the word of the Lord when they condemn the stubborn, and by the word of the Lord when they receive the penitent back into favour (John 20:23). Anyone who expects churches to stand for long without this bond of discipline is mistaken, unless we can do without with impunity a help the Lord knew would be necessary. The greatness of that necessity will become clearer from its many uses.
5. The three purposes of discipline
The Church has three purposes in correcting and excommunicating.
The first is that God not be insulted by having the name of Christian attached to people who lead shameful and scandalous lives, as though his holy Church were a gathering of the wicked and the abandoned. The Church is the body of Christ, and she can't be tainted by such rotten and putrid members without bringing some disgrace on her Head. So that nothing in the Church may shame his holy name, those whose disgraceful conduct would cast infamy on it must be put out of his household. The Lord's Supper has to be considered here too, since it would be profaned if everyone were admitted indiscriminately. It is perfectly true that anyone entrusted with administering it who knowingly and willingly admits an unworthy person, whom he ought and is able to turn away, is as guilty of sacrilege as if he had thrown the Lord's body to dogs. That is why Chrysostom bitterly rebukes priests who, for fear of the powerful, dare not keep anyone back. "Their blood will be required at your hands," he says. "If you fear man, he will mock you; if you fear God, you will be respected by men too. Let us not tremble before the rods of office, the purple, or the crown; our authority here is greater. I would sooner give my body to death and let my blood be shed than share in that pollution" (Hom. 83 on Matthew). So that this most sacred mystery isn't exposed to disgrace, great care is needed in giving it out, and that care can't be exercised without the Church's jurisdiction.
The second purpose is that the good may not be corrupted, as so often happens, by constant company with the wicked. We are so prone to go astray that nothing is easier than to be led off course by bad example. Paul had this in mind when he told the Corinthians to remove the incestuous man from their number: "A little leaven leavens the whole lump" (1 Cor. 5:6). He saw so much danger here that he forbade them even to keep company with such people: "not to associate with anyone who bears the name of brother if he is guilty of sexual immorality or greed, or is an idolater, reviler, drunkard, or swindler. Not even to eat with such a one" (1 Cor. 5:11).
The third purpose is that the offender may be ashamed and begin to repent. It is in their own interest, too, that their wrongdoing be punished. Left to be indulged, they would only become more stubborn, but the rod can wake them up. Paul hints at this when he writes, "If anyone does not obey what we say in this letter, take note of that person, and have nothing to do with him, that he may be ashamed" (2 Thess. 3:14). He says it again when he reports that he had handed the Corinthian over to Satan "so that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord Jesus" (1 Cor. 5:5). I understand that to mean he gave him over to temporal condemnation so that he might be made safe for eternity. He says "to Satan" because the devil is outside the Church, as Christ is within it. Some take this to refer to some bodily affliction, but that seems to me very unlikely (Augustine, Sermon 68 on the Words of the Apostle).
6. How the Church carries it out
Now that we've seen the purposes, we have to see how the Church is to carry out this part of discipline, which is jurisdiction. First, remember the division I made above between public and private sins. Public sins are those committed not before one or two witnesses but openly, to the offence of the whole Church. By private I don't mean sins that are altogether hidden from people, like those of hypocrites, which don't fall under the Church's judgment. I mean an in-between kind, which has witnesses and yet isn't public.
Public sins don't need the different steps Christ lists. Whenever such a thing happens, the Church should do her duty by summoning the offender and correcting him according to his fault. The in-between kind doesn't come before the Church unless there is stubbornness, following Christ's rule. In examining offences we also have to keep in mind the difference between lesser faults and flagrant wickedness. Lighter offences don't call for much severity. Verbal correction is enough, and it should be gentle and fatherly, so that it doesn't provoke or crush the offender but brings him back to himself, and he rejoices in the correction rather than being hurt by it.
Flagrant wickedness needs a sharper remedy. It isn't enough to rebuke verbally someone who has gravely offended the Church by an open act of bad example. For a time he should be denied the Lord's Supper until he shows proof of repentance. Paul doesn't give the Corinthian a mere verbal rebuke; he drives him out of the Church and reproves the Corinthians for having tolerated him so long (1 Cor. 5:2).
This was the practice of the ancient and purer Church when lawful government was in force. Anyone guilty of some flagrant wickedness who caused scandal was first ordered to abstain from the sacred Supper, and then to humble himself before God and show his repentance before the Church. There were also solemn rites, prescribed as signs of repentance for those who had fallen. When the penitent had given the Church satisfaction in this way, he was received back by the laying on of hands. Cyprian often calls this restoration "peace," and he describes the procedure briefly: "They do penance for a set time, then they come to confession, and receive the right of communion by the laying on of hands of the bishop and clergy" (Letters 1.2; 3.14, 26). Although the bishop and clergy oversaw the restoration of the penitent, the people's consent was also required, as Cyprian explains elsewhere.
7. No one is exempt, and the whole Church takes part
No one was exempt from this discipline. Even princes submitted to it along with their subjects, and rightly so, since it is the discipline of Christ, to whom all sceptres and crowns should bow. When Ambrose excommunicated the emperor Theodosius over the massacre at Thessalonica, Theodosius laid aside all the royal insignia that surrounded him and publicly in the Church mourned the sin into which others' deceit had led him, groaning and in tears begging forgiveness (Ambrose, Letters 1.3, and his funeral oration for Theodosius). Great kings shouldn't think it beneath them to prostrate themselves before Christ, the King of kings, or be annoyed at being judged by the Church. They seldom hear anything in their courts but flattery, so it is all the more necessary for the Lord to correct them through the mouths of his ministers. They should actually want the ministers not to spare them, so that the Lord may spare them.
I won't say here who should exercise this jurisdiction, because that was covered earlier (chapter 11, sections 5 and 6). I'll only add that the proper way to excommunicate, as Paul shows, is not for the elders to act alone, apart from everyone else, but with the knowledge and approval of the Church. The body of the people don't direct the process, but they watch it as witnesses and guardians, so that a few can't act on a whim. Throughout the proceeding, besides calling on the name of God, there should be a seriousness that reflects the presence of Christ and leaves no doubt that he is presiding over his own court.
8. Discipline must be exercised with gentleness
We shouldn't forget that the Church, in exercising severity, must combine it with a spirit of gentleness. As Paul commands, we must always take care that the person being disciplined isn't "overwhelmed by excessive sorrow" (2 Cor. 2:7), because then the result would be destruction instead of healing. The right measure of moderation is best found in the purpose. Excommunication aims to bring the sinner to repentance and to remove bad examples, so that Christ's name isn't blasphemed and others aren't tempted to the same behaviour. Keep that in view and we'll easily see how far severity should go and where it should stop. When the sinner gives the Church evidence of repentance, and by that evidence does what he can to wipe out the offence, he must not be pressed any further. If he is, the severity has gone beyond what is right.
On this point I can't excuse the excessive harshness of the ancients, which was completely at odds with the Lord's command and dangerous in a strange way. When they demanded a formal penance and barred people from communion for three, four, or seven years, or for life, what could the result be but great hypocrisy or great despair? When someone who had fallen again wasn't admitted to a second repentance but was thrown out of the Church for the rest of his life (Augustine, Letter 54), that wasn't useful or reasonable either. Anyone who looks at it with sound judgment will regret the lack of prudence. Here, though, I disapprove of the public custom rather than blame those who went along with it. Some of them plainly disapproved but submitted to what they couldn't change. Cyprian says outright that he wasn't strict by his own choice: "Our patience, ease, and kindness are ready for all who come. I want everyone to be brought back into the Church. I want all our fellow soldiers kept inside the camp of Christ and the dwelling places of God the Father. I forgive everything; I overlook much; out of eagerness to gather the brotherhood, I don't examine every offence committed against God too closely. I myself often go wrong by forgiving offences more than I should. Those who return in repentance and confess their sins with simple, humble satisfaction I welcome with ready and full joy" (Letters 1.3). Chrysostom, who is somewhat stricter, still says: "If God is so kind, why does his priest want to look severe?" We also know how generously Augustine treated the Donatists, readily admitting any who returned from schism to their bishoprics as soon as they declared their repentance. But since the opposite practice had taken hold, they were forced to follow it and set aside their own judgment.
9. Our attitude toward the excommunicated
If the whole body of the Church is required to act with such mildness, and not to push severity against the fallen to an extreme but to treat them with love, following Paul's instruction, then each individual believer should likewise adopt this kindness and humanity. We have no right to strike those who have been expelled from the Church off the list of the elect, or to despair of them as if they were already lost. We can rightly judge them strangers to the Church, and so strangers to Christ, but only for the duration of their excommunication. If they then show more insolence than humility, let us still leave them to the Lord's judgment, hoping better of them in the future than we see at present, and never ceasing to pray to God for them. To put it in a word, let us not consign to destruction their person, which is in the Lord's hand and subject to his decision alone. Let us only assess the character of each person's actions by the law of the Lord.
In following this rule, we hold to the divine judgment rather than pass any judgment of our own. Let's not claim for ourselves greater freedom in judging, if we don't want to limit God's power and lay down the law to his mercy. Whenever it seems good to him, the worst are changed into the best, strangers are grafted in and foreigners adopted into the Church. The Lord does this to defeat human expectations and confound human rashness, a rashness which, if unchecked, would seize a right of judging it has no title to.
10. Binding, excommunication, and anathema
When our Saviour promises that what his servants bind on earth will be bound in heaven (Matt. 18:18), he limits the power of binding to the Church's censure. That censure doesn't consign the excommunicated to eternal ruin and damnation. It assures them, when they hear their life and conduct condemned, that eternal damnation will follow if they don't repent.
Excommunication differs from anathema. Anathema shuts out all pardon and condemns the person to eternal destruction. Excommunication rebukes and censures the person's conduct, and although it punishes, it does so to bring him to salvation by warning him of what lies ahead. If it succeeds, reconciliation and restoration to communion are ready to be given. Anathema, moreover, should rarely if ever be used. So although church discipline doesn't allow us to be on familiar and close terms with the excommunicated, we should still do everything possible to bring them to a better mind and win them back to the fellowship and unity of the Church. The apostle says the same: "Do not regard him as an enemy, but warn him as a brother" (2 Thess. 3:15). If this kindness isn't kept in private as well as in public, there is a danger that our discipline will turn into a kind of torture, and that from correctors we will become executioners.
11. Patience with imperfect church discipline
Another requirement for moderate discipline, as Augustine argues against the Donatists, is that private believers shouldn't separate themselves from the Church the moment they see vices corrected less carefully than they'd like by the council of elders. Nor should pastors themselves, when they can't reform everything that needs it as far as they'd wish, give up their ministry or throw the whole Church into confusion by unusual severity. Augustine is quite right: "Whoever corrects what he can by rebuking it, or, without breaking the bond of peace, excludes what he cannot correct, or without injustice condemns it while patiently tolerating what he cannot exclude without breaking the bond of peace, is free and clear of the curse" (Against Parmenian 2.4).
Elsewhere he gives the reason: "Every godly reason and manner of church discipline should always have in view the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. The apostle commands us to keep it by bearing with one another. If it isn't kept, the medicine of discipline begins to be not just unnecessary but harmful, and so stops being medicine" (3.1). "Anyone who thinks carefully about these things neither neglects strict discipline in preserving unity, nor breaks the bond of fellowship by intemperate correction" (3.2).
Augustine admits that pastors should work to remove every defect from the Church, and that every individual should do so to the best of their ability. He doesn't hide that someone who neglects to admonish, accuse, and correct the wicked, even if he doesn't favour them or sin with them, is guilty before the Lord. And if he behaves so that, though able to bar them from the Supper, he doesn't, then the sin is no longer other people's but his own. He only wants the prudence the Lord himself requires: "lest in gathering the weeds you root up the wheat along with them" (Matt. 13:29). From Cyprian he draws this conclusion: "Let a man correct mercifully what he can; what he can't correct, let him bear patiently, and mourn and grieve over it in love."
12. The Donatists and the Anabaptists
Augustine says this because of the sourness of the Donatists. They saw faults in the Church that the bishops rebuked in words but didn't punish with excommunication, since they didn't think it would accomplish anything. The Donatists bitterly attacked the bishops as traitors to discipline and, by an ungodly schism, separated themselves from the flock of Christ. The Anabaptists do much the same today. They recognise no assembly of Christ unless it is distinguished in every respect by angelic perfection, and under the pretence of zeal they overthrow everything that builds the Church up.
Augustine describes them: "Not out of hatred for other people's wickedness but out of zeal for their own disputes, they trap the weak by the reputation of their name and try either to draw them away altogether or at least to split them off. They are swollen with pride, frantic with spite, treacherous in slander, and turbulent in rebellion. So that it won't be seen how empty they are of the light of truth, they hide in the shadow of a stern severity. The correction of a brother's fault, which Scripture commands be done with moderation, without damaging the sincerity of love or breaking the bond of peace, they twist into sacrilegious schism and a campaign of cutting off. So Satan disguises himself as an angel of light (2 Cor. 11:14) when, under the pretext of just severity, he persuades people to savage cruelty. He wants nothing more than to violate and shatter the bond of unity and peace, because while it is maintained all his power to do harm is weak, his cunning traps are broken, and his schemes of destruction come to nothing" (Against Parmenian 3.4).
13. When a whole multitude has gone astray
Augustine especially commends one thing: if the contagion of sin has taken hold of a multitude, mercy must go along with living discipline. "Plans of separation are futile, sacrilegious, and harmful, because they are ungodly and proud, and they do more to disturb the weak who are good than to correct the proud who are wicked" (Letter 64). He practised faithfully what he told others to do. Writing to Aurelius, bishop of Carthage, he complains that drunkenness, so severely condemned in Scripture, goes unpunished in Africa, and he advises calling a council of bishops to find a remedy. He immediately adds: "In my opinion such things aren't removed by rough, harsh, and domineering measures, but more by teaching than by commanding, more by admonishing than by threatening. That is how we should deal with a multitude of offenders. Severity is for the sins of a few" (Letter 64).
He doesn't mean that the bishops should look the other way or stay silent because they can't punish public offences severely, as he himself explains afterwards. He wants the manner of correction to be tempered so as to bring health to the body rather than destruction. So he concludes: "We must never neglect the apostle's command to separate from the wicked, when it can be done without risking the violation of peace, because he didn't want it done any other way (1 Cor. 5:13). We must also strive, by bearing with one another, to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace" (Eph. 4:2).
14. Fasting and prayer as part of discipline
The remaining part of discipline isn't strictly part of the power of the keys. It is when pastors, as the times require, urge the people to fasting and solemn prayer, or to other exercises of humility, repentance, and faith. The time, manner, and form of these aren't prescribed in God's Word but are left to the Church's judgment. This part of discipline is useful, and it has always been used in the Church, from the days of the apostles. The apostles weren't its first originators; they took the example from the Law and the Prophets. There we see that whenever any weighty matter arose, the people were gathered and supplication and fasting were appointed (for example Ezra 8:21, at the river Ahava). In this the apostles followed a course that wasn't new to God's people and that they knew would be useful. The same holds for the other exercises by which the people may be roused to their duty or kept in obedience. Sacred history is full of examples and there's no need to collect them.
In general we should hold this. When a religious controversy arises that a council or church court has to settle, when a minister is to be chosen, when any matter of difficulty and great importance is under consideration, and when signs of God's anger appear, such as plague, war, and famine, the sacred and healthy custom of every age has been for pastors to call the people to public fasting and extraordinary prayer. Someone might refuse the Old Testament examples as less applicable to the Christian Church. It is clear the apostles acted the same way, though as far as prayer goes I hardly think anyone will dispute it.
Let's say something about fasting, since many people don't see what use it could be and consider it hardly necessary, while others reject it altogether as superfluous. Where its use isn't well understood, it's easy to slide into superstition.
15. Three purposes of fasting
A holy and lawful fast has three purposes. We use it either to subdue the flesh so that it doesn't run wild, or to prepare ourselves better for prayer and holy meditation, or to testify that we are humbling ourselves before God when we want to confess our guilt to him.
The first purpose isn't often in view in public fasting, because not everyone has the same physical constitution or state of health, so it fits private fasting better. The second is common to both, since this preparation for prayer is needed by the whole Church as much as by each member. The same goes for the third. Sometimes God strikes a nation with war or plague or some other calamity. In a common chastisement like that, the whole people should plead guilty and confess their guilt. If the Lord's hand strikes someone privately, the same should be done by that person alone or with their household. The thing itself is really a matter of the heart. But when the heart is moved as it should be, it can't help but find expression outwardly, especially when that serves the common good, so that all, by openly confessing their sin, may give praise to God's justice and encourage one another by their example.
16. Public fasting and prayer on important occasions
Because fasting is a sign of humility, it is used more often in public than by individuals, although, as I said, it belongs to both. So, in the discipline we're discussing, whenever supplication is to be made to God on some important occasion, it is fitting to set aside a time for fasting and prayer. When the Christians of Antioch laid hands on Barnabas and Paul, to commend their ministry, which was of such great importance, they joined fasting and prayer (Acts 13:3). Later these two apostles, when they appointed elders in the churches, likewise used prayer and fasting (Acts 14:23). In general their only aim in fasting was to make themselves more alert and unencumbered for prayer. We all know from experience that after a heavy meal the mind doesn't rise toward God so as to be carried along by an earnest, burning desire to pray and to keep on praying.
That's how we should understand what Luke says of Anna, that she "worshiped with fasting and prayer night and day" (Luke 2:37). He isn't locating the worship of God in fasting; he's indicating that this was how the holy woman trained herself to persevere in prayer. Nehemiah's fast was like that, when he prayed to God with more intense zeal for his people's deliverance (Neh. 1:4). For the same reason Paul says married believers do well to abstain from each other for a time (1 Cor. 7:5), so that they may be freer for prayer. When he joins prayer to fasting as its help, he reminds us that fasting has no importance in itself except in so far as it serves this end. And when in the same place he tells spouses to give each other their due, it's clear he doesn't mean daily prayer but the prayers that need more than ordinary attention.
17. Fasting in times of calamity
Likewise, when plague begins to spread, or famine or war, or any other disaster seems to threaten a province and people (Esth. 4:16), it is also the duty of pastors to urge the Church to fast, so that she may humbly plead for the Lord's anger to be turned away. When he makes danger appear, he is declaring that he is ready and, as it were, armed for vengeance. In the old days, those accused in court would humble themselves before the judge with long beards, unkempt hair, and rough clothing in order to stir his pity. In the same way, when we are charged before God's tribunal, it honours him, builds up the Church, and is good and healthy for ourselves to plead against his severity in humble dress.
That this was common among the Israelites we can gather from Joel. When he says, "Blow the trumpet in Zion; consecrate a fast; call a solemn assembly" (Joel 2:15), he speaks of things as already customary. A little earlier he had said that the people were to be tried for their wickedness, that the day of judgment was at hand, and he had summoned them as defendants to plead their cause. Then he cries out that they should hurry to sackcloth and ashes, to weeping and fasting, that is, humble themselves before God with outward signs. Sackcloth and ashes may have suited those times better, but the assembly, the weeping, the fasting and the like belong equally to our age, whenever our circumstances require it. It is a holy exercise for people to humble themselves and to confess their humility, so why should we use it less than the people of old did in similar need?
We read that not only the Israelite Church, formed and shaped by God's word, fasted as a sign of sorrow, but also the Ninevites, whose only teaching had been Jonah's preaching (1 Sam. 7:6; 31:13; 2 Kings 1:12; Jonah 3:5). So why shouldn't we? Someone will say it is an outward ceremony that, like other ceremonies, came to an end in Christ. But in fact it is a splendid help to believers today, as it always was, and a useful reminder to rouse them, so that through too much complacency and sloth they don't provoke the Lord more and more when he is chastening them with his rod. When our Saviour excuses his disciples for not fasting, he doesn't say that fasting has been abolished; he reserves it for times of calamity and joins it with mourning: "The days will come when the bridegroom is taken away from them" (Matt. 9:15; Luke 5:35).
18. What fasting is
To avoid any mistake about the word, let's define what fasting is, since we don't mean by it simply a restrained and sparing use of food. It is something else. The life of the godly should be marked by frugality and sobriety, so as to display, as far as possible, a kind of fasting throughout the whole course of life. But there is another, temporary fast, when we cut back somewhat on our usual way of living, for a day or for a set period, and impose on ourselves a stricter restraint in the use of ordinary food. It consists of three things: the time, the kind of food, and the amount.
By time I mean that while fasting we are to carry out the activities for the sake of which the fast was appointed. For example, someone who fasts because of solemn prayer should come to it without having eaten. The kind of food means putting all luxury aside and being content with plain and humbler fare, so as not to stir the palate with delicacies. As for amount, we must eat more lightly and sparingly, only as necessity requires and not for pleasure.
19. Guarding fasting against superstition
The first thing always to be guarded against is the creeping in of superstition, as happened in the past, to the great harm of the Church. It would have been much better to have no fasting at all than to have it carefully observed yet corrupted by false and harmful ideas, into which the world keeps falling unless pastors forestall it with the greatest faithfulness and prudence.
First, pastors should constantly press Joel's command, "Rend your hearts and not your garments" (Joel 2:13). That means reminding the people that fasting in itself isn't worth much in God's sight unless it comes with inward feeling of the heart, real dissatisfaction with sin and with oneself, real humility and real grief arising from the fear of God. Fasting is useful for no other reason than that it is added to these as a lesser help. Nothing is more detestable to God than people trying to cover themselves by putting signs and outward appearances in place of integrity of heart. This is why Isaiah attacks so bitterly the hypocrisy of the Jews, who thought they had satisfied God merely by fasting, whatever ungodliness and impure thoughts they harboured in their hearts. "Is such the fast that I choose?" (Isa. 58:5, and read what follows). The fast of hypocrites is not only useless and wearisome; it is the worst kind of abomination.
A related evil, also to be carefully avoided, is to regard fasting as a meritorious work and a kind of divine worship. It is a thing indifferent in itself, with no importance except for the purposes it should serve. It is a most harmful superstition to confuse it with works God commands, which are necessary in themselves without reference to anything else. That was the Manichees' ancient dream, and in refuting them Augustine clearly shows that fasting is to be judged entirely by the purposes I've mentioned and can't be approved by God except in so far as it serves them (On the Morals of the Manichees 2.13; Against Faustus 30).
Another error, not as impious but still dangerous, is to demand fasting with greater strictness and severity as one of the chief duties, and to praise it so extravagantly that people imagine they've done something admirable when they've fasted. Here I dare not completely excuse the ancient writers from having sown some seeds of superstition and given occasion for the tyranny that arose later. We do sometimes find sound and prudent statements on fasting from them, but we also keep running into extravagant praises that celebrate it as one of the cardinal virtues (see Chrysostom's homily at the start of Lent, where he calls fasting a cure for souls and a washing away of sins).
20. Lent
The superstitious observance of Lent then spread everywhere. The common people imagined they were rendering God some outstanding service by it, and pastors commended it as a holy imitation of Christ. Yet it is plain that Christ didn't fast to set an example for others. By fasting as he began to preach the gospel, he meant to prove that his teaching wasn't of human origin but came from heaven. It's strange how men of sharp judgment could fall into so gross a delusion, when so many clear reasons refute it.
Christ didn't fast repeatedly, as he would have had to if he had meant to lay down a law for a yearly fast. He fasted once only, as he prepared to announce the gospel. Nor did he fast in the way people do, as he would have if he had meant to invite imitation. He gave an example designed to make everyone marvel at him rather than strive to copy him. In short, the nature of his fast is no different from Moses's when he received the law from the Lord (Exod. 24:18; 34:28). That miracle was performed in Moses to establish the law, so it couldn't be left out in Christ, or the gospel would seem inferior to the law. Yet from that day it never occurred to anyone, on the pretext of imitating Moses, to set up a similar fast among the Israelites. None of the holy prophets and fathers followed it either, though they had enough desire and zeal for every godly exercise. It is said that Elijah went forty days without food and drink (1 Kings 19:8), but that was only so that the people would recognise he had been raised up to defend the law, from which nearly all Israel had turned away.
So it was nothing but false zeal, full of superstition, that set up a fast under the title and pretext of imitating Christ. And there was a remarkable diversity in how it was kept, as Cassiodorus reports in the ninth book of the History of Socrates: "The Romans had only three weeks, but their fast was continuous, except on the Lord's Day and the Sabbath. The Greeks and Illyrians had six weeks, some seven, but the fast was broken up. They didn't differ less in the kind of food: some used only bread and water, others added vegetables; others had no objection to fish and fowl; others made no difference in their food." Augustine also mentions this variety in his second letter to Januarius.
21. Rules about food, and the state of discipline under the papacy
Worse times followed. To the foolish zeal of the common people were added crudeness and ignorance in the bishops, hunger for power, and tyrannical severity. Ungodly laws were passed, binding the conscience in deadly chains. Eating meat was forbidden, as if a person were defiled by it. Sacrilegious opinions were added one after another until everything became an abyss of error. And so that no kind of depravity would be missing, under an absurd pretence of abstinence they began to make a mockery of God. They look for the credit of fasting in the most exquisite delicacies. No ordinary dainties will do; there has never been greater abundance, variety, and richness of food. (Bernard criticises princes among others for longing, during Lent, for the coming feast of the Lord's resurrection so that they could indulge more freely.) In this splendid show they think they are serving God.
I won't mention that the very people who want to be thought the holiest are never more filthy in their indulgence than at such times. In short, the highest worship of God is to abstain from meat and, with that exception, to indulge in delicacies of every kind. On the other hand, it is the greatest impiety, one hardly to be atoned for by death, for anyone to taste the smallest piece of bacon or rancid meat with his bread. Jerome, writing to Nepotian, reports that even in his day some people mocked God with such follies. They wouldn't even put oil in their food, yet had the finest delicacies brought from every quarter. To do violence to nature, they even abstained from drinking water and had sweet and costly drinks made, which they drank not from a cup but from a shell. What was then the fault of a few is now common among all the rich, who fast for no other purpose than to feast more richly and lavishly.
I don't want to waste many words on a matter where there is no doubt. I only say that in fasts, as in every other part of discipline, the papists are so far from having anything right, sincere, or properly ordered that they have no reason to preen themselves as if they had anything left that deserves praise.
22. The discipline of the clergy, ancient and modern
We come now to the second part of discipline, which concerns the clergy in particular. It is contained in the canons that the ancient bishops made for themselves and their order. For example: no clergyman may spend his time hunting, gambling, or feasting; none may engage in lending at interest or in trade; none may attend lewd dances, and so on. Penalties were added to give the canons force, so that no one could break them with impunity. To this end each bishop was given oversight of his own clergy, to govern them by the canons and keep them to their duty. Annual visitations and synods were set up for this purpose, so that anyone who was negligent in office could be admonished and anyone who sinned could be punished according to his fault. The bishops also had provincial synods once, and anciently twice, a year, where they were examined if they had done anything contrary to their duty. If a bishop had been too harsh or violent with his clergy, there was an appeal to the synod, even if only one person complained. The severest punishment was removal from office and temporary exclusion from communion. Since this arrangement was standard, no synod broke up without fixing the time and place of the next. Calling a universal council belonged to the emperor alone, as all the ancient summonses show.
As long as this strictness was in force, the clergy asked no more of the people in words than they performed in deed and example. Indeed they were stricter with themselves than with ordinary people, and it is right that the people be ruled by a kinder and, if I may say so, looser discipline, while the clergy are stricter in their censures and less indulgent to themselves than to others.
How all this fell out of use isn't worth telling, since today nothing can be imagined more lawless and dissolute than this order, whose licentiousness is so extreme that the whole world is crying out against it. I grant that, so as not to seem to have lost sight of antiquity altogether, they deceive the eyes of simple people with certain shadows of it. But these resemble ancient customs no more than an ape's mimicry resembles what people do with reason and purpose.
There is a memorable passage in Xenophon where he tells how the Persians, after they had shamefully degenerated from their ancestors' customs and fallen from a severe way of life into luxury and softness, still kept up the ancient rites carefully to hide their disgrace (Cyropaedia 8). In Cyrus's day sobriety and self-control flourished so much that no Persian needed to wipe his nose, and it was considered shameful to do so. Their descendants kept it as a point of religion not to clear the nostril, though they were allowed to let the foul humours they had built up through gluttony fester inside. In the same way, by ancient custom it was unlawful to use cups at table, but it was perfectly acceptable to swallow wine until they had to be carried off drunk. One meal a day was the rule, and these fine successors didn't abolish it, but they stretched their feasting from midday to midnight. To finish the day's march fasting was the unvarying custom, as the law required, but to avoid tiring, the allowed and usual practice was to limit the march to two hours. Whenever the degenerate papists push their rules to show how much they resemble the holy fathers, this example will expose their ridiculous imitation. No painter could paint them more to the life.
23. The forced celibacy of priests
In one thing they are more than rigid and inflexible: in not letting priests marry. It doesn't matter to mention how freely prostitution flourishes among them, and how, trusting in their wretched celibacy, they have grown hardened to every kind of wrongdoing. The prohibition itself clearly shows how harmful all human traditions are, since this one has not only deprived the Church of fit and honest pastors but has introduced a fearful cesspool of iniquity and plunged many souls into the pit of despair.
When marriage was forbidden to priests, it was done with ungodly tyranny, contrary not only to God's Word but to all justice. First, people had no right at all to forbid what God left free. Second, it is too clear to need lengthy proof that God has expressly provided in his Word that this freedom shall not be taken away. I leave aside Paul's instruction in several passages that a bishop be "the husband of one wife." But what could be stronger than his declaration that in later times there would be ungodly people "who forbid marriage" (1 Tim. 4:3)? He calls such people not only impostors but demons. We have, then, a prophecy, a sacred oracle of the Holy Spirit meant to warn the Church from the start against dangers, declaring that the prohibition of marriage is a teaching of demons.
They think they escape neatly by twisting this passage and applying it to Montanus, the Tatians, the Encratites, and other ancient heretics. Those people alone, they say, condemned marriage, whereas we don't condemn it at all, we only deny it to the clerical order, for whom we think it unsuitable. As if, even granting that this prophecy was first fulfilled in those heretics, it couldn't apply to them too. Or as if anyone could listen to the childish quibble that they don't forbid marriage because they don't forbid it to everyone. That is just as if a tyrant argued that a law isn't unjust because its injustice falls only on part of the state.
24. The objection that clergy need a distinguishing mark
They object that there should be some distinguishing mark between clergy and people, as if the Lord hadn't provided the ornaments in which ministers should excel. They end up accusing the apostle of upsetting the order of the Church and destroying its ornament when, in drawing the portrait of a perfect bishop, he dared to list marriage among the other qualities he required.
I know how they explain this: that no one was to be appointed bishop who had a second wife. That interpretation, I admit, isn't new, but its weakness is plain from the context just after, which prescribes the kind of wives bishops and deacons should have. Paul counts marriage among the qualities of a bishop. Those people declare that marriage in the clerical order is an intolerable vice, and not content with that general abuse, they call it in their canons the uncleanness and pollution of the flesh (Siricius, to the bishops of Spain). Let everyone consider from what workshop these ideas have come. Christ honours marriage so highly that he makes it an image of his sacred union with the Church. What greater tribute could be paid to the dignity of marriage? How then can they have the nerve to call unclean and polluted something that gives a bright picture of Christ's spiritual grace?
25. The Levitical priests argument
Though their prohibition is so clearly contrary to the word of God, they still find something in Scripture to defend it. The Levitical priests, whenever their turn of service came round, had to keep apart from their wives, so that they would be pure and spotless in handling sacred things. So, they say, it would be very improper for our sacred things, which are nobler and ministered every day, to be handled by married men. As if the ministry of the gospel were the same as the Levitical priesthood.
Those priests were types of Christ, who as Mediator between God and men was to reconcile us to the Father by his own spotless purity. But sinners couldn't in every respect present a type of his holiness. So that they could at least outline it in some features, they were commanded to purify themselves beyond the ordinary human way when they approached the sanctuary. In that role they properly prefigured Christ appearing in the tabernacle, an image of the heavenly court, as peacemakers reconciling people to God. Pastors of the Church today don't play that part, so the comparison is pointless.
Hence the apostle says plainly, with no exception, "Let marriage be held in honour among all, and let the marriage bed be undefiled, for God will judge the sexually immoral and adulterous" (Heb. 13:4). And the apostles showed by their own example that marriage doesn't detract from the holiness of any office, however high. Paul says they not only kept their wives but took them along on their journeys (1 Cor. 9:5).
26. The primitive Church and the Council of Nicaea
How great is the nerve, then, when they hold up this ornament of chastity as a necessity, and heap the greatest abuse on the early Church, which was rich in remarkable learning about God and even more distinguished in holiness. If they have no regard for the apostles (they are sometimes quite willing to look down on them), what will they make, I ask, of all the ancient fathers, who certainly not only tolerated marriage in the order of bishops but approved of it? According to them, those fathers encouraged a foul profanation of sacred things, since the Lord's mysteries were carried out in so irregular a way.
At the Council of Nicaea, there was in fact some talk of proclaiming celibacy, as there are always small-minded, superstitious people devising some novelty to win admiration for themselves. What was decided? The opinion of Paphnutius prevailed, who declared lawful marital intercourse to be chastity (Tripartite History 2.14). So the marriage of priests remained honourable, and wasn't regarded as a disgrace or thought to stain their ministry.
27. The appeal to antiquity, and the praise of virginity
In the times that followed, an overly superstitious admiration for celibacy took hold. Unmeasured praises of virginity were pronounced again and again, until the common belief was that hardly any virtue could be compared with it. Marriage wasn't condemned as impurity, but its dignity was lowered and its holiness obscured, so that anyone who didn't abstain from it was thought not to have a mind strong enough to aim at perfection. Out of this came canons that enacted, first, that those who had reached the priesthood should not marry, and second, that no one should be admitted to that order unless unmarried or willing, with his wife's consent, to give up the marriage bed. These rules, since they seemed to win respect for the priesthood, were, I admit, received with great applause even in ancient times.
But if my opponents plead antiquity, my first answer is that under the apostles, and for several centuries after, bishops were free to have wives. The apostles themselves, and the other pastors of primitive authority who followed them, had no difficulty using this freedom, and the example of the primitive Church should rightly carry more weight than to let us think that what was then received and practised with approval is either unlawful or unbecoming. My second answer is that the age which, through excessive affection for virginity, began to be less favourable to marriage, didn't lay a law of celibacy on priests as if it were necessary in itself, but gave the unmarried preference over the married. My last answer is that they didn't demand it so rigidly as to make continence compulsory for those unfit for it. While the strictest laws were made against fornication, it was enacted only about those who married that they should be removed from office.
28. Conclusion on celibacy
So whenever the defenders of this new tyranny appeal to antiquity to defend their celibacy, we should call on them to restore the ancient chastity of their priests: to put away adulterers and whoremongers, not to let those to whom they deny an honourable and chaste use of marriage plunge into every kind of lust without penalty, to bring back that lost discipline that restrains all licentiousness, and to free the Church from the scandalous disgrace that has long disfigured her. When they've conceded this, we'll next have to remind them not to present as necessary what is in itself free and depends on the good of the Church.
I don't say this as if I thought that those canons imposing a bond of celibacy on the clergy should be given effect on any terms whatever. I say it so that those of better mind may see the nerve of our opponents in using the name of antiquity to slander the holy marriage of priests. Among the fathers whose writings survive, none of them, when they spoke their own mind, with the exception of Jerome, spitefully belittled the honour of marriage. A single passage from Chrysostom will do, since as a special admirer of virginity he can't be thought more generous than others in praising marriage. He says: "The first degree of chastity is pure virginity; the second is faithful marriage. So the chaste love of marriage is the second kind of virginity" (Homily on the Finding of the Cross).
Chapter 13
Vows, and the Tangled Mess Caused by Rash Vowing
1. Why vows need examining
It is a sad thing that the Church, whose freedom was bought at the incalculable price of Christ's blood, should have been oppressed by a cruel tyranny and almost buried under a heap of human traditions. But the folly of individuals shows that Satan and his servants were not given so much power without reason. It wasn't enough for people to ignore Christ's command and carry whatever burdens false teachers cared to lay on them. Each person had to have private burdens of their own, and so sank deeper by digging their own pit. That is what happened when people began inventing vows, which were meant to add a stronger and tighter obligation to the ties that already bind all Christians.
I have already shown how the worship of God was corrupted by those who ruled the Church under the name of pastors and trapped poor souls with their wicked laws. It is fitting, then, to deal now with a related evil, to show that the world, true to its warped nature, has always put every possible obstacle in the way of the very helps meant to bring it to God. To see how serious the damage done by these vows is, remember two principles already established. First, everything needed for ordering a godly and holy life is contained in the law (Book 2, chapter 8, section 5). Second, the Lord, to discourage us from inventing new works, included the whole of righteousness in simple obedience to his will. If these are true, it is easy to see that any worship we invent ourselves in order to serve God is not in the least acceptable to him, however much we may like it. In many passages the Lord does not merely reject such worship but loathes it.
That raises a question about vows made without any express warrant in God's word. How should they be regarded? Can Christians make them properly, and how far do they bind? What men call a promise, when it is made to God, is a vow. Among people we promise either what we think will please them or what we owe them. We should be far more careful in vows directed to God, with whom we must deal with the greatest seriousness. Here superstition has run wild in every age. People have vowed to God whatever came into their heads, or even onto their lips, without judgment and without choice. That is the origin of the foolish vows, even monstrous absurdities, with which the pagans mocked their gods. I wish Christians had not copied their recklessness. Yet for some centuries nothing has been more common. Whole populations despised the law of God and burned with a mad zeal for vowing whatever any dream of theirs suggested. I have no wish to exaggerate or to list the many serious sins committed here. I mention it only to show that when we discuss vows we are not discussing something unimportant.
2. To whom the vow is made: God, and only what he requires
If we want to avoid error in deciding which vows are legitimate and which are perverse, we must attend to three things: who it is that the vow is made to, who we are that make it, and with what intention we make it.
On the first, we must remember that we are dealing with God. Our obedience delights him so much that he abominates every kind of self-invented worship, however impressive it looks to people (Col. 2:23). If all worship we devise without his authority is an abomination to him, then no worship can please him except what his word approves. So we must not take the liberty of vowing anything to God without evidence of how he regards it. Paul's teaching that "whatever does not proceed from faith is sin" (Rom. 14:23) applies to every action, but it applies with special force where our thoughts are turned directly to God. If in the smallest matters (Paul was speaking of the distinction between foods) we go wrong where the sure light of faith is not shining before us, how much more restraint should we show when we take on something of the greatest weight? Nothing calls for more seriousness than the duties of religion. So the first safeguard in making vows is never to make one without first resolving in conscience to do nothing rashly. We are safe from rashness when God goes before us and, in a sense, dictates from his word what is good and what is useless.
3. Who we are that vow: our strength and our calling
The second point is that we must measure our strength and pay attention to our calling, so that we don't throw away the freedom God has given us. Someone who vows what is beyond their means or contrary to their calling is rash, and someone who despises God's kindness in making them lord of all things is ungrateful.
I don't mean that anything lies so within our power that we can lean on our own strength and promise it to God. The Council of Orange (canon 11) rightly decided that nothing is properly vowed to God except what we have first received from his hand, since everything we offer him is simply his gift. But some things are given to us by God's goodness and others are withheld by his justice, and so everyone should keep to the measure of grace given to them, as Paul instructs (Rom. 12:3; 1 Cor. 12:11). My point is only this. Your vows should be fitted to the measure God sets for you by his gifts, so that you don't claim too much for yourself by attempting more than he allows, and fall flat on your face.
The conspirators in Acts, for example, vowed that "they would neither eat nor drink till they had killed Paul" (Acts 23:12). Even had it not been a wicked plot, it would have been outrageously presumptuous, since it put a man's life and death in their own hands. Jephthah paid for his folly when he made his hasty vow in the heat of the moment (Judg. 11:30).
In this class of rash vows, the first place for sheer reckless presumption belongs to celibacy. Priests, monks and nuns forget their weakness and are sure they are fit for it. But what oracle taught them that the chastity they vow for life they will be able to keep for life? They hear God's verdict on the universal human condition: "It is not good that the man should be alone" (Gen. 2:18). They understand, and I wish they did not also feel, that the sin remaining in us is armed with the sharpest stings. How can they presume to shake off the common feelings of their nature for a whole lifetime, when the gift of self-control is often given only for a certain time, as a particular need requires? In such perversity they cannot expect God to help them. They should remember instead: "You shall not put the Lord your God to the test" (Deut. 6:16). To fight against the nature God gave us, and to reject his gifts as though they did not concern us, is exactly to put him to the test.
And they don't only do this. They also presume to brand marriage as a defilement, though God did not think it beneath his majesty to institute it, declared it honourable for all, and though Christ our Lord sanctified it by his presence and honoured it with his first miracle. So extravagant is their praise of every kind of celibacy! As if their own lives didn't prove that celibacy is one thing and chastity another. Yet they shamelessly call this life angelic, which is no small insult to God's angels, since they are comparing them to fornicators and adulterers, and to people far worse and fouler still. There is little need for argument here, because the facts refute them. We can see the fearful punishments with which the Lord avenges this arrogance and this contempt for his gifts. I spare the more hidden crimes out of shame; what is publicly known is bad enough. Bernard himself, attacking the crimes of the clergy, said: "I wish those who cannot contain themselves would fear to take the vow of celibacy. For it is a weighty saying that not everyone can receive it. Many either cannot hide their sin from the crowd or don't try to. They refuse the remedy of marriage and then give themselves over to every kind of wickedness."
Beyond any dispute, we should not vow anything that will prevent us from fulfilling our calling. A father of a family shouldn't vow to leave his wife and children and take on other burdens, and a person suited to public office shouldn't, once elected, vow to live as a private citizen.
What I said about not despising our liberty may need clarifying. God has given us dominion over all things and put them under us for our use. So we cannot hope that our service will please him if we enslave ourselves to external things that are meant to serve us. I say this because some people hunt for a reputation for humility by tying themselves up in all kinds of observances from which God, for good reason, wanted us to be completely free. To avoid this danger, let us always remember that we must never withdraw from the way of life God has established in the Christian Church.
4. The intention behind the vow: gratitude and repentance
My third point is that the state of mind in which you make a vow matters a great deal. God looks not at outward appearance but at the heart. So depending on the purpose the mind has in view, the same act may at one time please him and at another displease him very much. If you vow to abstain from wine as though there were holiness in doing so, you are superstitious. If you have some sound purpose in view, no one can object.
As far as I can see, there are four proper purposes for vows. For the sake of order, I assign two to the past and two to the future. The past-looking vows either express gratitude to God for blessings received, or inflict a punishment on ourselves for faults committed so as to turn aside his anger. The first kind we may call acts of thanksgiving and the second acts of repentance.
An example of the first is the tithe Jacob vowed if the Lord would bring him safely home from exile (Gen. 28:20). Another is the ancient peace offerings that devout kings and commanders vowed to give if they were victorious in a just war, or at least if the Lord delivered them from some great difficulty. That is how we should understand all the passages in the Psalms that mention vows (Ps. 22:26; 56:12; 116:14, 18). We can make similar vows today whenever the Lord has rescued us from a disaster, a dangerous illness or some other peril. It isn't out of keeping with a godly person to dedicate an offering to God in this way, as a formal sign of thanks so that they don't seem ungrateful for his kindness.
One familiar example will do for the second kind. Suppose someone has fallen into sin through overindulgence. Nothing stops them from renouncing all luxuries for a time to discipline their lack of self-control, and from using a vow to bind themselves more firmly. I don't lay this down as a fixed rule for everyone who has fallen in the same way. I only show what may lawfully be done by those who think such a vow will help them. I hold that it is lawful to vow in this way, and I leave it free.
5. Vows that look to the future
Vows looking to the future serve partly to make us more careful and partly to spur us on to our duty. Suppose someone sees that they are so prone to a particular vice that they cannot stop themselves from sliding into evil over something that is not bad in itself. They won't be acting absurdly if they cut that thing off for a time by a vow. If a person sees that some personal adornment puts them at risk, and yet desire makes them long for it, what could be better than putting a curb on themselves by imposing abstinence and freeing themselves from all doubt? In the same way, if someone is forgetful or lazy about the necessary duties of godliness, why shouldn't they jog their memory and shake off their laziness by making a vow?
In both cases, I admit, there is a kind of schooling involved. But since these are helps for weakness, the ignorant and imperfect use them with real benefit. So I hold that vows serving one of these purposes, especially in external matters, are lawful, provided they have God's approval, suit our calling, and stay within the measure of grace given to us.
6. The vow common to all believers, and how to judge particular vows
It is now not hard to see what view to take of vows overall. There is one vow shared by all believers. We take it in baptism, and we confirm and, as it were, ratify it by our profession of faith and by sharing in the Lord's Supper. The sacraments are a kind of mutual contract. The Lord conveys his mercy to us, and with it eternal life, and we in turn promise him obedience. The formula, or at least its substance, is that we renounce Satan and bind ourselves to the service of God, to obey his holy commands and no longer follow the corrupt desires of our flesh.
There is no doubt that this vow is holy and good for us. Scripture sanctions it, and indeed demands it of all God's children. It makes no difference that nobody in this life gives the perfect obedience to the law that God requires. That condition is built into the covenant of grace, which includes forgiveness of sins and the Spirit of holiness. The promise we make there is joined with a plea for pardon and a request for help.
In judging particular vows, we need to remember the three rules above. With them anyone can easily assess any single vow.
I don't recommend even the vows I call holy so heavily that I would have them made every day. I wouldn't dare to give a rule about timing or number, but if anyone takes my advice, they will make only sober and temporary vows. If you keep launching into one vow after another, the solemnity will be lost through frequency and you will slip easily into superstition. If you bind yourself by a perpetual vow, you will have great trouble in getting free, or, worn down by time, you will finally dare to break it.
7. The superstition that has surrounded vows
It is now easy to see how much superstition the world has laboured under in this matter for centuries. One person vowed to be teetotal, as though abstaining from wine were in itself a service pleasing to God. Another bound himself to fast, another to avoid meat on certain days which he had wrongly imagined to be holier than others. Much more childish things were vowed, and not by children. It was thought the height of wisdom to vow pilgrimages to holy places, sometimes making the journey on foot or half naked, so that greater fatigue would earn greater merit.
If these and similar things, which the world has pursued with incredible zeal, are tested by the rules we laid down, they turn out to be not only empty and pointless but full of plain impiety. Whatever the flesh may think, God hates nothing more than invented worship. To this we must add the harmful notions that follow. Hypocrites, having performed such trivialities, think they have earned extraordinary righteousness. They place the substance of godliness in outward observances and look down on everyone else who seems less careful about them.
8. Monastic vows: ancient monasticism and its purpose
There is no point in listing every kind of vow. But monastic vows are held in great reverence because they seem to have the public approval of the Church, so I will say a few words about them.
First, nobody should defend present-day monasticism on the grounds of long tradition. Living in monasteries used to be very different. Those who retired to them wanted to train themselves in the greatest austerity and endurance. The discipline of those monks resembled what the Spartans are said to have practised under the laws of Lycurgus, and was even stricter. They slept on the ground, drank water, ate bread, herbs and roots, and their great luxuries were oil and pulses. They avoided anything more refined and any care for the body. This might sound exaggerated if it weren't confirmed by eyewitnesses such as Gregory of Nazianzus, Basil and Chrysostom.
By this basic training they prepared themselves for greater responsibilities. The monastic communities of the time were a kind of seminary for the ordained ministry. The men I just named were all raised in monasteries and called from there to be bishops, as were many other great and excellent men of their age. Augustine also shows that in his day monasteries regularly supplied clergy to the Church. He writes to the monks of the island of Capraria: "We urge you, brothers in the Lord, to hold to your purpose and persevere to the end. If our mother the Church ever needs your labour, do not take it up with eager self-importance, and do not refuse it out of the flattery of laziness, but obey God with a gentle heart. Do not put your own ease before the needs of the Church. If no good people had been willing to serve her while she was in labour, you could never have been born" (Letter 48). He is speaking of the ministry through which believers are born again spiritually. He also writes to Aurelius (Letter 60): "It is both a cause of failure for them and a most unseemly insult to the clerical order if deserters from monasteries are chosen for the clergy, since from those who stay in the monastery it is our custom to choose for the clergy only the better and more proven. Otherwise, as the common saying goes, 'A bad singer is a good flute-player,' so it will be said of us in jest, 'A bad monk is a good cleric.' There would be too much cause for grief if we stirred monks up to ruinous pride and thought the clergy deserved so serious an insult, seeing that sometimes a good monk scarcely makes a good cleric. He may have enough self-control but lack the necessary learning."
These passages show that devout people used monastic discipline to prepare for the government of the Church, so that they would be better suited and better trained for the weighty office. This doesn't mean that all of them reached that goal or even aimed at it, since the great majority of monks were uneducated. Those who were fit were chosen.
9. Augustine's portrait of the early monks
Augustine gives a picture of ancient monasticism in two places. One is his book On the Morals of the Catholic Church, where he defends the holiness of the calling against the slanders of the Manichaeans. The other is On the Work of Monks, where he attacks some degenerate monks who had begun to corrupt the institution. I will give a summary of what he says, as far as possible in his own words:
"They despise the allurements of this world and gather in common for a most chaste and holy life. They spend their time together in prayer, reading and discussion, not puffed up with pride, not stirred up by quarrelsomeness, not sallow with envy. No one owns anything personally, and no one is a burden to anyone. They work with their hands at things that feed the body without drawing the mind away from God. They hand the fruit of their labour to those they call deans. The deans manage everything with great care and give an account to one they call father. These fathers are not only of the purest character but outstanding in knowledge of divine things and noble in every respect. Without any pride they consult those they call their sons, though the fathers have full authority to command and the sons are very ready to obey. At the end of the day they gather from their cells, still fasting, to hear their father, and at least three thousand assemble under each father (he is speaking of Egypt and the East). Then the body is refreshed as far as health and safety require, each person restraining their appetite so as not to overindulge even in the scant and very plain food provided. They abstain not only from meat and wine to subdue lust, but from the things that most readily stir the appetite of the stomach and palate, which to some seem more refined. (In this way the desire for exquisite delicacies that contain no meat is often absurdly and shamefully defended.) Whatever is left over after necessary food, and the surplus is very large because of their labour and their frugal meals, is carefully distributed to the needy, the more carefully because those who distribute it did not earn it for themselves. They never act with the aim of having abundance for themselves, but always with the aim of letting no surplus remain with them" (Morals of the Catholic Church 31).
Describing their austerity, of which he had seen examples both at Milan and elsewhere, he continues: "Meanwhile no one is pushed to austerities he cannot bear. No one is made to do what he declines, or condemned by the others whom he admits he is too weak to imitate. They remember how highly charity is commended. They remember that 'to the pure all things are pure' (Titus 1:15). So all their vigilance goes not into rejecting kinds of food as unclean but into subduing desire and maintaining love for the brothers. They remember: 'Food is meant for the stomach and the stomach for food' (1 Cor. 6:13). Many who are strong abstain for the sake of the weak. In many this is not the reason, and they take pleasure in living on the plainest and cheapest food. So the very people who restrain themselves in health do not refuse in sickness what their health requires. Many don't drink wine, yet don't think themselves polluted by it, since they most kindly have it given to the sicker ones and to those whose health needs it. And any who refuse foolishly, they admonish as brothers, lest by empty superstition they become weaker rather than holier. So they practise godliness with great care, knowing that bodily exercise is of value only for a short time. Above all, charity is observed. Their food is adapted to charity, their speech to charity, their dress to charity, their looks to charity. They come together and breathe only charity. They think it as wrong to offend charity as to offend God. If anyone opposes it, he is cast out and shunned. If anyone offends it, he is not allowed to stay a single day" (Morals of the Catholic Church 33).
Since this holy man seems in these words to have painted the monastic life of ancient times, I thought it right to include them here, though they are long. Collecting the same material from different writers would have made me even longer.
10. How far today's monasticism has fallen from this
I had no intention of discussing the whole subject here. I wanted only to show what sort of monks the early Church had and what the monastic calling then was, so that sound readers can see from the contrast how shameless it is to appeal to antiquity in support of present-day monkery. I will mark three differences.
First, Augustine, in tracing a holy and legitimate monasticism, wants to keep away any harsh demands about matters the word of the Lord has left free. Today nothing is demanded more harshly. They treat it as an unforgivable crime to deviate in the slightest from the prescribed form in the colour or style of clothing, the kind of food, or other trivial and lifeless ceremonies.
Second, Augustine argues forcefully that monks may not live in idleness off other people's resources (On the Work of Monks). He says no such thing could be found in a well-run monastery in his day. Our monks place the main part of their holiness in idleness. Take away their idleness, and where will that contemplative life be, in which they boast that they surpass everyone and come close to the angels?
Third, Augustine requires a monasticism that is nothing other than training for, and an aid to, the duties of godliness that are commended to all Christians. When he makes charity its chief and almost its only rule, do we imagine he praises the kind of association in which a few people, bound to one another, are cut off from the whole body of the Church? On the contrary, he wants them to set the rest an example of preserving the Church's unity.
On both counts, present-day monasticism is so unlike the old that it would be hard to find anything more different, not to say opposite. Our monks are not satisfied with the godliness that Christ commands his followers to concentrate on. They imagine a new kind of godliness, and by aspiring to it they think themselves more perfect than everyone else.
11. The claim to a higher perfection
If they deny this, I would like to know why they give the title of "the state of perfection" to their own order alone and refuse it to all other callings from God. I know the clever answer: their order is called that not because it contains perfection but because it is the best way of acquiring it. Yet when they want to praise themselves to the people, set a trap for rash and ignorant youths, defend their privileges, or raise their own dignity at others' expense, they boast that they are in a state of perfection. When they are pressed too hard to defend this empty arrogance, they retreat to saying they haven't yet attained perfection but are in a state where they aspire to it more than others do. Meanwhile the people go on admiring them as though the monastic life alone were angelic, perfect and free of every fault. Under this pretence they run a very profitable trade, and their modest gloss lies buried in a few books. Anyone can see this is intolerable nonsense.
But let us deal with them as if they claimed no more for their profession than that it is a state for acquiring perfection. By giving it that name they surely mark it out from other ways of life by a special distinction. And who will allow this honour to be transferred to an institution of which not one syllable of approval is spoken in Scripture, while all the other callings of God are judged unworthy of it, though they are commanded by his own lips and honoured with distinguished titles? How great an insult it is to God when some human invention is preferred to all the ways of life he has ordained and approved!
12. The "evangelical counsels"
They may say I slander them when I claim they are not content with the rule God has laid down. Even if I said nothing, they accuse themselves quite enough. They openly declare that they take on a greater burden than Christ placed on his followers, since they promise to keep the "evangelical counsels" about loving enemies, giving up the desire for revenge, and not swearing oaths, which Christians in general are supposedly not bound to keep.
What antiquity can they claim here? None of the ancients ever thought of such a thing. They all say with one voice that nothing Christ said is optional, and that every word must be obeyed. The very things these admirable interpreters pretend Christ merely advised, the ancients uniformly declare, without any hesitation, that he expressly commanded. I have shown elsewhere that this is a deadly error, so it is enough to note briefly here that monasticism as it now exists is founded on an idea which all godly people ought to detest: the pretence that there is some more perfect rule of life than the common rule God has given the whole Church. Whatever is built on that foundation cannot help being abominable.
13. The rich young man
They offer another argument for their perfection and think it unanswerable. Our Lord told the young man who asked him about perfect righteousness: "If you would be perfect, go, sell what you possess and give to the poor" (Matt. 19:21). Whether they actually do this I am not now arguing. Let us grant that they do. They boast, then, that they have become perfect by giving up everything. If the sum of perfection lies in this, what does Paul mean when he says that though a man should give away all his goods to feed the poor, if he has not love he is nothing (1 Cor. 13:3)? What kind of perfection is it that, if love is missing, amounts to nothing for the very person who has it? They must answer that it is the highest work of perfection but not the only one. Yet Paul steps in again and says without hesitation that love, with no such renunciation, is "the bond of perfection" (Col. 3:14).
If it is certain that the pupil does not disagree with the master, and the pupil clearly denies that a person's perfection consists in giving up all their goods and asserts that perfection can exist without it, then we must see in what sense to take Christ's words, "If you would be perfect, go, sell what you possess."
The meaning will not be obscure if we consider to whom the words were spoken, which we should do with all our Saviour's discourses (Luke 10:25). A young man asks by what works he may enter eternal life. Since he was asked about works, Christ refers him to the law. And rightly, for considered in itself the law is the way of eternal life, and the only reason it cannot give eternal life is our corruption. By this answer Christ declared that he was not giving any other rule of life than the one already given in the law of the Lord. He thus bore witness to the divine law as a teaching of perfect righteousness, and at the same time answered the slander that he was inciting people to revolt against the law with some new rule.
The young man, who was not ill-disposed but was swollen with empty confidence, answers that he has kept all the commandments from his youth. It is absolutely certain that he was immeasurably far from the goal he claimed to have reached. Had his claim been true, he would have lacked nothing of perfection, for the law, as has been shown, contains perfect righteousness. This is obvious from the fact that keeping it is called the way to eternal life. To show him how little progress he had made in the righteousness he so boldly claimed to have fulfilled, it was right to put his besetting sin before him. He had great wealth and his heart was set on it. So because he didn't feel this secret wound, Christ probes it: "Go, sell what you have." If he had kept the law as well as he supposed, he would not have gone away sorrowful on hearing this. Whoever loves God with their whole heart not only counts everything that opposes that love as rubbish but hates it as ruin (Phil. 3:8).
So when Christ orders a rich miser to leave everything he has, it is the same as ordering the ambitious to renounce all their honours, the pleasure-seeking all their luxuries, and the immoral every instrument of their lust. Consciences that are not reached by a general warning have to be called back to a specific awareness of their specific sin. It is pointless, then, to twist that particular case into a general rule, as if Christ had decided that a person's perfection lies in abandoning their goods. He meant only to make a young man who was far too pleased with himself feel his sore spot and understand that he was still a long way from the perfect obedience to the law which he falsely credited to himself.
I admit that some of the Fathers misunderstood this passage. This gave rise to an enthusiasm for voluntary poverty, where only those who abandoned all earthly goods and gave themselves to Christ in destitution were thought blessed. But I am confident that after my explanation no good and reasonable person will have any doubt about Christ's meaning here.
14. Monasticism as a "second baptism," and its separation from the Church
Still, nothing was further from the Fathers' intention than to establish the kind of perfection that cowled monks later invented to create a sort of double Christianity. At that time the sacrilegious doctrine had not yet been announced which compares the monastic profession to baptism and flatly declares that it is a form of second baptism. Who can doubt that the Fathers abhorred such blasphemy with all their hearts? Chrysostom, in his homily on Paul's words "Greet Prisca," says that all who retire to monasteries separate themselves from the Church, since they openly assert that their monasticism is a form of second baptism.
Do I need to argue at length that the last quality Augustine attributes to the ancient monks, that they adapted themselves to charity in everything, is utterly foreign to this new profession? The facts themselves show that everyone who retires to a monastery withdraws from the Church. Do they not separate themselves from the lawful society of believers by acquiring for themselves a special ministry and a private administration of the sacraments? What is destroying the Church's communion if not that?
To follow the comparison I began with and close the point: how do they resemble the ancient monks here? The old monks, though they lived apart from others, did not have a separate church. They shared the sacraments with others, attended public assemblies, and were then part of the people. But what have these men done by erecting a private altar for themselves except break the bond of unity? They have excommunicated themselves from the whole body of the Church and despised the ordinary ministry through which the Lord has chosen to preserve peace and love among his people.
So I hold that for every monastery there is today, there is a gathering of schismatics who have disturbed the order of the Church and been cut off from the lawful society of believers. And so that there could be no doubt about their separation, they have given themselves the various names of factions. They are not ashamed to glory in what Paul so detests that he cannot express his loathing strongly enough. Unless, of course, we suppose that the Corinthians did not divide Christ when one teacher was set above another (1 Cor. 1:12-13; 3:4), and that no injury is done to Christ now when, instead of hearing "Christians," we hear some called Benedictines, others Franciscans, others Dominicans, names they proudly use in place of a religious identity because they want to stand out from the common body of Christians.
15. The conduct of the monks
The differences I have pointed out so far between the ancient monks and those of our time are differences of profession, not of conduct. Readers should remember that I have spoken of monasticism rather than of monks, and have marked not the vices that cling to a few but the vices inseparable from the way of life itself.
As for conduct, what use is it to list and show how great the difference is? This much is certain: there is no class of people more stained by every kind of vice. Nowhere do faction, hatred, partisanship and intrigue flourish more. In a few monasteries, it is true, they live chastely, if we call it chastity where lust is repressed only so far as not to be openly scandalous. Even so, you will scarcely find one in ten that is not more a brothel than a holy house of chastity. And how thriftily they live? Like pigs wallowing in their sty. But I will go no further, lest they complain that I am treating them too harshly, though anyone who knows the facts will admit that in the few things I have said I have not spoken as an accuser.
Augustine testifies that the monks of his day excelled in chastity, yet he also complains of many vagabonds who by wicked tricks and frauds extracted money from simple people, carrying around the relics of martyrs for a shameful trade, selling any dead man's bones as relics, and bringing disgrace on their order by many similar crimes. He declared that he had seen no better people than those who had made progress in monasteries, and that he had seen none worse than those who had fallen back in monasteries. What would he say if he saw almost all monasteries today overflowing, and bursting, with so many deplorable vices? I say nothing that is not notorious. Even so, the charge does not apply to every single person. The rule and discipline of holy living was never so well framed in monasteries that there were not always some drones quite unlike the rest. In the same way, I accept that today's monks have not degenerated so completely from that holy antiquity as to have no good men among them. But these few lie scattered among a huge crowd of wicked and dishonest men, and are not only despised but pettily attacked, and sometimes even treated cruelly by the others, who, as the Milesian proverb has it, think they should have no good man among them.
16. Weaknesses even in the ancient model
By this contrast between ancient and modern monasticism I hope I have achieved my aim, which was to show that our cowled monks falsely claim the example of the early Church in defence of their profession, since they differ from the monks of that time no less than apes differ from men.
At the same time, I don't hide the fact that even in the ancient form Augustine commends, there was something I don't much like. I grant that they were not superstitious about the outward exercises of a stricter discipline, but I say they were not free of a measure of showiness and misplaced zeal. It was a fine thing to throw away their possessions and free themselves from worldly cares. But God values more highly the godly management of a household, where the head of the family, rejecting greed, ambition and the other lusts of the flesh, sets out to serve God in some particular calling. It is fine to philosophise in seclusion, far from the company of others. But it ill suits Christian gentleness for anyone, as if in hatred of the human race, to flee to the wilderness and to solitude, and at the same time to abandon the duties the Lord has especially commanded. Even if we grant that there was nothing worse in that profession, it was still no small evil that it introduced a useless and dangerous example into the Church.
17. Why modern monastic vows cannot stand
Now let us look at the nature of the vows by which the monks of today are admitted to this famous order.
First, their intention is to set up a new and invented worship to win God's favour. From what I have said, I conclude that everything they vow is an abomination to God.
Second, they design their way of life to suit themselves, with no regard for God's calling or approval. The attempt is rash and unlawful, because their conscience has no ground on which to stand before God, and "whatever does not proceed from faith is sin" (Rom. 14:23).
Third, by binding themselves to many perverse and impious forms of worship, such as modern monasticism displays, they consecrate themselves not to God but to the devil. The prophets could say that the Israelites sacrificed their sons to demons and not to God (Deut. 32:17; Ps. 106:37), simply because they had corrupted the true worship of God with profane ceremonies. So why may we not say the same of monks who, along with the cowl, wrap themselves in the net of a thousand impious superstitions?
Then what is the content of their vows? They offer God a promise of perpetual virginity, as if they had made an agreement with him beforehand to free them from the need to marry. They cannot claim to make this vow trusting wholly in the grace of God. He declares this to be a special gift not given to everyone (Matt. 19:11), and nobody has a right to assume that the gift will be theirs. Let those who have it use it. If they ever feel the weakness of the flesh, let them turn for help to the one by whose power alone they can resist. If that does not work, let them not despise the remedy offered to them. If the ability to live single is denied them, God's voice plainly calls them to marry.
By self-control I mean not only keeping the body clean from sexual immorality but keeping the mind's purity untainted. Paul warns against outward lewdness and also against being "inflamed with passion" (1 Cor. 7:9).
They say it has been the practice from the earliest times for those who wished to give themselves wholly to God to bind themselves by a vow of continence. I admit the custom is ancient, but I do not admit that the age in which it began was so free from every fault that everything done then must be taken as a rule. Besides, the inflexible harshness of holding that once the vow is made there is no room for repentance crept in only gradually. Cyprian shows this: "If virgins have dedicated themselves to the faith of Christ, let them live modestly and chastely, without pretence. So strong and steady, let them wait for the reward of virginity. But if they will not or cannot persevere, it is better for them to marry than to fall into the fire by their sins." Today, with what abuse would they tear apart anyone who tried to temper the vow of continence in such a fair way! So those have wandered far from the ancient custom who not only show no moderation and grant no pardon when someone proves unequal to the vow, but shamelessly declare that it is a worse sin to cure the weakness of the flesh by marriage than to defile body and soul through whoring.
18. Widows in the apostolic Church
They still insist, and try to show, that this vow was in use in the apostles' days, because Paul says that widows who marry after having been enrolled for public service "have abandoned their former faith" (1 Tim. 5:12). I don't at all deny that widows who dedicated themselves and their labours to the Church also came under an obligation of lifelong celibacy. They did this not because they thought of it as a religious duty, as later became the case, but because they could not perform their duties without having their time at their own disposal and being free of the marriage tie. If, after giving their pledge, they began to think of a new marriage, what was that but to shake off God's calling? It is no surprise, then, that Paul says such desires make them "wanton against Christ."
He explains further that by not keeping their promises to the Church they break and cancel their first faith given in baptism. One of the things contained in that first faith is that everyone should fulfil their calling. Or, if you prefer, take it as meaning that having lost their modesty, they went on to cast off all care for decency, giving themselves over to every kind of wantonness and forwardness, living loose and undisciplined lives, than which nothing could be less fitting for Christian women. I am quite pleased with this interpretation.
Our answer, then, is this. The widows who were admitted to a public ministry came under an obligation of lifelong celibacy. So we easily see why, when they married, they threw off all modesty and became more insolent than Christian women should be. In this way they sinned not only by breaking the pledge given to the Church but by revolting against the common rule of godly women.
But I make three points. First, I deny that they had any other reason for professing celibacy than that marriage was entirely inconsistent with the duties they undertook. They bound themselves to celibacy only to the extent that the nature of their work required. Second, I do not accept that they were bound to celibacy in such a sense that it would not be better for them to marry than to be tormented by the urges of the flesh and fall into impurity. Third, I hold that what Paul commanded was safe in the ordinary case, because he ordered the choice to be made from women who were content with one marriage and had already proved their self-control. Our only reason for disapproving of the vow of celibacy is that it is wrongly treated as an act of worship and is rashly undertaken by people who do not have the power to keep it.
19. Deaconesses and nuns
What ground is there for applying this passage to nuns? The deaconesses were appointed not to placate God by chanting or unintelligible murmuring, and spend the rest of their time in idleness, but to perform a public ministry of the Church toward the poor and to labour with all zeal, persistence and diligence in works of charity. They did not vow celibacy so as to offer abstinence from marriage afterwards as a kind of worship to God, but only so that they might be freer of encumbrance in carrying out their work. Finally, they did not take the vow on reaching adolescence or in the bloom of youth, learning too late by experience over what a cliff they had thrown themselves. They took it when they were thought to have passed all danger, and so made a vow that was as safe as it was holy.
Setting aside the first two points, I say it was wrong to allow women to take a vow of continence before the age of sixty, since the apostle admits only such women and tells the younger ones to marry and have children (1 Tim. 5:9, 14). So it cannot be excused on any ground that the age was reduced first to twelve, then to twenty, and finally to thirty. Still less can we tolerate the case of wretched girls who, before they have reached an age at which they can know themselves or have any experience of their own character, are not only tricked but forced by pressure and threats into these accursed snares.
I will not argue at length against the other two vows (poverty and obedience). I say only that, besides involving no small amount of superstition as things now stand, they seem to be designed on purpose to make those who take them mock God and men. But so that we don't seem to attack every point in a spirit of malice, we will be content with the general refutation already given.
20. Do vows that were wrongly made still bind the conscience?
I think I have explained sufficiently what kind of vows are legitimate and acceptable to God. Yet some uninformed and timid consciences, even when they see a vow is displeasing and condemned, still hesitate about whether it binds them. They are grievously tormented, shuddering at the thought of breaking a pledge given to God and, on the other hand, afraid of sinning more by keeping it. We must come to their aid and help them out of this difficulty.
To remove all scruple at once, I say that all vows that are not legitimate and not properly made are worth nothing in God's sight and should be regarded by us as null. In human contracts, only those promises bind in which the person we contract with wishes us to be bound. It is absurd, then, to say we are bound to perform things God does not require of us at all, especially since our works can only be right when they please God and our consciences bear witness that they do. It always remains fixed that "whatever does not proceed from faith is sin" (Rom. 14:23). Paul means by this that any work undertaken in doubt is faulty, because at the root of all good works lies faith, which assures us they are acceptable to God.
So if Christians may not attempt anything without this assurance, why should they not be set free afterwards, and give up their error, if they undertook something rashly through ignorance? Vows made rashly are of exactly this kind. They not only do not bind, they must be cancelled. What then of vows that are not merely worthless in God's sight but are an abomination, as has been shown? It is unnecessary to go on arguing a point that doesn't need it.
To put godly consciences at rest and free them from all doubt, one argument seems to me enough. All works that do not flow from a pure source and are not directed to a proper end are rejected by God, and so completely rejected that he forbids us to continue them no less than to begin them. It follows that vows dictated by error and superstition carry no weight with God and ought to be abandoned by us.
21. Those who leave the monastic life
Whoever understands this solution has the means to answer the slanders of the wicked against those who leave monasticism for some honest way of earning a living. They are fiercely accused of perjury and breach of faith, because they have broken the bond, commonly supposed to be unbreakable, by which they had tied themselves to God and the Church.
My answer is, first, that there is no bond when God cancels what a human being confirms. Second, even granting that they were bound while they remained entangled in ignorance and error, now that they have been enlightened by the knowledge of the truth, they are at the same time free by the grace of Christ. If the cross of Christ is powerful enough to free us from the curse of God's law that held us bound, how much more must it rescue us from foreign chains that are nothing but the cunning nets of Satan? There can be no doubt that Christ frees everyone on whom he shines with the light of his gospel from all the snares in which they had tangled themselves through superstition.
They have a second defence as well, if they were unfit for celibacy. If an impossible vow is certain destruction to the soul, and God wills the soul to be saved and not destroyed, it follows that the vow must not be kept. We have shown how impossible the vow of continence is for those who have not received it as a special gift, and experience declares it even if I were silent. The great obscenity with which almost all monasteries teem is no secret. If some seem more decent and modest than others, they are still not chaste. The sin of unchastity presses on them and lurks within.
This is how God punishes by fearful examples the audacity of people who forget their weakness, reach against nature for what has been denied them, despise the remedies the Lord has put in their hands, and are confident they can overcome the disease of incontinence by stubborn obstinacy. For what else can we call it when someone, reminded of their need for marriage and of the remedy the Lord has provided in it, not only despises it but binds themselves by an oath to despise it?
Chapter 14
The Sacraments
1. What a sacrament is
Alongside the preaching of the gospel, we have another help for our faith in the sacraments. It matters a great deal that we have sound teaching about them, both about why they were instituted and about how they are to be used now. First we need to ask what a sacrament is. I think a simple and fitting definition is this: a sacrament is an outward sign by which the Lord seals his promises of goodwill toward us on our consciences, to support the weakness of our faith, and by which we in turn declare our devotion to him, before himself and also before angels and people. More briefly, we can call it a testimony of God's favour toward us, confirmed by an outward sign, with a matching declaration of our faith toward him. You can take your pick of these definitions. They mean the same as Augustine's, who called a sacrament a visible sign of a sacred thing, or the visible form of an invisible grace, though his is no better or surer. His brevity makes it a little obscure and misleads less educated readers, so I wanted to remove any doubt by saying it at greater length.
2. Why the word "sacrament"
The reason the early writers used this word is not hard to see. The old Latin translators rendered the Greek word mystery, especially when it concerned divine things, with the word sacramentum. So in Ephesians: "he made known to us the mystery of his will" (Eph. 1:9); "the administration of God's grace that was given to me for you, that the mystery was made known to me by revelation" (Eph. 3:2). In Colossians: "the mystery hidden for ages and generations but now revealed to his saints, to whom God chose to make known how great among the Gentiles are the riches of the glory of this mystery" (Col. 1:26-27). And in 1 Timothy: "Great indeed, we confess, is the mystery of godliness: he was manifested in the flesh" (1 Tim. 3:16). The translators didn't want to use the plain Latin word for "secret," since it seemed too small for something so great. When a thing was both sacred and hidden, they said sacramentum. Church writers often use it this way, and what Latin writers call sacraments, Greek writers call mysteries. The two words mean the same, which settles the matter. From there the word came to be applied to signs that give a solemn picture of spiritual and heavenly things. Augustine notes this: "It would take too long to discuss the variety of signs; those that concern divine things are called sacraments" (Letter 138).
3. Why God seals his promises with signs
From this definition we see that there is never a sacrament without a promise that comes first. The sacrament is added like an appendix, to confirm and seal the promise and to make it more certain. In this way God makes provision first for our ignorance and slowness, and then for our weakness. Strictly speaking, it doesn't confirm his word so much as establish us in faith in it. God's truth is steady and sure in itself and can't be made more certain by anything else. But our faith is small and feeble, and unless it is propped up on every side and supported in every way, it is shaken and tossed about, and wavers, and even falls. The sacrament cannot make God's promise more certain in itself, but it can make our trust in the promise more certain in us.
Here our merciful Lord stoops with astonishing kindness to our capacity. He sees that we are earthbound by nature, always crawling along the ground and clinging to the flesh, with no thought for what is spiritual and no ability even to imagine it. So he doesn't refuse to lead us to himself through earthly things, and to show us in the flesh a mirror of spiritual blessings. As Chrysostom says, "If we were without bodies, he would give us these things naked and bodiless. But because our souls are joined to bodies, he gives us spiritual things in visible ones. It isn't that the qualities set before us in the sacraments belong to the things themselves; God gives them this meaning."
4. The word that must accompany the sign
It is commonly said that a sacrament consists of the word and the outward sign. By "the word" we must not mean a formula muttered without meaning or faith, which is supposed to consecrate the element by its mere sound, like a magic spell. We mean the word that is preached, which makes us understand what the visible sign signifies. Under the Pope's tyranny the mystery was often profaned. It was thought enough for the priest to mumble the words of consecration while the people looked on without understanding. In fact it was done so that no teaching would reach them, since everything was said in Latin to people who couldn't read it. Superstition went so far that consecration was thought not to be done properly unless it was a low murmur few could hear.
Augustine teaches something very different about the sacramental word. "Let the word be added to the element, and it becomes a sacrament. For where does water get such power that it touches the body and cleanses the heart, except by the word? And not because it is spoken, but because it is believed. Even in the word, the passing sound is one thing and the abiding power another. 'This is the word of faith that we proclaim,' says the apostle" (Rom. 10:8). So Acts speaks of God "cleansing their hearts by faith" (Acts 15:9), and Peter says baptism "now saves you, not as a removal of dirt from the body but as an appeal to God for a good conscience" (1 Pet. 3:21). By this word, Augustine says, baptism too is consecrated so that it can cleanse. You can see that he requires preaching to produce faith.
We don't need to labour the point. No one can doubt what Christ did and commanded, what the apostles followed, or what a purer Church observed. From the beginning of the world, whenever God gave a sign to the patriarchs, it was bound inseparably to teaching. Without that teaching our senses would stare at an empty object. So when we hear about the sacramental word, we should understand the promise that the minister proclaims aloud, which takes the people by the hand and leads them to where the sign points.
5. The objection that the sign teaches nothing new
Some press a clever but weak dilemma against this. Either we know that the word preceding the sacrament is God's true will, or we don't. If we know it, we learn nothing new from the sacrament that follows. If we don't, we can't learn it from the sacrament, whose whole power depends on the word. My short answer is that the seals on charters and public documents are nothing in themselves, and would be pointless if nothing were written on the parchment. Yet that doesn't stop them from sealing and confirming what is written. This comparison isn't a recent invention of ours. Paul uses it himself when he calls circumcision a seal (Rom. 4:11). There he argues that Abraham's circumcision was not for his justification but was a confirmation of the covenant, by faith in which he had already been justified.
Why should anyone be upset when we teach that the promise is sealed by the sacrament, since the promises themselves show that one promise supports another? The clearer a piece of evidence is, the better it supports faith. Sacraments bring the clearest promises, and compared with the bare word they have this particular feature: they show the promises to us as if in a painted picture.
Nor should we be moved by the objection that a sacrament and a seal on a document are different, since sacraments are made of the physical stuff of this world, which can't seal God's spiritual and eternal promises, whereas a seal can certify a prince's decree about passing and fading things. A believer, when the sacraments are set before him, doesn't stop at the physical sight. By the steps of analogy I've described, he rises in devout meditation to the great mysteries hidden in the sacraments.
6. Why sacraments are signs of the covenant
The Lord calls his promises covenants (Gen. 6:18; 9:9; 17:2) and the sacraments signs of the covenants. We can see something similar in human agreements. What could the killing of a pig accomplish in making a treaty, unless words were spoken, or rather came first? Pigs are slaughtered all the time with no hidden meaning. What would it mean to clasp right hands, when hands are often joined in the middle of a fight? But when words have come first, then these symbols give a covenant its force, even though the agreement was already drafted, thought through and enacted in words.
So sacraments are exercises that strengthen our faith in God's word. Because we are physical, they are given to us in physical things, to train us by adapting to our slow capacity, as nurses lead little children by the hand. This is why Augustine calls a sacrament a visible word: it shows God's promises as in a picture, and sets them before our eyes in a form we can see. There are other comparisons that describe them well. They can be called pillars of our faith. A building rests on its foundation, yet stands more firmly when pillars hold it up; in the same way faith rests on the word of God as its proper foundation, and leans more firmly on it when the sacraments are added. Or we can call them mirrors, in which we look at the riches of the grace God gives us. There God shows himself to us as far as our dullness allows us to recognise him, and declares his love and kindness to us more plainly than words do.
7. The wicked receive the signs but not the grace
It is unreasonable to say that sacraments are not displays of God's grace toward us because they are also given to the ungodly, who don't find God any more favourable as a result and only bring greater condemnation on themselves. By that logic the gospel would be no display of God's grace, since many who hear it reject it, and Christ himself would be no display of grace, since of the many who saw and knew him very few received him. The seals on public documents are similar. Many people mock or dodge the royal seal, though they know the king used it to confirm his will. Others trample it as nothing to do with them, and others curse it. Since the two cases are alike, the comparison I made should be easier to accept.
So it is certain that the Lord offers us his mercy and a pledge of his grace, in his holy word and in the sacraments. But only those who receive the word and sacraments with firm faith grasp it, just as Christ, though offered for salvation to everyone, is not recognised and received by everyone. Augustine said this when he said the word has its effect in the sacrament not because it is spoken but because it is believed. So Paul, writing to believers, includes communion with Christ in the sacraments: "As many of you as were baptised into Christ have put on Christ" (Gal. 3:27), and "In one Spirit we were all baptised into one body" (1 Cor. 12:13). But when he speaks of people misusing the sacraments, he gives them no more weight than cold, empty figures. That tells us that however much the ungodly and hypocrites, by their perversity, may smother, obscure or block the effect of God's grace in the sacraments, that doesn't stop the sacraments, where and when God pleases, from giving true evidence of communion with Christ, or stop God's Spirit from doing exactly what they promise.
We conclude, then, that sacraments are rightly called evidence of God's grace, and seals, as it were, of his goodwill toward us. By sealing it to us, they sustain, nourish, strengthen and increase our faith.
8. Can faith be increased by the sacraments?
The usual objections to this are weak. Some say that if our faith is good it can't be made better, since faith is nothing less than resting firmly and wholeheartedly on God's mercy. They would do better to pray with the apostles, "Increase our faith!" (Luke 17:5) than to insist so confidently on a perfect faith that no one has ever reached in this life or ever will. Let them explain what kind of faith belonged to the man who said, "I believe; help my unbelief!" (Mark 9:24). His faith, though only beginning, was good, and could be made better by the removal of the unbelief. But the best refutation is their own conscience. If they admit they are sinners, which they cannot deny, they must put that down to the imperfection of their faith.
They also say that Philip told the eunuch who asked to be baptised, "If you believe with all your heart, you may" (Acts 8:37), and ask what room there is for baptism to confirm anything when faith fills the whole heart. I ask in turn whether they don't feel that a good part of their heart is empty of faith, and whether they don't see new gains every day. One man boasted that he grew old learning. We Christians would be thrice wretched if we grew old without making progress, since our faith should advance through every stage of life until we reach mature adulthood (Eph. 4:13). To believe "with all your heart" doesn't mean to believe perfectly. It means to embrace Christ sincerely with heart and soul, not to be filled with him but to hunger and thirst for him and long for him with burning love. Scripture often says a thing is done "with all the heart" when it is done sincerely: "With my whole heart I seek you" (Ps. 119:10). In the same way, when deceivers are rebuked, it says "they speak with flattering lips and a double heart" (Ps. 12:2).
They add that if faith grows through the sacraments, the Holy Spirit is given in vain, since it is his office to begin, sustain and complete our faith. I grant that faith is wholly the Holy Spirit's work. Enlightened by him we know God and the treasures of his grace, and without his light our minds are so blind they see nothing and so dull they have no taste for spiritual things. But where they speak of one divine blessing, we count three. First the Lord teaches and trains us by his word. Then he confirms us by his sacraments. Finally he lights up our minds by the light of his Holy Spirit, and opens our hearts to his word and sacraments, which would otherwise only strike our ears and fall before our eyes without touching us within.
9. The Spirit is the inner teacher; the sacraments are his ministry
So, regarding the increase and strengthening of faith, let me remind the reader of what I think I've already said plainly. In giving the sacraments this role, I don't mean that some secret power permanently lives in them, by which they can of themselves promote or strengthen faith. I mean that the Lord instituted them for the express purpose of helping to establish and increase our faith. The sacraments do their work properly only when the Spirit goes with them, the inner Teacher, whose power alone reaches the heart, stirs the affections and gives the sacraments access to our souls. If he is absent, the sacraments can do nothing for us, any more than the sun shining on blind eyes or sounds spoken into deaf ears. So in dividing the work between the Spirit and the sacraments, I give all the power to him and leave only a ministry to them. Without the Spirit's working that ministry is empty and pointless; when he works within and exerts his power, it is full of force.
Now it is clear how a godly mind is strengthened in faith by the sacraments. It happens in the way light is seen by the eye and a voice is heard by the ear. The eye wouldn't be affected by light unless it had a pupil for the light to fall on, and the ear wouldn't be reached by sound, however loud, unless it were made for hearing. If the eye's power of sight is what lets it see light, and the ear's power of hearing is what lets it perceive a voice, and in our hearts it is the Holy Spirit's work to begin, maintain, nourish and establish faith, then two things follow. The sacraments do not help us one bit without the Holy Spirit's power. And yet in hearts already taught by that Teacher, nothing prevents the sacraments from strengthening and increasing faith. The only difference is that sight and hearing are planted in eye and ear by nature, whereas Christ works in our minds above nature, by special grace.
10. How the Spirit uses the sacraments: an illustration
This also answers an objection that troubles some anxious people: that if we credit created things with increasing or confirming faith, we do the Spirit of God an injustice, since he alone is its author. But we don't rob him of the credit for strengthening and increasing faith. What strengthens and increases faith is nothing other than his preparing our minds, by his inner light, to receive the confirmation the sacraments offer.
If this is still unclear, an illustration may help. Suppose you set out to persuade someone to do something. You would think of every argument that might win him over and, in a way, compel him to serve your purpose. But you gain nothing if he doesn't have a clear and sharp judgment to weigh your arguments, or isn't teachable and ready to listen, or doesn't think so well of your honesty and good sense that he's already disposed in your favour. Many stubborn people can't be moved by any argument, and where trust is lacking or authority is despised, little progress is made even with the teachable. On the other hand, where the opposite attitudes are present, the person will go along with the very advice he would otherwise have laughed at.
The Spirit does the same work in us. So that the word doesn't fall on our ears, and the sacraments aren't set before our eyes, in vain, he shows that it is God who speaks to us there. He softens our stubborn hearts and shapes them to obey his word. In short, he carries those outward words and sacraments from the ear into the soul. So both word and sacraments confirm our faith, putting before us our heavenly Father's kind intentions, in knowing which the whole assurance of our faith rests and its strength grows. And the Spirit also confirms our faith, by engraving that assurance on our minds and making it effective. Meanwhile it is easy for the Father of lights, who lights up the bodily eye by the rays of the sun, to light up our minds through the sacraments, as through a kind of intermediate brightness.
11. The same is true of the preached word
The Lord showed that this holds for the outward word when he compared it to seed in the parable (Matt. 13:4; Luke 8:15). Seed that falls on neglected ground can only die, but thrown into well-worked soil it yields a hundredfold. In the same way God's word addressed to a stubborn heart stays fruitless, like seed on barren waste, but when it meets a soul that the heavenly Spirit has subdued, it is most fruitful. And if the seed and the word are alike, and corn can grow from seed and increase and ripen, why can't faith likewise begin, grow and be completed through the word?
Paul explains both sides well in different places. Reminding the Corinthians how God gave effect to his labours, he boasts of having "the demonstration of the Spirit and of power" (1 Cor. 2:4), as if his preaching were inseparably joined to the Holy Spirit's power in enlightening and stirring the mind within. In another place, where he reminds them what the word does in itself when preached by a man, he compares ministers to farmers, who after all their labour and care have nothing more they can do. What would ploughing, sowing and watering accomplish unless heaven made the seed grow? So he concludes that "neither he who plants nor he who waters is anything, but only God who gives the growth" (1 Cor. 3:7). The apostles used the Spirit's power in their preaching because God used them as instruments he had appointed for unfolding his spiritual grace. But we must keep the distinction in view, and remember what a person can do by himself and what belongs to God alone.
12. God sometimes removes the sign; the glory still belongs to God alone
Sacraments confirm our faith in such a way that the Lord, when he wants to withdraw our assurance of what he promised in them, sometimes takes the sacraments themselves away. When God deprived Adam of the gift of immortality and drove him out of the garden, it was "lest he reach out his hand and take also of the tree of life and eat, and live forever" (Gen. 3:22). What does this mean? Could that fruit have restored the immortality Adam had already lost? Not at all. It is as if God said: let him not be lulled into false confidence by keeping the symbol of my promise; let what might give him some hope of immortality be taken away. In the same way, when Paul urges the Ephesians to remember that they were "separated from Christ, alienated from the commonwealth of Israel and strangers to the covenants of promise, having no hope and without God in the world" (Eph. 2:12), he says they had no share in circumcision. He is saying, by a figure of speech, that everyone who lacked the sign of the promise was excluded from the promise.
To the other objection, that attributing so much power to created things gives them God's glory and so diminishes it, the answer is plain: we attribute no power to the created things. All we say is that God uses whatever means and instruments he sees fit, so that everything serves his glory, since he is Lord and ruler of all. He feeds our bodies with bread and other food, lights the world by the sun and warms it by fire, yet bread, sun and fire are nothing except as instruments through which he gives us his blessings. In the same way he nourishes our faith spiritually through the sacraments, whose only task is to put his promises before our eyes, or rather to be pledges of those promises.
As we should put no confidence in the other creatures that God's kindness has appointed for our use, and through which he sends us his gifts, nor admire them or praise them as the causes of our blessings, so our confidence should not be fixed on the sacraments, nor should God's glory be transferred to them. Passing beyond all of them, our faith and confession should rise to him who is the author of the sacraments and of all things.
13. The word "sacrament" and the soldier's oath
Some make an argument from the word "sacrament" itself. They say it has many meanings in good Latin authors, but only one that fits signs: the oath a soldier swore to his commander when he enlisted. As recruits bound themselves to their commander by that oath and professed military service, so by our signs we acknowledge Christ as our commander and declare that we serve under his banner. They add comparisons: the toga marked Romans off from Greeks, who wore the cloak, and the senator was distinguished from the knight by purple and crescent shoes, and the knight from the common man by a ring. So we wear our symbols to distinguish ourselves from the unbelieving.
But what I've already said shows that the early writers, in calling signs sacraments, weren't attending to how Latin authors used the word. For convenience they gave it a new sense, as a way of simply saying "sacred signs." Even if we wanted to argue subtly, we could say they used it in a way parallel to the word "faith." Faith properly means truthfulness in keeping promises, but they have used it for the certainty or firm conviction of that truth. Likewise a sacrament, which is the soldier's act in vowing obedience, they made the act by which the commander admits soldiers to the ranks. For in the sacraments the Lord promises to be our God, and we promise to be his people. But I'll leave these subtleties aside. I think I've shown plainly enough that all the ancient writers meant was that sacraments are signs of sacred and spiritual things.
As for the comparisons drawn from outward uniforms, we accept them but don't approve of making what is secondary in the sacraments the first and only thing. The first purpose is that they serve our faith in God. The second is that they back up our confession before others. These comparisons fit only the second. Let this be a fixed point, then: sacraments would be cold and lifeless, as we've seen, if they were not aids to our faith, and additions to the teaching for the same end and purpose.
14. The opposite error: a hidden power in the sacraments
Just as these objectors weaken the sacraments and overthrow their use, there are others who give them a kind of secret power that Scripture never says God put in them. The simple and unwary are dangerously deceived by this error, since they are taught to look for God's gifts where they can't possibly be found, and are quietly drawn away from God to embrace empty things in place of his truth. The schools of the Sophists have taught with general agreement that the sacraments of the new law, that is, those now used in the Christian Church, justify and confer grace, provided we don't put the obstacle of mortal sin in the way.
It is impossible to say how deadly this idea is, all the more because for many centuries, to the Church's great harm, it has prevailed across much of the world. It is plainly from the devil. First, by promising righteousness without faith, it drives souls headlong to destruction. Second, by finding a cause of righteousness in the sacraments, it entangles wretched minds, already inclined to the earth, in a superstition that makes them rest in the sight of a physical thing rather than in God himself. I wish we didn't have such experience of both evils, so that a long proof wasn't needed. For what is a sacrament received without faith but certain ruin for the Church? Nothing is to be expected beyond the promise, and the promise threatens wrath to the unbeliever just as it offers grace to the believer. So it is an error to suppose that the sacraments give anything more than what God's word offers and true faith receives.
Another consequence follows: assurance of salvation doesn't depend on taking part in the sacraments, as if justification consisted in that. Justification is stored up in Christ alone. We know it is communicated no less by the preaching of the gospel than by the seal of the sacrament, and can be fully enjoyed without that seal. Augustine is right that there can be invisible sanctification without a visible sign, and a visible sign without true sanctification. As he says elsewhere, "People put on Christ sometimes to the extent of sharing in the sacrament, and sometimes to the extent of holiness of life." The first can be shared by the good and the bad; the second belongs only to the good.
15. The sacrament and the reality it signifies
Here is the point of the distinction Augustine so often makes, if it is rightly understood, between the sacrament and the matter of the sacrament. He doesn't merely mean that the figure and the truth are both contained in it. He means that they aren't so joined that they can't be separated, and that we must always distinguish the thing from the sign, so as not to transfer to one what belongs to the other. (Sometimes the distinction is put in terms of the outward form of administration, meaning the words of institution, the consecration of the elements and their distribution, on one side, and their spiritual meaning and worth on the other. The grace of the sacraments lies not in the act or its form but in the word received by faith.)
Augustine speaks of the separation when he says that only in the elect do the sacraments accomplish what they picture. Of the Jews he says, "Though the sacraments were common to all, the grace was not common; yet grace is the power of the sacraments. So too the washing of regeneration is now common to all, but the grace by which Christ's members are born again with their Head is not common to all." Of the Lord's Supper he says, "Today we too receive visible food, but the sacrament is one thing, the power of the sacrament another. Why do many take part at the altar and die, and die by taking part? Even the Lord's cup was poison to Judas, not because he received something evil, but because, being wicked, he wickedly received something good." A little later: "The sacrament of this, that is, of the unity of the body and blood of Christ, is prepared daily in some places, and at intervals in others, at the Lord's table, and is taken by some to life and by others to destruction. But the thing itself, of which it is the sacrament, is life to everyone and destruction to none who shares in it." And before that he said, "The one who has eaten shall not die, but he must be one who has reached the power of the sacrament, not only the visible sacrament; who eats inwardly, not only outwardly; who eats with the heart, not with the teeth."
Here you are consistently told that a sacrament is so cut off from the reality by the unworthiness of the person receiving it that nothing remains but an empty and useless figure. If you want not a sign without truth but the thing together with the sign, the word included in it must be grasped by faith. You will benefit from the sacraments exactly to the degree that you profit by them in communion with Christ.
16. Christ is the substance of every sacrament
If this is unclear because it is so brief, let me explain at more length. I say that Christ is the matter, or if you prefer, the substance, of all the sacraments. In him they have all their solidity, and apart from him they promise nothing. That is why Peter Lombard's error deserves even less patience, since he plainly makes the sacraments causes of the righteousness and salvation of which they are only parts. Saying goodbye to every other cause of righteousness that human ingenuity devises, our duty is to hold to this one alone. As far as the sacraments help us to cherish, strengthen and increase the true knowledge of Christ, so that we possess him more fully and enjoy him in all his riches, they are effective for us. This happens when what is offered there is received by us in true faith.
You will ask whether the wicked, by their ingratitude, make God's ordinance fruitless and void. My answer is that I'm not saying the power and truth of the sacrament depend on the condition or choice of the one who receives it. What God instituted stays firm and keeps its nature, however people vary. But since offering is one thing and receiving another, nothing prevents a symbol, consecrated by the Lord's word, from being truly what it is said to be and keeping its power, even though it does the wicked and ungodly no good. Augustine settles this well in a few words: "If you receive it carnally, it doesn't cease to be spiritual, but it is not spiritual to you."
As Augustine shows in those passages that a sacrament is worthless if separated from its truth, so he also reminds us that even when the two are joined we must distinguish them, so that we don't cling too much to the outward sign. "To follow the sign and take signs for the thing signified is a slavish weakness; but to interpret signs as useless is a wild error." He names two faults to avoid. One is receiving the signs as if they had been given in vain, and so, by spitefully destroying or weakening their hidden meanings, keeping them from bearing fruit. The other is failing to raise our minds above the visible sign, and so attributing to it blessings that come to us from Christ alone, through the Holy Spirit who makes us sharers in Christ. External signs help if they invite us to Christ; if they are twisted to any other purpose, all their usefulness is lost.
17. Summary: the sacraments do what the word does
Let it be settled, then, that the sacraments have the same office as the word of God, which is to hold out and offer Christ to us, and in him the treasures of heavenly grace. They give nothing and are worth nothing if they are not received in faith, just as wine or oil or any other liquid, however much you pour, runs away and is lost unless there is an open vessel to receive it. If the vessel isn't open, it stays quite empty even though it is splashed all over.
We must also take care not to fall into a similar error through the rather extravagant language the early Christian writers used in praising the dignity of the sacraments. We must not think some hidden power lives in the sacraments by which they of themselves give us the gifts of the Holy Spirit, as wine is drunk from a cup. The only office God has given them is to attest and ratify the Lord's goodwill toward us, and they avail no further than as the Holy Spirit goes with them to open our minds and hearts and make us able to receive this testimony. In it, various and splendid graces are plainly shown. As we noted earlier (Book 4, chapter 13, section 6, and chapter 14, sections 6 and 7), sacraments are to us what messengers of good news are to people, or what deposits are in ratifying agreements. They don't themselves bestow any grace, but they announce and display it, and like deposits and badges they confirm the gifts God in his generosity has given us. The Holy Spirit, whom the sacraments do not bring indiscriminately to all, but whom the Lord specially gives to his people, brings God's gifts with him, makes room for the sacraments and makes them bear fruit.
We don't deny that God, by the immediate working of his Spirit, supports his own ordinance, so that the administration of the sacraments he instituted is not fruitless and empty. Still, we hold that the inner grace of the Spirit, as distinct from the outward ministration, must be seen and considered separately. God truly performs whatever he promises and pictures by signs.
The signs are not empty, because they prove that he is their true and faithful author. The only question is whether the Lord works by a power proper and inherent in the signs, as the schools put it, or hands his office over to outward symbols. We hold that whatever instruments he uses take nothing away from his own primary working. On this teaching, the dignity of the sacraments is highly honoured, their use is plainly shown, their usefulness is sufficiently declared, and moderation is kept in everything. Nothing is attributed to them that shouldn't be, and nothing is denied them that they should have. At the same time we are rid of the fiction that makes the elements into vessels and carriers of the cause of justification and the power of the Holy Spirit, and the true power, which had been overlooked, is clearly explained.
We should also notice that what the minister pictures and attests by outward action, God performs inwardly, so that what God claims for himself alone is not ascribed to a mortal. Augustine is careful about this: "How do both God and Moses sanctify? Not Moses in place of God, but Moses through visible sacraments by his ministry, God by invisible grace through the Holy Spirit. In this is the whole fruit of the visible sacraments. For what do these visible sacraments profit without the sanctification of invisible grace?"
18. Signs in nature and in miracles
The word "sacrament," in the sense we've used so far, covers in general all the signs God has ever commanded people to use, to make them sure and confident of the truth of his promises. Sometimes he placed these in natural things, and sometimes he displayed them in miracles. An example of the first is the tree of life, which he gave to Adam and Eve as a pledge of immortality so that they could be confident of the promise whenever they ate its fruit. Another is the rainbow he gave to Noah and his descendants as a reminder that he would never again destroy the earth by a flood. These were sacraments for Adam and Noah. It wasn't that the tree could give Adam and Eve an immortality it couldn't give itself, or that the bow, which is only the sun's rays reflected on the cloud opposite, could hold back the waters. But they had been marked by God's word, to be proofs and seals of his covenant. The tree was a tree before, and the bow was a bow. But once they were inscribed with God's word, they were given a new form and began to be what they had not been.
Lest anyone think this was said in vain, the rainbow is still a witness to us today of the covenant God made with Noah. Every time we look at it, we read God's promise that the earth will never again be destroyed by a flood. If some pseudo-philosopher wants to mock the simplicity of our faith by arguing that the colours arise naturally from the sun's rays reflected off the opposite cloud, let us grant the fact. But let us also laugh at his stupidity in failing to see God as the Lord and ruler of nature, who makes all the elements serve his glory as he pleases. If God had stamped memorials like this on the sun, the stars, the earth or stones, they would all have been sacraments to us. Why is an unshaped lump of silver not worth the same as coined silver, when it is the same metal? Only because the lump has nothing but its own nature, while the coin, stamped with the public mark, becomes money and receives a new value. Will the Lord not be able to stamp his creatures with his word, so that bare elements become sacraments?
Examples of the second kind are these: he showed Abraham a light in the smoking furnace (Gen. 15:17); he covered the fleece with dew while the ground was dry, and then the ground with dew while the fleece stayed dry, to assure Gideon of victory (Judg. 6:37-40); he made the shadow go back ten steps on the stairway to assure Hezekiah of his recovery (2 Kings 20:9-11; Isa. 38:7). These things were done to help and establish their faith, and so they were sacraments too.
19. The ordinary sacraments of the Church
My purpose now is to speak especially of the sacraments the Lord chose to institute as ordinary sacraments in his Church, to bring up his worshippers and servants in one faith and one confession of faith. Augustine says, "In any religious name, true or false, people cannot be brought together unless they are united by some shared use of visible signs or sacraments." Our most merciful Father foresaw this need, and from the very beginning appointed certain exercises of devotion for his servants. Satan later transferred these to ungodly and superstitious worship and corrupted them in many ways. That is the origin of the initiations into mysteries among the pagans and their other degenerate rites. Full of error and superstition as they were, they still show that people can't do without outward signs of religion. But because they were not founded on God's word, and did not point to the truth that every sign ought to hold out, they are not worth mentioning alongside the sacred symbols God instituted, which have not been turned from their purpose, which is to help true godliness. And these consist not of simple signs like the rainbow and the tree of life, but of ceremonies, or if you like, the signs used here are ceremonies.
As we've said, they are testimonies of grace and salvation from the Lord. For our part, they are also marks of profession, by which we openly swear by God's name and bind ourselves to be faithful to him. Chrysostom shrewdly calls them agreements, by which God enters into covenant with us and we become bound to holiness and purity of life, since each side makes a pledge to the other. God there promises to cover and wipe out any guilt and penalty we have incurred by our transgressions, and reconciles us to himself in his only begotten Son. We in turn, by this profession, commit ourselves to the pursuit of godliness and righteousness. So it can fairly be said that these sacraments are ceremonies by which God chooses to train his people: first, to stir up, nourish and strengthen faith within, and second, to testify to our religion before others.
20. The sacraments of the old and new covenants
These have been different at different times, according to the way the Lord has seen fit to reveal himself. Circumcision was commanded to Abraham and his descendants, and later purifications, sacrifices and the other rites of the law of Moses were added. These were the sacraments of the Jews until Christ came. When they were set aside, the two sacraments the Christian Church now uses, baptism and the Lord's Supper, were instituted. I mean the ones instituted for the use of the whole Church. The laying on of hands, by which ministers of the Church are admitted to their office, I don't object to calling a sacrament, but I don't count it among the ordinary sacraments. We will see shortly what place the other so-called sacraments should have.
The ancient sacraments had the same aim as ours: to direct us to Christ and almost lead us by the hand to him, or rather, like images, to represent him and make him known to us. As we've shown that sacraments are a kind of seal on God's promises, we should hold it as most certain that no divine promise has ever been offered to anyone except in Christ. So when the sacraments remind us of any divine promise, they must of necessity show us Christ. That is the meaning of the heavenly pattern of the tabernacle and its worship, which was shown to Moses on the mountain. The only difference is that the old sacraments foreshadowed a promised Christ while he was still awaited, whereas ours bear witness to him as already come and revealed.
21. What the old sacraments taught about Christ
When these are explained one by one, they become much clearer. Circumcision was a sign reminding the Jews that whatever comes from human seed, that is, human nature as a whole, is corrupt and needs to be cut away. It was also a proof and memorial confirming them in the promise made to Abraham of a seed in whom all the nations of the earth would be blessed, and from whom they themselves were to look for blessing. That saving seed, as Paul teaches (Gal. 3:16), was Christ, in whom alone they trusted to recover what they had lost in Adam. So circumcision was for them what Paul says it was for Abraham, a sign of the righteousness of faith (Rom. 4:11), a seal by which they were more certainly assured that their faith in waiting for the Lord would be counted to them as righteousness. We will have a better opportunity to follow out the comparison between circumcision and baptism later (Book 4, chapter 16, sections 3 and 4).
Their washings and purifications set before their eyes the uncleanness, defilement and pollution that contaminated them by nature, and promised another washing in which all their impurities could be wiped and washed away. That washing was Christ. Washed by his blood, we bring his purity before God's sight, so that he covers all our defilements. The sacrifices convicted them of their unrighteousness, and at the same time taught that some satisfaction had to be paid to God's justice. So there had to be some high priest, some mediator between God and humanity, to satisfy God by shedding blood and offering a victim sufficient for the forgiveness of sins. The high priest was Christ. He shed his own blood and was himself the victim. In obedience to the Father he offered himself to death, and by that obedience wiped out the disobedience by which humanity had provoked God's anger (Phil. 2:8; Rom. 5:19).
22. What our sacraments add
Our sacraments set Christ before us more clearly, the more familiarly he has been revealed to people since the Father truly displayed him, as he had promised. Baptism testifies that we are washed and purified; the Supper of the Eucharist, that we are redeemed. Washing is pictured by water, satisfaction by blood. Both are found in Christ, who, as John says, "came by water and blood" (1 John 5:6), that is, to cleanse and to redeem. The Spirit of God is also a witness to this. Indeed there are three witnesses in agreement: the water, the Spirit and the blood. In the water and the blood we have evidence of cleansing and redemption, but the Spirit is the chief witness, who gives us full assurance of the testimony. This great mystery was displayed in splendour on Christ's cross, when water and blood flowed from his side (John 19:34). For that reason Augustine rightly called it the fountain of our sacraments. We will say more about these shortly.
There is no doubt that, comparing one age with another, the grace of the Spirit is now displayed more abundantly. This is part of the glory of Christ's kingdom, as we gather from several passages, especially John 7. This is how we should understand Paul's words that the law was "a shadow of the good things to come" while "the substance belongs to Christ" (Col. 2:17; Heb. 10:1). His purpose is not to say that the signs of grace by which God proved his truth to the patriarchs were ineffective, since he proves it to us today in baptism and the Lord's Supper. His purpose is to contrast the two and show how great is what has been given to us, so that no one should find it strange that Christ's coming did away with the ceremonies of the law.
23. Against the claim that the old sacraments only foreshadowed
The scholastic teaching I should mention in passing makes the difference between the sacraments of the old and new covenants so great that the former only foreshadowed God's grace while the latter actually confer it. It must be thrown out completely. The apostle speaks no more highly of one than of the other when he says that the fathers ate the same spiritual food, and explains that this food was Christ (1 Cor. 10:3). Who will dare to call an empty sign something that gave the Jews a real communion with Christ?
The context of Paul's argument strongly supports our view. He wants to guard us against trusting a cold knowledge of Christ, an empty Christian label and outward observances, and so daring to despise God's judgment. So he gives striking examples of God's severity against the Jews, to warn us that if we indulge in the same vices, the same punishments hang over us. For the comparison to work, he had to show that there is no inequality between us and them in those blessings we are forbidden to boast about. So he first makes them equal to us in the sacraments, and leaves us not one scrap of privilege that could give us hope of escaping punishment. We also cannot attribute more to our baptism than he attributes elsewhere to circumcision, when he calls it a seal of the righteousness of faith (Rom. 4:11). Whatever is now shown to us in the sacraments, the Jews received in theirs: Christ, with his spiritual riches. They experienced the same power in theirs that ours have, namely that they were seals of God's favour toward them for the hope of eternal salvation.
If the opponents had been sound interpreters of the letter to the Hebrews, they wouldn't have been so deceived. But reading there that sins were not atoned for by the ceremonies of the law, and that the old shadows had no importance for justification, they overlooked the contrast being drawn. They fastened on the single point that the law in itself did nothing for the worshipper, and decided that the ceremonies were mere figures without truth. The writer's purpose is to show that the ceremonial law has nothing in it until we come to Christ, on whom alone all its power depends.
24. Does Paul belittle circumcision?
They will build on what Paul says about the circumcision of the letter (Rom. 2:25-29; 1 Cor. 7:19; Gal. 6:15). They object that it counts for nothing with God, gives nothing and is empty, and that such passages seem to rank it far below our baptism. Not at all. The very same could rightly be said of baptism, and it is said: first by Paul himself, when he shows that God pays no attention to the outward washing by which we are admitted into religion unless the mind is cleansed within and keeps its purity to the end; and second by Peter, when he says that the reality of baptism lies not in the outward washing but in the testimony of a good conscience (1 Pet. 3:21).
But in another place Paul seems to speak with the greatest contempt of circumcision made with hands, when he contrasts it with the circumcision made by Christ (Col. 2:11). My answer is that even there nothing detracts from its dignity. Paul is arguing against people who insisted on it as necessary after it had been abolished. So he urges believers to lay aside the ancient shadows and hold to the truth. These teachers, he says, insist that your bodies be circumcised, but you have been circumcised spiritually in soul and body. So you have the reality, which is far better than the shadow. Someone could still have answered that the figure should not be despised just because they had the reality, since the believers of old also experienced the putting off of the old self he was speaking of, and for them outward circumcision was not superfluous. Paul anticipates this objection by adding at once that the Colossians were buried with Christ in baptism. That shows that baptism is now for Christians what circumcision was for the ancients, and that circumcision could not be imposed on Christians without wronging baptism.
25. The shadows of the law in Colossians and Hebrews
It is harder to explain the passage that follows, which I quoted a moment ago: that all the Jewish ceremonies were shadows of things to come, but the substance is of Christ (Col. 2:17). The hardest point of all is the one discussed in several chapters of Hebrews: that the blood of animals did not reach the conscience, that the law had "only a shadow of the good things to come, instead of the true form of these realities" (Heb. 10:1), that worshippers under the Mosaic ceremonies attained no degree of perfection, and so on.
I repeat what I've already hinted. Paul does not call the ceremonies shadowy because there was nothing solid in them, but because their fulfilment was in a way held in suspense until Christ was revealed. And the words should be understood as speaking not of their effectiveness but of their manner of signifying. Until Christ appeared in the flesh, all signs showed him as absent, though he exerted the presence of his power, and so of his person, on believers inwardly.
But the most important observation is that in all these passages Paul isn't speaking in the abstract but by way of reply. He was contending with false apostles who held that godliness consisted in mere ceremonies with no reference to Christ. To refute them it was enough to consider what ceremonies accomplish in themselves. The author of Hebrews has the same aim. So let us remember that he is treating ceremonies not in their true and natural meaning, but when they are twisted into a false and corrupt one; not their lawful use, but their superstitious abuse. Is it surprising that ceremonies cut off from Christ have no power? All signs become empty when the thing signified is taken away. In the same way, when Christ spoke to those who thought manna was merely food for the body, he adapted his words to their crude idea and said he supplied a better food, one that fed souls for immortality.
If you want a clearer solution, the substance is this. First, the whole apparatus of ceremonies under the law of Moses, unless directed to Christ, is vanishing and empty. Second, the ceremonies looked to Christ in such a way that they were fulfilled only when he appeared in the flesh. Finally, at his coming they had to disappear, as a shadow vanishes in the clear light of the sun. I touch on this briefly now, because I will come back to it when I compare baptism with circumcision.
26. Reading Augustine and the early writers on the old and new sacraments
Those unfortunate sophists are perhaps misled by the extravagant praises of our signs in the ancient writers, for example this passage of Augustine: "The sacraments of the old law only promised a Saviour, whereas ours give salvation." They don't see that these and similar expressions are exaggerations, and so they have built exaggerated doctrines on them, in a sense quite foreign to the ancient writers. Augustine means nothing more than in another place, where he says, "The sacraments of the law of Moses foretold Christ; ours announce him." And again, "Those were promises of things to be fulfilled; these are signs that they have been fulfilled." As if he had said: those pictured him while he was still awaited, ours show him as present now that he has come. And about the manner of signifying he says, "The Law and the Prophets had sacraments that foretold something to come; the sacraments of our time attest that what they foretold as coming has come."
He explains what he thinks about the reality and the power in several passages: "The sacraments of the Jews were different in their signs but alike in what they signified; different in visible appearance, alike in spiritual power." Again: "In different signs there was the same faith. It was with signs as with words: words change their sound with the times, yet words are nothing but signs. The fathers drank the same spiritual drink, but not the same bodily drink. See, then, how, while faith remains, the signs vary. There the rock was Christ; to us, what is placed on the altar is Christ. They drank, as a great sacrament, the water flowing from the rock; believers know what we drink. If you look at the visible appearance, there was a difference; if at the meaning understood, they drank the same spiritual drink." And again: "In this mystery their food and drink are the same as ours, the same in meaning, though not in form, for the same Christ was pictured to them in the rock, and has been revealed to us in the flesh."
We grant that there is some difference here too. Both testify that God's fatherly kindness and the graces of the Spirit are offered to us in Christ, but ours do so more clearly and splendidly. In both Christ is shown, but in ours more fully and completely, in line with the distinction between the Old and New Testaments I discussed earlier. That is the meaning of Augustine, whom I quote more often as the best and most faithful witness of all antiquity, when he says that after Christ was revealed, sacraments were instituted that were fewer in number, but of more majestic meaning and more excellent power.
Here the reader should be reminded that all the Sophists' idle talk about opus operatum, the idea that the sacrament works by the mere performing of the act, is not only false but contrary to the very nature of sacraments. God appointed them so that believers, who are empty and lacking in every good, would bring nothing of their own but simply beg. It follows that in receiving them they do nothing worthy of praise, and that in this action, which on their side is purely passive, no work can be credited to them.
Chapter 15
Baptism
1. Baptism is the sign of admission, and its first purpose is to assure us of cleansing
Baptism is the sign of entry by which we are admitted into the fellowship of the church, so that, grafted into Christ, we may be counted God's children. God gave it for the two purposes I have already said belong to all the sacraments: first, to serve our faith in him, and second, to serve as a confession before other people. I will explain each in turn. Baptism helps our faith in three ways, and each needs separate treatment.
The first purpose for which the Lord appointed it is to be a sign and evidence of our cleansing. Or, to put it better, it is a sealed document in which he assures us that all our sins are so deleted, covered and wiped out that they will never come into his sight, never be mentioned, never be counted against us. He wills that all who believe be baptised for the forgiveness of sins. So those who have thought baptism is nothing more than a badge by which we profess our religion before people, as soldiers wear their commander's insignia to show whose army they belong to, have missed the main thing. The main thing is that we receive it together with the promise: "Whoever believes and is baptised will be saved" (Mark 16:16).
2. Water does not cleanse us, but the sign points us to the blood of Christ
This is how we should understand Paul's words that "Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her, that he might sanctify her, having cleansed her by the washing of water with the word" (Eph. 5:25-26), and again, "not because of works done by us in righteousness, but according to his own mercy, he saved us, by the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit" (Titus 3:5). Peter likewise says, "Baptism, which corresponds to this, now saves you" (1 Pet. 3:21). None of them means that our cleansing and salvation are accomplished by water, or that water has in itself the power to purify, regenerate and renew. Nor do they make water the cause of salvation. They mean only that in this sacrament we come to know and be sure of these gifts. The words themselves make this plain. Paul joins the word of life and the baptism of water together, as if to say: the gospel announces the message of our cleansing and sanctification, and baptism seals that message. Peter adds at once that this baptism is "not the removal of dirt from the body, but an appeal to God for a good conscience" (1 Pet. 3:21).
In fact the only cleansing baptism promises is through the sprinkling of Christ's blood, who is represented by water because water cleans and washes. Who, then, could say that we are cleansed by water, when water itself testifies that Christ's blood is our true and only washing? We could have no better answer to people who credit everything to the power of the water than the very meaning of baptism. It leads us away from the visible element before our eyes, and away from every other means, so that we fix our minds on Christ alone.
3. Baptism cleanses us once for the whole of life
We must not think baptism is given only for the past, so that for sins we fall into afterwards we have to look for new remedies in other so-called sacraments, as though the power of baptism had run out. This mistake led some in ancient times to refuse baptism until they were close to death and drawing their last breath, so that they could be pardoned for all their past in one stroke. The early bishops often wrote against this perverse precaution.
We should hold that whenever we are baptised, we are washed and cleansed once for our whole life. So whenever we fall, we should call our baptism to mind and strengthen our hearts with it, so that we may be sure and unafraid of the forgiveness of our sins. Baptism may seem to belong to the past once it has been administered, but later sins do not cancel it. The purity of Christ was offered to us in it, and that purity is always in force. No stain destroys it, and it washes away all our defilements.
None of this gives us licence to sin in future; nothing in it supports such audacity. This teaching is meant only for people who have sinned and groan under the weight of their sins, so that they have something to support and console them and do not rush headlong into despair. In the same sense Paul says that Christ was put forward as a propitiation "in his divine forbearance he had passed over former sins" (Rom. 3:25). He does not deny that constant and lifelong forgiveness comes through him. He only shows that it is intended by the Father for poor sinners who are wounded by remorse and long for the physician. To them God's mercy is offered. Those who count on getting away with it and treat grace as licence only provoke God's anger and justice.
4. Penance and the keys do not replace baptism
I know it is a common belief that the forgiveness we receive in baptism at our first regeneration is, after baptism, obtained through penance and the power of the keys (see Book 4, chapter 19, section 17). But people who think this overlook that the power of the keys depends so completely on baptism that it must never be separated from it. The sinner receives forgiveness through the church's ministry, which means through the preaching of the gospel. And what does that preaching say? That we are washed from our sins by the blood of Christ. And what is the sign and evidence of that washing, if not baptism? So that forgiveness refers back to baptism.
This error came from the invented sacrament of penance, which I have already touched on, and the rest will be said in its proper place. It is no surprise that people so attached to outward things, because their minds are coarse, show their weakness here too. They were not content with God's pure institution, and they brought in new aids of their own devising, as if baptism were not itself a sacrament of repentance. But if repentance is commended for the whole of life, the power of baptism must reach just as far. So there is no doubt that all the godly can, throughout their lives, whenever their consciences trouble them over their sins, call their baptism to mind and so reassure themselves of that single, lasting washing we have in Christ's blood.
5. The second benefit: baptism shows our dying and rising with Christ
The second benefit of baptism is that it shows us our death to sin in Christ and our new life in him. "Do you not know that all of us who have been baptised into Christ Jesus were baptised into his death? We were buried therefore with him by baptism into death, in order that... we too might walk in newness of life" (Rom. 6:3-4). Paul is not only urging us to imitate Christ, as if baptism reminded us that, as Christ died, we should die to our desires, and as he rose, we should rise to righteousness. He goes much deeper. He teaches that by baptism Christ makes us share in his death, grafting us into it. A branch draws substance and nourishment from the root it is joined to, and in the same way those who receive baptism with true faith truly feel the power of Christ's death in putting their flesh to death, and the power of his resurrection in the Spirit's giving them life.
On this Paul builds his appeal: if we are Christians, we should be dead to sin and alive to righteousness. He argues the same way elsewhere, that we have been circumcised and have put off the old self, since we were "buried with him in baptism" (Col. 2:11-12). And in this sense, in the passage quoted earlier, he calls baptism "the washing of regeneration and renewal of the Holy Spirit" (Titus 3:5). So we are promised two things: first, the free pardon of sins and the counting of righteousness to us, and second, the grace of the Holy Spirit to re-form us for a new life.
6. The third benefit: union with Christ, and baptism in the name of Father, Son and Spirit
The last benefit our faith receives from baptism is the assurance that we are not only grafted into Christ's death and life, but so joined to Christ himself that we share in all his blessings. He consecrated and sanctified baptism in his own body so that he might hold it in common with us as the firmest bond of union and fellowship that he saw fit to form with us. That is why Paul proves we are God's children from the fact that in baptism we "put on Christ" (Gal. 3:26-27). So we see baptism fulfilled in Christ, and for this reason we call him the true object of baptism.
It is no surprise, then, that the apostles are said to have baptised in the name of Christ (Acts 8:16; 19:5), though they were told to baptise in the name of the Father and the Spirit as well (Matt. 28:19). All the divine gifts that baptism holds out are found in Christ alone. Yet whoever baptises into Christ cannot help calling on the name of the Father and the Spirit at the same time. We are cleansed by his blood because our gracious Father, in his unmatched mercy, wanted to receive us into favour and appointed him as Mediator to reconcile us to himself. We obtain regeneration only from his death and resurrection, when, sanctified by his Spirit, we are given a new and spiritual nature. So in the Father we find the cause of our cleansing and regeneration, in the Son the substance of it, and in the Spirit its effect, and we see this in a way we can grasp. That is how John first baptised, and how the apostles baptised afterwards, with the baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins. By repentance they meant regeneration, and by forgiveness of sins, cleansing.
7. John's baptism and the apostles' baptism are the same
This shows beyond doubt that John's ministry was the same as the one later handed to the apostles. Different hands administering baptism do not make it a different baptism. What shows it is the same baptism is sameness of teaching. John and the apostles taught one doctrine. Both baptised to repentance, both for the forgiveness of sins, both in the name of Christ, from whom repentance and forgiveness come. John pointed to him as "the Lamb of God, who takes away the sin of the world" (John 1:29), describing him as the sacrifice the Father accepted, the propitiation that brings righteousness, and the author of salvation. What could the apostles add to that confession?
So no one should be troubled because the ancient writers work to distinguish the two baptisms. Their opinions should not carry so much weight with us that they shake the certainty of Scripture. Who would listen to Chrysostom denying that forgiveness of sins was included in John's baptism, rather than to Luke, who says the opposite, that John preached "a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins" (Luke 3:3)? Nor can we accept Augustine's subtle claim that sins were forgiven in hope through John's baptism but are forgiven in reality through Christ's. The Evangelist plainly says that John promised forgiveness of sins in his baptism, so why take anything away from that when nothing forces us to? If someone asks what difference there is, he will find only this: John baptised in the name of the one who was to come, the apostles in the name of the one who had already appeared (Luke 3:16; Acts 19:4).
8. The greater gifts of the Spirit do not make two baptisms
The fact that the Spirit's gifts were poured out more generously after Christ's resurrection does not show that there were two baptisms. The baptism the apostles administered while Christ was still on earth was called his baptism, and yet the Spirit was not poured out more abundantly on it than on John's. Even after the ascension the Samaritans did not receive the Spirit beyond the ordinary measure of earlier believers until Peter and John were sent to lay hands on them (Acts 8:14-17).
I think what misled the ancient writers into saying that John's baptism was only a preparation for the other was that they read of people baptised with John's baptism being baptised again by Paul (Acts 19:3-5; Matt. 3:11). How badly they erred in this will be shown more fully in its place. Why, then, did John say that he baptised with water but that one was coming who would baptise with the Holy Spirit and with fire? A few words explain it. He was not contrasting one baptism with another. He was contrasting his own person with Christ's. He was only a minister of water, while Christ was the giver of the Holy Spirit, and Christ would show this power by a visible miracle on the day he sent the Spirit on the apostles in the form of tongues of fire. What greater claim could the apostles make, and what greater claim can those who baptise today make? They are only ministers of the outward sign, while Christ is the author of the inward grace. The same ancient writers consistently teach this, especially Augustine, who in his refutation of the Donatists rests his case chiefly on this principle: whoever baptises, Christ alone presides.
9. Israel's passage through the sea and the cloud foreshadowed baptism
What we have said about dying to sin and being cleansed was foreshadowed among the people of Israel, who for that reason are described by the apostle as having been "baptised into Moses in the cloud and in the sea" (1 Cor. 10:2). The dying was pictured when the Lord rescued them from Pharaoh's hand and cruel slavery, opened a path for them through the Red Sea, and drowned Pharaoh and the Egyptians who were pressing close behind and threatening them with destruction. In baptism he promises us the same, and shows by a visible sign that by his power we are led out and delivered from the captivity of Egypt, which is the slavery of sin, and that our Pharaoh, the devil, is drowned, though he never stops trying and harassing us.
But the Egyptian was not sunk into the depths of the sea; he was thrown up on the shore, where he still alarmed the Israelites by his threatening look though he could not hurt them. In the same way our enemy still threatens, shows his weapons and is felt, but cannot conquer. The cloud was a sign of cleansing (Num. 9:18). As the Lord then shaded them with the cloud and kept them cool so that they would not faint under the blazing sun, so in baptism we see that we are covered and protected by Christ's blood, so that God's wrath, which is truly an unbearable fire, does not rest on us. The mystery was then obscure and known to few. But since there is no other way to obtain salvation than through these two graces, God was pleased to give the ancient fathers, whom he had adopted as heirs, both signs.
10. Baptism does not remove original sin; it removes its condemnation
It is now clear how false is the teaching, held by some long ago and still insisted on by others, that baptism frees us from original sin and from the corruption passed down from Adam to all his descendants, and restores us to the same righteousness and purity of nature Adam would have had if he had kept the integrity he was created with. People who teach this never understand what original sin, original righteousness and the grace of baptism are. It was shown earlier (Book 2, chapter 1, section 8) that original sin is the depravity and corruption of our nature, which first makes us liable to God's wrath and then produces in us the works Scripture calls "the works of the flesh" (Gal. 5:19).
Two things must therefore be kept distinct. First, we are damaged and twisted in every part of our nature. Second, because of this corruption we are rightly held condemned and guilty before God, to whom nothing is acceptable but purity, innocence and righteousness. So even infants bring their condemnation with them from their mother's womb. They have not yet produced the fruits of their unrighteousness, but they carry its seed within them. Their whole nature is a kind of seed of sin, and so it cannot help being hateful and abominable to God.
Baptism assures believers that this condemnation is entirely lifted from them. As we said, the Lord promises by this sign that full and complete pardon has been granted, both for the guilt that was counted against us and for the penalty that guilt deserved. Believers also take hold of righteousness, but only the kind of righteousness God's people can have in this life, which is righteousness by imputation alone, God in his mercy regarding them as righteous and innocent.
11. The corruption remains, but it no longer rules
The corruption itself never stops in us. It keeps producing new fruit, those works of the flesh described earlier, as a burning furnace keeps sending out flame and sparks or a spring keeps pouring out water. Desire for evil is never entirely dead or put out in people until, freed by death from the body of death, they have laid aside their nature completely (Book 3, chapter 3, sections 10-13). Baptism tells us that our Pharaoh is drowned and sin put to death. But it does not mean that sin no longer exists or causes no trouble. It means only that sin no longer has dominion. As long as we live shut up in this prison of the body, the remains of sin dwell in us, but if we faithfully hold to the promise God gave us in baptism, they will neither rule nor reign.
Still, no one should deceive himself or look complacently on his own sickness when he hears that sin always lives in us. We say this not so that people already too prone to sin can sleep easy in their sins, but so that those who are tested and stung by the flesh do not faint and lose heart. Let them remember they are still on the road, and think they have made great progress when they feel their desires weakening a little day by day, until they reach the goal they aim at, the final death of the flesh, which will be completed at the end of this mortal life. Meanwhile let them keep fighting hard, urge themselves on, and press toward complete victory. Their effort should be spurred by the thought that after a long struggle much still remains to be done. We should hold that we are baptised for the putting to death of our flesh, which begins in baptism, goes on every day, and will be finished when we leave this life to go to the Lord.
12. Paul teaches this in Romans 6 to 8
I am saying nothing here that Paul does not make perfectly clear in the sixth and seventh chapters of Romans. He had spoken of free justification. Some wicked people concluded from this that they could live as they pleased, since acceptance with God is not won by the merit of works. So Paul adds that everyone clothed in Christ's righteousness is at the same time regenerated by the Spirit, and that we have a pledge of this regeneration in baptism. He therefore urges believers not to let sin reign in their bodies. Knowing that believers always have some weakness, and wanting to keep them from being cast down by it, he adds for their comfort that they are not under the law. Then, because there seemed to be a danger that Christians would become presumptuous when freed from the law's yoke, he shows what kind of release this is, and at the same time what the law is for.
The substance is that we are freed from the law's severity so that we may cling to Christ, and that the law's role is to convince us of our depravity and make us confess our powerlessness and wretchedness. And because this corruption of nature is not so easy to see in a worldly man who indulges his passions without fear of God, Paul gives an example from a regenerate man, that is, himself. He says he was in constant struggle with the remains of his flesh and was held in miserable bondage, unable to give himself fully to obeying God's law. So he is forced to groan: "Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death?" (Rom. 7:24).
But if God's children are kept prisoner as long as they live, they must be deeply anxious about their danger unless their fears are calmed. For this one purpose Paul adds the consolation that "there is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus" (Rom. 8:1). He teaches that those whom the Lord has once taken into favour, grafted into fellowship with Christ, and received into the church through baptism, are freed from guilt and condemnation as long as they persevere in faith in Christ, even though sin besets them and they carry it about with them. If this is the plain and true meaning of Paul, there is nothing strange in the doctrine he gives here.
13. The second purpose: baptism as our confession before people
Baptism also serves as our confession before people. It is the mark by which we openly declare that we want to be counted among God's people, by which we testify that we agree with all Christians in worshipping one God and holding one religion, and by which, in short, we publicly state our faith. Then not only our hearts but our tongues and every part of our bodies proclaim God's praise in every way they can. In this way everything we have is rightly made to serve God's glory, which ought to be displayed everywhere, and others are encouraged by our example to do the same.
Paul had this in mind when he asked the Corinthians whether they had been baptised in the name of Paul (1 Cor. 1:13). He meant that by being baptised in Christ's name they had given themselves to Christ, and had sworn and bound themselves to him before people, so that they could no longer confess anyone but Christ alone unless they were willing to renounce the confession they had made in baptism.
14. How to receive baptism: as from the hand of God
Now that we have explained what the Lord had in view in instituting baptism, it is easy to judge how we should use and receive it. It is given to lift up, nourish and strengthen our faith, so we must receive it from the hand of its author. We must be firmly convinced that it is he himself who speaks to us through the sign. It is he himself who washes and cleanses us and wipes out the memory of our faults. It is he himself who makes us share in his death, destroys Satan's kingdom, weakens the power of our desires, and even makes us one with himself, so that, clothed with him, we may be counted God's children.
We should feel these things as truly and certainly in our minds as we see our bodies washed, immersed and surrounded by water. This comparison gives the surest rule for the sacraments: in physical things we are to see spiritual things, as clearly as if they were set before our eyes, since the Lord has chosen to represent them in such pictures. It does not mean that these graces are contained in the sacrament and tied to it, so that it confers them by its own power. It means only that by this sign the Lord declares he is pleased to give us all these things. And he does not merely feed our eyes with an empty show. He leads us to the reality itself and effectively does what he pictures.
15. Cornelius and Paul: baptism confirms what faith already holds
Cornelius the centurion is a proof of this. He had already received the graces of the Holy Spirit and was then baptised for the forgiveness of sins. He was not looking for fuller forgiveness from baptism but for a surer exercise of faith, indeed for a ground of assurance from a pledge.
Someone may object: why did Ananias tell Paul to "be baptised and wash away your sins" (Acts 22:16), if sins are not washed away by the power of baptism? I answer that we are said to receive, obtain and gain whatever the Lord shows us in a way our faith can grasp, whether he attests it for the first time or gives added confirmation to what he had already attested. All Ananias meant was: be baptised, Paul, so that you may be sure your sins are forgiven. In baptism the Lord promises forgiveness of sins; receive it and be secure.
I have no wish to take anything away from the power of baptism. I only want to add the substance and reality to the sign, since God works through outward means. But we gain nothing from this sacrament, any more than from the others, except as far as we receive it in faith. Where faith is missing, it is evidence of our ingratitude and proves us guilty before God for not believing the promise given there.
As a sign of our confession, baptism should be our testimony that we trust in God's mercy and are pure through the forgiveness of sins that Christ Jesus won for us, and that we have entered God's church so that with one agreement of faith and love we may live in harmony with all believers. This was Paul's meaning when he said, "By one Spirit we were all baptised into one body" (1 Cor. 12:13).
16. The minister's worth does not affect the sacrament
If we were right to conclude that a sacrament is not to be judged by the hand that administers it, but received as from the hand of God, from whom it undoubtedly comes, then we can infer that its dignity is neither increased nor reduced by the minister. When a letter is sent and the writer's hand and seal are recognised, it makes no difference who or what the messenger was. In the same way it should be enough for us to recognise our Lord's hand and seal in his sacraments, whoever administers them.
This refutes the error of the Donatists, who measured the sacrament's power and worth by the dignity of the minister. Today's Anabaptists are like them. They deny that we have been properly baptised because we were baptised in the papacy by wicked men and idolaters, and so they furiously insist on baptising again. We are well armed against these absurdities if we remember that we were initiated by baptism not into any man's name but into the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit. So baptism is not from man but from God, whoever administered it. Say the people who baptised us were wholly ignorant of God and godliness, or despisers of it. They still did not baptise us into fellowship with their ignorance or sacrilege, but into faith in Jesus Christ, because the name they invoked was not their own but God's, and they baptised into no other name. And if the baptism was God's, it certainly carried the promise of forgiveness of sins, putting the flesh to death, new life by the Spirit, and fellowship with Christ.
It did the Jews no harm to be circumcised by impure and apostate priests. It did not nullify the sign so that it had to be repeated. It was enough to return to its true origin. Someone may object that baptism ought to be celebrated in the assembly of the godly, but that does not prove it loses all its power because it is partly defective. When we show what must be done to keep baptism pure and free of every taint, we do not abolish God's institution even though idolaters may corrupt it. Circumcision was long ago spoiled by many superstitions, yet it did not cease to be regarded as a sign of grace. Josiah and Hezekiah, when they gathered from all Israel the people who had turned away from God, did not call them to be circumcised again.
17. Baptism's promise stays firm even when we believed nothing for years
The Anabaptists also ask what faith followed our baptism for several years, hoping to prove that our baptism was empty, since it is not sanctified unless the word of promise is received in faith. Our answer is that, being blind and unbelieving, we did not for a long time take hold of the promise given us in baptism. Yet the promise, because it was God's, stayed fixed, firm and true. "Let God be true though everyone were a liar" (Rom. 3:3-4); though all were lost, Christ remains safe.
We admit, then, that at that time baptism did us no good, since in us the offered promise, without which baptism is nothing, lay neglected. Now that by God's grace we begin to repent, we blame our blindness and hardness of heart for being so long ungrateful for his great goodness. But we do not believe the promise itself has vanished. We reason instead that God promises forgiveness of sins in baptism and will certainly do what he has promised for all believers. That promise was offered to us in baptism, so let us embrace it by faith. As far as we were concerned it lay buried for a long time because of our unbelief; now let us receive it in faith.
In the same way, when the Lord called the Jewish people to repentance, he gave no command about another circumcision, though, as we have said, they had been circumcised by a wicked and sacrilegious hand and had lived long in the same ungodliness. He urged only a turning of the heart. However badly they had broken the covenant, its sign stayed firm and unbroken, as the Lord had appointed. They were restored to the covenant God had once made with them in circumcision on the sole condition of repentance, even though they had, as far as they could, polluted and destroyed the sign they received from a covenant-breaking priest.
18. Paul did not rebaptise John's disciples
The Anabaptists think their strongest weapon is the claim that Paul rebaptised people who had been baptised with John's baptism (Acts 19:3, 5). They argue that if John's baptism was the same as ours, as we admit, then just as those who had been wrongly taught were baptised again into the faith once they learned the truth, so a baptism without true doctrine should be counted as nothing, and we should be baptised anew into the true religion we have only now begun to learn.
Some think these men had been baptised by a foolish imitator of John who had initiated them into empty superstition. They suppose this from the fact that the men admitted complete ignorance of the Holy Spirit, an ignorance John would never have left his disciples in. But it is not likely that Jews, even if they had not been baptised at all, were wholly ignorant of the Spirit, who is celebrated in so many passages of Scripture. Their answer that they did not know whether there was a Spirit must be understood as if they had said they had not yet heard whether the gifts of the Spirit Paul asked about were given to Christ's disciples.
I grant that John's was a true baptism and one and the same as Christ's. But I deny that these men were rebaptised. (See Calvin's treatise against the Anabaptists.) What, then, do the words "they were baptised in the name of the Lord Jesus" mean? Some explain that they were simply taught sound doctrine by Paul. I prefer a simpler reading: the baptism of the Holy Spirit, that is, the visible gifts of the Spirit, was given through the laying on of hands. These gifts are sometimes called by the name of baptism. On the day of Pentecost the apostles are said to have remembered the Lord's words about baptism with the Spirit and with fire, and Peter reports that the same words came to him when he saw these gifts poured out on Cornelius and his household.
It is no objection to this reading that Luke adds afterwards, "when Paul had laid his hands on them, the Holy Spirit came on them" (Acts 19:6). Luke is not describing two different events. He follows the Hebrew way of telling a story, which states the substance first and then explains it more fully, as anyone can see from the context. He says, "On hearing this, they were baptised in the name of the Lord Jesus. And when Paul had laid his hands on them, the Holy Spirit came on them." The second sentence describes what that baptism was.
Besides, if ignorance spoils a first baptism and requires correction by a second, the apostles themselves should have been rebaptised first, since for more than three full years after their baptism they had barely received a small portion of purer teaching. And since so many of our own ignorances are corrected daily by God's mercy, what rivers would be enough for so many repeated baptisms?
19. The form of baptism: remove the human additions
I trust the power, dignity, usefulness and purpose of the sacrament are now clear enough. As for the outward sign, I wish Christ's own institution had been kept, as a check on human boldness. As if baptising with water according to Christ's command were a contemptible thing, a blessing, or rather an incantation, was devised to pollute the true consecration of the water. Later the candle and the chrism were added, and exorcism was thought to open the door for baptism. I know how ancient the origin of this accumulation of additions is, but it is still lawful for me and for all the godly to reject whatever people have presumed to add to Christ's institution. When Satan saw that the world's foolish credulity received his impostures almost without objection at the beginning of the gospel, he moved on to cruder mockery. That is how spittle and other follies were brought in, with unrestrained licence, to the open disgrace of baptism. Let our experience of them teach us that nothing is holier, better or safer than to be content with Christ's authority alone.
How much better it would be to put aside all the theatrical show that dazzles simple people's eyes and dulls their minds. When someone is to be baptised, he should be brought forward and presented to God with the whole church looking on as witnesses and praying over him. The confession of faith in which the candidate has been taught should be recited, the promises given in baptism explained, and then he should be baptised in the name of the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit, and the service closed with prayer and thanksgiving. In this way nothing fitting would be left out, and the one ceremony that came from its divine Author would shine out clearly, not buried or polluted by foreign additions.
Whether the person baptised is fully immersed, once or three times, or only sprinkled with water, matters not in the least. Churches should be free to choose either, according to the differences of climate, although it is clear that the word "baptise" means to immerse, and that this was the practice of the early church.
20. Baptism belongs to the ministry, not to private persons or women
It is also worth noting that private individuals should not take it on themselves to administer baptism. Like the administration of the Supper, it is part of the ministerial office. Christ did not command just any men or women to baptise, but those he had appointed apostles. And when, in giving the Supper, he told his disciples to do what they had seen him do, he having acted as the proper dispenser, he surely meant them to imitate his example in this.
For many centuries, almost from the very beginning of the church, it has been the custom for lay people to baptise when someone was in danger of death and a minister could not get there in time. This custom does not seem to me to be defensible on sufficient grounds. Even the early Christians who kept or tolerated it were not sure it was rightly done. Augustine expresses this doubt: "Although a layman has given baptism under compulsion of necessity, I do not know whether anyone can piously say it ought to be repeated. If it was done without any necessity, it is taking over another's office; if necessity pressed, it is either no fault or a pardonable one" (Against the Letter of Parmenian, 2.13). As for women, the Council of Carthage decreed without exception that they were not to presume to baptise at all.
But, someone says, a sick person is in danger of being deprived of the gift of regeneration if he dies without baptism. Not at all. God declares that he adopts our children as his own before they are born, when he promises to be a God to us and to our offspring after us. Their salvation is included in that promise. No one would dare insult God by denying that he can make good on his promise.
Few see how much harm has come from the badly explained teaching that baptism is necessary for salvation, and so they think caution the less necessary. When the opinion takes hold that all who happen not to be dipped in water are lost, our condition becomes worse than that of God's ancient people, as if his grace were more restricted than it was under the law. Then Christ would have to be thought to have come not to fulfil the promises but to abolish them, since the promise that was effective in itself for salvation before the eighth day would no longer be effective without the help of a sign.
21. Tertullian and Epiphanius against women baptising
What the custom was before Augustine's day we learn first from Tertullian, who says that a woman is not permitted to speak in the church, nor to teach, nor to baptise, nor to offer, so that she may not claim for herself any part of a man's office, let alone a priest's (Prescription Against Heretics, 41). Epiphanius is a sufficient witness to the same thing when he reproaches Marcion for allowing women to baptise. I know the answer given by those who take the opposite view, that common practice is quite different from an emergency remedy used under extreme necessity. But since he calls it a mockery to let women baptise and makes no exception, it is plain that he condemns the abuse as inexcusable on any pretext. In his third book he makes no reservation either when he says that it was not permitted even to the holy mother of Christ.
22. Zipporah is no precedent, and children who die unbaptised are not excluded from heaven
The example of Zipporah (Exod. 4:25) is quoted beside the point. The angel of God was appeased after she took a flint and circumcised her son, and people wrongly infer that God approved of what she did. If that were so, we would have to say God was pleased with the worship that Gentiles brought from Assyria and set up in Samaria. But there are other good reasons why what a foolish woman did is wrongly turned into a precedent. I could say there was something special in her case that made it unfit to be a precedent, and especially that we nowhere read that the command to circumcise was given to priests only, so baptism and circumcision are different cases. That alone would be a sufficient answer. For Christ's words are plain: "Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptising them" (Matt. 28:19). He appointed the same people to be preachers of the gospel and dispensers of baptism. And in the church "no one takes this honour for himself, but only when called by God, just as Aaron was" (Heb. 5:4). Anyone who baptises without a lawful call takes over another's office. Paul declares that whatever we attempt with a doubting conscience, even in the smallest matters such as food and drink, is sin (Rom. 14:23). So when women baptise, the sin is greater, because it is plain that the rule Christ gave is being broken, and we know it is wrong to separate what God has joined.
But I pass over all this. I only want my readers to notice that the last thing Zipporah intended was to render service to God. Seeing her son in danger, she frets and complains, and with some anger throws the foreskin on the ground, rebuking her husband and taking offence at God. Her whole conduct is plainly driven by passion. She complains against both her husband and God because she is forced to shed her son's blood. We may add that however well she behaved in other respects, her presumption in this is inexcusable: she circumcised her son while her husband was present, and he was no mere private person but Moses, the chief prophet of God, the greatest who ever arose in Israel. This was no more allowable for her than it would be for women today under a bishop's eye.
But this whole controversy is settled at once when we hold that children who die before there is an opportunity to immerse them in water are not shut out of the kingdom of heaven. As we have seen, unless we admit this, great harm is done to God's covenant, as if the covenant were weak in itself, when its effect depends neither on baptism nor on anything added to it. The sacrament is added afterwards as a kind of seal, not to give power to the promise as if it were invalid in itself, but only to confirm it to us. It follows that the children of believers are not baptised in order to become God's children for the first time, having been strangers to the church before. They are received into the church by a formal sign because, by virtue of the promise, they already belonged to the body of Christ. So if the sign is omitted without sloth, contempt or negligence, we are safe from all danger.
The far better course, therefore, is to show God's ordinance such respect that we seek the sacraments nowhere but where the Lord has placed them. When we cannot receive them from the church, God's grace is not so inseparably tied to them that we cannot obtain it by faith, according to his word.
Chapter 16
Infant Baptism: Its Agreement with Christ's Institution and with the Nature of the Sign
1. Why the question has to be faced
In our own day certain wild spirits have stirred up great trouble in the Church over infant baptism, and they are still at it. So I can't avoid adding something here, by way of appendix, to restrain their fury. If anyone thinks I'm spending more words than the subject deserves, let them remember that where something of the greatest importance is at stake, the peace and purity of the Church are owed so much that we shouldn't be fussy about anything that serves both. I'll also try to arrange this discussion so that it sheds still more light on baptism itself.
The argument against infant baptism does sound convincing. They say it rests on no institution of God. It was brought in by human presumption and idle curiosity, and then, through foolish ease, was carelessly accepted into practice. And a sacrament, they say, has nothing to hang on if it doesn't stand on the firm foundation of God's word. But what if, when the matter is properly examined, it turns out that a false and unjust slander has been brought against the Lord's holy ordinance? So let's begin with its origin. If it proves to have been devised by human rashness alone, let's drop it and regulate the true observance of baptism entirely by the Lord's will. But if it proves not to lack his sure authority, let's take care not to throw out God's sacred institutions and so insult their Author.
2. The promises are what give a sign its meaning
First, there is a well-known teaching on which all godly people agree: the right understanding of signs lies not merely in the outward ceremonies, but chiefly in the promise and in the spiritual mysteries the ceremonies are appointed to picture. Anyone who wants to understand baptism thoroughly, its purpose and its true character, must not stop at the element and the physical act. They must look to the divine promises offered to us there, and rise to the inner realities it represents. Someone who grasps these has reached the solid truth and, so to speak, the whole substance of baptism, and from there will see the nature and use of the outward sprinkling. Someone who despises them and keeps their thoughts fixed on the visible ceremony will understand neither the force of baptism nor its proper nature, nor what is meant, nor what is gained by the use of water. Scripture confirms this in too many clear passages for me to go through them here.
What remains, then, is to ask about the nature and effect of baptism as shown by the promises given in it. Scripture shows first that it points to the cleansing from sin we obtain by the blood of Christ. Second, it points to the putting to death of the flesh, which means sharing in his death, by which believers are born again to newness of life and so to fellowship with Christ. Everything Scripture teaches about baptism can be gathered under these heads, with the addition that it is also a badge by which we profess our religion before others.
3. What circumcision promised
Before baptism was instituted, God's people had circumcision in its place. So let's see how far these two signs are alike and how far they differ. That will show what the relation between them is.
When the Lord commands Abraham to keep circumcision (Gen. 17:10), he begins by saying that he will be God to Abraham and to his seed, and that he himself is wholly sufficient, so that Abraham may count on him as the fountain of every blessing. These words contain the promise of eternal life, as our Saviour himself interprets them when he uses them to prove the immortality and resurrection of believers: "God is not the God of the dead, but of the living" (Matt. 22:32). So too Paul, showing the Ephesians how deep the ruin was from which the Lord had rescued them, observes that because they had not been admitted to the covenant of circumcision, they were at that time "alienated from the commonwealth of Israel and strangers to the covenants of promise, having no hope and without God in the world" (Eph. 2:12). All of that is bound up in the covenant. Now the first approach to God, the first step into immortal life, is the forgiveness of sins. So this matches what baptism promises us, our cleansing.
The Lord then goes on to tell Abraham to walk before him in sincerity and integrity of heart. That corresponds to mortification, or regeneration. And in case anyone doubts that circumcision was the sign of mortification, Moses makes it plain elsewhere. He exhorts Israel to circumcise the foreskin of their hearts, because the Lord had chosen them for his own people out of all the nations of the earth. The Lord, in choosing Abraham's descendants as his people, commanded them to be circumcised, and Moses declares that they must be circumcised in heart, explaining what that bodily circumcision pictured. To stop anyone attempting this in their own strength, he adds that it is the work of God's grace. The prophets say all this so often that I needn't collect the passages.
So the fathers received in circumcision a spiritual promise like the one we receive in baptism, since it pictured for them both the forgiveness of sins and the putting to death of the flesh. Besides, we have shown that Christ, in whom both of these reside, is the foundation of baptism. He must therefore be the foundation of circumcision too. He was promised to Abraham, and in him all nations are blessed. The sign of circumcision was added to seal that grace.
4. Same promise, same reality, different ceremony
Now it is easy to see where the two signs agree and where they differ. The promise, in which the whole power of a sign lies, is the same in both: the fatherly favour of God, forgiveness of sins, eternal life. The thing pictured is the same: regeneration. The foundation on which all this rests is the same. So there is no difference in the inner meaning, by which the whole power and distinctive nature of a sacrament has to be judged. The only difference is in the outward ceremony, which is the smallest part, since the chief part consists in the promise and the thing signified. We can conclude, then, that whatever is true of circumcision is also true of baptism, except for the difference in the visible ceremony.
This comparison follows the apostle's rule that every interpretation of Scripture must be brought into line with the analogy of faith (Rom. 12:3, 6). And in this matter the truth can almost be felt. Circumcision was a kind of badge for the Jews. It assured them they were adopted as God's people and family, and it was their first entry into the Church, as they in turn pledged their allegiance to God. In the same way we are now initiated by baptism, enrolled among his people, and at the same time swear loyalty to his name. So it is beyond dispute that baptism has taken the place of circumcision and does the same work.
5. If the thing signified belongs to infants, so does the sign
Now suppose we're asking whether baptism is rightly given to infants. Wouldn't we say that anyone is trifling, or rather raving, who stops at the water and the outward act and won't let their mind rise to the spiritual mystery? If reason is listened to, it is clear that baptism is properly given to infants, and that it is something due to them. In the old days the Lord didn't give them circumcision without making them sharers in everything circumcision signified. He would have been fooling his people with a mere sham if he'd soothed them with deceptive symbols, and the very thought is shocking. He plainly declares that the circumcision of the infant will serve as a seal of the promise of the covenant.
And if the covenant stands firm, it applies to the children of Christians today no less than it applied to the children of the Jews under the Old Testament. If they share in the thing signified, how can they be refused the sign? If they have the reality, how can the picture be denied them? In a sacrament the outward sign is so joined to the word that the two can't be pulled apart. But if they could be, which would we value more? Surely when we see the sign serving the word, we'll say it is subordinate and give it the lower place. Since, then, the word of baptism is meant for infants, why would we deny them the sign, which is only an attachment to the word? Even if no other reason could be given, this one would be enough to answer every opponent.
The objection that circumcision had a fixed day is a mere quibble. We admit that we are not tied to particular days as the Jews were. But when the Lord declares that, though he prescribes no day, he is pleased for infants to be formally admitted to his covenant, what more do we need?
6. The covenant with Abraham is still in force
Scripture gives us even clearer knowledge of the truth. It is perfectly plain that the covenant the Lord once made with Abraham applies to Christians now no less than it once applied to the Jewish people. So that word concerns Christians as much as Jews, unless we imagine that Christ at his coming diminished or cut back the Father's grace, which would be close to blasphemy. This is why the children of the Jews, set apart from the heathen as heirs of the covenant, were called a holy seed. For the same reason the children of Christians, or of those with even one believing parent, are called holy, and by the apostle's testimony they differ from the unclean offspring of idolaters.
Then, since the Lord ordered the covenant to be sealed in infants by an outward sacrament right after he made it with Abraham, how can anyone say that Christians today may not attest it and seal it in their children? Don't object that the only symbol the Lord appointed for confirming his covenant was circumcision, which was abolished long ago. The answer is easy. Under the form of the old dispensation he appointed circumcision to confirm his covenant. Circumcision has been abolished, but the reason for confirmation remains, and it is a reason we share with the Jews. So we always need to consider carefully what is common to both and where they differ from us. The covenant is common. The reason for confirming it is common. The way of confirming it differs only in this: they had circumcision, and in its place we have baptism.
Otherwise, if the testimony that assured the Jews of their children's salvation is taken from us, the result is that the coming of Christ has made God's grace, formerly given to the Jews, darker and less fully attested to us. We can't say that without grave insult to Christ, through whom the Father's boundless goodness has been poured out on the earth and shown to people more brightly and kindly than ever. So we have to confess that this grace cannot be more restricted and less clearly displayed now than it was under the dim shadows of the law.
7. Christ and the little children
For this reason our Lord Jesus Christ, to give the world an example that he came to enlarge the Father's grace, not to limit it, kindly takes little children in his arms and rebukes his disciples for trying to keep them from coming (Matt. 19:13). The disciples were keeping away from him the very ones to whom the kingdom of heaven belongs, and he is the only way to heaven.
But someone will ask, what has this to do with baptism? He isn't said to have baptised them, but to have received, embraced and blessed them. So if we want to imitate his example, we should pray for infants, not baptise them. Let's look at what our Saviour did a little more carefully than these people do. We mustn't overlook that when he ordered the children to be brought to him, he gave the reason: "to such belongs the kingdom of heaven." Then he showed his goodwill by what he did. He embraced them, and with prayer and blessing commended them to his Father.
If it is right for children to be brought to Christ, why shouldn't they be admitted to baptism, the sign of our communion and fellowship with Christ? If the kingdom of heaven is theirs, why deny them the sign that opens, as it were, the door of the Church, so that once inside they are counted among the heirs of the heavenly kingdom? How unjust it would be to drive away those Christ invites, to strip those he adorns with his gifts, to shut out those he gladly admits. And if we want to dwell on the difference between what our Saviour did and baptism, how much more highly should we value baptism, by which we testify that infants are included in the divine covenant, than the picking up, embracing, laying on of hands and praying over them, by which Christ, present in person, declared that they were his and were sanctified by him!
The other tricks they use to dodge this passage only show their ignorance. They quibble that since the Lord says "let the children come," they must have been several years old and able to come. But the Evangelists call them by words that mean babies at their mothers' breasts, and "come" simply means "approach." See what shifts people are driven to once they've hardened themselves against the truth! Nor is there anything solid in the claim that the kingdom of heaven is assigned not to children but to people like children, since the words are "of such," not "of these." If that were granted, what reason would our Saviour be giving for saying they aren't strangers to him on account of their age? When he orders little children to be allowed to come to him, it is plain that it is simple infancy he means. To keep that from sounding absurd, he adds, "to such belongs the kingdom of heaven." If infants must be included, the words "of such" make it clear that infants themselves, and those like them, are meant.
8. "The apostles never baptised an infant," and "it's a novelty"
Anyone can see now that infant baptism, so strongly supported by Scripture, is not a human invention. Nor is there anything plausible in the objection that we never read of even one infant being baptised by the apostles. The Evangelists don't say so expressly, but neither do they expressly exclude infants when they mention a whole household being baptised (Acts 16:15, 32). What sensible person would argue from that that the children weren't baptised? If that kind of argument were good, we would have to bar women from the Lord's Supper, since we never read that they were admitted to it in the apostles' days.
But here we rest content with the rule of faith. When we think about the nature of the Lord's Supper, we can easily judge who should take part in it. The same goes for baptism. When we look at the purpose for which it was instituted, we clearly see that it applies no less to children than to adults, and so they can't be deprived of it without manifest fraud against the will of its divine Author.
The claim they spread among ordinary people, that for many years after Christ's resurrection infant baptism was unknown, is a shameful lie. There is no writer, however ancient, who doesn't trace its origin to the days of the apostles.
9. What infant baptism gives to parents and to children
Briefly, we should note what good the practice does, both for believers who bring their children to church to be baptised and for the infants who receive the water, so that nobody despises the ordinance as pointless or superfluous. Anyone who ridicules baptism on those grounds would have to ridicule circumcision too, which God himself ordained. What can they say against one that couldn't be thrown back at the other? This is how the Lord punishes the arrogance of those who immediately condemn whatever their natural reason can't grasp.
But God gives us other weapons against their stupidity. His holy institution, from which our faith draws wonderful comfort, doesn't deserve to be called superfluous. The divine sign given to the child is like a seal pressed on the promise made to the godly parent. It confirms that the Lord will be God not only to the parent but to the parent's seed, showing his grace and goodness not only to them but to their descendants to the thousandth generation. When God's boundless goodness is displayed like this, it first gives rich material for proclaiming his glory. It fills godly hearts with no ordinary joy and moves them to love their gracious Father more, when they see that for their sake he cares for their descendants too.
I'm not moved by the objection that the promise alone should be enough to assure us of our children's salvation. God saw it differently. He knows our weakness and chose to accommodate it. So those who embrace the promise of mercy for their children should consider it their duty to offer them to the Church to be sealed with the sign of mercy. They'll be encouraged to a firmer confidence as they see with their own eyes the Lord's covenant engraved on their children's bodies.
On the other side, children themselves gain something from their baptism. Being grafted into the body of the Church, they become objects of greater concern to the other members. And when they've grown up, they're strongly stirred to a serious desire to serve God, who received them as sons by the solemn sign of adoption before their age allowed them to know him as Father. Finally, we should stand in great awe of the warning that God will take vengeance on anyone who disdains to put the sign of the covenant on their child (Gen. 17:14). Such contempt is a rejection, and virtually a renunciation, of the grace offered.
10. The Anabaptists claim baptism and circumcision are different
Now let's take up the arguments with which some furious people keep attacking this holy ordinance of God. First, feeling themselves hard pressed by the likeness between baptism and circumcision, they insist there is a wide gulf between the two signs and that the one has nothing to do with the other. They say the things signified are different, the covenant is altogether different, and the persons included under the name of children are different.
When they come to proof, they first pretend that circumcision was a figure of mortification, not of baptism. We gladly grant that, since it supports our case admirably. Our only proof is that baptism and circumcision are both signs of mortification, from which we conclude that one was put in place of the other, baptism showing us exactly what circumcision showed the Jews.
When they claim the covenant is different, with what barbarous boldness they twist and wreck Scripture, and not in one passage only but so as to leave no passage safe and whole! They portray the Jews as so earthly that they were more like animals than people. They say the covenant made with them reached no further than this temporary life, and the promises given them shrank down to present, bodily blessings. If we accept that, what is left but that the Jewish nation was stuffed for a time with God's kindness, as pigs are fattened in a sty, only to perish for ever at the end? Whenever we cite circumcision and its promises, they answer that circumcision was a literal sign and its promises carnal.
11. The covenant was spiritual, with earthly blessings added
If circumcision was a merely literal sign, then baptism must be viewed the same way, since in Colossians 2 the apostle makes the one no more spiritual than the other. He says that in Christ we "were circumcised with a circumcision made without hands, by putting off the body of the flesh, in the circumcision of Christ," and to explain this he immediately adds, "having been buried with him in baptism." What do those words mean except that the truth and fulfilment of baptism is the truth and fulfilment of circumcision, since they picture one thing? His aim is to show that baptism is to Christians what circumcision once was to the Jews. We've already shown clearly that the promises of both signs and the mysteries they represent agree, so I won't linger. I'll only ask believers to consider, without my saying more, whether a sign that has nothing heavenly or spiritual beneath it can be called earthly and literal.
But to keep them from blinding the simple with their smoke, I'll deal in passing with one objection they use to cover this brazen falsehood. It is absolutely certain that the original promises that made up God's covenant with the Israelites under the old dispensation were spiritual and looked to eternal life. The fathers received them spiritually, so that they could have a sure hope of immortality and reach for it with their whole soul. At the same time, we are far from denying that God showed his kindness to them by earthly and bodily blessings, though we hold that through these the hope of the spiritual promises was strengthened. So when he promised eternal blessedness to his servant Abraham, he added the promise of possessing the land of Canaan, to set a visible mark of his favour before Abraham's eyes. We should understand all the earthly promises given to the Jewish nation in the same way, with the spiritual promise always holding first place as the head to which the others pointed. I treated this fully when I discussed the difference between the old and new dispensations, so I only touch on it here.
12. Who are Abraham's "children"?
On the name "children," the difference they claim is this. Under the old dispensation, they say, Abraham's children were those descended from his seed, but now the name is given to those who imitate his faith. So the physical infants brought into the covenant by circumcision pictured the spiritual children of the new covenant, who are born again by God's word to immortal life. There is a small spark of truth in this, but these giddy people go badly wrong by grabbing the first thing that comes to hand when they should go further and compare many passages. They fasten obstinately on a single word. So they can't help being deceived again and again, since they don't work at getting a full understanding of anything.
We certainly admit that for a time Abraham's physical offspring held the place of the spiritual seed, which is grafted into him by faith (Gal. 4:28; Rom. 4:12). We're called his sons though we have no natural relationship to him. But if they mean, as they hardly hide, that the spiritual promise was never made to Abraham's physical seed, they are badly mistaken. We must take a better aim, the one Scripture's unerring guidance gives us. The Lord promises Abraham a seed in whom all the nations of the earth will be blessed, and at the same time assures him that he will be God to him and to his seed. All who receive Christ in faith as the author of that blessing are heirs of this promise, and so are called Abraham's children.
13. Jews and Gentiles equal in Abraham
After Christ's resurrection the boundaries of the kingdom began to spread far and wide among all nations without distinction, and believers were gathered from every quarter, as Christ had foretold, to sit down with Abraham, Isaac and Jacob (Matt. 8:11). Still, for many ages before that the Jews had enjoyed this great mercy. And since God had chosen them alone, passing over all other nations, to be for a time the guardians of his favour, he called them his special people (Exod. 19:5). As a witness to this kindness he appointed circumcision. By that sign the Jews were taught that God watched over their safety, and they were lifted to the hope of eternal life. For what could ever be lacking to anyone God has taken under his protection?
So the apostle, to prove that Gentiles as well as Jews are children of Abraham, argues like this: "Faith was counted to Abraham as righteousness. How then was it counted to him? Was it before or after he had been circumcised? It was not after, but before. He received the sign of circumcision as a seal of the righteousness that he had by faith while he was still uncircumcised. The purpose was to make him the father of all who believe without being circumcised, so that righteousness would be counted to them as well, and to make him the father of the circumcised who are not merely circumcised but also walk in the footsteps of the faith that our father Abraham had before he was circumcised" (Rom. 4:9-12). Don't we see that both are made equal in dignity? Until the time fixed by the divine decree he was the father of the circumcision. But when the wall of separation between Gentiles and Jews was broken down (Eph. 2:14), access to the kingdom of God was given to the Gentiles too. He became their father without the sign of circumcision, its place being filled by baptism.
In saying expressly that Abraham was not the father only of those of the circumcision, Paul meant to check the pride of people who, with no regard for godliness, boasted in mere ceremonies. In the same way we can today answer the empty boasting of those who look for nothing in baptism but water.
14. Romans 9 does not cancel the covenant with Abraham's seed
Against this they bring a passage from Romans in which the apostle says that those who are children of the flesh are not Abraham's children, and only the children of the promise are counted as his seed (Rom. 9:7). He seems to hint that physical descent from Abraham, which we think of some importance, counts for nothing. But we need to look carefully at what the apostle is discussing there. He wants to show the Jews that God's goodness isn't confined to Abraham's seed and that descent alone contributes nothing. As proof he cites Ishmael and Esau. They were rejected like strangers though they were Abraham's genuine offspring by the flesh, and the blessing rested on Isaac and Jacob. This supports what he affirms afterward, that salvation depends on the mercy God gives to whomever he pleases, and that the Jews have no ground for boasting in the name of the covenant unless they keep the law of the covenant, which means obeying the word.
On the other hand, having demolished their empty confidence in their ancestry, Paul knew that the covenant made with Abraham's descendants could not come to nothing. So he declares that the honour due to descent from Abraham must still be paid. On that account the Jews were the first and natural heirs of the gospel, except in so far as they were rejected for their ingratitude as unworthy, and rejected in such a way that their nation was not left wholly without the heavenly blessing. For this reason, though they were stubborn covenant-breakers, he still calls them holy, such is the respect he pays to the holy line God honoured with his sacred covenant. We, by comparison, are called untimely-born children of Abraham, children not by nature but by adoption, like a branch broken off its own tree and grafted onto another stock.
So that they wouldn't be cheated of their privilege, the gospel had to be preached to them first. They are, as it were, the firstborn in God's family. The honour due on that account has to be paid them until they have rejected the offer and, by their ingratitude, caused it to be passed on to the Gentiles. And however stubbornly they keep fighting the gospel, we're not to despise them. We must remember that, for the promise's sake, God's blessing still rests among them, and as the apostle testifies, it will never wholly depart from them, since "the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable" (Rom. 11:29).
15. The covenant with believers' children stands in the Christian Church
This is the value of the promise given to Abraham's descendants, and this is how it should be weighed. We have no doubt that when God separates his children from outsiders and strangers, his election works freely. At the same time, we see that he was pleased to embrace the seed of Abraham in a special way with his mercy, and to seal it by circumcision as a better witness to that mercy. The Christian Church is in just the same situation. As Paul declares there that the Jews are sanctified through their parents, so he says elsewhere that the children of Christians receive holiness from their parents (1 Cor. 7:14). From this it follows that those who are unclean are rightly distinguished from the rest.
Who can doubt, then, how false their next claim is, that the infants who were circumcised in former times only pictured the spiritual infancy produced by regeneration through God's word? When the apostle says that "Christ became a servant to the circumcised to show God's truthfulness, in order to confirm the promises given to the patriarchs" (Rom. 15:8), he isn't philosophising subtly. He means that since the covenant made with Abraham concerns his seed, Christ came for the salvation of the Jewish nation in order to fulfil the Father's promise. Do you see how he considers that, after Christ's resurrection, the promise is to be fulfilled to Abraham's seed not allegorically but literally, as the words say? Peter says the same to the Jews: "The promise is for you and for your children" (Acts 2:39), and in the next chapter he calls them sons of the covenant, that is, heirs (Acts 3:25). Not far from this is the other passage of the apostle already quoted, which treats the circumcision of infants as a witness to the fellowship they have with Christ.
And indeed, if we listen to the absurdities of these people, what becomes of the promise in the second commandment, where the Lord engages to be gracious to the seed of his servants for a thousand generations? Shall we turn to allegory? That would be the merest quibble. Shall we say it has been abolished? That would do away with the law Christ came not to destroy but to fulfil, since the law is aimed at our everlasting good. So let it be beyond controversy that God is so good and generous to his people that he is pleased to extend their privileges, as a mark of his favour, to the children born to them.
16. Their other distinctions contradict each other
The distinctions these people try to draw between baptism and circumcision are not only ridiculous and void of reason, but they conflict with each other. They say baptism refers to the first day of spiritual struggle, and circumcision to the eighth day, when mortification is already complete. Then they forget that distinction and change their tune, making circumcision a picture of the putting to death of the flesh and baptism a burial, which is given only to those already dead. What are these dizzy contradictions but a madman's dreams? By the first view baptism should come before circumcision, by the second after it. This isn't the first time we've seen human minds wander back and forth when they put their dreams in place of God's unerring word. So we hold that their first distinction is a pure fancy.
If we wanted to make an allegory of the eighth day, theirs wouldn't be the right way to do it. Better to follow the early Christians and relate the number eight to the resurrection, which took place on the eighth day and on which our newness of life depends. Or relate it to the whole course of this present life, during which mortification should be going on and ends only when life itself ends. Though it also seems God meant to spare the tenderness of infancy by putting off circumcision to the eighth day, since the wound would have been more dangerous if inflicted right after birth. Much more reasonable is Scripture's own statement that we, already dead, are buried by baptism (Rom. 6:4). It says plainly that we are buried into death so that we may die thoroughly, and from then on pursue that mortification.
Equally clever is their jibe that women shouldn't be baptised if baptism is to match circumcision. Since the sanctification of Israel's seed was attested by the sign of circumcision, it can't be doubted that it was appointed for the sanctification of females as well as males. Though the rite could be performed only on males, females were partners and sharers in circumcision through them.
So let's disregard these quibbling distinctions and fix our eyes on the complete resemblance between baptism and circumcision: the same inner work, the same promise, the same use, the same effect.
17. Infants are not simply left in Adam: regeneration and infants
They seem to think they have their strongest reason for denying baptism to children when they say infants are too young to understand the mystery sealed there, which is spiritual regeneration, and this doesn't fit earliest infancy. So they infer that children must be treated as sons of Adam until they reach an age fit for the second birth.
All this is directly contrary to God's truth. If infants are to be counted as sons of Adam, they are left in death, since in Adam all we can do is die. On the contrary, Christ commands that they be brought to him. Why? Because he is life. To give them life, he makes them partners with himself, whereas these people would drive them away from Christ and hand them over to death. If they pretend infants don't perish when counted as Adam's sons, Scripture refutes the error more than enough. It declares that in Adam all die (1 Cor. 15:22), so there is no hope of life except in Christ. To become heirs of life we must share in him. Again, since it is written elsewhere that we are all by nature children of wrath (Eph. 2:3) and were conceived in sin (Ps. 51:5), and condemnation always goes with that, we must part with our own nature before we can come near the kingdom of God. And what could be clearer than "flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God" (1 Cor. 15:50)? Everything that is our own must be abolished, and that cannot happen without regeneration, and only then shall we see this inheritance. In short, if Christ speaks truly when he says he is life, we must be grafted into him, the one who frees us from the bondage of death.
"But how," they ask, "can infants be regenerated when they know neither good nor evil?" We answer that God's work, though beyond our understanding, is not therefore nothing. Moreover, infants who are to be saved, and it is certain that some are saved at that age, must without question be regenerated by the Lord beforehand. If they bring inborn corruption with them from their mother's womb, they must be cleansed before they can enter God's kingdom, where "nothing unclean will ever enter" (Rev. 21:27). If they are born sinners, as David and Paul affirm, they must either remain unaccepted and hated by God, or be justified. And why ask for more, when the Judge himself publicly declares that "unless one is born again he cannot see the kingdom of God" (John 3:3)?
To silence this sort of objector, God gave a proof of what he can do in others, in the case of John the Baptist, whom he sanctified from his mother's womb (Luke 1:15). They gain nothing by their quibble that this happened only once, so it doesn't follow that the Lord always acts this way with infants. That isn't how we argue. Our only aim is to show that they unjustly and spitefully shut God's power inside limits it can't be shut in. Their other dodge carries as little weight: that "from the womb" in the usual idiom of Scripture means "from childhood." It is easy to see that the angel meant something different when he announced to Zechariah that the child not yet born would be filled with the Holy Spirit. Instead of trying to lay down a law for God, let's hold that he sanctifies whom he pleases, in the way he sanctified John, since his power is not diminished.
18. Christ was sanctified from infancy, and no elect child is lost unrenewed
Indeed, Christ was sanctified from earliest infancy so that he might sanctify his elect in himself at any age without distinction. To wipe out the guilt of the disobedience committed in our flesh, he took on that very flesh, so that in it he might perform perfect obedience on our behalf and in our place. So too he was conceived by the Holy Spirit so that, fully pervaded with holiness in the flesh he had assumed, he might pour it into us. If in Christ we have a perfect pattern of all the graces God gives to his children, here we have proof that infancy is not incapable of receiving sanctification. This much at least we set down as beyond question: none of the elect is called out of this present life without first being sanctified and regenerated by the Spirit of God.
They object that Scripture acknowledges no sanctification except from incorruptible seed, that is, God's word. But they misread Peter, who is speaking only of believers who had been taught by the preaching of the gospel (1 Pet. 1:23). We confess that the Lord's word is the only seed of spiritual regeneration. We deny the inference that God's power therefore can't regenerate infants. That is as possible and easy for him as it is wonderful and incomprehensible to us. It would be dangerous to deny that the Lord can give them knowledge of himself in whatever way he pleases.
19. "Faith comes by hearing"
"But faith comes by hearing," they say, and infants can't hear in the relevant sense, and they can't know God, since Moses says they have no knowledge of good and evil (Deut. 1:39). They overlook that when the apostle makes hearing the beginning of faith, he is describing the usual order in which the Lord calls his people. He isn't laying down an unbreakable rule that no other method can replace. The Lord has certainly called many and given them the true knowledge of himself by inward means, by the Spirit's illumination, with no preaching in between.
But since they think it absurd to credit infants with any knowledge of God, let them tell me where the danger lies in saying that infants now receive some part of the grace of which they will soon receive the full measure. If fullness of life consists in perfect knowledge of God, then those whom death snatches away in the first moments of infancy pass into eternal life, and so are certainly admitted to see God's face. Why, then, may God not, if he chooses, shine a small ray now on those he is about to light with the full brightness of his glory, especially if he doesn't remove their ignorance until he frees them from the prison of the flesh?
I wouldn't rashly claim that they have the same faith we experience, or any knowledge much like faith; I would rather leave that undecided. But I would like to check the dull arrogance of those who, with puffed-out cheeks, affirm or deny whatever suits them.
20. "Baptism is the sacrament of repentance and faith"
To get firmer footing, they add that baptism is the sacrament of repentance and faith. Since neither fits tender infancy, they say we must beware of emptying baptism of its meaning by admitting infants to it. But these darts are aimed more at God than at us. Many passages of Scripture make it certain that circumcision was a sign of repentance (Jer. 4:4), and Paul calls it a seal of the righteousness of faith (Rom. 4:11). So let God be asked why he ordered circumcision on the bodies of infants. Baptism and circumcision are in the same position here, and whatever they refuse to baptism they can't give to circumcision.
If they fall back on their usual evasion that the infancy of the body pictured spiritual infants, we've already shut that escape. We say that since God gave circumcision, the sign of repentance and faith, to infants, it shouldn't seem absurd that they now share in baptism, unless people want to shout against a divine institution. And as in all his acts, so here enough wisdom and righteousness shine out to silence the slanders of the ungodly. When infants were circumcised, they didn't grasp what the sign meant, yet they were truly circumcised for the putting to death of their corrupt and polluted nature, a mortification they aspired to when they grew up. The objection is easily answered by this: children are baptised into future repentance and faith. These aren't yet formed in them, but the seed of both lies hidden in them by the Spirit's secret working.
This answer overthrows all the objections twisted out of the meaning of baptism, such as Paul's title for it, "the washing of regeneration and renewal" (Titus 3:5). They argue from it that baptism should be given only to those capable of such experiences. But we can reply that circumcision, which is also called regeneration, should then be given only to the regenerate. That would condemn a divine institution. As I hinted before, all the arguments aimed at shaking circumcision have no force against baptism.
Nor can they escape by saying that whatever rests on God's authority stands firm even without any reason we can see, but that this reverence isn't due to infant baptism or similar things not recommended to us by God's express word. They are always caught in this dilemma: God's command to circumcise infants was either legitimate and beyond cavil, or it deserved censure. If there was nothing improper or absurd in it, no absurdity can be shown in the practice of infant baptism.
21. The sign need not follow the reality in time
Here is how we answer the charge of absurdity. If those on whom the Lord has set his election depart this life as infants, after receiving the sign of regeneration, he renews them by the inscrutable power of his Spirit in whatever way he alone sees fit. If they reach an age at which they can be taught what baptism means, they will be spurred on to greater zeal for renewal, the badge of which they will learn they received in earliest infancy so that they might reach for it all their lives.
The two passages in which Paul teaches that we are buried with Christ in baptism (Rom. 6:4; Col. 2:12) point the same way. He doesn't mean that anyone about to be baptised must already have been buried with Christ. He simply states the doctrine baptism teaches, and states it to people already baptised, so that not even the most obtuse can claim from this passage that burial must come before baptism. In just this way Moses and the prophets reminded the people of what circumcision meant, though infants received it. Likewise Paul says to the Galatians, "As many of you as were baptised into Christ have put on Christ" (Gal. 3:27). Why? So that they would from then on live to Christ, to whom they had not lived before. And though with adults the receiving of the sign ought to follow an understanding of its meaning, a different rule must be followed with children, as I'll explain shortly.
No other conclusion can be drawn from Peter, on whom they lean heavily. He says baptism is "not the removal of dirt from the body but an appeal to God for a good conscience, through the resurrection of Jesus Christ" (1 Pet. 3:21). From this they argue that nothing is left for infant baptism, which becomes mere empty smoke and a flat contradiction of baptism's meaning. The mistake that misleads them is that they always want the thing to come before the sign in time. The truth of circumcision also consisted in this same answer of a good conscience, yet if the truth had to come first, infants would never have been circumcised by God's command. He himself, by showing that the answer of a good conscience is the truth of circumcision and at the same time commanding infants to be circumcised, plainly signals that in their case circumcision looked to the future. So nothing more should be required now in infant baptism than to confirm and ratify the covenant the Lord has made with them. The rest of the sacrament's meaning will follow at the time God himself has appointed.
22. Remission of sins, and the cleansing of the Church
Everyone can see, I think, that arguments of this kind are plain distortions of Scripture. The remaining ones are similar and I'll go through them quickly.
They object that baptism is given for the forgiveness of sins. Granted, that supports us strongly. Since we are born sinners, we need forgiveness and pardon from the womb. And since God doesn't shut this age out from the hope of mercy but assures it of mercy, why should we deprive it of the sign, which is far less than the reality? The arrow they shoot at us we throw back at them: infants receive forgiveness of sins, so they are not to be denied the sign.
They cite Ephesians, that Christ gave himself for the Church "that he might sanctify her, having cleansed her by the washing of water with the word" (Eph. 5:26). Nothing could be better chosen to overthrow their error, and it gives us an easy proof. If in baptism Christ means to attest the washing by which he cleanses his Church, it would seem unfair to deny that attestation to infants, who are rightly reckoned part of the Church, since they are called heirs of the heavenly kingdom. Paul includes the whole Church when he says it was cleansed by the washing of water. In the same way, from his statement elsewhere that by baptism we are grafted into the body of Christ, we infer that infants, whom he counts among his members, should be baptised so that they aren't cut off from his body. See the violent assault they make with all their siege engines on the walls of our faith!
23. Peter and Philip: converts from outside the covenant
Next they come to the practice of the apostolic age. They claim there is no instance of anyone admitted to baptism without first professing faith and repentance. When Peter's hearers, cut to the heart, asked, "What shall we do?", he answered, "Repent and be baptised every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins" (Acts 2:37-38). When the eunuch asked Philip to baptise him, Philip said, "If you believe with all your heart, you may" (Acts 8:36-37). From this they think they can prove that baptism can't lawfully be given to anyone without prior faith and repentance.
If we yield to this argument, the first passage, which doesn't mention faith, would prove that repentance alone is enough, and the second, which doesn't demand repentance, that faith alone is needed. They'll say, I suppose, that each passage helps the other and the two must be joined. I in turn say these two must be compared with other passages that help solve the difficulty. Many passages of Scripture depend for their meaning on their particular setting, and this is one.
Those to whom Peter and Philip spoke were of an age to turn from sin and receive faith. We firmly insist that such people are not to be baptised unless their conversion and faith can be recognised, at least as far as human judgment can tell. But infants are plainly in a different class. When someone in former times joined the religious community of Israel, he had to be taught the covenant and instructed in the Lord's law before he received circumcision, because he came from another nation. In other words, he was a stranger to the people of Israel, with whom the covenant that circumcision confirmed had been made.
24. Adult converts versus the children of believers
So when the Lord chose Abraham for himself, he didn't begin with circumcision while hiding what the sign meant. He first announced that he meant to make a covenant with him, and after Abraham believed the promise, he made him a sharer in the sacrament. Why does the sacrament come after faith in Abraham, yet before any understanding in his son Isaac? It is right that someone who in adult years is admitted to the fellowship of a covenant by one from whom he was formerly estranged should first learn its terms. It is different with the infant born to him. By the terms of the promise, that child is included in the promise by hereditary right from his mother's womb.
To put it more briefly and clearly: if the children of believers share in the covenant without the help of understanding, there is no reason to deny them the sign merely because they can't swear to its terms. This is no doubt why the Lord sometimes declares that the children born to the Israelites were borne and begotten to him (Ezek. 16:20; 23:37). He gives the place of sons to the children of those to whose seed he has promised to be a Father. But a child descended from unbelieving parents is counted a stranger to the covenant until he is united to God by faith. So it isn't strange that the sign is withheld when the thing signified would be empty and deceptive. In this sense Paul says the Gentiles, while they were sunk in idolatry, were strangers to the covenant (Eph. 2:11).
The whole matter can be stated, if I'm not mistaken, briefly and clearly like this. Those who embrace the faith of Christ in adult years, having until then been strangers to the covenant, are not to receive the sign of baptism without prior faith and repentance. These alone can give them access to the fellowship of the covenant. But children born of Christians are received by God as heirs of the covenant the moment they are born, and so they are to be admitted to baptism.
The Evangelist's account that those baptised by John confessed their sins (Matt. 3:6) belongs here. We hold that this example should be followed today. If a Turk offered himself for baptism, we wouldn't perform the rite without a confession satisfactory to the Church.
25. "Born of water and the Spirit"
Another passage they bring is from John 3, where our Saviour's words seem to them to require a present regeneration in baptism: "Unless one is born of water and the Spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God" (John 3:5). Here, they say, baptism is called regeneration by our Lord's own lips, so on what grounds, and with what consistency, is baptism given to those who obviously can't be regenerated?
First, they are mistaken in thinking baptism is mentioned here simply because the word "water" appears. After our Saviour had explained the corruption of nature and the need to be born again, Nicodemus kept dreaming of a physical birth. So our Saviour tells him the way God regenerates us, by water and the Spirit, that is, by the Spirit, who in watering and cleansing the souls of believers does the work of water. By "water and the Spirit" I simply understand "the Spirit, who is water." The expression isn't new. It agrees perfectly with Matthew 3: "He will baptise you with the Holy Spirit and fire" (Matt. 3:11). As to baptise with the Holy Spirit and fire is to give the Spirit, who in regeneration has the office and nature of fire, so to be born again of water and the Spirit is nothing other than to receive the Spirit's power, which has the same effect on the soul that water has on the body. I know a different interpretation is given, but I have no doubt this is the true meaning, because our Saviour's only purpose was to teach that all who aspire to the kingdom of heaven must put off their own nature.
And if we wanted to imitate these people's way of quibbling, we could easily grant what they want and answer that baptism comes before faith and repentance, since in this passage our Saviour mentions water before the Spirit. This must certainly be understood of spiritual gifts, and if those follow baptism, I've gained all I contend for. But quibbling aside, the plain interpretation is the one I've given: nobody can enter the kingdom of God until renewed by living water, which is the Spirit.
26. The unbaptised are not necessarily lost
This also plainly blows away the fiction of those who consign all the unbaptised to eternal death. Suppose, as they insist, that baptism is given only to adults. What will they say of a young person who, after being properly taught the basics of godliness, is carried off by sudden death while waiting for the day of his baptism? The Lord's promise is clear: "Whoever hears my word and believes him who sent me has eternal life. He does not come into judgment, but has passed from death to life" (John 5:24). We never read that he condemned someone for not yet being baptised.
I don't want to be understood as suggesting that baptism can be despised with impunity. So far from excusing such contempt, I hold that it violates the Lord's covenant. The point is only that we mustn't regard baptism as so necessary that everyone who loses the chance to receive it has immediately perished. If we accepted their fiction, we would condemn without exception everyone prevented by some accident from receiving baptism, however richly they had the faith by which Christ himself is possessed.
Besides, if baptism is necessary for salvation, as they hold, then by denying it to infants they consign every one of them to eternal death. Let them consider how that agrees with Christ's words, "to such belongs the kingdom of heaven" (Matt. 19:14). And even if we conceded them everything about the meaning of John 3:5, they would get nothing from it until they had first overthrown the doctrine we've already established about the regeneration of infants.
27. The great commission, and Christ's own baptism
They boast that their strongest fortress is the very institution of baptism, which they find in the last chapter of Matthew, where Christ sends his disciples into all the world and tells them to teach and then baptise. Mark 16 adds, "Whoever believes and is baptised will be saved" (Mark 16:16). What more do we ask, they say, when Christ's words plainly declare that teaching must come first and baptism follow faith? Our Lord himself gave an example of this order, they add, by choosing not to be baptised until his thirtieth year.
In how many ways they tangle themselves up here, and show their ignorance! They err worse than children in deriving the first institution of baptism from this passage, when Christ had ordered the apostles to administer it from the start of his ministry. So there's no ground for insisting that the law and rule of baptism must be sought in these two passages as though they were the original institution.
But even granting them their mistake, how feeble the argument is! If I wanted to evade, I'd have not just an escape route but a wide field to roam. They cling desperately to the order of the words. Because it says "Go, preach and baptise," and again "Whoever believes and is baptised," they insist on preaching before baptising and believing before being baptised. By the same logic we could answer that they must baptise before teaching people to observe what Christ commanded, because it says "baptising them... teaching them to observe all that I have commanded you." The same applies to the other passage about being born of water and the Spirit. If we interpret as they insist, baptism must come before spiritual regeneration because it's mentioned first. Yet Christ doesn't say we are born again of the Spirit and water, but of water and the Spirit.
28. The commission speaks of those old enough to be taught
That bulletproof argument of theirs already seems considerably shaken. But since the plain truth gives us enough protection, I'm unwilling to dodge the point with cheap subtleties. Let them have a solid answer.
The command Christ gives here chiefly concerns the preaching of the gospel, and baptism is added as a kind of appendage. He speaks of baptism only as its administration is subordinate to the work of teaching. Christ sends his disciples to publish the gospel to all the nations of the world so that, by the doctrine of salvation, they may gather into his kingdom people who were lost. But who are these people? Clearly only those capable of receiving his teaching are in view. He adds that such people, once taught, are to be baptised, and he adds the promise, "Whoever believes and is baptised will be saved." Is there a syllable about infants in the whole passage?
What form does their argument take, then? Adults must be instructed and brought to faith before being baptised, and therefore it is wrong to make baptism common to infants. At the very most they can prove from this passage only that the gospel must be preached before baptism to those capable of hearing it, for only of such does the passage speak. Let them, if they can, build an obstacle to baptising infants out of that.
29. A plain comparison, and Christ's thirtieth year
I'll make their fallacies obvious even to the blind with a very simple comparison. Suppose someone insisted that infants be starved on the pretext that the apostle lets only those who work eat (2 Thess. 3:10). Wouldn't everyone ridicule him? Why? Because what was said of one class of people and one age he twists to apply to everybody. These people are no more skilful here. What anyone can see is meant only for adult age, they apply to infants, laying on them a rule laid down only for people of riper years.
As for our Saviour's example, it gives them no support. He wasn't baptised before his thirtieth year. True, but the reason is clear. He was then setting out to lay the solid foundation of baptism by his preaching, or rather to confirm the foundation John had already laid. So when he was pleased to institute baptism by his teaching, he sanctified it in his own person, and did so at the most fitting time, the start of his ministry, to give his institution greater authority. They can prove only that baptism began along with the preaching of the gospel. And if they are set on the thirtieth year, why don't they keep to it, instead of admitting anyone to baptism according to their own view of his progress? Even Servetus, one of their masters, who stubbornly insisted on this age, had begun to play the prophet in his twenty-first year. As though anyone could be tolerated in claiming a teacher's office in the Church before being a member of the Church!
30. Why baptism but not the Lord's Supper for infants
Finally they object that there is no stronger reason to admit infants to baptism than to the Lord's Supper, and yet they are never admitted to the Supper. As though Scripture didn't draw a wide distinction between the two in every way!
In the early Church the Lord's Supper was often given to infants, as Cyprian and Augustine show, but the practice rightly died out. If we look at the particular nature of baptism, it is a kind of entrance and initiation into the Church, by which we are counted among God's people. It is a sign of our spiritual regeneration, by which we are born again as God's children. The Supper, on the other hand, is meant for people of riper years, who have passed tender infancy and can take solid food.
Scripture draws this distinction very clearly. As far as baptism goes, the Lord makes no selection by age. But he doesn't admit everyone to the Supper. He limits it to those who can discern the Lord's body and blood, examine their own consciences, proclaim the Lord's death, and understand its power. Could we want anything clearer than the apostle's exhortation, "Let a person examine himself, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup" (1 Cor. 11:28)? Examination must come first, and it would be pointless to expect it from infants. And again, "Whoever eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment on himself" (1 Cor. 11:29). If they can't take part worthily without being able to discern the holiness of the Lord's body, why would we hold out poison to our little children in place of life-giving food? And what does the Lord command? "Do this in remembrance of me." What does the apostle conclude from that? "As often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord's death until he comes." How can we require infants to remember an event they know nothing about, or to proclaim the Lord's death when they have no idea of its nature or benefit? Baptism requires nothing of the kind.
So the two signs differ enormously. We see the same difference in the corresponding signs under the old dispensation. Circumcision, which as is well known corresponds to our baptism, was intended for infants. But the Passover, whose place the Supper has taken, didn't admit every sort of guest. It was properly eaten only by those old enough to ask what it meant (Exod. 12:26). If these people had the least bit of soundness in their brains, would they be so blind to something so clear and plain?
31. The arguments of Servetus
I'm reluctant to bother the reader with the string of fancies that Servetus, no small figure among the Anabaptists and indeed the great pride of that crowd, thought were impressive when he armed himself for battle. But it's worth answering them briefly. I'll give his main points and my replies.
He says that because Christ's sacraments are perfect, they require people who are perfect, or at least capable of perfection. The answer is plain. The perfection of baptism, which extends to death, is wrongly confined to one moment, and the perfection to which baptism calls us to advance throughout life is foolishly demanded by him all at once.
He says Christ's sacraments were appointed for remembrance, so that everyone may remember being buried with Christ. I answer that this is his own invention, and anyway what he transfers to baptism belongs properly to the Supper, as Paul's words "let a person examine himself" show. Nothing like that is said of baptism. So those too young to examine themselves are rightly baptised.
His third point is that everyone who doesn't believe in the Son remains in death and the wrath of God rests on them (John 3:36), so infants, who can't believe, lie under condemnation. I answer that Christ isn't speaking there of the general guilt of Adam's whole posterity, but threatening those who despise the gospel and proudly and stubbornly reject the grace offered. That has nothing to do with infants. And I can turn the argument around. Everyone whom Christ blesses is freed from Adam's curse and God's wrath. Since infants are certainly blessed by him, they are freed from death.
He next quotes a text that appears nowhere in Scripture: "Whoever is born of the Spirit hears the voice of the Spirit." Even if such a passage existed, all he could extract is that believers are shaped to obedience as the Spirit works in them. But what is said of some it is illogical to apply to all.
His fourth objection is that "the natural comes first" (1 Cor. 15:46), so we must wait the full time for baptism, which is spiritual. I admit that all Adam's descendants, born of the flesh, carry their condemnation from the womb. But that is no obstacle to the immediate application of the divine remedy. Servetus can't show that God has appointed several years to pass before the new spiritual life begins. Paul testifies that though lost by nature, the children of believers are holy by supernatural grace.
He then offers the allegory that David, going up Mount Zion, took with him neither the blind nor the lame but strong soldiers (2 Sam. 5:8). What if I meet that with the parable in which God invites the lame and the blind to the heavenly feast? How will Servetus untie that knot? Another allegory says the apostles were fishers of men, not of children. I ask what our Saviour means when he says the net catches fish of every kind (Matt. 13:47). But since I take no pleasure in playing with allegories, I simply say: when the office of teaching was given to the apostles, they were not forbidden to baptise infants. And I'd like to know why, when the Evangelist uses a word that covers the whole human race without exception, Servetus says infants aren't included.
He argues that since spiritual things go with spiritual (1 Cor. 2:13), infants, not being spiritual, are unfit for baptism. It is plain how perversely he twists Paul. That passage concerns doctrine. The Corinthians were puffed up with a vain cleverness, and Paul rebukes their folly because they still needed the first rudiments of heavenly teaching. Who could infer from this that baptism must be denied to infants, whom the Lord, though born of the flesh, consecrates to himself by free adoption?
His objection that, if infants are new people, they must be fed spiritual food is easily met. By baptism they are admitted into Christ's fold, and the sign of adoption is enough for them until they grow up and can take solid food. We must wait for the time of examination that God plainly requires in the Supper. He says Christ invites all his people to the Supper. But since it is plain that he admits only those prepared to celebrate the remembrance of his death, it follows that infants, whom he honoured with his embrace, stand in a distinct position until they grow up, yet are not strangers. When he objects that it's strange for an infant not to partake of the Supper, I answer that souls are fed by other food than the outward eating of the Supper, and so Christ is the food of infants even though they don't take the sign. It is different with baptism, which opens the door of the Church to them.
He says a good householder gives his household food at the proper time (Matt. 24:45). I gladly agree, but how will he fix the time of baptism so as to prove it isn't given to infants at the right time? He cites Christ's command to the apostles to hurry because the fields are white for harvest (John 4:35). Our Saviour only means that, seeing the present fruit of their labour, the apostles should teach with more energy. Who can infer from that that only harvest time is fit for baptism?
His eleventh argument is that in the early Church Christians and disciples were the same. But he reasons clumsily from part to whole. The name "disciples" was given to adults who had already been taught and had taken Christ's name, just as the Jews had to be disciples under Moses' law. Nobody can rightly infer from this that infants, whom the Lord declared to be of his household, are outsiders. He also says all Christians are brothers and infants can't be among them while we exclude them from the Supper. I return to my position: first, that only members of Christ are heirs of the kingdom of heaven; and second, that Christ's embrace was the true badge of adoption, in which infants share equally with adults, and that temporary abstinence from the Supper doesn't stop them belonging to the body of the Church. The thief on the cross, once converted, became a brother of believers though he never took the Lord's Supper.
Servetus adds that nobody becomes our brother except through the Spirit of adoption, who is given only through the hearing of faith. I answer that he keeps falling into the same fallacy, wrongly applying to infants what is said only of adults. Paul is teaching there the ordinary way God calls his elect and brings them to faith: by raising up faithful teachers and so reaching out his hand to them through their labours. Who will presume from this to lay down the law for God and say he may not graft infants into Christ by some other secret means?
He objects that Cornelius was baptised after receiving the Holy Spirit. But how absurd to turn a single example into a general rule is clear from the eunuch and the Samaritans, where the Lord followed a different order, with baptism coming before the gifts of the Holy Spirit.
His fifteenth argument is worse than absurd. He says we become gods by regeneration, but that those are gods to whom the word of God comes (John 10:35; 2 Pet. 1:4), which infants cannot be. His attributing deity to believers is one of his ravings, and this is not the place to discuss it. But it is the height of effrontery to twist the passage in the Psalm (Ps. 82:6) to so foreign a meaning. Christ says that kings and magistrates are called gods by the prophet because they carry out an office appointed by God. This clever interpreter transfers what was said by special command to certain individuals to the doctrine of the gospel, in order to wipe infants out of the Church.
He objects that infants cannot be reckoned new people because they aren't begotten by the word. I say again what I've said repeatedly: doctrine is an incorruptible seed for regenerating us, if we are capable of receiving it. When we are too young to be taught, God uses his own methods of regenerating.
He goes back to allegory and says that under the law the sheep and goat were not offered the moment they were dropped (Exod. 12:5). If I wanted to deal in figures, I could reply, first, that every firstborn that opened the womb was holy to the Lord (Exod. 13:12), and second, that a lamb a year old was to be sacrificed. So it was not necessary to wait for mature age, and God chose the young and tender offspring for sacrifice.
He argues that nobody could come to Christ except those John had prepared, as though John's ministry weren't temporary. In any case, there was surely no such preparation in the children Christ took in his arms and blessed.
At last he calls in Hermes Trismegistus and the Sibyls to prove that holy washings are fit only for adults. See how highly he thinks of Christian baptism when he tests it by the profane rites of the heathen and won't have it administered except in the way Trismegistus approves! We defer more to the authority of God, who has seen fit to consecrate infants to himself and initiate them by a sacred sign whose meaning they are too young to understand. We don't think it lawful to borrow from the purifications of the heathen to change, in our baptism, the eternal and inviolable law God established in circumcision.
His last argument is that if infants without understanding may be baptised, baptism could be mimicked and administered in jest by boys at play. Let him argue that with God, by whose command circumcision was given to infants before they had understanding. Was it a fit subject for ridicule or boyish play, then, to overthrow God's sacred institution? But no wonder these reprobate minds, as if gripped by frenzy, bring forward the grossest absurdities in defence of their errors, since God by this spirit of giddiness justly punishes their pride and obstinacy. I trust I have shown how feebly Servetus has supported his friends the Anabaptists.
32. What Satan is after, and what we owe our children
No sound person, I think, can now doubt how rashly the Church is disturbed by those who stir up quarrels and troubles over infant baptism. It's important to see what Satan has in mind with all this craft. He means to rob us of the unique blessing of confidence and spiritual joy that comes from it, and so to detract from the glory of God's goodness. How sweet it is for godly minds to be assured, not only by word but by what they can see with their eyes, that they are so much in their heavenly Father's favour that he concerns himself with their families' welfare! Here we see how he acts toward us as a most caring parent, who doesn't stop caring for us even after our death but consults and provides for our children. Shouldn't our whole heart be stirred within us, as David's was (Ps. 48:11), to bless his name for such a display of goodness?
There's no doubt that Satan's purpose in attacking infant baptism with all his forces is to hide from view, and gradually erase, the witness of divine grace which the promise itself sets before our eyes. In that way people would not only be wickedly ungrateful for God's mercy, but also less careful in training their children in godliness. It is no small spur to bringing them up in the fear of God and in obedience to his law to reflect that from their birth he has regarded and acknowledged them as his children. So if we don't want to obscure God's kindness out of malice, let's present our infants to him, to whom he has given a place among his friends and household, which is to say, among the members of the Church.
Chapter 17
The Lord's Supper and the Benefits It Gives
1. Why Christ gave us the Holy Supper
Once God has received us into his family, he doesn't treat us as servants but as sons. He plays the part of a kind and anxious father and provides for us through the whole course of our lives. And he isn't content with that. He has been pleased to give us a pledge that his generosity will continue. For this purpose he gave his Church a second sacrament through his only-begotten Son: a spiritual feast at which Christ testifies that he himself is the living bread (John 6:51), on which our souls feed for a true and blessed immortality.
The knowledge of this great mystery is essential, and its importance demands an accurate explanation. Satan, to rob the Church of this priceless treasure, long ago spread first mists and then darkness over its light. He stirred up strife and controversy to turn simple people away from any taste for this sacred food, and in our own day he has tried the same trick. So I'll begin with a plain summary suited to the unlearned, and then deal with the difficulties by which Satan has tried to trap the world.
The signs are bread and wine, which represent the invisible food we receive from the body and blood of Christ. In baptism God regenerates us, grafts us into the fellowship of his Church and makes us his by adoption. In the same way, as a provident father, he now keeps supplying the food that sustains and preserves us in the life to which his word has given birth. Christ is the only food of our soul, so our heavenly Father invites us to him, so that, refreshed by communion with him, we may gather new strength again and again until we reach heavenly immortality.
But the secret union of Christ with believers is beyond our natural grasp. So he gives us its picture and image in visible signs suited to our capacity. He gives us, as it were, pledges and badges, and makes the thing as certain to us as if we saw it with our eyes. The familiarity of the comparison reaches even dull minds, and shows that souls are fed by Christ just as bodily life is sustained by bread and wine.
So we can see what this mystical blessing is for. It assures us that the body of Christ was sacrificed once for us, so that we may now eat it, and in eating feel the power of that one sacrifice within us. His blood was shed once for us, to be our permanent drink. That is the force of the promise attached to it: "Take, eat; this is my body, which is broken for you" (Matt. 26:26). We are told to take and eat the body that was once offered for our salvation, so that when we see ourselves sharing in it, we can be sure the power of that death will work in us. That is why he calls the cup the covenant in his blood. The covenant he once sealed with his blood, he in a sense renews, or rather continues, as far as the strengthening of our faith is concerned, every time he holds out his sacred blood to us as drink.
2. What godly souls gain from it
Devout people can draw great confidence and joy from this sacrament, because it testifies that they form one body with Christ, so that everything he has they may call their own. It follows that we can be confident that eternal life, of which he himself is heir, is ours, and that the kingdom of heaven he has entered can no more be taken from us than from him. In the same way, we can't be condemned for our sins, since he absolves us from their guilt and has been pleased to have them counted as his own.
This is the wonderful exchange his boundless goodness has made. He became Son of Man with us, and made us sons of God with him. By coming down to earth he prepared our ascent to heaven. By taking on our mortality he gave us his immortality. By accepting our weakness he made us strong in his strength. By submitting to our poverty he passed his riches to us. By taking on himself the burden of unrighteousness that crushed us, he clothed us with his righteousness.
3. The sacrament attests all of this
This sacrament gives us full assurance of all these things. We can be as certain that they are given to us as if Christ were standing bodily before our eyes or we could touch him with our hands. These are words that can never lie or deceive: "Take, eat, drink. This is my body, which is broken for you; this is my blood, which is shed for the forgiveness of sins." In telling us to take, he says it is ours. In telling us to eat, he says it becomes one substance with us. In saying his body was broken and his blood shed for us, he shows that both were not so much his own as ours, because he took them and gave them up not for his own benefit but for our salvation.
We should notice carefully that the main force of the sacrament, almost all of it, lies in the words "It is broken for you" and "It is shed for you." It wouldn't matter much to us that the Lord's body and blood are handed out now if they hadn't once been offered for our redemption. That's why they're represented under bread and wine. We learn that they are not only ours but meant to nourish our spiritual life. By the physical things in the sacrament we are led, by a kind of analogy, to spiritual things. When bread is given as a symbol of Christ's body, we should immediately think of this comparison: as bread nourishes, sustains and protects our bodily life, so Christ's body is the only food that strengthens and keeps the soul alive. When we see wine set out as the symbol of blood, we should think that whatever wine does for the body, the blood of Christ does for the soul. It nourishes, refreshes, strengthens and gladdens. If we consider what we've gained from the breaking of his body and the shedding of his blood, we'll see that these properties of bread and wine are a fitting picture of it.
4. The sacrament sends us to the cross
So the main purpose of a sacrament isn't simply to hold out Christ's body to us without any deeper meaning. It is to seal and confirm the promise by which he declares that his flesh is real food and his blood real drink, nourishing us to eternal life, and that he is the bread of life, so that whoever eats of it will live for ever. To seal that promise, the sacrament sends us to the cross of Christ, where the promise was fulfilled in every part. We don't eat Christ rightly and to our salvation unless we eat him as crucified, grasping with a living faith the power of his death.
When he called himself the bread of life, he didn't take that title from the sacrament, as some wrongly claim. He was this bread as the Father gave him to us, and he showed himself to be this when he shared our mortal humanity and made us sharers of his divine immortality; when he offered himself in sacrifice and took our curse on himself to cover us with his blessing; when by his death he swallowed up death; and when in his resurrection he raised to glory and incorruption the perishable flesh he had put on.
5. How Christ becomes ours, and two faults to avoid
What remains is that all this becomes ours by application. That happens through the gospel, and more clearly through the sacred Supper, where Christ offers himself to us with all his blessings and we receive him by faith. So the sacrament doesn't make Christ the bread of life for the first time. It reminds us that he was made the bread of life so that we might eat him continually. It gives us a taste of that bread and makes us feel its power. It assures us, first, that everything Christ did and suffered was done to give us life, and second, that this life-giving is eternal. By it we are ceaselessly nourished, sustained and kept alive. Christ wouldn't have been bread of life for us if he hadn't been born, died and risen. And he couldn't be that bread now if the power and fruit of his birth, death and resurrection weren't eternal.
Christ put all this well: "The bread that I will give for the life of the world is my flesh" (John 6:51). He means that his body would be like bread for the spiritual life of the soul, because it was to be handed over to death for our salvation, and that he holds it out to us as food when he makes us share in it by faith. So he gave himself once, to become bread, when he gave himself to be crucified for the world's redemption. He gives himself daily when, in the word of the gospel, he offers himself to be received by us as the crucified one. He does it when he seals that offer in the sacred mystery of the Supper, and when he accomplishes inwardly what he shows outwardly.
Two faults must be avoided here. We must not undervalue the signs and cut them off from the meanings they are in some way tied to. Nor must we exaggerate them so much that we seem to obscure the mysteries themselves.
No one is so irreligious as to deny that Christ is the bread of life that feeds believers to eternal life. But not everyone agrees on how we partake of him. Some say that eating Christ's flesh and drinking his blood is simply believing in him. But it seems to me that in that great discourse Christ meant something more definite and more exalted. He meant that we are given life by truly sharing in him, and he called this eating and drinking so that no one would suppose the life we get from him comes by bare knowledge. Bread nourishes the body by being eaten, not by being looked at. In the same way the soul must really and fully share in Christ, so that his power may build it up into spiritual life.
At the same time we admit that this is nothing other than the eating of faith, and that no other eating can be imagined. But there is a difference between their way of speaking and mine. For them, to eat is simply to believe. I say that Christ's flesh is eaten by believing, because faith makes it ours, and that this eating is the effect and fruit of faith. Put more plainly: for them, eating is faith; to me it seems to be a consequence of faith. The difference is small in words but not in substance. The apostle teaches that Christ dwells in our hearts by faith (Eph. 3:17), yet no one will take that dwelling to be faith itself. Everyone sees that it describes the wonderful effect of faith, which is that believers have Christ dwelling in them. In the same way the Lord, by calling himself the bread of life, taught us not only that our salvation is stored up in faith in his death and resurrection, but also that through real communion with him his life passes into us and becomes ours, just as bread taken as food gives strength to the body.
6. Augustine and Chrysostom on this eating
Augustine, whom my opponents claim as their patron, wrote that we eat by believing. All he meant was that this eating is of faith and not of the mouth. I don't deny that. But I add that by faith we embrace Christ not as one who appears at a distance but as one who unites himself to us, so that he is our head and we are his members. I don't entirely disapprove of that way of speaking. I only deny that it is a full account if they mean it to define what eating Christ's flesh is.
Augustine uses the expression often. In On Christian Doctrine (Book 3) he says that "Unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man" is a figure that tells us to share in our Lord's passion and to store up in memory, with sweetness and profit, that his flesh was crucified and wounded for us. He also says that the three thousand converted at Peter's preaching (Acts 2:41), by believing, drank the blood they had cruelly shed. But in very many other places he praises faith because through it our souls are refreshed by the communion of Christ's blood no less than our bodies are by the bread they eat. Chrysostom says the same: "Christ makes us his body, not by faith only, but in reality." He doesn't mean that we receive this blessing from anywhere but faith. He only wants to stop anyone from thinking of mere imagination when they hear the word faith.
I say nothing here about those who hold that the Supper is merely a mark of outward profession. I think I answered that error well enough when I treated the sacraments in general (Chapter 14, section 13). My readers should simply notice that when the cup is called the covenant in his blood (Luke 22:20), a promise is stated whose purpose is to strengthen faith. It follows that unless we look to God and embrace what he offers, we don't use the sacred Supper rightly.
7. More than a communion of the Spirit alone
I'm not satisfied with the view of those who admit we have some kind of communion with Christ but make us sharers only of his Spirit, saying nothing of his flesh and blood. Was it said for no reason that his flesh is real food and his blood real drink, and that we have no life unless we eat that flesh and drink that blood? If it's clear that full communion with Christ goes beyond their account, which is too narrow, I'll try briefly to show how far it extends, before I move on to the opposite fault of excess.
I'll have a longer argument with the extravagant teachers who, out of their crude notions, invent an absurd way of eating and drinking and turn Christ, stripped of his flesh, into a phantom. If it is even right to put this great mystery into words, I have to say that I feel it, and so freely admit that I can't comprehend it with my mind. I'm far from wanting anyone to measure its height by my small capacity. I'd rather urge my readers not to confine their thinking within such narrow limits, and to try to rise much higher than I can lead them. Whenever I consider this subject, after doing my utmost I feel I've spoken far beneath its dignity. The mind can think more than the tongue can say, but even the mind is overwhelmed by the greatness of the subject. All that's left is to break out in wonder at a mystery that the mind can't take in and the tongue can't express. Still, I'll give a summary of my view as best I can. I don't doubt it's true, and so I trust that devout hearts will not reject it.
8. Life in the flesh of Christ
First, Scripture teaches that from the beginning Christ was the living Word of the Father, the fountain and source of life, from which everything receives life. So John calls him at one point the Word of life, and at another says that in him was life. He means that even then Christ pervaded all creatures and breathed into them the power of living. John then adds that the life was finally made manifest when the Son of God took our nature and showed himself in bodily form, to be seen and touched. Christ had always poured his power into creatures. But man, cut off from God by sin, had lost his share in life and saw death hanging over him on every side. To regain the hope of immortality he needed to be restored to communion with that Word. How much confidence can it give you to know that the Word of God, from whom you are at the greatest distance, holds the fullness of life in himself, when in yourself, wherever you look, you see only death?
But since that fountain of life began to live in our nature, he no longer hides far from us. He shows himself openly, to be shared. More than that, he makes the very flesh in which he lives life-giving for us, so that by sharing in it we may be fed for immortality. "I am the bread of life," he says. "I am the living bread that came down from heaven." "The bread that I will give for the life of the world is my flesh" (John 6:48, 51). By these words he declares that he is life not only as the eternal Word of God who came down to us from heaven, but also that by coming down he gave strength to the flesh he took on, so that a communication of life to us could flow from it. That is why he adds that his flesh is real food and his blood real drink. By this food believers are raised to eternal life.
So godly people have wonderful comfort in this: they now find life in their own flesh. They don't have to reach for it by some difficult route. It is set out freely before them. They only need to open the door of their hearts and take it in, and they will have it.
9. How the flesh of Christ gives life
Christ's flesh doesn't have the power in itself to make us live. In its first condition it was subject to mortality, and even now that it is clothed with immortality it doesn't live of itself. Yet it is rightly called life-giving, because it is filled with the fullness of life in order to pass that life on to us. That's how I understand our Saviour's words, as Cyril does: "As the Father has life in himself, so he has granted the Son also to have life in himself" (John 5:26). There he is speaking not of the properties he had with the Father from the beginning, but of those he received in the flesh in which he appeared. He shows that the fullness of life is in his humanity too, so that everyone who shares in his flesh and blood enjoys a share in life at the same time.
A familiar example explains it. Water is sometimes drunk straight from the spring, sometimes drawn, sometimes led off by channels to irrigate fields. It doesn't flow out by itself for all these uses. It is taken from its source, which with a constant flow keeps sending out a fresh and sufficient supply. In the same way the flesh of Christ is a rich and inexhaustible fountain, which pours into us the life that flows into it from the Godhead.
Who can't see that the communion of Christ's flesh and blood is necessary for everyone who longs for heavenly life? This is behind the apostle's statements that the Church is Christ's body and his fullness. He is the head, "from whom the whole body, joined and held together by every joint with which it is equipped, ... makes the body grow" (Eph. 1:23; 4:15-16). Our bodies are "members of Christ" (1 Cor. 6:15). None of this can happen unless he clings to us wholly, in body and spirit. The apostle describes the close tie that unites us to his flesh in even grander terms when he says that we are "members of his body, of his flesh and of his bones" (Eph. 5:30). Finally, to show that the matter is too high for words, he ends with the cry, "This mystery is profound" (Eph. 5:32). It would be extreme folly not to acknowledge the believers' communion with the Lord's body and blood, a communion the apostle says is so great that he would rather marvel at it than explain it.
10. Distance in space is no obstacle
In sum, the flesh and blood of Christ feed our souls just as bread and wine maintain our bodily life. The sign would not fit if our souls did not find their nourishment in Christ. And that couldn't be unless Christ truly became one with us and refreshed us by the eating of his flesh and the drinking of his blood.
It may seem incredible that Christ's flesh, so far from us in terms of place, should be food for us. But let's remember how far the secret power of the Holy Spirit surpasses everything we can conceive, and how foolish it is to try to measure its vastness by our small capacity. What our mind can't grasp, let faith conceive: the Spirit truly unites things that are separated by space. Christ testifies and seals in the Supper that sacred communion of flesh and blood by which he pours his life into us, as if it penetrated our bones and marrow. He doesn't do this by holding out a vain or empty sign, but by exercising there an effective power of the Spirit by which he fulfils what he promises. The thing signified there he truly offers to all who sit down at that spiritual feast, though only believers receive it with benefit, since only they receive this great gift with true faith and thankfulness.
That's why the apostle says, "The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ?" (1 Cor. 10:16). It's no objection that this is figurative language, giving the sign the name of the thing signified. I grant that the breaking of bread is a symbol and not the reality. But granting that, we rightly infer from the offering of the symbol that the thing itself is offered. Unless we want to accuse God of deceit, we'll never dare to say that he holds out an empty symbol. So if the Lord truly represents the partaking of his body by the breaking of bread, there should be no doubt that he truly offers and carries it out.
The rule godly people should always keep is this: whenever they see the symbols the Lord has instituted, they should think and be fully persuaded that the truth of the thing signified is present too. Why does the Lord put the symbol of his body into your hands, if not to assure you that you truly share in him? If that is so, let us be as sure that the visible sign is given as a seal of an invisible gift as that his body itself is given to us.
11. Summary of the first part: the sign and the truth
My position, then, is this. It has always been received in the Church, and is still taught by those who think rightly. The sacred mystery of the Supper consists of two things: the physical signs, which are set before the eyes and represent invisible things in a way suited to our weak capacity, and the spiritual truth, which is both pictured and offered by the signs.
When I try to explain its nature plainly, I'm used to setting out three things: the thing meant, the matter that depends on it, and the power that follows from both. The thing meant is the promises, which are in a sense contained in the sign. The matter, or substance, is Christ, with his death and resurrection. The effect is redemption, justification, sanctification, eternal life and all the other benefits Christ gives us.
All these things relate to faith. But I leave no room for the objection that when I say Christ is grasped by faith, I mean he is grasped only by the intellect and imagination. He is offered in the promises, not so that we should stop at seeing him or knowing about him, but so that we may enjoy true communion with him. I don't see how anyone can hope for redemption and righteousness in the cross of Christ, and life in his death, without first trusting in true communion with Christ himself. Those blessings couldn't reach us unless Christ first made himself ours.
So I say that in the mystery of the Supper, through the symbols of bread and wine, Christ, his body and his blood, are truly offered to us. In them he fulfilled all obedience to win righteousness for us. The aim is first that we should become one body with him, and then that, made sharers of his substance, we should feel the result in a share of all his blessings.
12. Against a local presence in the bread
Now I come to the extravagant mixtures that superstition has introduced. Here Satan has used every trick to pull people's minds away from heaven and fill them with the perverse idea that Christ is attached to the element of bread.
First, we shouldn't dream of the kind of presence the Roman court's schoolmen have imagined, as if Christ's body were locally present, to be picked up in the hand, chewed with the teeth and swallowed down the throat. This was the form of retraction Pope Nicholas dictated to Berengarius as a sign of his repentance. It was worded so monstrously that the author of the Gloss admits that unless the reader is very careful, it will lead him into a worse heresy than Berengarius's. Peter Lombard works hard to excuse the absurdity, but he leans toward a different view.
We can't doubt that Christ's body is limited by the settled rule that belongs to a human body, and that it is contained in heaven, where it was once received and where it will stay until he returns to judge. So we think it altogether wrong to bring it back under these perishable elements, or to imagine it present everywhere. And we don't need to, in order to share in it. By his Spirit the Lord gives us the blessing of being one with him in soul, body and spirit. The bond of that connection is the Spirit of Christ, who unites us to him and is a kind of channel through which everything Christ has and is flows to us. We see the sun send its rays to the earth to generate, nourish and strengthen what grows there, and in a way pour its substance into it. Why would the radiance of the Spirit be any less able to convey to us the communion of Christ's flesh and blood? That's why Scripture, when it speaks of our sharing in Christ, credits the whole effect to the Spirit. One passage will do in place of many. In Romans 8:9-11 Paul shows that the only way Christ lives in us is by his Spirit. He doesn't thereby remove the communion of flesh and blood we're speaking of. He shows that it is by the Spirit alone that we possess Christ whole and have him abiding in us.
13. The schoolmen's refinements
The schoolmen are horrified at this crude impiety and speak more modestly, but they only amuse themselves with subtler illusions. They admit that Christ isn't contained in the sacrament bodily or as if enclosed in a place. But then they devise a method they don't understand themselves and can't explain to others. It comes to this: Christ may be sought in what they call the "species" of bread. When they say the substance of bread is converted into Christ, don't they attach him to the white colour, which is all they leave of the bread? They say that although he is contained in the sacrament, he still remains in heaven and is present in the sacrament only in the way of an abode. But whatever words they dress it in, the sum is that what was bread becomes Christ by consecration, so that Christ afterwards lies hidden under the appearance of bread. They aren't ashamed to say this outright. Lombard writes that the body of Christ, which is visible in itself, "lurks and lies covered after consecration under the species of bread." So the shape of the bread is nothing but a mask that hides his flesh from our eyes.
It isn't hard to see the trap in this. The superstition under which not only the common people but their leaders too have laboured for many ages, and still labour, is plain. They care little for true faith, by which alone we come into fellowship with Christ and become one with him. As long as they have a fleshly presence of him, which they invented without any warrant from the word, they think he is present enough. All their cleverness has gained is that bread is treated as God.
14. Transubstantiation and the testimony of antiquity
From this came the invented doctrine of transubstantiation, for which they now fight more fiercely than for all the other articles of their faith. The first builders of a local presence couldn't explain how Christ's body could be mixed with the substance of bread without running into many absurdities. So they had to take refuge in the fiction that the bread is converted into the body. They didn't mean that the body properly takes the place of the bread, but that Christ, to hide himself under the form, reduces the bread's substance to nothing.
It is strange that they have sunk into such ignorance, even stupor, as to put forward this monstrous fiction not only against Scripture but against the agreement of the ancient Church. I admit that some of the ancients occasionally used the word "conversion." They didn't mean to abolish the substance of the outward signs. They meant to teach that the bread set apart for this sacrament is very different from ordinary bread and is now something else. All of them clearly and consistently teach that the sacred Supper has two parts, an earthly and a heavenly, and they have no dispute that the earthly part is bread and wine. Whatever they pretend, antiquity, which they often dare to set against the clear word of God, gives this dogma no support. It is a recent invention. It was unknown not only to the better ages, when purer teaching flourished, but even after that purity had declined considerably. No early Christian writer fails to say plainly that the symbols of the Supper are bread and wine, though, as I said, they sometimes honour them with various epithets to recommend the dignity of the mystery.
My opponents reply: if there is a conversion, one thing must become another. If they mean that something becomes different from what it was before, I agree. If they twist it to support their fiction, let them tell me what kind of change they see in baptism. There too the Fathers speak of a wonderful conversion, saying that the perishable element is made into the spiritual washing of the soul. Yet no one denies that it is still water. They say that in baptism there is no statement like "This is my body." But we aren't arguing about those words, whose meaning is clear enough. We're arguing about the word "conversion," which shouldn't mean more in the Supper than in baptism. Let's drop these quibbles over words.
The real point is this. The meaning would have no coherence unless the truth pictured there had a living image in the outward sign. Christ wanted to testify by an outward symbol that his flesh is food. If he offered only an empty show of bread and not true bread, where is the comparison that leads us from the visible thing to the invisible? On their view, all that could be meant is that we are fed by the appearance of Christ's flesh. In the same way, if the appearance of water deceived our eyes in baptism, it wouldn't be a sure pledge of our cleansing. The deceptive spectacle would throw us into doubt. So the nature of a sacrament is overturned if the earthly sign doesn't correspond to the heavenly reality, and the truth of the mystery is lost if true bread doesn't represent Christ's true body.
I say it again: the Supper is nothing but a visible attestation of the promise in the sixth chapter of John, that Christ is the bread of life who came down from heaven. So visible bread must be there to picture that spiritual bread, unless we want to destroy all the benefits God gives here to support our weakness. And how could Paul conclude that we are all one bread and one body because we share one bread (1 Cor. 10:17), if only the look of bread, and not the real thing, remained?
15. The root of the error, and a few arguments answered
They could never have been so shamefully taken in by Satan's tricks if they hadn't been bewitched by the idea that the body of Christ, enclosed under the bread, is passed by the bodily mouth into the stomach. The source of this crude notion was that consecration worked for them like a magic spell. They overlooked the principle that bread is a sacrament only to those to whom the word is addressed. The water of baptism isn't changed in itself, but begins to be for us what it was not before as soon as the promise is attached. A parallel sacrament shows this. The water that gushed from the rock in the desert was for the Israelites a sign of the same thing that wine pictures for us in the Supper. Paul says they drank the same spiritual drink (1 Cor. 10:4). Yet the same water was available to the people's flocks and herds. So the earthly elements, when used for a spiritual purpose, undergo no other change than in relation to people, for whom they become seals of promises.
God's purpose, as I've said repeatedly, is to lift us up to himself by suitable means. Those who call us to Christ, but to a Christ lurking invisibly under bread, defeat that purpose by their perversity. The human mind can't free itself from the vastness of space and rise to Christ above the heavens. What nature denied them, they tried to gain by a harmful remedy. Staying on earth, they felt no need of a heavenly nearness to Christ, and that is what drove them to transform his body. Even in Bernard's day, when harsher language had become common, transubstantiation was not yet recognised. In all earlier ages the common comparison was that a spiritual reality is joined to bread and wine in this sacrament.
They think they have a clever answer in the rod of Moses. When it was turned into a serpent, they say, it was still called a rod, so the bread may likewise change into a new substance and still be called bread. But what likeness is there between a famous miracle seen by the eyes of all and their invented illusion, which no eye on earth can witness? Moses' rod soon visibly went back to its form. And the texts about the Supper are quite different: "the bread that we break," "as often as you eat this bread," "they devoted themselves to the breaking of bread." If the sacrament resembled that miracle there might be some colour to their argument. As it stands, let it be settled that there is no true and fitting promise in the Supper that Christ's flesh is real food unless the outward symbol corresponds in true substance.
One error breeds another. A passage in Jeremiah has been so absurdly twisted to prove transubstantiation that it is painful to mention. The prophet complains that wood was put into his bread, meaning that his enemies' cruelty had made his bread bitter, just as David complains, "They gave me poison for food, and for my thirst they gave me sour wine to drink" (Ps. 69:21). These men turn it into an allegory that Christ's body was nailed to the wood of the cross. Some of the Fathers thought so! We should pardon their ignorance and bury the embarrassment, rather than add impudence and set them against the prophet's real meaning.
16. Consubstantiation and the appeal to ubiquity
Some see that the correspondence between the sign and the thing signified can't be destroyed without destroying the truth of the sacrament. They admit that the bread of the Supper is truly the substance of an earthly, perishable element and can't be changed in itself, but they say Christ's body is included under it. If they meant that when the bread is held out in the sacrament, an offering of the body goes with it, because the truth is inseparable from its sign, I wouldn't object much. But they fix the body in the bread and attach to it an omnipresence that goes against its nature. By adding "under the bread" they insist that it lies hidden beneath it. So I must spend a little time exposing the trick and dragging it out of hiding. I don't intend to discuss the whole matter here, only to lay the foundations for a discussion that will follow in its place.
They insist that Christ's body is invisible and immense, so that it can be hidden under bread. They think there's no other way for us to have communion with him than by his coming down into the bread, though they don't understand the manner of descent by which he raises us up to himself. They use every colour they can, but after all is said it is clear that they insist on the local presence of Christ. The reason is that they can't conceive any other participation in his flesh and blood than one that consists of physical joining and contact, or some crude kind of enclosing.
17. Ubiquity confuses the two natures of Christ
Some, to hold stubbornly to an error they adopted rashly, don't hesitate to claim that the dimensions of Christ's flesh are no more limited than those of heaven and earth. His birth as an infant, his growth, his stretching on the cross and his confinement in the tomb, they say, happened by a kind of dispensation, so that he could perform the duties of being born, dying and the other human acts. His appearing in his familiar bodily form after the resurrection, his ascension, and his appearances to Stephen and Paul after the ascension were by the same dispensation, so that people could see he had been made King in heaven. What is this but to call Marcion up from his grave? There can be no doubt that if Christ's body was like that, it was a phantom.
Others use a slightly subtler evasion. They say that the body given in the sacrament is glorious and immortal, so there's nothing absurd in its being contained under the sacrament in various places, or in no place, and in no form. But I ask: what did Christ give his disciples the day before he suffered? Don't the words say that he gave the mortal body, which was to be handed over shortly afterwards? They answer that he had already shown his glory to three disciples on the mountain (Matt. 17:2). True, but his purpose was to give them a taste of immortality for a time. They can't find two bodies there, only the one he had taken on, dressed in new glory. When he distributed his body at the first Supper, the hour was at hand when he would be "stricken, smitten by God, and afflicted" (Isa. 53:4). He was far from intending at that moment to display the glory of his resurrection.
What a door this opens to Marcion, if Christ's body was seen humble and mortal in one place and glorious and immortal in another! And on their opinion the same thing happens every day, since they must admit that Christ's body, visible in itself, lurks invisibly under the symbol of bread. Yet those who put out such monstrous doctrines are not ashamed. They attack us with bitter abuse for not subscribing to them.
18. Further absurdities, and how Christ is truly given
Suppose Christ's body and blood are attached to the bread and wine. Then the one must be separated from the other. The bread is given apart from the cup, so the body joined to the bread must be separated from the blood contained in the cup. They say the body is in the bread and the blood in the cup, and the bread and wine are some distance apart in space. No quibble can avoid the conclusion that the body is divided from the blood. Their usual excuse, that the blood is in the body and the body in the blood by what they call "concomitance," is worse than frivolous, since the symbols in which they are contained are distinct.
But if our eyes and minds are carried up to heaven, to see Christ there in the glory of his kingdom, then the symbols invite us to him whole. Under the symbol of bread we feed on his body, and under the symbol of wine we drink his blood separately, and so have full enjoyment of him. He has withdrawn his flesh from us and ascended bodily to heaven, but he sits at the right hand of the Father. That is, he reigns in the Father's power, majesty and glory. This kingdom is not limited by gaps of space or confined by dimensions. Christ can show his power wherever he pleases, in heaven and on earth. He can make his presence known by the exercise of his power, always be with his people, breathe his life into them, live in them, sustain, strengthen and revive them, and keep them safe, just as if he were with them in the body. In short, he can feed them with his own body, communion with which he pours into them. This is how the body and blood of Christ are offered to us in the sacrament.
19. The nature of the true presence
The presence of Christ in the Supper must be understood in a way that neither attaches him to the element of bread, nor encloses him in the bread, nor limits him in any way, since this would plainly diminish his heavenly glory. It must also be a presence that neither strips him of his proper dimensions, nor divides him by differences of place, nor gives him a body of boundless size spread through heaven and earth. All of this plainly contradicts his true human nature.
We should never lose sight of two restrictions. First, nothing should be said that takes away from Christ's heavenly glory. That happens whenever he is brought under the perishable elements of this world or fixed to any earthly creature. Second, no property should be given to his body that is inconsistent with his human nature. That happens when it is called infinite, or made to occupy many places at once.
But once these absurdities are set aside, I gladly accept anything that helps express the true and substantial communication of the Lord's body and blood, which is offered to believers under the sacred symbols of the Supper. They are received not by imagination or intellect alone, but are truly enjoyed as the food of eternal life.
There's no reason for the world's dislike of this view, or for the unfair prejudice against anyone who defends it, except Satan's dreadful power to bewitch. What we teach agrees fully with Scripture. It contains nothing absurd, obscure or ambiguous, and does nothing to hinder true piety and solid edification. In short, it has nothing in it to offend except that for some ages, while the ignorance and barbarism of the sophists ruled the Church, clear light and open truth were shamefully suppressed. And since Satan, through restless spirits, is still doing all he can to dishonour this doctrine with every kind of slander, it is right to state and defend it with the greatest care.
20. The words of institution
Before going further, we must look at the ordinance as Christ instituted it, because the most plausible objection of our opponents is that we abandon his words. The best way to clear ourselves of that charge is to begin with an interpretation of the words themselves.
Three Evangelists and Paul report that our Saviour took bread, gave thanks, broke it and gave it to his disciples, saying, "Take, eat; this is my body, which is given (or broken) for you." Of the cup, Matthew and Mark say, "This is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins" (Matt. 26:26-28; Mark 14:22-24). Luke and Paul say, "This cup is the new covenant in my blood" (Luke 22:20; 1 Cor. 11:25).
Those who defend transubstantiation insist that the word "this" refers to the appearance of bread, because the whole address is an act of consecration and there is no substance that can be pointed to. But if they cling so devoutly to the words, then since what our Saviour gave his disciples he declared to be his body, nothing is further from the strict sense of the words than the fiction that what was bread is now body. What Christ took in his hands and gave the apostles, he said was his body. But he had taken bread. Who can't see that what was given is still bread? So nothing is more absurd than to transfer what is said of the bread to the appearance of bread. Others read the word "is" as meaning "is transubstantiated," which is a forced and violent gloss. No language or nation uses "is" for "is converted into something else." They have no grounds to claim they are moved by reverence for the words.
Among those who leave the bread in the Supper and say it is Christ's body, there is great variety. The more modest, though they insist on the letter "This is my body," then abandon that strictness and say it means the body is with the bread, in the bread and under the bread. I'll deal with the reality they affirm later at greater length. For now I'm considering only the words, which they say stop them from admitting that the bread is called the body because it is a sign of the body. If they shun everything like a figure, why do they jump from Christ's plain statement to expressions that are very different? There is a great difference between saying the bread is the body and saying the body is with the bread. Since they can't defend the simple statement that the bread is the body, they try to slip out of the difficulty by hiding behind these phrases.
Others, who are bolder, don't hesitate to say that, strictly speaking, the bread is the body, and so prove that they are really people of the letter. If it is objected that then the bread is Christ, and being Christ is God, they deny it, because Christ's words don't say so. They gain nothing by the denial, since all agree that the whole Christ is offered to us in the Supper. It is intolerable blasphemy to say, without a figure, that a perishable element is Christ.
I ask them: do you take these two propositions to be the same, "Christ is the Son of God" and "Bread is the body of Christ"? If they grant that these differ (and they will have to), let them say what the difference is. All they can offer, I presume, is that the bread is called body in a sacramental way. It follows that Christ's words are not subject to the common rule and should not be tested by grammar alone.
I ask these strict insisters on the letter whether Luke and Paul, when they call the cup the covenant in his blood, don't say the same thing as in the previous clause where they call the bread his body. There was the same solemnity in the one part of the mystery as in the other, and since brevity is obscure, the longer sentence better explains the meaning. So whenever they argue from the one expression that the bread is the body, I'll bring the apt interpretation from the longer one: that it is a covenant in his body. Can we find surer or more faithful interpreters than Luke and Paul? I have no wish to take anything from the force of what it means to have a covenant in the body and blood of Christ. The covenant, ratified by the sacrifice of his death, would do us no good without the addition of that secret communication by which we are made one with Christ.
21. Why the name of the thing is given to the sign
So we have to hold that, because of the affinity between the things signified and their signs, the name of the thing is given to the sign figuratively but very fittingly. I leave aside allegories and parables, so no one can say I'm looking for loopholes. I say that the manner of speaking Scripture always uses when it deals with the sacred mysteries is metonymy. You can't understand in any other way that circumcision is called a "covenant," that the lamb is the Lord's "Passover," that the sacrifices of the law are "atonements," or that the rock from which water flowed in the desert was Christ (Gen. 17:10; Exod. 12:11; 17:6; 1 Cor. 10:4).
Nor is the name merely moved from the higher to the lower. The name of the visible sign is also given to the thing signified, as when God is said to have appeared to Moses in the bush, when the ark of the covenant is called God and the face of God, and when the dove is called the Holy Spirit (Exod. 3:2; Ps. 42:2; Matt. 3:16). The sign differs in essence from the thing signified, since one is spiritual and heavenly and the other physical and visible. But the sign doesn't merely depict what it represents as a bare and empty badge. It truly offers it. So why shouldn't it rightly take its name? If symbols devised by people, which are more often images of absent things than marks of present ones, and are very often deceptive, are sometimes honoured with the names of what they stand for, much more do God's own institutions take the names of things whose meaning they always carry truly, with the reality attached. The likeness is so great, and the connection so close, that it's easy to pass from the one to the other.
So let our opponents stop their mockery of us as "Tropists" when we explain the sacramental way of speaking by the ordinary usage of Scripture. As the apostle says that the rock from which spiritual water flowed to the Israelites was Christ (1 Cor. 10:4), because it was a visible symbol under which that spiritual drink was truly received, though not by the eye, so the bread is now called Christ's body, because it is a symbol under which the Lord offers us the true eating of his body.
Nobody should dismiss this as a novelty, because Augustine took and expressed the same view: "If sacraments did not have some likeness to the things they are sacraments of, they would not be sacraments at all. And because of this likeness they generally take the names of the things themselves. So the sacrament of Christ's body is, after a certain fashion, Christ's body, and the sacrament of Christ's blood is Christ's blood; and so the sacrament of faith is faith" (Letter 98, to Boniface). He has many similar passages, but one is enough. I'll just remind readers that the holy man teaches the same in his letter to Evodius. When Augustine teaches that nothing is more common than metonymy in mysteries, it's a frivolous quibble to object that he doesn't mention the Supper. By that reasoning we couldn't argue from genus to species: every animal moves, therefore the horse and the ox move. Augustine himself settles it when he says that Christ did not hesitate to call the symbol of his body his body (Against Adimantus, ch. 12), and again: "Wonderful was the patience of Christ, who admitted Judas to the feast at which he handed to his disciples the symbol of his body and blood" (on Psalm 3).
22. The force of "is"
Suppose some stubborn person, ignoring everything else, insists on the word "is" as setting this mystery apart from all others. The answer is easy. They say the verb "to be" is so emphatic that it leaves no room for interpretation. Even if I grant this, the same verb occurs in Paul's words (1 Cor. 10:16), where he calls the bread the communion of the body of Christ. But communion is something different from the body itself. In fact, wherever the sacraments are the subject, the same verb appears: "My covenant shall be in your flesh as an everlasting covenant" (Gen. 17:13); "It is the Lord's Passover" (Exod. 12:11). To say no more, when Paul says that the rock was Christ (1 Cor. 10:4), why should "was" there be thought less emphatic than in Christ's words? When John says, "As yet there was no Spirit, because Jesus was not yet glorified" (John 7:39), I'd like to know what force the verb has there. If our opponents' rule were strictly applied, the eternal being of the Spirit would be destroyed, as if he had begun to exist only after Christ's ascension. And let them tell me what Paul means when he calls baptism "the washing of regeneration and renewal by the Holy Spirit" (Titus 3:5), when it is certain that for many it was of no use.
But they are best refuted by Paul's statement that the Church is Christ. After using the picture of the human body, he adds, "so it is with Christ" (1 Cor. 12:12), meaning not the only-begotten Son of God in himself but Christ in his members.
I think I've gained this much: all sensible and honest people will be disgusted by our enemies' slander when they claim that we discredit Christ's words, though we embrace them as obediently as they do and weigh them with more reverence. Their careless assurance shows that they don't greatly care what Christ meant, so long as it gives them a shield for their obstinacy. Our careful investigation shows the authority we give to Christ. They spitefully claim that human reason will not let us believe what Christ said with his own mouth. I've already shown in large part how wrongly they pin that charge on us, and I'll show it more clearly. Nothing prevents us from believing Christ when he speaks and accepting everything he assents to. The only question is whether it is wrong to ask what his words really mean.
23. Other objections: the letter, and the disciples' understanding
These worthy masters, to prove they hold to the letter, forbid us to depart from it at all. Yet when Scripture calls God "a man of war," I see that the expression would be too harsh uninterpreted, and I have no doubt the likeness is taken from human beings. The only handle the Anthropomorphites had against the orthodox Fathers was to fasten on phrases like "the eyes of the Lord see," "it came to his ears," "his hand is stretched out" and "the earth is his footstool," and to cry out that God was being robbed of the body Scripture gives him. If that rule were accepted, total barbarism would bury all the light of faith. What monstrous absurdities could fanatics not extract if they were allowed to press every difficult phrase in support of their dogmas?
They object that it's unlikely Christ spoke in riddles or obscurely when he was giving special comfort to the apostles in their trouble. That supports our view. If it hadn't occurred to the apostles that the bread was called the body figuratively, as a symbol of the body, the strangeness of the thing would certainly have left them bewildered. At that very time, John reports, the smallest difficulties confused them (John 14:5, 8; 16:17). They argued among themselves about how Christ would go to the Father. How then would they have been so ready to believe something contrary to all reason, that Christ sat at table before their eyes and was at the same time contained invisibly under the bread? They show their agreement by eating the bread without hesitation, so plainly they understood Christ's words as we do. They took it as nothing unusual, in a mystery, that the name of the thing signified is moved to the sign. So the disciples, like us, had clear and sure comfort, not wrapped in a riddle. Certain people reject our interpretation only because the devil has blinded them to prefer the darkness of a riddle to the plain sense of a fitting figure.
Besides, if we press the words strictly, our Saviour will be made to say something wrong about the bread as distinct from the cup. He calls the bread his body and the wine his blood. Either there is confusion in the terms, or the body must be separated from the blood. "This is my body" could be said as truly of the cup as of the bread, and the bread could be called the blood. If they answer that we must look to the purpose for which the symbols were instituted, I agree. But they still don't escape the absurdity their error drags along: that the bread is blood and the wine is body. And I don't know what they mean when they grant that bread and body are different things yet maintain that one is predicated of the other literally and without figure. It's as if someone said a garment is different from a man and yet is properly called a man.
Still, as if victory depended on obstinacy and abuse, they say that Christ is accused of falsehood whenever someone tries to interpret his words. It should now be easy for the reader to see the injustice done to us by these carpers over syllables, who tell simple people that we dishonour Christ's words. As we've shown, they themselves madly twist and confuse those words, while we expound them faithfully and accurately.
24. God's power and the question of what he has chosen to do
This shameful slander can't be fully wiped away until we answer another charge. They say that we are so wedded to human reason that we allow God's power nothing beyond what the order of nature admits and common sense dictates. I appeal against these wicked slanders to the doctrine I've set out, which makes it clear enough that I don't measure this mystery by the capacity of human reason or subject it to the laws of nature. Did we learn from physics that Christ feeds our souls from heaven with his flesh, as our bodies are fed with bread and wine? How does flesh have this power to give life to souls? Everyone will say it isn't natural. It is no more agreeable to human reason to hold that Christ's flesh reaches us to be our food. In short, anyone who has tasted our teaching will be carried away with wonder at the secret power of God.
But these worthy zealots make up a miracle for themselves and think that without it God and his power vanish. Again I ask the reader to consider carefully the nature of our doctrine: does it depend on common understanding, or does it, having risen above the world on the wings of faith, climb to heaven? We say that Christ comes down to us, by the outward symbol as well as by his Spirit, to give life to our souls truly by the substance of his flesh and blood. Whoever doesn't feel that these few words contain many miracles is worse than stupid. Nothing is more contrary to nature than to draw the spiritual and heavenly life of the soul from flesh that came from the earth and was subject to death. Nothing is more unbelievable than that things separated by the whole space between heaven and earth should, despite the distance, not only be connected but united, so that souls receive nourishment from Christ's flesh. So let these unreasonable men stop slandering us for maliciously limiting God's boundless power. They are either foolishly mistaken or wickedly lying.
The question here is not what God could do but what he has chosen to do. We affirm that he has done what pleased him, and it pleased him that Christ should be like his brothers in every respect, "yet without sin" (Heb. 4:15). What is our flesh? Isn't it what has definite dimensions, is held in a certain place, and is touched and seen? "Why," they say, "can't God make the same flesh occupy several places, so that it is confined to no one place and has neither measure nor form?" Fool! Why do you demand God's power to make a thing be flesh and not flesh at once? It is as if you demanded that he make light be light and darkness at the same time. He wills light to be light, darkness to be darkness, and flesh to be flesh. True, when he chooses, he turns darkness into light and light into darkness. But when you insist that there should be no difference between light and darkness, what are you doing but overturning the order of divine wisdom? Flesh must be flesh and spirit spirit, each under the law and condition on which God created it. The condition of flesh is that it has one particular place, its own dimensions and its own form. On that condition Christ took flesh, to which, as Augustine says (Letter to Dardanus), he gave incorruption and glory but without destroying its nature and reality.
25. "We have the word"
They object that they have the word, by which God's will has been openly shown. That's true if they let us keep the gift of interpretation in the Church, which is meant to throw light on the word. I admit they have the word, but only as the Anthropomorphites of old had it when they made God corporeal, or as Marcion and the Manichees had it when they made Christ's body heavenly or phantom. These people quoted passages too: "The first man was from the earth, a man of dust; the second man is from heaven" (1 Cor. 15:47); Christ "made himself nothing, taking the form of a servant, being born in the likeness of men" (Phil. 2:7). Likewise these boasters think God's power doesn't exist unless they invent a monster in their own heads that upsets the whole order of nature. That is what really limits God's power: trying to test what he can do by our own inventions.
From the word they have taken the idea that Christ's body is visible in heaven and yet lurks invisibly on earth under countless bits of bread. They say this is necessary so that Christ's body can be given in the Supper. In other words, because they were pleased to extract a fleshly eating from Christ's words, carried away by their own prejudice, they found it necessary to coin this subtlety, which is wholly against Scripture. We take nothing from God's power, and our doctrine in fact praises it loudest.
They keep charging us with robbing God of his honour by rejecting what is hard to believe by common understanding, though Christ's own mouth promised it. I answer as I did before: in the mysteries of faith we don't consult common understanding. With the gentle teachableness and meekness James recommends (James 1:21), we receive the teaching that has come from heaven. Where they go badly wrong, I am confident we keep proper moderation. When they hear Christ's words, "This is my body," they imagine a miracle quite remote from his intention. Then, when the grossest absurdities arise from this fiction, having already tangled themselves in snares through their haste, they plunge into the abyss of God's omnipotence in order to put out the light of truth. Hence their proud sullenness.
We have no desire to know how Christ is hidden under the bread. We are satisfied with his own words, "This is my body." We study this passage, as we do all Scripture, with obedience and care to understand it soundly. We don't grab, in some wrong-headed heat, whatever first comes to mind. After careful thought we embrace the meaning the Spirit of God suggests. Trusting him, we look down as from a height on whatever earthly wisdom may say against it. We hold our minds captive, not allowing one murmur, and humble them so they won't presume to contradict. That is how we have reached the interpretation of Christ's words that everyone moderately versed in Scripture knows to be constantly used of the sacraments. Still, in a difficult matter we don't think it wrong to ask, as the blessed Virgin did, "How can this be?" (Luke 1:34).
26. Scripture on the ascension and Christ's bodily absence
Nothing will confirm the faith of the godly more than showing them that the doctrine we've set out is drawn from the pure word of God and rests on its authority. I'll make this plain as briefly as I can.
The body with which Christ rose is declared, not by Aristotle but by the Holy Spirit, to be finite and to be contained in heaven until the last day. I know how confidently our opponents dodge the passages quoted for this. When Christ says he will leave the world and go away (John 14:2, 28), they reply that his departure was only a change from his mortal state. If that were so, Christ wouldn't have put the Holy Spirit in his place to make up, as they put it, for his absence, since the Spirit doesn't take over his place, and Christ himself doesn't come down from heavenly glory to take up mortal life again. The coming of the Spirit and the ascension of Christ are plainly set against each other. It follows that Christ is with us according to the flesh in the same way he sends his Spirit, not as the same thing.
Moreover, he plainly said he would not always be in the world with his disciples (Matt. 26:11). They think they dispose of this neatly by saying Christ meant he would not always be poor and humble, or subject to the needs of a perishable life. That is plainly against the context, which has nothing to do with poverty or want or the miserable condition of earthly life, but with worship and honour. The disciples were displeased with Mary's anointing because they thought it a useless extravagance and would have preferred that the money they thought wasted be spent on the poor. Christ answers that he will not always be with them to receive such honour.
Augustine gives no different exposition, and his words are not ambiguous. When Christ says "You do not always have me," he spoke of his bodily presence. In terms of his majesty, his providence and his ineffable, invisible grace, what he said is fulfilled: "Behold, I am with you always, to the end of the age" (Matt. 28:20). But in terms of the flesh the Word took on, the flesh born of the Virgin, seized by the Jews, nailed to the tree, hung on the cross, wrapped in linen, laid in the tomb and revealed in the resurrection, "You do not always have me." Why? Because for forty days he spoke with his disciples in bodily presence and then, going out with them, ascended while they watched but did not follow. He is not here, for he sits there at the Father's right hand. And yet he is here, for the presence of his majesty is not withdrawn. As to the presence of his majesty we have Christ always. As to his bodily presence it was rightly said, "You do not always have me." The Church had him in bodily presence for a few days. Now she holds him by faith but doesn't see him with the eye (Augustine, on John, tractate 50).
Here, to note it briefly, Augustine makes Christ present with us in three ways: in majesty, in providence and in ineffable grace. Under the last I include that wonderful communion of his body and blood, as long as we understand that it is brought about by the power of the Holy Spirit and not by the invented enclosing of his body under the element. Our Lord declared that he had flesh and bones that could be touched and seen (Luke 24:39). "Going away" and "ascending" don't mean he only appeared to go away and ascend. They mean he truly did what the words say.
Someone will ask whether we are then to assign Christ a certain region of heaven. I answer with Augustine that this is a curious and unnecessary question, provided we believe that he is in heaven.
27. The ascension and the angels' words
Doesn't the very word "ascension," so often repeated, mean removal from one place to another? They deny it, because they say height only denotes majesty of rule. But what was the actual manner of the ascent? Wasn't he carried up while the disciples watched? Don't the Evangelists plainly report that he was taken up into heaven? These clever sophists reply that a cloud came between and took him out of sight, to teach the disciples that he would not afterwards be visible in the world. As if he should rather have vanished at once, to make them believe in an invisible presence, or the cloud should have gathered round him before he moved a step. When he is lifted up into the air, and the cloud that comes between shows he is no longer to be sought on earth, we can safely conclude that his dwelling is now in the heavens, as Paul also says when he tells us to look for him from there (Phil. 3:20).
For this reason the angels remind the disciples that it's pointless to keep gazing into heaven, because Jesus, who was taken up, will come in the same way they saw him go (Acts 1:11). Here the opponents of sound doctrine think they escape by an ingenious quibble: he will come in visible form, though he never left the earth but stayed invisibly among his people. As if the angels had hinted at a double presence, and had not simply made the disciples eyewitnesses of the ascent, so no doubt would remain. It was as though they said: by rising to heaven while you looked on, he has shown his heavenly power. It remains for you to wait patiently until he comes again to judge the world. He has not entered heaven to occupy it alone, but to gather you and all the godly with him.
28. The Fathers, and Augustine above all, are on our side
The defenders of this false doctrine aren't ashamed to claim the support of the ancients, especially Augustine. I'll explain briefly how wrong they are to try. Godly and learned men have already collected the passages, so I don't want to argue a settled case, and anyone who wishes can consult their writings. I won't even gather from Augustine everything that bears on the matter. I'll simply show that, beyond any dispute, he is wholly on our side.
Our opponents try to claim him on the ground that throughout his works the flesh and blood of Christ are said to be dispensed in the Supper, meaning the victim once offered on the cross. That is frivolous, since he also calls it the Eucharist, or the sacrament of the body. And there's no need to look far for the sense in which he uses "flesh" and "blood," since he explains it himself: sacraments take their names from their likeness to the things they signify, so the sacrament of the body is after a fashion the body (Letter 98, to Boniface). Another well-known passage agrees: "The Lord did not hesitate to say, 'This is my body,' when he gave the sign" (Against Adimantus, ch. 12).
They object that Augustine says plainly that the body of Christ falls to the earth and enters the mouth. But he says it in the same sense in which he says it is consumed, for he joins the two together. Nor is it a problem that he says the bread is consumed once the mystery is finished, for just before he had said that such things are known to men, and when done by men may be honoured as religious but not admired as wonderful (On the Trinity, 3.10). His meaning is the same in the passage they too eagerly claim, where he says that Christ in a manner carried himself in his own hands when he held out his body at the Supper. By that very phrase, "in a manner," he declares that Christ was not really and truly enclosed in the bread. That is no surprise, since elsewhere he plainly argues that bodies cannot exist without particular places, and that what is nowhere does not exist.
It is a paltry quibble to say he isn't discussing the Supper there, where God exercises a special power. The question had been raised about Christ's flesh, and the holy man answers directly: "Christ gave immortality to his flesh but did not destroy its nature. In regard to this form, we must not suppose it is spread everywhere. We must take care not to defend the divinity of the man in such a way as to take away the truth of his body. It doesn't follow that what is in God is everywhere as God is" (Letter to Dardanus). He gives the reason at once: "One person is God and man, and both are one Christ, everywhere as God, and in heaven as man." How careless it would have been not to exclude the mystery of the Supper, a matter so grave, if it were in any way against the doctrine he was handling. And anyone who reads carefully what follows will see that the Supper is included under that general teaching: Christ, the only-begotten Son of God and also Son of man, is everywhere wholly present as God, dwelling in the temple of God, the Church, and is in a place in heaven because of the dimensions of his real body. To unite Christ with the Church, Augustine doesn't bring his body out of heaven. He certainly would have, if the body of Christ were not truly our food unless it were enclosed in the bread.
Elsewhere, explaining how believers now possess Christ, he says, "You have him by the sign of the cross, by the sacrament of baptism, by the food and drink of the altar" (on John, tractate 50). I won't argue whether he was right to list a superstitious rite among the signs of Christ's presence. But by comparing the presence of the flesh to the sign of the cross, he shows he has no idea of a double body of Christ, one hidden under the bread and another visible in heaven. And if any explanation is needed, he adds at once: "As to the presence of his majesty, we always have Christ. As to the presence of his flesh, it was rightly said, 'You do not always have me.'"
They object that he also adds, "In regard to ineffable and invisible grace, what he said is fulfilled: 'I am with you always.'" That helps them nothing. It is finally limited to his majesty, which is always set against body, while the flesh is expressly distinguished from grace and power. The same contrast appears elsewhere, when he says that "Christ left the disciples in bodily presence so that he might be with them in spiritual presence." Here the essence of the flesh is plainly distinguished from the power of the Spirit that joins us to Christ across a great distance of space. He uses the same pattern repeatedly. "He was to come to the living and the dead in bodily presence, according to the rule of faith and sound doctrine; for in spiritual presence he was to come to them and be with the whole Church in the world until its end. So this speech is addressed to believers, whom he had begun to save by bodily presence and whom he was to leave in bodily absence, so that by spiritual presence he might keep them with the Father." To take "bodily" as meaning merely "visible" is trifling, since Augustine sets Christ's body against his divine power. And by adding "that he might keep them with the Father," he plainly says that Christ sends his grace to us from heaven through the Spirit.
29. The invisible presence refuted
They put great confidence in the hiding place of an invisible presence. Let's see how well they hide in it. First, they can't produce a single syllable of Scripture to prove that Christ's body is invisible. They simply assume what no sound person will grant, that Christ's body can't be given in the Supper unless it is covered with the mask of bread. That is the very point in dispute, far from being a first principle. And in all this chatter they are forced to give Christ a double body: visible in itself in heaven, but invisible in the Supper by a special arrangement. How well this fits with the rest of Scripture is easy to judge, as with Peter's statement that heaven must receive, or contain, Christ until he comes again (Acts 3:21).
These men teach that he is in every place but without form. They say it's unfair to subject a glorified body to the ordinary laws of nature. But that answer drags along Servetus's delirious dream, which every godly mind rightly abhors, that Christ's body was absorbed by his divinity. I don't say that this is their opinion. But if filling all things invisibly is counted as a property of a glorified body, plainly the bodily substance is abolished and no distinction is left between his Godhead and his human nature. Again, if Christ's body is so many-sided that it appears in one place and is invisible in another, where is the nature of a body with its proper dimensions, and where is its unity? Tertullian is far more correct when he argues that Christ's body was natural and real, because its figure is set before us in the mystery of the Supper as a pledge and assurance of spiritual life (Against Marcion, Book 4). The figure would be false if what it represents were not real.
And certainly Christ said of his glorified body, "Touch me and see. A spirit does not have flesh and bones as you see that I have" (Luke 24:39). Christ himself proves the reality of his flesh by its being open to sight and touch. Take these away, and it ceases to be flesh. They always run back to their hiding place of "dispensation," which they made up. But our duty is to embrace what Christ plainly says and give it unreserved assent. He proves he is not a phantom because he is visible in his flesh. If you take away what he claims as proper to the nature of his body, a new definition of body would have to be invented.
However they twist, they won't find room for their invented dispensation in Paul's words: "Our citizenship is in heaven, and from it we await a Saviour, the Lord Jesus Christ, who will transform our lowly body to be like his glorious body" (Phil. 3:20-21). We aren't to hope for conformity to Christ in the qualities they ascribe to him, a body without bounds and invisible. They won't find anyone foolish enough to be persuaded of that. So let them not list it as a property of Christ's glorious body that it is in many places and in no place at once. In short, let them either openly deny the resurrection of his flesh, or admit that Christ, clothed with heavenly glory, did not put off his flesh but will make us, in our flesh, his companions and sharers of the same glory, since we are to share one resurrection with him.
What does Scripture say more clearly than this: as Christ took our flesh when he was born of the Virgin, and suffered in our true flesh when he made satisfaction for us, so when he rose he took the same true flesh again and carried it with him to heaven? Our hope of resurrection and ascent to heaven is that Christ rose and ascended, and as Tertullian says, "carried an earnest of our resurrection with him into heaven." How weak and fragile this hope would be, if this very flesh of ours in Christ had not been truly raised and entered the kingdom of heaven! But the essential properties of a body are to be bounded by space and to have dimension and form. So let's be done with the foolish fiction that fastens people's minds, as well as Christ, to bread. What is the point of this hidden presence under the bread, except that those who want Christ joined to them may stop at the symbol? But our Lord himself wanted us to turn away not only our eyes but all our senses from the earth, when he forbade the woman to touch him until he had ascended to the Father (John 20:17). When he saw Mary hurrying, with devout and reverent zeal, to kiss his feet, he had no reason to disapprove and forbid her to touch him before he ascended, unless he wanted to be sought nowhere else.
The objection that he later appeared to Stephen is easily answered. Our Saviour didn't need to change his place, since he could give his servant's eyes the power to see into heaven. The same goes for Paul. Nor does the objection that Christ came out of the closed tomb and entered where the disciples were while the doors were shut (Matt. 28:6; John 20:19) help their error. Water served as a solid pavement for him when he walked on it (Matt. 14), so it's no wonder the hard stone yielded to his step. It is more likely the stone was removed at his command and went back to its place after he passed. Entering through shut doors was less a passing through solid matter than making a way for himself by divine power and standing among his disciples in a most miraculous manner. Nor do they gain anything from Luke's report that Christ suddenly vanished from the eyes of the disciples at Emmaus (Luke 24:31). In withdrawing from their sight he didn't become invisible; he only disappeared. Luke says that on the road he didn't take a new form but that "their eyes were kept from recognising him."
These men not only transform Christ so that he lives on earth, but say there is another Christ elsewhere of a different kind. In short, with this trifling they make the flesh of Christ a spirit, not directly but by roundabout words, and then give him properties wholly opposed to flesh. It follows that he must be double.
30. Ubiquity refuted
Grant what they absurdly claim about an invisible presence. They still have to prove immensity, without which it's pointless to try to enclose Christ under the bread. Unless Christ's body can be everywhere without limits of space, it is impossible to believe that he is hidden under the bread in the Supper. So they have been driven to bring in the monstrous dogma of ubiquity. But strong and clear passages of Scripture have shown, first, that it is bounded by the dimensions of a human body, and second, that his ascension into heaven made it plain that it is not in all places, but that on moving to a new place it leaves the one it had before.
The promise they appeal to, "I am with you always, to the end of the age," doesn't apply to the body. First, a permanent connection with Christ couldn't exist unless he lived in us bodily, apart from the use of the Supper, so they have no good grounds for fighting so bitterly over Christ's words in order to enclose him under the bread (they themselves admit that we have him just as well without the Supper). Second, the context proves that Christ isn't speaking of his flesh at all, but promising the disciples his unbeatable help to guard and sustain them against all the attacks of Satan and the world. He appoints them to a hard task and strengthens them by the assurance of his presence, so they wouldn't hesitate to undertake it or be fearful in carrying it out. It's as if he said his unconquerable protection would not fail them.
Unless we want to throw everything into confusion, we must distinguish the manner of presence. Some, to their great disgrace, would rather show their ignorance than give up one iota of their error. I don't mean the Papists, whose doctrine is more tolerable, or at least more modest. But some are so carried away by contention that they say that because the natures are united in Christ, wherever his divinity is, his flesh, which can't be separated from it, must be too. It is as if that union formed a kind of blend of the two natures, making him neither God nor man. That was the view of Eutyches, and after him Servetus. But it is plain from Scripture that the one person of Christ is made up of two natures, each keeping its own properties unimpaired. They won't dare deny that Eutyches was rightly condemned. It is strange that they pay no attention to the reason: by destroying the distinction between the natures and insisting only on the unity of the person, he turned God into man and man into God. What madness it is to mix heaven and earth rather than withdraw Christ's body from its heavenly sanctuary!
As for the passages they cite, "No one has ascended into heaven except he who descended from heaven, the Son of Man who is in heaven" (John 3:13), and "The only Son, who is in the bosom of the Father, he has made him known" (John 1:18), they show the same dullness, scorning the communication of properties, which holy Fathers invented for good reason. When Paul says the rulers of this age "crucified the Lord of glory" (1 Cor. 2:8), he doesn't mean that anything was suffered in his divinity. He means that Christ, who was rejected, despised and suffered in the flesh, was also God and Lord of glory. In this way the Son of Man was in heaven, because he was also Christ, and he who dwelt on earth according to the flesh as Son of Man was also God in heaven. For this reason he is said to have come down from heaven in respect of his divinity. This doesn't mean his divinity left heaven to hide in the prison of the body. It means that although he filled all things, his divinity dwelt bodily, that is, naturally and in an ineffable way, in the humanity of Christ.
There's a common distinction in the schools that I don't hesitate to quote: although the whole Christ is everywhere, everything that is in him is not everywhere. I wish the Schoolmen had weighed the force of that sentence, because it would have prevented their absurd fiction of a bodily presence. So our whole Mediator is everywhere, and is always present with his people, and in the Supper shows his presence in a special way. But while he is wholly present, not everything in him is present, because, as I said, in his flesh he will stay in heaven until he comes to judge.
31. Two ways of understanding "presence"
They are badly mistaken to think there is no presence of Christ's flesh in the Supper unless it is placed in the bread. They leave nothing for the secret working of the Spirit, who unites Christ himself to us. In their view Christ seems not to be present unless he comes down to us, as if we didn't equally gain his presence when he lifts us up to himself. The only question is the manner: they place Christ in the bread, while we think it wrong to draw him down from heaven. Let the reader judge which is more correct. Only let's be done with the slander that Christ is taken away from his Supper if he doesn't lurk under a covering of bread. This mystery is heavenly, so there is no need to bring Christ to earth to connect him with us.
32. The manner is a mystery, but the reality is certain
If anyone asks me about the manner, I won't be ashamed to confess that it is too high a mystery for my mind to understand or my words to express. To speak more plainly, I experience it more than I understand it. So I embrace the truth of God, in which I can safely rest, without argument. He declares that his flesh is the food and his blood the drink of my soul, and I give my soul to him to be fed with such food. In his sacred Supper he tells me to take, eat and drink his body and blood under the symbols of bread and wine. I have no doubt that he truly gives them and that I receive them.
I only reject the absurdities that appear unworthy of Christ's heavenly majesty and are inconsistent with the reality of his human nature. They must also be against the word of God, which teaches that Christ was received into the glory of the heavenly kingdom, raised above all the circumstances of the world (Luke 24:26), and which is just as careful to give him the properties of a true human nature. This shouldn't seem incredible or contrary to reason (Irenaeus, 4.34), because as Christ's whole kingdom is spiritual, whatever he does in his Church shouldn't be tested by the wisdom of this world. In Augustine's words, "This mystery is performed by man like the others, but in a divine manner, and on earth, but in a heavenly manner."
That is the presence of the body that the nature of the sacrament requires. We say it is shown here with such power and effect that it not only gives our minds unshakeable assurance of eternal life, but also secures the immortality of our flesh, since it is now made alive by his immortal flesh and in a way shines with his immortality. Those who go beyond this with their exaggerations do nothing but obscure the plain and simple truth.
If anyone is still not satisfied, let them remember that we are speaking of a sacrament, every part of which should point to faith. By sharing in the body, as we've explained, we nourish faith as richly and abundantly as those who drag Christ himself down from heaven. I freely admit that I reject the mixing or pouring of Christ's flesh into our soul that they teach. It is enough for us that Christ breathes life into our souls from the substance of his flesh, and indeed pours his own life into us, though the actual flesh of Christ does not enter us.
I'll add that the analogy of faith, by which Paul tells us to test every interpretation of Scripture, plainly supports us here. Let those who oppose so clear a truth consider what standard of faith they follow: "Every spirit that confesses that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is from God" (1 John 4:2-3; 2 John 7). These men, though they disguise it or don't see it, rob him of his flesh.
33. Communion, and whether the wicked eat Christ's body
The same view applies to communion, which they say doesn't exist unless they swallow Christ's flesh under the bread. It is no small insult to the Spirit to refuse to believe that it is by his incomprehensible working that we share in Christ's body and blood. If the nature of the mystery, as handed down to us and known to the ancient Church for four hundred years, had been weighed as it deserves, it would have been more than enough for us, and the door would have been shut against many shameful errors. These errors have set off terrible quarrels that have miserably troubled the Church, both anciently and in our own day, as curious people insist on an extravagant mode of presence that Scripture doesn't support. And for a matter so foolishly and rashly invented they keep up the uproar, as if enclosing Christ in the bread were the beginning and end of piety.
The first priority was to know how the body of Christ, once given for us, becomes ours, and how we share in his shed blood, because this is to possess the whole crucified Christ and enjoy all his benefits. But they ignore these points, which matter so much, even neglect and nearly suppress them, and busy themselves only with the one tangled question: how is the body of Christ hidden under the bread, or under the appearance of bread?
They falsely pretend that all we teach about spiritual eating is opposed to true and, as they call it, real eating, since we look only at the manner of eating. In their view the manner is fleshly, since they enclose Christ under the bread. In ours it is spiritual, since the sacred working of the Spirit is the bond of our union with Christ. Equally unfounded is their other objection, that we attend only to the fruit or effect believers receive from eating Christ's flesh. I said before that Christ himself is the matter of the Supper, and that the effect follows from this: by the sacrifice of his death our sins are atoned for, by his blood we are washed, and by his resurrection we are raised to the hope of heavenly life.
A foolish idea, whose author was Lombard, twists their minds so that they think the sacrament is the eating of Christ's flesh. His words are: "The sacrament and not the thing are the forms of bread and wine; the sacrament and the thing are the flesh and blood of Christ; the thing and not the sacrament is his mystical flesh." A little later: "The thing signified and contained is the proper flesh of Christ; the thing signified and not contained is his mystical body." I agree with his distinction between Christ's flesh and its power to nourish. But his claim that it is a sacrament, and a sacrament contained under the bread, is an error that can't be tolerated.
From this arose the false view of sacramental eating, which imagined that even the wicked and profane, however far from Christ, eat his body. But Christ's flesh in the mystery of the Supper is as much a spiritual matter as eternal salvation. We conclude that all who lack the Spirit of Christ can no more eat Christ's flesh than drink wine that has no taste. Christ is shamefully torn apart when his body, as if lifeless and without strength, is thrown to unbelievers. This plainly contradicts his words, "Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood abides in me, and I in him" (John 6:56). They object that he isn't speaking there of sacramental eating. I grant it, provided they don't keep stumbling over this stone, that his flesh itself is eaten without any benefit. I'd like to know how they keep it from benefiting once it has been eaten. Here, I think, they will find no way out.
They object that human ingratitude can't in any way detract from or interfere with faith in God's promises. I admit and hold that the power of the sacrament remains whole, however hard the wicked work to wipe it out. Still, it is one thing to be offered and another to be received. Christ gives this spiritual food and holds out this spiritual drink to all. Some eat eagerly; others scornfully reject it. Will their rejection make the food and drink lose their nature? They say this comparison supports their view, that Christ's flesh, even if it has no taste, is still flesh. But I deny that it can be eaten without the taste of faith. Or, if it's more agreeable to speak with Augustine, I deny that people carry away from the sacrament more than they gather in the vessel of faith. So nothing is taken from the sacrament; its reality and power stay unimpaired, though the wicked go away empty after partaking outwardly.
If they object that it takes from the words "This is my body" if the wicked receive only perishable bread, the answer is easy. God doesn't want his truth to be recognised in the mere receiving but in the constancy of his goodness, since he is ready to give, indeed generously offers, to the unworthy what they reject. The integrity of the sacrament, which the whole world can't violate, is that the flesh and blood of Christ are given no less truly to the unworthy than to God's elect believers. Yet it is also true that, as rain falling on a hard rock runs off because it can't soak in, so the wicked by their hardness push away God's grace and keep it from reaching them. It is also no more possible to receive Christ without faith than for seed to sprout in fire.
They ask how Christ can have come for the condemnation of some, unless they receive him unworthily. That's absurd, since we nowhere read that they bring death on themselves by receiving Christ unworthily, but by rejecting him. The parable doesn't help them, where Christ says the seed that fell among thorns sprang up but was later choked (Matt. 13:7). He is speaking there of the effect of a temporary faith, which those who put Judas on a level with Peter don't think necessary for eating Christ's flesh and drinking his blood. The same parable refutes their error, since some seed fell on the path and some on stony ground, and neither took root. So it is the hardness of the unbelieving that stops Christ from reaching them.
For all who want this sacrament to advance our salvation, nothing is more fitting than to lead believers to the fountain, to draw life from the Son of God. Its dignity is praised well enough when we hold that it is a help by which we are grafted into the body of Christ, or, already grafted, are united to him more and more until the union is completed in heaven. They object that Paul could not have made them guilty of the body and blood of the Lord if they hadn't partaken of them (1 Cor. 11:27). I answer that they were condemned not for eating but for profaning the ordinance, trampling underfoot the pledge they should have received with reverence, the pledge of sacred union with God.
34. What Augustine and Cyril say about the wicked
Among the ancient writers Augustine in particular maintains that the grace pictured in the sacraments is not weakened or voided by people's unbelief or malice. It will be useful to show from his words how ignorantly those who throw Christ's body to be eaten by dogs twist them to their purpose. Sacramental eating, for them, is the way the wicked receive Christ's body and blood without the Spirit's working or any gracious effect. Augustine, on the contrary, weighing the words "Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood has eternal life" (John 6:54), says: "That is the power of the sacrament, and not merely the visible sacrament: the sacrament of the one who eats inwardly, not of the one who eats outwardly, or merely with the teeth" (on John, tractate 26). He concludes that the sacrament of this thing, the unity of Christ's body and blood in the Supper, is set before some for life and before others for destruction, while the thing itself, of which it is the sacrament, is for life to everyone and for destruction to no one, whoever may take it.
Lest anyone quibble that "the thing" means not the body but the grace of the Spirit, which could be separated from it, Augustine clears away that mist by his contrasting terms, visible and invisible. Christ's body can't be placed under the former. So it follows that unbelievers share only in the visible symbol. And to remove all doubt, after saying that this bread needs an appetite in the inner person, he adds: "Moses and Aaron and Phinehas and many others who ate the manna pleased God. Why? Because they understood the visible food spiritually, hungered for it spiritually, tasted it spiritually, and were fed on it spiritually. We too today have received visible food, but the sacrament is one thing and the power of the sacrament another." A little later: "So whoever does not abide in Christ, and in whom Christ does not abide, without doubt neither eats his flesh spiritually nor drinks his blood, though he may with his teeth carnally and visibly press the symbol of the body and blood."
Again, the visible sign is set against spiritual eating. This refutes the error that Christ's invisible body is eaten sacramentally in reality though not spiritually. We are also told that nothing is given to the impure and profane beyond the visible taking of the sign. Hence his famous saying that the other disciples ate bread that was the Lord, whereas Judas ate the bread of the Lord (on John, tractate 62). By this he clearly excludes unbelievers from sharing in Christ's body and blood. He means the same when he says, "Why do you wonder that the bread of Christ was given to Judas, though he handed Christ over to the devil, when you see, on the other hand, that a messenger of the devil was given to Paul to perfect him in Christ?" (On Baptism, against the Donatists, Book 5).
Elsewhere he does say that the bread of the Supper was the body of Christ to those to whom Paul said, "Whoever eats and drinks in an unworthy manner eats and drinks judgment on himself," and that it doesn't follow that they received nothing because they received unworthily. But he explains in what sense in another passage (City of God, 21.25). There he sets out expressly to explain how the wicked and profane, who profess faith in Christ with the mouth but deny him in deed, eat Christ's body, and he refutes the opinion of some who thought they ate not only sacramentally but really. He says: "Nor can they be said to eat the body of Christ, because they are not to be counted among the members of Christ. For, not to mention other reasons, they can't be at the same time members of Christ and members of a prostitute. Finally, when Christ himself says, 'Whoever eats my flesh and drinks my blood abides in me, and I in him,' he shows what it is to eat Christ's body, not sacramentally but in reality. It is to abide in Christ, so that Christ abides in him. It is as if he said: let the person who doesn't abide in me, and in whom I don't abide, not say or think he eats my body or drinks my blood." Notice the contrast between eating sacramentally and eating really, and there can be no doubt.
He confirms the same in these words: "Prepare not the jaws but the heart, for which alone the Supper is appointed. We believe in Christ when we receive him by faith. In receiving, we know what we think. We receive a small portion, but our heart is filled. It is not what is seen but what is believed that feeds" (Against Faustus, 13.16). In another passage, saying plainly that the good and the bad communicate by signs, he excludes the latter from the true eating of Christ's flesh. In another he concludes about eating and its fruit: "Then the body and blood of Christ will be life to each, if what is visibly taken in the sacrament is spiritually eaten and spiritually drunk" (Sermon on the Words of the Apostle). Let those who make unbelievers sharers in Christ's flesh and blood, if they want to agree with Augustine, set before us the visible body of Christ, since for him the whole truth is spiritual. His words certainly imply that sacramental eating, when unbelief bars the way to the reality, is only visible or outward eating.
If the body of Christ could be truly eaten and yet not spiritually, what could he mean when he says elsewhere, "You are not to eat this body that you see, nor drink the blood that those who will crucify me will shed. I have given you a certain sacrament; understood spiritually, it will give you life" (on Psalm 98)? He certainly didn't mean to deny that the body offered in the Supper is the same one Christ offered in sacrifice. He was pointing to the manner of eating: the body, though taken up into heavenly glory, breathes life into us by the secret power of the Spirit.
I admit he often says that "the body of Christ is eaten by unbelievers," but he explains himself by adding "in the sacrament." And he speaks elsewhere of a spiritual eating in which our teeth do not chew grace (on John, tractate 27). So that my opponents can't say I'm trying to bury them under quotations, I ask how they get past this one sentence: "In the elect alone, the sacraments do what they picture." They surely won't deny that the bread in the Supper pictures Christ's body. It follows that the reprobate are not allowed to share in it.
Cyril thought no differently, as these words show: "As when someone pours melted wax into melted wax and mixes the whole together, so, when someone receives the body and blood of the Lord, he must be joined with him, so that Christ is found in him and he in Christ." From these words I think it is plain that there is no true and real eating by those who eat the body of Christ only sacramentally, since the body cannot be separated from its power, and the promises of God do not fail, though while he never stops raining from heaven, rocks and stones are not soaked by the moisture.
35. The adoration of the sacrament has no basis
This reasoning should easily talk us out of the fleshly adoration that some have recklessly introduced into the sacrament. They argue: if it is the body, then the soul and divinity that go with the body, and can't be separated from it, are there too, so Christ must be worshipped there. First, if we deny their invented "concomitance," what will they do? They insist mainly on the absurdity of separating Christ's body from his soul and divinity. But what sane person can persuade himself that the body of Christ is Christ? They think their syllogisms settle it. Yet Christ speaks of his body and blood separately without describing the manner of his presence. How can they reach in a doubtful matter the certainty they want? And if their consciences are ever troubled by some heavier fear, will syllogisms set them free? When they see that no certainty can be found in the word of God, in which alone our minds can rest, and that the teaching and practice of the apostles stand against them, with no authority behind them but their own, how will they feel?
Other sharp stings will follow. Was it a small matter to worship God in this form without any express command? In a matter of true worship were we to act so lightly, without one word of Scripture? If all their thoughts had been kept subject to God's word, they would have listened to what he said, "Take, eat, drink," and obeyed the command to receive the sacrament, not worship it. Those who receive it without adoration, as God commanded, are sure they haven't strayed from the command. There is no better security than this at the start of any work. They have the example of the apostles, of whom we read not that they prostrated themselves and worshipped, but that they sat down, took and ate. They have the practice of the apostolic Church, where, as Luke reports, believers communicated not in adoration but in the breaking of bread (Acts 2:42). They have the teaching of the apostles as Paul taught it to the Corinthians, who says that what he delivered he had received from the Lord (1 Cor. 11:23).
36. Why adoration is idolatry
I say all this to lead godly readers to see how dangerous it is, in difficult matters, to wander from the plain word of God to the dreams of our own brains. What I've said above should free us from all scruple here. For a godly soul to take hold of Christ in the sacrament, it must rise to heaven. If the sacrament's job is to help the weakness of the human mind, helping it climb to see the height of spiritual mysteries, then those who stop at the outward sign are straying from the right path of seeking Christ.
Can we deny that it is superstition when people throw themselves down before bread to worship Christ in it? The Council of Nicaea surely meant to meet this evil when it forbade us to give humble heed to the visible signs. For the same reason it was once the custom, before consecration, to call out to the people to lift up their hearts, sursum corda. Scripture itself not only carefully records Christ's ascension, by which he withdrew his bodily presence from our sight and company so that we would give up all fleshly thoughts of him. It also, whenever it mentions him, tells us to raise our minds and seek him in heaven, seated at the Father's right hand (Col. 3:1-2). By that rule we should have worshipped him spiritually in heavenly glory, rather than inventing a dangerous kind of adoration full of crude, fleshly ideas about God.
Those who devised the adoration of the sacrament not only dreamed it up on their own, with no authority from Scripture, where no mention of it can be shown (it wouldn't have been left out if God approved). They also ignored Scripture, abandoned the living God and made a god for themselves, after the desires of their own hearts. What is idolatry if not worshipping the gifts instead of the giver? The sin is double. The honour taken from God is given to a creature, and God is also dishonoured by the pollution and profaning of his own goodness, as his holy sacrament is turned into a detestable idol. To avoid falling into the same pit, let us confine our eyes, ears, hearts, minds and tongues wholly to God's sacred teaching. This is the school of the Holy Spirit, the best of teachers. There we make such progress that, while there is nothing to learn anywhere else, we should be willing to stay ignorant of whatever is not taught there.
37. Why the sacrament was instituted: remembrance and confession
Once superstition passes its proper bounds, it has no end to its errors. People went much further and devised rites completely foreign to the institution of the Supper, to the point of paying divine honours to the sign. They say their reverence is paid to Christ. First, if this were done in the Supper, I would say that only that adoration is legitimate which doesn't stop at the sign but rises to Christ seated in heaven. As it is, on what grounds do they say they honour Christ in that bread, when they have no promise to that effect? They consecrate the "host," as they call it, carry it around in solemn procession, put it on display to be admired, revered and prayed to.
I ask by what power they think it is rightly consecrated. They will quote the words "This is my body." I will answer that "Take, eat" was said at the same time. And I count that as important, because the promise is attached to the command, and the former is so bound up in the latter that it can't be separated from it. An example makes it clearer. God gave a command when he said, "Call on me," and added a promise, "I will deliver you" (Ps. 50:15). If someone called on Peter or Paul and relied on this promise, wouldn't everyone say he was mistaken? What else do those do who ignore the command to eat and seize the clipped promise "This is my body," bending it to rites foreign to Christ's institution? Let's remember that this promise was given to those who keep the command attached to it, and that those who move the sacrament to another purpose have no support from the word of God.
We've already shown how the mystery of the Supper serves our faith in God. But the Lord doesn't only remind us of this great gift of his goodness. He passes it, so to speak, from hand to hand and urges us to recognise it. At the same time he warns us not to be ungrateful for his kindness, but to proclaim it with fitting praise and celebrate it with thanksgiving. So when he gave the apostles the sacrament, he taught them to do it in remembrance of him, which Paul explains as "you proclaim the Lord's death" (1 Cor. 11:26). That means that all should publicly and with one voice confess that all our confidence of life and salvation rests on the Lord's death, so that we glorify him by our confession and by our example encourage others to give him glory. Here again we see the purpose of the sacrament: to keep Christ's death in our remembrance. When we are told to proclaim the Lord's death until he comes, all that is meant is that we should declare with our mouths what our faith has recognised in the sacrament, that the death of Christ is our life. This is the second use of the sacrament, and it concerns outward confession.
38. The third purpose: love and unity
Third, the Lord intended the sacrament as a kind of encouragement, stronger than any other, to urge us to purity and holiness of life and to love, peace and harmony. There the Lord gives us his body so that he may become completely one with us and we with him. Since he has only one body, of which he makes us all sharers, we must all become one body by this sharing. The bread offered in the sacrament pictures this unity. As it is made of many grains, mixed together so that one can't be told from another, so our minds should be so warmly united that they leave no room for any dissension or division.
I prefer to put this in Paul's words: "The cup of blessing that we bless, is it not a participation in the blood of Christ? The bread that we break, is it not a participation in the body of Christ? Because there is one bread, we who are many are one body, for we all partake of the one bread" (1 Cor. 10:16-17). We will have profited greatly in the sacrament if this thought is impressed and engraved on our minds: that none of our brothers or sisters can be hurt, despised, rejected, injured or offended in any way without our at the same time hurting, despising and injuring Christ. We can't be at odds with our brothers and sisters without being at odds with Christ. We can't love Christ without loving them. The care we take of our own body we should take of theirs, since they are members of our body. As no part of our body suffers pain without the pain spreading to the others, so every evil our brother suffers should move us to compassion.
That's why Augustine often and fittingly calls this sacrament the bond of love. What stronger incentive could there be to stir up mutual love than that Christ gives himself to us, not only inviting us by his example to give and devote ourselves to each other, but, by making himself common to all, making us all one in him?
39. The sacrament needs the word
This confirms very well what I said elsewhere, that the Supper can't be rightly administered without the word. Every benefit we get from the Supper depends on the word. Whether we are to be strengthened in faith, or practised in confession, or stirred to duty, preaching is needed. Nothing is more backward than to turn the Supper into a silent action. That is what happens under the Pope's tyranny, where the whole effect of consecration is made to depend on the priest's intention, as if it didn't concern the people, to whom above all the mystery should be explained.
This error arose from not noticing that the promises by which consecration is carried out are meant not for the elements but for those who receive them. Christ doesn't speak to the bread and tell it to become his body. He tells his disciples to eat, and promises them the communion of his body and blood. In the order Paul gives, the promises are to be offered to believers along with the bread and cup. We shouldn't imagine some magic spell, thinking it enough to mutter the words as if the elements heard them. We should treat those words as a living sermon that builds up the hearers, enters their minds, is planted in their hearts and does its work in fulfilling what it promises.
For these reasons it is clear that the practice some insist on, setting apart the sacrament so that it can be given outside the usual gathering to the sick, is useless. Either the sick will receive it without hearing the words of institution read, or the minister will join the true explanation of the mystery to the sign. In silent distribution there is abuse and defect. If the promises are told and the mystery explained so that those about to receive may receive with profit, there is no doubt that this is the true consecration. What then becomes of that other consecration, whose effect extends even to the sick? Those who do this appeal to the example of the early Church. I admit it. But in so important a matter, where error is so dangerous, nothing is safer than to follow the truth.
40. Unworthy eating and the need for self-examination
The sacred bread of the Lord's Supper is spiritual food, sweet and savoury as well as healthful to godly worshippers. When they taste it, they feel that Christ is their life, they are moved to give thanks, and they are urged to love one another. But on the other hand, it turns into the most harmful poison for all whom it does not nourish and strengthen in faith and does not move to thanksgiving and love. As bodily food taken into a stomach diseased with bad humours is itself spoiled and corrupted and harms rather than feeds, so this spiritual food, given to a soul polluted with malice and wickedness, plunges it into greater ruin. The fault is not in the food but in the fact that "to the corrupt and unbelieving, nothing is pure" (Titus 1:15), however much it has been sanctified by the Lord's blessing.
Paul says, "Whoever eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord"; he "eats and drinks judgment on himself if he does not discern the body" (1 Cor. 11:27, 29). People who rush like pigs to seize the Lord's Supper, without a spark of faith or any zeal for love, don't discern the Lord's body at all. They don't believe that body is their life, so they insult it in every possible way, stripping it of its dignity, and profane and defile it by receiving it like this. And while estranged from their brothers and sisters, they dare to mix the sacred symbol of Christ's body with their quarrels. No thanks to them if Christ's body isn't torn to pieces. So they are rightly held guilty of the body and blood of the Lord, which they pollute so vilely with sacrilegious impiety.
By this unworthy eating they bring judgment on themselves. They have no faith in Christ, yet by receiving the sacrament they profess to place their salvation in him alone and give up all other confidence. So they are their own accusers; they testify against themselves and seal their own condemnation. Divided and separated by hatred and ill-will from their brothers and sisters, the members of Christ, they have no part in Christ, yet they declare that the only safety is to share in Christ and be united to him.
For this reason Paul commands a person to examine himself before he eats that bread and drinks that cup (1 Cor. 11:28). As I understand it, he means that each person should go down into himself and consider two things. First, whether with inward confidence of heart he rests on the salvation Christ won, and acknowledges it with his mouth. Second, whether with zeal for purity and holiness he aspires to imitate Christ; whether, after his example, he is ready to give himself to his brothers and sisters and to hold himself in common with those with whom he has Christ in common; whether, as Christ regards him, he in turn regards all his brothers and sisters as members of his body, and wants to cherish, defend and help them as his own members. The point is not that the duties of faith and love can now be perfected in us, but that we must strive with all our heart to increase our faith daily.
41. The false examination of the Papacy
In trying to prepare for worthy eating, people have often terribly harassed and tortured miserable consciences, and they have not come any closer to the goal. They said that those eat worthily who are in a state of grace, and they took "in a state of grace" to mean pure and free from all sin. By that definition everyone who has ever lived on earth has been shut out from this sacrament. If we are to look for our worthiness in ourselves, we are finished. Only despair and fatal ruin remain. However hard we struggle, we not only make no progress, but we become most unworthy just when we have laboured hardest to make ourselves worthy.
To cure this sore they devised a way of producing worthiness: after examining ourselves as far as we can and taking account of all our actions, we are to atone for our unworthiness by contrition, confession and satisfaction. I spoke of the nature of this atonement in its place (Book 3, chapter 4, sections 2, 17 and 27). For our present purpose I say that these things give poor and fleeting comfort to alarmed and downcast consciences, terrified by their sins. If the Lord admits to his Supper only the righteous and innocent, everyone would need to be careful before feeling sure of the righteousness God is said to require. How can we be sure that those who have done what lay in them have done their duty to God? Even if we were sure, who would dare to assure himself that he had done what lay in him? With no certain basis for our worthiness, access to the Supper would always be barred by the dreadful warning, "Whoever eats and drinks in an unworthy manner eats and drinks judgment on himself."
42. What true worthiness is
Now it's easy to judge the nature, and the author, of the doctrine that prevails in the Papacy. By its inhuman harshness it deprives and robs wretched sinners, crushed by sorrow and trembling, of the comfort of this sacrament, in which everything delightful in the gospel was set before them. The devil could have found no shorter way of destroying people than to infatuate them this way and shut them out from the taste and savour of the food with which their most merciful Father in heaven had been pleased to feed them.
So that we don't rush over such a cliff, let's remember that this sacred feast is medicine for the sick, comfort for the sinner and a gift for the poor. For the healthy, the righteous and the rich, if there were any, it would be of no value. Christ is given there as food, and we see that without him we fail, pine and waste away, as hunger destroys the body's strength. And since he is given for life, we see that without him we are certainly dead. So the best and only worthiness we can bring to God is to offer him our own vileness and, if I may say so, our unworthiness, so that his mercy may make us worthy. It is to despair of ourselves so that we may be comforted in him, to humble ourselves so that he may lift us up, to accuse ourselves so that he may justify us. It is also to aim at the unity he recommends in the Supper, and, as he makes us all one in himself, to desire to have one soul, one heart, one tongue.
If we ponder and meditate on these things, we may be shaken, but we will never be overwhelmed by thoughts such as: how can we, who have no good in us, are polluted by the stains of sin and half dead, eat the Lord's body worthily? We will instead consider that we poor people are coming to a generous giver, we sick to a physician, we sinners to the author of righteousness, in short, we dead to the one who gives life. The worthiness God commands consists chiefly in faith, which places everything in Christ and nothing in ourselves, and in love, which, though imperfect, may be enough to offer to God so that he may increase it, since it can't be fully paid.
Some agree with us that worthiness consists of faith and love, but have gone far wrong about its measure. They demand a perfection of faith to which nothing can be added, and a love equal to what Christ showed toward us. Like the other group, they bar everyone from this sacred feast. If their view were right, everyone who receives would receive unworthily, since all without exception are guilty and imperfect. It would be foolish, even idiotic, to require for receiving the sacrament a perfection that would make the sacrament pointless and superfluous. It wasn't instituted for the perfect but for the weak and sick, to stir up, excite, stimulate and exercise the feeling of faith and love, and at the same time to correct the shortcomings of both.
43. The outward form of the ordinance, and the order of service
As for the outward form of the ordinance, it makes no difference whether believers take the bread in their hands and divide it among themselves, or each eats what is given to him; whether they return the cup to the deacon or hand it to their neighbour; whether the bread is leavened or unleavened and the wine red or white. These things are indifferent and left to the Church's freedom. It is certain, though, that the ancient Church's custom was for all to receive into their hand, and Christ said, "Take this and divide it among yourselves" (Luke 22:17). History reports that leavened, ordinary bread was used until the time of Alexander, bishop of Rome, who was the first to prefer unleavened bread. I don't see why, unless it was to catch the astonished eyes of the crowd by the novelty of the spectacle more than to train them in sound religion.
I appeal to anyone with the slightest zeal for piety: don't they see how much more brightly God's glory shines here, and how much more spiritual comfort believers feel, than in those stiff and theatrical foolishnesses whose only use is to impress the gaping crowd? They call it restraining the people by religion, when in fact the stupefied people are dragged this way and that by superstition. If anyone wants to defend such inventions by antiquity, I know how old the use of chrism and exorcism in baptism is, and how soon after the age of the apostles the Supper was tainted. Such is the forwardness of human confidence, which can't restrain itself but is always playing and romping in the mysteries of God. But let us remember that God values obedience to his word so highly that he wants us by it to judge angels and the whole world.
Once all this mass of ceremonies is dropped, the sacrament could be celebrated in the most fitting way if it were given to the Church very frequently, at least once a week. It should begin with public prayer. Then a sermon should be preached. Then the minister, having placed bread and wine on the table, should read the institution of the Supper. He should next explain the promises given there, and at the same time keep back from communion all those excluded by the Lord's prohibition. He should then pray that the Lord, who has been kind enough to give us this sacred food, would also train and teach us to receive it with faith and gratitude, and, as we are unworthy in ourselves, would make us worthy of the feast by his mercy. Then either a psalm should be sung or something read, while the faithful in order share in the sacred feast, the minister breaking the bread and giving it to the people. When the Supper is over, there should be an exhortation to sincere faith and the confession of faith, to love and to lives that fit Christians. Last, thanks should be given and God's praises sung. After that the Church should be dismissed in peace.
44. Frequent communion in the early Church
What we've said about the sacrament shows abundantly that it was not instituted to be received once a year, and then perfunctorily, as is now the common custom. It was instituted so that all Christians might use it often and often call to mind the sufferings of Christ, thereby sustaining and strengthening their faith, stirring themselves to sing God's praises and proclaim his goodness, and nurturing and testifying toward each other that mutual love whose bond they see in the unity of Christ's body. Every time we share in the symbol of our Saviour's body, as if a pledge were given and received, we bind ourselves to each other to all the duties of love, so that none of us does anything to hurt a brother or sister, or leaves undone anything that could help when need arises and opportunity offers.
That this was the practice of the apostolic Church Luke tells us in Acts: "They devoted themselves to the apostles' teaching and the fellowship, to the breaking of bread and the prayers" (Acts 2:42). So we should always make sure that no assembly of the Church is held without the word, prayer, the distribution of the Supper, and alms. We can gather from Paul that this was the order the Corinthians observed, and it is certain that this was the practice for many ages afterward. By the ancient canons attributed to Anacletus and Calixtus, after the consecration all were to communicate who did not want to be outside the Church's bounds. In the ancient canons that bear the name "Apostolic," those who do not stay to the end and share in the sacred communion are to be corrected as disturbing the Church. The Council of Antioch decreed that those who enter the Church and hear the Scriptures but abstain from communion are to be removed from the Church until they amend. And although the first Council of Toulouse softened this, or at least put it in milder terms, it too decreed that those who after hearing the sermon never communicated were to be warned, and if they still abstained after warning, excluded.
45. Augustine and Chrysostom on neglect
By these rulings holy men wanted to keep and secure the use of frequent communion, handed down by the apostles themselves. It was most beneficial to believers, and they saw it gradually falling out of use through the people's negligence. Augustine says of his own age: "The sacrament of the unity of our Lord's body is in some places provided daily, in others at certain intervals, at the Lord's table; and at that table some partake to life, others to destruction" (on John, tractate 26). And in his letter to Januarius: "Some communicate daily in the body and blood of the Lord; others receive on certain days. In some places not a day passes on which it is not offered; in others only on the Sabbath and the Lord's Day; in others on the Lord's Day only."
Since the people were sometimes slack, holy men urged them with sharp rebukes, so as not to seem to condone their laziness. Chrysostom is an example (on Ephesians, homily 3): "It wasn't said to the man who dishonoured the feast, 'Why have you not taken your seat?' but 'How did you get in here?' (Matt. 22:12). Whoever does not partake of the sacred rites is wicked and shameless to be present. Suppose someone invited to a feast came in, washed his hands, took his seat and seemed ready to eat, and then tasted nothing. Wouldn't he insult both the feast and the host? So you, standing among those who prepare by prayer to take the sacred food, profess to be one of them by not leaving, and yet you don't partake. Wouldn't it have been better not to appear at all? 'I am unworthy,' you say. Then you were not worthy of the communion of prayer either, which is the preparation for taking the sacred mystery."
46. Communion once a year is the devil's invention
Without doubt, the custom of communion once a year is an invention of the devil, whoever brought it in. They say Zephyrinus was the author of the decree, though it is impossible to believe it was the same as what we now have. It may be that, as things were then, his ordinance did the Church no harm. There can be no doubt that at that time the sacred Supper was given to the faithful at every meeting, and that a great part of them communicated. But it hardly ever happened that all could communicate at the same time, and those who lived among the profane and idolaters needed to testify their faith by some outward sign. So this holy man, for the sake of order, appointed that day, so that on it all of Christendom might make a confession of faith by sharing in the Lord's Supper.
Zephyrinus's ordinance, otherwise good, was perverted by those who came after, when they made a fixed law of one communion a year. As a result almost everyone, once they have communicated, sleep on in security as if discharged for the rest of the year. It should have been quite otherwise. Each week at least the Lord's table should have been spread for the company of Christians, and the promises declared on which we might then feed spiritually. No one should be forced, but all should be urged and encouraged, and the torpor of the sluggish should be rebuked, so that all, like starving people, come to the feast. I complained at the outset, then, with good reason, that this practice was brought in by the devil's craft, since by prescribing one day in the year it makes the whole year a time of sloth.
We see that this perverse abuse had already crept in by Chrysostom's time, but we also see how much it displeased him. In the passage I just quoted he complains bitterly of the inequality, that people did not come often during the rest of the year even when prepared, but came only at Easter, though unprepared. Then he cries out: "O custom! O presumption! The daily offering is made in vain; we stand at the altar in vain. There is no one to partake with us." He was far from approving the practice by lending it his authority.
47. Communion in one kind
From the same workshop came another rule, which snatched half the Supper from the greater part of God's people: the symbol of blood. It was forbidden to the "laity" and "profane" (such are the names they give to God's heritage) and became the private possession of a few shaven and anointed men. The decree of the eternal God is that all are to drink. An upstart dares to cancel and repeal this with a new and contrary law that says all are not to drink.
So that such legislators won't seem to fight against their God for no reason, they pretend there are dangers if the sacred cup were given indiscriminately to all, as if the eternal wisdom of God had not seen and provided for those. Then they argue cleverly that one kind is enough for both. If the body is, as they say, the whole Christ, who can't be separated from his body, then the blood is included in the body by concomitance. Here we see how far our own understanding is from God's agreement when it begins to romp with loosened reins. The Lord points to the bread and says, "This is my body." Then pointing to the cup, he calls it his blood. The boldness of human reason objects, "The bread is the blood, the wine is the body," as if the Lord had distinguished his body from his blood in both words and signs for no reason, and as if anyone had ever heard Christ's body or blood called God and man. If he had meant to designate himself whole, he could have said, "It is I," in the manner of Scripture, and not "This is my body," "This is my blood."
But wanting to help the weakness of our faith, he put the cup apart from the bread, to show that he is enough for us as drink no less than as food. If one part is taken away, we can find only half of the elements in what remains. So even if it were true, as they pretend, that the blood is in the bread and the body in the cup by concomitance, they would still deprive the godly of the confirmation of faith that Christ delivered as necessary. Let's say goodbye to their subtleties and keep the benefit that comes, by Christ's ordinance, from a double pledge.
48. The evasions answered, and the witness of the early Church
I know how the servants of Satan, who habitually mock the Scriptures, quibble here. First, they say that from a simple fact we aren't to make a rule binding on the Church for ever. But they say what is untrue when they call it a simple fact. Christ not only gave the cup but appointed that the apostles should do so in future. His words contain the command: "Drink of it, all of you." And Paul reports that it was done that way and recommends it as a settled institution. Another evasion is that Christ admitted only the apostles to this sacred Supper, because he had already chosen them for the priesthood. I wish they would answer five questions they can't dodge, which easily refute them and their lies.
First, by what oracle was this solution, so contrary to the word of God, revealed to them? Scripture names twelve who sat down with Jesus, but it doesn't so detract from Christ's dignity as to call them priests. Besides, although he gave it then to twelve, he commanded them to "do this," that is, to distribute it among themselves in the same way.
Second, why did all without exception share in both symbols during that purer age, from the apostles down for a thousand years? Did the early Church not know who the guests were whom Christ wanted admitted to his Supper? It would be the most shameless impudence to carp and quibble here. We have church histories, and we have the writings of the Fathers, which supply clear proofs. Tertullian says, "The flesh feeds on the body and blood of Christ, that the soul may be filled with God." Ambrose says to Theodosius, "How will you receive the sacred body of the Lord with such hands? How will you have the boldness to put the cup of the precious blood to your lips?" Jerome speaks of "the priests who perform the Eucharist and distribute the Lord's blood to the people." Chrysostom says, "Not as under the old law, where the priest ate one part and the people another, but one body and one cup is set before all. All that belongs to the Eucharist is common to priest and people." Augustine attests the same in many places.
49. The early witness continues
But why argue about a fact so well known? Look at all the Greek and Latin writers. Passages like these appear everywhere. Nor did the practice fall into disuse as long as the Church had any integrity. Gregory, whom you may rightly call the last bishop of Rome, says it was observed in his time: "What the blood of the Lamb is, you have learned not by hearing but by drinking. His blood is poured into the mouths of the faithful." Even four hundred years after his death, when everything had degraded, the practice remained. It was regarded not merely as a custom but as an inviolable law. Reverence for the divine institution was still kept, and they had no doubt it was sacrilege to separate what the Lord had joined. Gelasius says: "We find that some, taking only the portion of the sacred body, abstain from the cup. These people, who seem caught in some strange superstition, should either receive the whole sacrament or be kept from the whole. For the division of this mystery cannot be made without great sacrilege."
Cyprian gave reasons that surely ought to weigh with Christian minds: "How do we teach or urge them to shed their blood in confessing Christ, if we deny Christ's blood to those about to enlist? Or how do we make them fit for the cup of martyrdom, if we do not first admit them by right of communion in the Church to drink the cup of the Lord?" (Sermon on the Lapsed). The canonists' attempt to restrict Gelasius's decree to priests is too childish a quibble to deserve a reply.
50. The last questions, and conclusion
Third, why did our Saviour say of the bread simply "Take, eat," and of the cup "Drink of it, all of you," as if he had deliberately meant to provide against Satan's craft? Fourth, if, as they say, the Lord honoured priests alone with his Supper, who would ever have dared to call in outsiders whom the Lord had excluded, to share a gift that wasn't in his power to give, without a command from the only one who could give it? And what presumption it is today to distribute the symbol of Christ's body to the common people, if they have neither command nor example from the Lord! Fifth, did Paul lie when he told the Corinthians, "I received from the Lord what I also delivered to you" (1 Cor. 11:23)? What he delivered, he goes on to say, was that all should communicate in both symbols without distinction. If Paul received from the Lord that all were to be admitted without distinction, let those who drive away almost the whole people of God see from whom they received their rule. They can't pretend now to have their authority from God, with whom there is no "Yes and No" (2 Cor. 1:19-20).
And yet they dare to cloak these abominations with the name of the Church and defend them on that pretext, as if those Antichrists were the Church, who so recklessly trample on, waste and repeal the teaching and institutions of Christ, or as if the apostolic Church, in which religion flourished in full strength, were not the Church.
Chapter 18
The Popish Mass: How It Not Only Profanes but Abolishes the Lord's Supper
1. The mass as the chief abomination set against the Supper
By these and similar inventions Satan has tried to smother the sacred Supper of Christ in thick darkness, so that its purity would not survive in the Church. But the head of this horrid abomination was a sign he raised which didn't just cloud and distort the Supper but wiped it out altogether, so that it vanished from human memory. With a most pestilential error he blinded almost the whole world into believing that the mass is a sacrifice and offering that wins the forgiveness of sins.
I say nothing about how the sounder schoolmen first received this idea. I leave them to their puzzling subtleties, which, however cleverly they are defended, every good person should reject, since all they do is wrap the brightness of the Supper in deeper darkness. Setting them aside, let my readers understand that I am fighting the opinion with which the Roman Antichrist and his prophets have filled the whole world: that the mass is a work by which the priest who offers Christ, and the others who share in the offering, earn merit with God; or that it is an expiatory victim by which they win back God's favour. This isn't only the common opinion of the crowd. The rite itself is arranged as a kind of propitiation, by which satisfaction is made to God for the living and the dead. The words used say so, and so does daily practice.
I know how deep this plague has sunk its roots. I know how well it hides under a show of goodness, carrying the name of Christ in front of it and persuading many that the whole sum of the faith is contained in the single word "mass". But once it has been shown plainly from God's word that this mass, however glossed and splendid, is the greatest insult to Christ, that it buries his cross, consigns his death to oblivion, takes away the benefit his death was meant to bring, and weakens and scatters the sacrament by which the memory of his death was kept alive, will its roots be so deep that this most powerful axe, the word of God, cannot cut it down? Will any appearance be so attractive that this light cannot expose the evil lurking inside it?
2. First blasphemy: priests put in the place of the only Priest
So let me show, as I promised, that the mass heaps intolerable blasphemy and insult on Christ. The Father didn't appoint him Priest and Pontiff for a limited time, as priests were appointed under the Old Testament. Their lives were mortal, so their priesthood couldn't be immortal, and successors had to be put in the place of the dead. But Christ is immortal and has no need of a stand-in. So the Father appointed him "a priest for ever, after the order of Melchizedek" (Ps. 110:4; Heb. 5:6), to exercise a priesthood that never passes to anyone else. This was pictured long before in Melchizedek, whom Scripture introduces once as priest of the living God and never mentions again, as though he had no end of life. That's the sense in which Christ is a priest after his order.
But those who sacrifice daily must necessarily hand the offering over to priests whom they appoint as Christ's vicars and successors. By doing this they rob Christ of his honour and strip him of his eternal priesthood. They even try to remove him from the Father's right hand, where he can't sit as an immortal unless he is an eternal priest. They can't say that their priestlings are substituted for Christ not as if he were dead, but as stand-ins in a priesthood that never ceases. The apostle's words leave no room to wriggle: "The former priests were many in number, because they were prevented by death from continuing in office, but he holds his priesthood permanently, because he continues for ever" (Heb. 7:23-24).
Still, to defend their impiety, they arm themselves with the example of Melchizedek. He "brought out bread and wine" (Gen. 14:18), they say, so this must foreshadow their mass, as if there were any likeness between Christ and Melchizedek in the offering of bread and wine. The claim is too silly to need an answer. Melchizedek gave bread and wine to Abraham and his companions to refresh them after the march and the battle. What has that to do with sacrifice? Moses praises the kindness of a holy king, and these men invent a mystery of which he says nothing.
They try another gloss, because the text adds at once that he was "priest of God Most High". My answer is that they wrongly twist to the bread and wine what the apostle applies to the blessing: "This Melchizedek, king of Salem, priest of God Most High, met Abraham and blessed him." From this the same apostle, and no one could interpret better, argues his superiority: "It is beyond dispute that the lesser is blessed by the greater" (Heb. 7:1, 7). And if Melchizedek's offering were a figure of the sacrifice of the mass, would the apostle, who goes into the smallest details, have forgotten something so grave? However they quibble, they can't destroy the argument the apostle himself gives: the right and honour of the priesthood has ceased among mortal men, because Christ, who is immortal, is the one perpetual priest.
3. Second blasphemy: the altar overthrows the cross
Another iniquity of the mass is that it sinks and buries the cross and passion of Christ. This much is perfectly certain: the cross of Christ is overthrown the moment an altar is erected. If on the cross he offered himself as a sacrifice to sanctify us for ever and win eternal redemption for us (Heb. 9:11-12; 10:10, 14), then the power and efficacy of his sacrifice has no end. Otherwise we would think no more highly of Christ than of the oxen and calves sacrificed under the law, whose offering is shown to be weak and ineffective precisely because it had to be repeated. So we must admit either that the sacrifice Christ offered on the cross lacked the power of eternal cleansing, or that he accomplished it once for all by his one sacrifice.
That's why the apostle says: "Now once at the end of the age he has appeared to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself" (Heb. 9:26). Again: "We have been sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all" (Heb. 10:10). And again: "By a single offering he has perfected for all time those who are being sanctified" (Heb. 10:14). He adds the well-known conclusion: "Where there is forgiveness of these, there is no longer any offering for sin" (Heb. 10:18). Christ said the same with his last breath, when he cried as he gave up his spirit, "It is finished" (John 19:30). We usually treat the last words of the dying as weighty. Christ, dying, declares that by his one sacrifice everything needed for our salvation is accomplished and complete. Are we, as if it were imperfect, going to dare to add innumerable sacrifices to it every day?
God's holy word doesn't merely affirm but proclaims and insists that this sacrifice was accomplished once and remains in force for ever. So don't those who demand another accuse it of weakness and imperfection? And what is the purpose of the mass, set up so that a hundred thousand sacrifices can be offered every day, but to bury and suppress the passion of our Lord, in which he offered himself to his Father as the only victim? Anyone not blind can see that it was Satanic audacity to oppose a truth so clear and transparent.
I know the cover the father of lies usually puts over his fraud: that the sacrifices aren't different or many, but that the one sacrifice is repeated. That smoke is easily blown away. The apostle argues throughout his whole discourse not only that there are no other sacrifices, but that this one was offered once and is never to be repeated. The more subtle try to escape through a narrower gap: it isn't repetition, they say, but application. This sophism is just as easy to refute. Christ didn't offer himself once so that his sacrifice would be ratified every day by fresh offerings. He offered himself once so that its benefit would be communicated to us through the preaching of the gospel and the dispensing of the sacred Supper. So Paul says, "Christ, our Passover lamb, has been sacrificed," and tells us to "celebrate the festival" (1 Cor. 5:7-8). The way the cross of Christ is truly applied to us is when its enjoyment is communicated to us and we receive it with true faith.
4. The appeal to Malachi
It's worth hearing what other foundation they give their sacrifice of the mass. They drag in the prophecy of Malachi, where the Lord promises that "in every place incense will be offered to my name, and a pure offering" (Mal. 1:11). As if it were new or unusual for the prophets, when they speak of the calling of the Gentiles, to describe the spiritual worship of God to which those nations are summoned in the outward rites of the law! That was the plainest way of telling the people of their own age that they were to be called into true fellowship in religion, just as the prophets generally describe the truth revealed in the gospel by the types of their own time. So they use going up to Jerusalem for turning to the Lord, bringing every kind of gift for the worship of God, and dreams and visions for the fuller knowledge that believers would receive in Christ's kingdom.
The passage they quote from Malachi resembles one in Isaiah, where the prophet speaks of three altars to be set up in Assyria, Egypt and Judea (Isa. 19:19). I ask them three things. Do they grant that this prophecy is fulfilled in the kingdom of Christ? Where are those altars, and when were they ever built? And do they suppose a single temple is meant for a single kingdom, as the temple at Jerusalem was? If they think about these things, they will admit, I believe, that under types suited to his age the prophet was foretelling the spread of the spiritual worship of God over the whole world.
That's our answer. Examples like this are everywhere in Scripture, so I won't list more. They are also miserably deceived in thinking the mass is the only sacrifice there is, when in truth believers now sacrifice to God and offer him a pure offering, as I'll explain shortly.
5. Third blasphemy: a new testament and the memory of Christ's death erased
Now I come to the third thing the mass does: it wipes out the true and only death of Christ and drives it from human memory. Among men, a testament is confirmed by the death of the one who made it. In the same way our Lord confirmed by his death the testament in which he left us forgiveness of sins and eternal righteousness. Anyone who dares to change or add to this testament denies his death and treats it as of no importance.
And what is the mass but a new and altogether different testament? Doesn't every mass promise a new forgiveness of sins and a new purchase of righteousness, so that there are now as many testaments as there are masses? Then let Christ come again and make this new testament by another death, or rather ratify the innumerable testaments of the mass by innumerable deaths! Didn't I say truly at the start that the one true death of Christ is wiped out by the mass? What does the mass aim at, directly, but to put Christ to death again, if that were possible? As the apostle says, "Where a will is involved, the death of the one who made it must be established" (Heb. 9:16). The novelty of the mass shows on its face that it is a testament of Christ, and so it demands his death.
Besides, the victim offered must be slain and immolated. If Christ is sacrificed at each mass, he must be cruelly slain every moment in a thousand places. That isn't my argument but the apostle's: "Nor was it to offer himself repeatedly... for then he would have had to suffer repeatedly since the foundation of the world" (Heb. 9:25-26).
I admit they have an answer ready, and they even accuse us of slander, saying we charge them with something they never thought and couldn't think. We know the life and death of Christ are not in their hands. We don't care whether they mean to kill him. Our aim is only to show the absurdity that follows from their impious and accursed dogma, and I demonstrate it from the apostle's own mouth. They may insist a hundred times that the sacrifice is "bloodless". I reply that it doesn't depend on human will to change the nature of sacrifice, for that would overturn God's sacred and inviolable institution. The apostle's principle therefore stands firm: "without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness of sins" (Heb. 9:22).
6. Fourth blasphemy: the benefit of Christ's death taken away
The fourth feature of the mass is that it robs us of the benefit that came to us through Christ's death, because it stops us recognising it and thinking of it. Who can believe he has been redeemed by Christ's death when he sees a new redemption in the mass? Who can feel sure that his sins are forgiven when he sees a new forgiveness? It's no good saying that we obtain forgiveness in the mass only because it was already purchased by Christ's death. That is the same as saying we are redeemed by Christ on condition that we redeem ourselves.
The doctrine spread by Satan's ministers, which they defend today with clamour, fire and sword, is that when we offer Christ to the Father in the mass, we obtain forgiveness of sins by this work of offering and become partakers of Christ's sufferings. What is left for Christ's sufferings, then, but to be an example of redemption from which we learn to be our own redeemers?
Christ himself, when he seals our assurance of pardon in the Supper, doesn't tell his disciples to stop at that act. He sends them to the sacrifice of his death, showing that the Supper is a reminder, or as it's commonly called a memorial, from which they may learn that the expiatory victim to appease God was to be offered only once. It isn't enough to hold that Christ is the only victim. We must also hold that his is the only immolation, so that our faith may be fixed on his cross.
7. Fifth blasphemy: the Supper itself abolished
Now I come to the crowning point. When the mass was set up, the sacred Supper, on which the Lord left the memorial of his passion formed and engraved, was taken away, hidden and destroyed. The Supper is a gift of God, to be received with thanksgiving. The sacrifice of the mass pretends to give God a price, to be received as satisfaction. Sacrifice differs from the sacrament of the Supper as widely as giving differs from receiving. Here human ingratitude shows itself in its wretchedness. When the generosity of God's goodness ought to have been acknowledged and thanks returned, man makes God his debtor.
The sacrament promised that by Christ's death we were not only restored to life once but are constantly quickened, because all the parts of our salvation were then completed. The sacrifice of the mass speaks very differently: Christ must be sacrificed daily so that he can lend us something.
The Supper was to be dispensed at the public gathering of the Church, to remind us of the fellowship by which we are all united in Christ Jesus. The sacrifice of the mass dissolves and tears that fellowship apart. After the heresy took hold that priests had to sacrifice for the people, as if the Supper had been handed over to them, it stopped being shared with the assembly of believers as the Lord commanded. In came private masses, which look more like a kind of excommunication than the communion the Lord ordained, since the priestling, about to devour his victim by himself, separates himself from the whole body of the faithful. Let there be no mistake: I call it a private mass whenever believers don't partake of the Lord's Supper together, however great a crowd may be standing by.
8. Where the mass came from, and why private masses profane the Supper
I've never been able to find out for certain where the name "mass" came from. It seems likely that it was taken from the offerings collected, which is why the ancients usually speak of it in the plural. But I won't argue about the name. I hold that private masses are diametrically opposed to Christ's institution and are therefore an impious profanation of the sacred Supper.
What did the Lord command? Wasn't it to take and divide among ourselves? What does Paul teach about keeping this command? Isn't it that the breaking of bread is the communion of the body and blood (1 Cor. 10:16)? So when one person takes without distributing, where is the likeness? "But he acts in the name of the whole Church." By what command? Isn't it openly mocking God when one man privately grabs for himself what ought to be shared among many?
The words of our Saviour and of Paul are clear enough, so we can conclude briefly: wherever there is no breaking of bread for the communion of the faithful, there is no Supper of the Lord, only a false and preposterous imitation of it. A false imitation is an adulteration, and adulterating so high an ordinance is not without impiety. So private masses are an impious abuse. And as in religion one fault always begets another, once the custom of offering without communion crept in, they began to say innumerable masses in all the separate corners of the churches, and to pull the people this way and that when they should have come together as one assembly and so recognised the mystery of their unity.
Let them now go and deny their idolatry, when they hold up the bread in their masses to be adored as Christ. It's no use quoting the promises of Christ's presence. However those promises are understood, they were certainly not given so that impure and profane men could make Christ's body as often as they like and for whatever abuse they like. They were given so that believers, who follow Christ's command in celebrating the Supper with reverence, could truly share in it.
9. The purer Church knew nothing of this, and Scripture knows nothing of it
I add that this perverse practice was unknown to the purer Church. The more shameless of our opponents may try to gloss over it and shelter behind the ancient teachers, but it is plain as the noonday sun that everything they do is contrary to ancient practice. It is an abuse that arrived when everything in the Church had become depraved and corrupted. As I've shown in other cases, all antiquity is against them, and anyone who reads the Fathers diligently can verify it.
Before I finish, I ask our doctors of the missal a question. They know that obedience is better than sacrifice and that God wants us to listen to his voice rather than offer sacrifice (1 Sam. 15:22). How can they believe this way of sacrificing pleases God, when it is certain that he doesn't command it, and they can't support it with one syllable of Scripture?
And when they hear the apostle say that "no one takes this honour on himself, but only when called by God, just as Aaron was", and that Christ too "did not exalt himself to be made a high priest, but was appointed by him who said to him, 'You are my Son, today I have begotten you'" (Heb. 5:4-5), they must either prove that God is the author and founder of their priesthood, or admit that no honour from God belongs to an office they have rushed into, uncalled, with wicked rashness. They can't produce one iota of Scripture for their priesthood. And must not their sacrifices be vain, since they can't be offered without a priest?
10. What the ancients meant by "sacrifice"
Someone may push at me short sayings of the ancients and, on their authority, insist that the sacrifice performed in the Supper should be understood differently from the way I've explained it. My brief reply is this. If the question is whether the Fathers approve the fiction of sacrifice as the papists imagine it in the mass, there is nothing in them to support the sacrilege. They do use the word "sacrifice", but they explain at the same time that they mean nothing more than the commemoration of that one true sacrifice which Christ, our only sacrifice, as they themselves everywhere proclaim, performed on the cross.
Augustine says: "The Hebrews, in the victims of beasts which they offered to God, celebrated the prediction of the future victim which Christ offered. Christians now celebrate the memory of a finished sacrifice by the sacred offering and sharing of the body of Christ" (Against Faustus 20.18). The treatise on faith addressed to Peter the deacon, whoever wrote it, teaches the same at greater length: "Hold most firmly and have no doubt at all that the Only-Begotten became incarnate for us, that he offered himself for us as an offering and sacrifice to God for a sweet-smelling savour. To him, with the Father and the Holy Spirit, animals were sacrificed in the time of the Old Testament, and to him now, with the Father and the Holy Spirit, with whom he is one God, the holy Church throughout the world does not cease to offer the sacrifice of bread and wine. For in those fleshly victims there was a picture of the flesh of Christ, which he was to offer for our sins, and of the blood he was to shed for the forgiveness of sins. But in this sacrifice there is thanksgiving and remembrance of the flesh he offered for us and the blood he shed for us."
Augustine himself explains in several places (Letter 120 to Honoratus; Against an Adversary of the Law) that it is nothing other than a sacrifice of praise. In short, you will find throughout his writings that the Lord's Supper is called a sacrifice only because it is a commemoration, an image and a testimony of that singular, true and only sacrifice by which Christ paid for our guilt.
There is a memorable passage in On the Trinity (4.14), where after discussing the one sacrifice he concludes: "In a sacrifice four things are considered: to whom it is offered, by whom, what is offered, and for whom. The one true Mediator, reconciling us to God by the sacrifice of peace, remained one with him to whom he offered, made himself one with those for whom he offered, and is himself both the one who offered and the one thing offered." Chrysostom speaks to the same effect. The ancients so firmly claim the honour of the priesthood for Christ alone that Augustine says it would be the act of Antichrist to make any bishop an intercessor between God and man (Against Parmenian 2.8).
11. Where some of the ancients went wrong
We don't deny that in the Supper the sacrifice of Christ is displayed so vividly that it almost sets the sight of the cross before our eyes. The apostle says the same to the Galatians: Jesus Christ was "publicly portrayed" before their eyes when the preaching of the cross reached them (Gal. 3:1). But I can see that those ancient writers bent this commemoration to a purpose different from what the divine institution intended. Somehow the Supper seemed to them to present the look of a repeated, or at least renewed, sacrifice.
So the safest course for the godly is to rest satisfied with God's pure and simple ordinance. It is called his Supper precisely because his authority alone ought to appear in it. The ancients kept a pious and orthodox understanding of the whole ordinance, and I can't find that they meant to take anything away from the Lord's one sacrifice. So I can't charge them with impiety. Still, I think they can't be excused from erring somewhat in the manner of the action. They imitated the Jewish way of sacrificing more closely than either Christ ordained or the nature of the gospel allowed. The only thing they can fairly be blamed for is this misplaced analogy: not content with Christ's simple and genuine institution, they leaned too much toward the shadows of the law.
12. A table, not an altar
Anyone who looks carefully will see that the Lord's word makes a distinction between the Mosaic sacrifices and our eucharist. The former showed the Jewish people the same efficacy of Christ's death that is now shown to us in the Supper, but the form of the picture was different. There the Levitical priests were ordered to prefigure the sacrifice Christ would accomplish. A victim stood in for Christ himself, an altar was built on which it was to be slain, and the whole service was arranged to set before the eye an image of the sacrifice to be offered to God in expiation.
Now that the sacrifice has been made, the Lord has prescribed a different method for us: to pass on to his believing people the benefit of the sacrifice his Son offered. So the Lord has given us a table at which to feast, not an altar on which to offer a victim. He hasn't consecrated priests to sacrifice but ministers to distribute a sacred meal.
The more sublime and holy this mystery is, the more reverently it must be handled. Nothing is safer than to banish all the boldness of human sense and hold only to what Scripture delivers. If we remember that it is the Supper of the Lord and not of men, why should we let any human authority or length of custom turn us a nail's breadth from Scripture? That's why the apostle, wanting to remove completely the vices that had crept into the Church at Corinth, took the quickest route and called them back to the institution itself, showing that a permanent rule must be drawn from it.
13. What "sacrifice" and "priest" mean here
So that no quarrelsome person can start a dispute with us over the terms "sacrifice" and "priest", I'll briefly explain what we mean by each in this whole discussion. Some people, for no reason I can see, stretch the word "sacrifice" to cover all sacred ceremonies and religious acts. We know that in Scripture's regular usage the name of sacrifice is given to what the Greeks call by several different terms, and in its general sense it includes everything offered to God. So we must make a distinction, and the distinction should follow the sacrifices of the Mosaic law, under whose shadows the Lord chose to represent to his people the whole reality of sacrifices.
Those sacrifices took various forms, but all of them can be sorted into two classes. Either an offering was made for sin by a kind of satisfaction, by which the penalty was redeemed before God, or it was a symbol and witness of religion and worship. The second kind was sometimes a petition asking for God's favour, sometimes thanksgiving for benefits received, and sometimes a simple exercise of piety to renew the covenant. Burnt offerings, drink offerings, grain offerings, first fruits and peace offerings belonged here.
Let's divide them into two classes accordingly. One class I'll call sacrifices of thanksgiving or worship, because they consist of the reverence and service believers owe and render to God, and because they are offered only by those who, enriched with his boundless benefits, give themselves and all they do to him in return. The other class I'll call propitiatory, or expiatory. A sacrifice of expiation is one whose purpose is to appease God's wrath, satisfy his justice and so wash away sins, so that the sinner, cleansed and restored to purity, may return to God's favour.
That is why the law gave this name to the victims offered for sin (Exod. 29:36). It wasn't that they could win back God's favour and wipe out guilt. It was that they prefigured the true sacrifice of this kind, which was at last carried out in reality by Christ alone. By him alone, because no one else could. And once only, because the efficacy of Christ's one sacrifice is eternal, as he declared when he said, "It is finished". That is, everything needed to regain the Father's favour and obtain forgiveness of sins, righteousness and salvation was performed and completed by his one offering, and nothing was left lacking. No place remained for another sacrifice.
14. Why the mass is blasphemy and its celebrants are not priests
I conclude, then, that it is an abominable insult and intolerable blasphemy, against Christ and against the sacrifice he made for us on the cross, for anyone to think of repeating the offering, purchasing forgiveness of sins, propitiating God and obtaining justification. And what else is done in the mass but to make us partakers of Christ's sufferings by a new offering?
As if that weren't enough, they weren't satisfied to say that it is properly a common sacrifice for the whole Church. They added that they can apply it specially to this person or that, as they choose, or rather to anyone willing to buy their merchandise at a price. They couldn't match the price Judas got, but to claim some kinship with their founder they make the likeness lie in the number. He sold for thirty pieces of silver. They, by the French way of reckoning, sell for thirty pieces of brass. He did it once. They do it as often as a buyer turns up.
We deny that they are priests in this sense, that by such offerings they intercede with God for the people and make expiation for sins by propitiating him. Christ is the only Pontiff and Priest of the New Testament. All priestly offices were transferred to him, and in him they closed and ended. Even if Scripture said nothing of the eternal priesthood of Christ, God has appointed no new priest after abolishing the ancient sacrifices, and so the apostle's argument stands unanswerable: "No one takes this honour on himself, but only when called by God, just as Aaron was" (Heb. 5:4). How can these sacrilegious men, who by their own account are murderers of Christ, dare to call themselves priests of the living God?
15. Plato's irony turned on the mass
There is a most elegant passage in the second book of Plato's Republic. Speaking of ancient expiations, he mocks the foolish confidence of wicked men who thought these rites were veils for hiding their crimes from the gods. As if they had made a pact with the gods, they sinned the more securely. In describing this he seems to give an accurate picture of how the expiation of the mass is used in the world today.
Everyone knows it's wrong to cheat and defraud another person. To wrong widows, plunder orphans, harass the poor, seize other people's goods by crooked means, get hold of an inheritance by fraud and perjury, or oppress by violence and tyrannical terror: everyone admits these things are impious. So how do so many dare to do them all, as if sure of getting away with it? If we think carefully, the only thing giving them such nerve is that they trust that by the sacrifice of the mass, as a price paid, they will satisfy God, or at least easily find a way to settle with him.
Plato goes on to mock the gross stupidity of those who think they can buy off, by such expiations, the punishments they would otherwise suffer after death. And what are the anniversary masses and most of the masses said today but a means for those who have lived as the cruellest tyrants, the most rapacious plunderers, or experts in every kind of wickedness, to escape the fire of purgatory, as if they'd been redeemed at that price?
16. The sacrifice of thanksgiving: love and the offering of ourselves
The other kind of sacrifice, which I've called eucharistic, includes all the duties of love by which we embrace our brothers and sisters and so honour the Lord himself in his members. It includes all our prayers, praises and thanksgivings, and every act of worship we perform for God. All of these depend on the greater sacrifice by which we dedicate ourselves, body and soul, to be a holy temple to the Lord. It isn't enough for our outward acts to be shaped to obedience. We must first dedicate and consecrate ourselves, and then all we have, so that everything in us serves his glory and is stirred up to magnify it.
This kind of sacrifice has nothing to do with appeasing God, with obtaining forgiveness of sins or with winning justification. It is wholly given to magnifying and praising God, since it can only be pleasing and acceptable to him from those who have already received forgiveness and been reconciled and freed from guilt. The Church can't do without it. So it will last for ever, as long as the people of God last, as we saw above from the prophet. In this sense we can understand the prophecy, "From the rising of the sun to its setting my name will be great among the nations, and in every place incense will be offered to my name, and a pure offering" (Mal. 1:11). We are very far from abolishing this sacrifice.
So Paul urges us, by the mercies of God, to present our bodies "as a living sacrifice, holy and acceptable to God, which is your spiritual worship" (Rom. 12:1). It's significant that he adds "spiritual", because he is pointing to the spiritual way of worshipping God and quietly setting it against the fleshly sacrifices of the Mosaic law. In the same way, doing good and sharing are called sacrifices with which God is pleased (Heb. 13:16). The kindness of the Philippians in meeting Paul's needs is called "a fragrant offering, a sacrifice acceptable and pleasing to God" (Phil. 4:18). And so all the good works of believers are called spiritual sacrifices.
17. Praise, thanksgiving and the priesthood of all believers
Why list them all? This way of speaking is constant in Scripture. Even while God's people were kept under the outward guardianship of the law, the prophets made clear that beneath those fleshly sacrifices lay a reality shared by the Jewish people and the Christian Church. So David prayed, "Let my prayer be counted as incense before you" (Ps. 141:2). Hosea gives the name "the fruit of our lips" (Hos. 14:2) to thanksgivings, which David elsewhere calls "sacrifices of praise". The apostle follows him in speaking of offering "a sacrifice of praise to God", which he explains as "the fruit of lips that acknowledge his name" (Heb. 13:15).
This kind of sacrifice is indispensable in the Lord's Supper, where we proclaim his death and give him thanks, and offer nothing but the sacrifice of praise. From this duty of sacrificing, all Christians are called "a royal priesthood" (1 Pet. 2:9), because through Christ we offer that sacrifice of praise of which the apostle speaks, the fruit of our lips giving thanks to his name. We don't come into God's presence with our gifts without an intercessor. Christ is our Mediator, and through him we offer ourselves and all we have to the Father. He is our High Priest, who has entered the upper sanctuary and opens the way for us. He is the altar on which we lay our gifts, so that whatever we attempt, we attempt in him. He is the one who "has made us a kingdom, priests to his God and Father" (Rev. 1:6).
18. A cup of gold: the mass in its best dress
What remains but for the blind to see, the deaf to hear, even children to perceive the abomination of the mass? Held out in a golden cup, it has so intoxicated all the kings and nations of the earth, from highest to lowest, and so struck them with stupor and giddiness, that, duller than animals, they have staked the vessel of their salvation on this fatal whirlpool. Satan never used a more powerful engine to assault and storm the kingdom of Christ. This is the Helen for whom the enemies of the truth fight today with such rage, fury and cruelty, and truly the Helen with whom they commit spiritual adultery, the most execrable of all.
I'm not laying my little finger on the gross abuses by which they might pretend the purity of their sacred mass is profaned: the vile trade they carry on, the sordid profit they make, the greed they feed on. I'm only pointing out, in a few plain words, how holy the sanctity of the mass is, and how well it has deserved, for several ages, to be admired and venerated! It would be a larger task to illustrate these mysteries as they deserve, and I don't want to meddle with the obscene impurities that lie daily before everyone's eyes. I want it understood that the mass, taken in the choicest form in which it can be presented, without any appendages, teems from head to foot with every kind of impiety, blasphemy, idolatry and sacrilege.
19. A summary of the two sacraments
My readers now have a short view of everything I thought it important to know about these two sacraments, which were given to the Christian Church to be used from the beginning of the new dispensation to the end of the world. Baptism is a kind of entrance into the Church, an initiation into the faith. The Lord's Supper is the constant nourishment with which Christ spiritually feeds his family of believers.
So, as there is one God, one faith, one Christ and one Church, which is his body, so baptism is one and is not repeated. But the Supper is given again and again, to show that those who have once been welcomed into the Church are constantly fed by Christ.
Besides these two, God has instituted no other, and the assembly of the faithful ought to recognise no other. Anyone who remembers what I've already set out plainly will see that sacraments are not to be instituted by human will. Sacraments are appointed by God to instruct us in his promise and testify to his goodwill toward us. And the Lord has no counsellor (Isa. 40:13; Rom. 11:34). Who can give us any certainty about his will, or assure us how he feels toward us, what he is willing to give and what to withhold? It follows that no one can set up a sign meant to be a testimony of his will and a promise. He alone can give the sign and bear witness to himself. Put more briefly, perhaps in plainer but clearer terms: there can never be a sacrament without a promise of salvation. All people gathered into one could not, of themselves, give us any promise of salvation, and so they cannot, of themselves, give out and set up a sacrament.
20. Content with two sacraments: human additions smother God's ordinances
With these two, then, let the Christian Church be content. Let it not only refuse to admit or acknowledge a third now, but not even desire or expect one until the end of the world. To the Jews, besides their ordinary sacraments, others were given that differed somewhat with the times, such as the manna, the water from the rock and the bronze serpent (Exod. 16:13-15; 17:6; Num. 21:9; 1 Cor. 10:4). Through this variety they were reminded not to stop at such figures, whose state couldn't last, but to look for something better from God, lasting without decay and without end.
Our situation is very different. Christ has been revealed to us. In him "are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge" (Col. 2:3), in such richness and abundance that to ask or hope for any new addition to those treasures is to offend God and provoke him against us. We should hunger for Christ alone, seek him, look to him, learn from him, and learn again, until the great day when the Lord fully shows the glory of his kingdom and reveals himself as he is to our astonished eyes (1 John 3:2).
That's why our age is called in Scripture the last hour, the last days, the last times (1 John 2:18; 1 Pet. 1:20), so that no one deceives himself with the empty expectation of some new doctrine or revelation. "Long ago, at many times and in many ways, God spoke to our fathers by the prophets, but in these last days he has spoken to us by his Son" (Heb. 1:1-2). He alone can reveal the Father, and has revealed him fully, as far as matters to us, while we now see him in a mirror (1 Cor. 13:12).
Since men have been denied the power to make new sacraments in God's Church, it would be good if the ones that are of God had as little human invention mixed into them as possible. When water is poured in, the wine is diluted, and when leaven is added, the whole lump is leavened. In the same way the purity of God's ordinances is spoiled whenever man adds anything of his own. And we see how far the sacraments as now practised have fallen from their genuine purity. Everywhere there is more than enough pomp, ceremony and gesturing, while the word of God, without which not even the sacraments are sacraments, is given no account and no mention. In such a crowd the very ceremonies God ordained cannot lift their heads, but lie, so to speak, crushed. In baptism, as we have rightly complained elsewhere, how little is seen of the one thing that ought to shine there, baptism itself! The Supper was altogether buried when it was turned into the mass. The most that can be said is that it is seen once a year, and then in a garbled, mutilated and torn form.
Chapter 19
The Five So-Called Sacraments: Their False Claim Exposed and Their True Character Explained
1. Why the other five need separate treatment
What I've said about the sacraments should be enough, for gentle and sober people, to keep them from curiosity and from accepting, without any authority from God's word, sacraments beyond the two the Lord himself instituted. But the notion of seven sacraments is on almost everyone's lips. It's repeated in every school and sermon, and by sheer antiquity it has put down roots in people's minds. So I think it's worth looking separately and more closely at the other five, which are commonly ranked alongside the Lord's true sacraments. I want to wipe away the polish and hold them up for plain people to see what they really are and how wrongly they've been called sacraments.
I want every believer to know from the start that I'm not quarrelling about a word for the love of an argument. I have weighty reasons for objecting to how it's being used. I know Christians are masters of words, as they are of all things, and may fit words to things at their pleasure, provided the meaning stays godly, even if the expression is somewhat loose. I grant all that, though it's better to make words serve things than things serve words. But with the word "sacrament" the case is different. Those who list seven sacraments define every one of them as a visible form of invisible grace, and then make each a vehicle of the Holy Spirit, an instrument for conferring righteousness, a cause of obtaining grace. Peter Lombard himself denies that the sacraments of the Mosaic Law can properly be called by that name, because they didn't deliver what they pictured. Is it bearable that the signs the Lord consecrated with his own lips and distinguished with magnificent promises should be denied the name, while the honour is handed to rites that men either made up themselves or at least observe without any express command from God? So let them either change the definition or stop using the word, which later breeds false and absurd opinions.
They say extreme unction is a figure and cause of invisible grace because it is a sacrament. If we can't accept that inference, we must at least contest the name, so that we don't receive it on terms that invite the error. And when they prove it's a sacrament, they give the reason that it consists of an outward sign and a word. If we find neither command nor promise, what can we do but protest?
2. Only God can institute a sacrament
So it's clear that we aren't fighting over a word but raising a necessary discussion about the thing itself. We hold firmly to what we've already shown by arguments that can't be answered: the power to institute a sacrament belongs to God alone. A sacrament must, by God's sure promise, lift up and comfort the consciences of believers, and they could never get that assurance from men. A sacrament is meant to be a testimony of God's goodwill toward us, and no man or angel can bear that witness, since God has no counsellor (Isaiah 40:13; Romans 11:34). He alone, with proper authority, testifies about himself in his word. A sacrament is a seal of God's promise. It couldn't be sealed by physical things, the elements of this world, unless God's will had confirmed and set them apart for the purpose. A man can't institute a sacrament, because it isn't in human power to make divine mysteries lie hidden under such lowly things. The word of God must come first to make a sacrament a sacrament, as Augustine shows so well (Homilies on John 80).
It is also useful to keep some distinction between sacraments and other ceremonies, if we want to avoid a lot of absurdity. The apostles prayed on bended knees (Acts 9:40; 20:36), so we mustn't bend our knees without a sacrament. The disciples are said to have prayed toward the east, so looking east is a sacrament. Paul wants men everywhere to lift up holy hands (1 Timothy 2:8), and the saints are often described praying with raised hands, so let the stretching out of hands be a sacrament too. In short, let every gesture of the saints pass into a sacrament. I wouldn't object much to that if it didn't bring greater problems with it.
3. Seven sacraments are unknown to the ancient writers
If they press us with the authority of the ancient Church, they're using a pretext. The number seven is found nowhere in the church writers, and no one knows when it crept in. I admit those writers sometimes use the word "sacrament" freely, but what do they mean by it? All ceremonies, outward rites and exercises of piety. When they speak of the signs that ought to testify to God's favour toward us, they're content with two, baptism and the Eucharist.
So that no one thinks I'm saying this falsely, here are some passages from Augustine. "First, I want you to hold that the main point in this discussion is that our Lord Jesus Christ, as he says in the gospel, has placed us under a light yoke and an easy burden. So he has knit together the fellowship of his new people with sacraments, very few in number, very easy to keep and most excellent in meaning: such is baptism, consecrated in the name of the Trinity, and the communion of the body and blood of the Lord, and any other, if it is recommended in the canonical Scriptures" (Letter 118 to Januarius). Again: "After the resurrection of our Lord, he himself and the apostolic teaching appointed a few signs in place of many, very easy to perform, most majestic in meaning, most pure in observance: such are baptism and the celebration of the body and blood of the Lord" (On Christian Doctrine 3.9).
Why does he make no mention of the sacred number seven? Is it likely he'd have left it out if it had been established in the Church then, especially since he's usually more fussy about numbers than he needs to be? And when he mentions baptism and the Supper and says nothing of the others, doesn't he make it plain enough that these two excel in a special dignity and that other ceremonies take a lower place? So I say that these sacramental teachers are supported neither by God's word nor by the agreement of the early Church, however much they flatter themselves that they have that agreement. Let's now take them one at a time.
Confirmation
4. Confirmation in the ancient Church
In the early Church it was customary for the children of Christians, once they'd grown up, to appear before the bishop and do what was required of adults who came forward for baptism. These adults sat among the catechumens until they'd been properly taught the mysteries of the faith and could make their confession before bishop and people. The infants who had been initiated by baptism hadn't yet confessed their faith to the Church. So toward the end of boyhood, or at adolescence, their parents brought them forward again and the bishop examined them in the catechism then in common use. To give this act, which rightly called for gravity and holiness, more reverence and dignity, the ceremony of laying on of hands was added. So the boy, his faith approved, was sent away with a solemn blessing.
The ancient writers often mention this custom. Pope Leo says (Letter 39), "If anyone returns from heretics, he must not be baptised again, but what was lacking to him there, the power of the Spirit, is to be given by the bishop's laying on of hands." Our opponents will cry out that something by which the Holy Spirit is given deserves to be called a sacrament. But Leo explains elsewhere what he means (Letter 77): "Whoever was baptised by heretics must not be rebaptised, but confirmed by the laying on of hands with the invocation of the Holy Spirit, because he received only the form of baptism without sanctification." Jerome also mentions it (Against the Luciferians). I don't deny that Jerome is somewhat mistaken in calling the practice apostolic, but he's a long way from the follies of these men, and he softens his statement by adding that this blessing is given by bishops only, more in honour of the priesthood than from any legal necessity. This laying on of hands, used simply as a blessing, I commend, and I'd like to see it restored to its pure use today.
5. The later, invented confirmation
A later age almost obliterated the reality and introduced a counterfeit confirmation, presented as a divine sacrament. They made up the idea that confirmation's power lies in giving the Holy Spirit to increase grace in someone already prepared for righteousness in baptism, and in strengthening for the fight those who were born again to life in baptism. This confirmation is done with anointing and these words: "I sign you with the sign of the holy cross, and confirm you with the chrism of salvation, in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit."
All very fine and impressive. But where is the word of God promising the Spirit's presence here? They can't produce a single syllable. How can they assure us that their chrism is a vehicle of the Holy Spirit? We see oil, a thick and greasy liquid, and nothing more. "Let the word be added to the element," says Augustine, "and it becomes a sacrament." Let them produce that word if they want us to see anything in the oil beyond oil. And if they wanted to show themselves true ministers of sacraments, the dispute would be over, because the first duty of a minister is to do nothing without a command. Let them produce a command for this ministry and I won't say another word. If they have none, nothing excuses their sacrilegious nerve.
That's why our Saviour questioned the Pharisees about John's baptism: "Was it from heaven or from men?" (Matthew 21:25). If they'd answered "from men," he would have had them admit it was empty and worthless. If "from heaven," they'd be forced to accept John's teaching. So, not wanting to insult John, they didn't dare say it was from men. In the same way, if confirmation is from men, it's proved worthless and empty. If they want to persuade us it's from heaven, let them prove it.
6. The apostles' laying on of hands was for a purpose that has ended
They defend themselves with the example of the apostles, who, they assume, did nothing rashly. They're right about that, and we wouldn't blame them if they really imitated the apostles. But what did the apostles do? Luke tells us (Acts 8:15, 17) that when the apostles at Jerusalem heard that Samaria had received the word of God, they sent Peter and John there. Peter and John prayed that the Samaritans might receive the Holy Spirit, who hadn't yet come on any of them, since they had only been baptised in the name of Jesus. After the prayer they laid their hands on them, and through that laying on of hands the Samaritans received the Holy Spirit. Luke mentions the laying on of hands repeatedly.
I hear what the apostles did: they faithfully carried out their ministry. The Lord was pleased to have the visible and wonderful gifts of the Spirit, which he then poured out on his people, administered and distributed by the apostles through the laying on of hands. I don't think there was any deeper mystery in it. I take it that they used this ceremony to show by an outward act that they were commending to God, and as it were offering to him, the person on whom they laid hands. If that ministry were still in the Church, we too would need to keep the laying on of hands. But since that gift is no longer given, what is the laying on of hands for?
The Holy Spirit is certainly still with God's people, and without his guidance and direction the Church couldn't survive. We have a promise that lasts for ever, in which Christ invites the thirsty to come to him and drink living water (John 7:37). But the miraculous powers and visible workings that were distributed by laying on of hands have ceased. They were only for a time. It was right that the new preaching of the gospel and the new kingdom of Christ should be marked and magnified by unusual, unheard-of miracles. When the Lord stopped them, he didn't abandon his Church. He showed that the splendour of his kingdom and the dignity of his word had been shown well enough. So how can these stage-players claim to imitate the apostles? The purpose of the laying on of hands was that the Spirit's power might be seen at work immediately. They can't produce that. Why then do they claim for themselves a laying on of hands that the apostles used for a quite different end?
7. The oil of salvation
The same answer applies if anyone insists that the Lord's breathing on his disciples (John 20:22) is a sacrament that gives the Holy Spirit. The Lord did that once, and didn't intend us to do it too. In the same way the apostles laid on hands at the time when the Lord was pleased to have the visible gifts of the Spirit given in answer to their prayers, not so that later generations could ape them with an empty, useless sign without the reality. But suppose they do prove they imitate the apostles in the laying on of hands (though in this they resemble the apostles in nothing, except perhaps a ridiculous, misplaced zeal). Where did they get their oil, which they call the oil of salvation? Who taught them to look for salvation in oil? Who taught them to credit it with the power to strengthen? Was it Paul, who pulls us far away from the elements of this world and condemns nothing more than clinging to such observances?
I'll say boldly, not on my own authority but from the Lord: those who call oil the oil of salvation renounce the salvation that is in Christ, deny Christ, and have no part in the kingdom of God. Oil is for the stomach and the stomach for oil, but the Lord will destroy both. All these weak elements, which perish in the very using, have nothing to do with God's kingdom, which is spiritual and will never perish.
"What then?" someone will ask. "Do you apply the same rule to the water of baptism, and the bread and wine of the Lord's Supper?" I answer that in sacraments of divine appointment we must consider two things: the substance of the physical thing set before us, and the form the word of God has stamped on it, in which all its force lies. So far as the bread, wine and water keep their substance, Paul's statement applies: "Food for the stomach and the stomach for food, and God will destroy both" (1 Corinthians 6:13). They pass and vanish with the form of this world. But so far as they are sanctified by God's word to be sacraments, they don't hold us to the flesh. They teach us truly and spiritually.
8. Confirmation insults baptism
Look more closely at how many monsters this greasy oil breeds and feeds. These anointers say the Holy Spirit is given in baptism for righteousness and in confirmation for increase of grace; that in baptism we're born again to life and in confirmation equipped for the fight. So they aren't ashamed to deny that baptism can be properly completed without confirmation. How wicked! Aren't we buried with Christ in baptism and made sharers in his death so that we may also share in his resurrection? Paul explains this fellowship with Christ's death and life as the putting to death of our flesh and the quickening of the Spirit, our old self crucified so that we may walk in newness of life (Romans 6:4-6). What is being equipped for the fight, if not this?
But if trampling on God's word means nothing to them, why don't they at least respect the Church they claim to obey in everything? What heavier charge could be brought against their teaching than the decree of the Council of Milevis, in the time of Augustine? "Let anyone who says that baptism is given only for the forgiveness of sins, and not as an aid to future grace, be anathema."
When Luke says in the passage we quoted that the Samaritans had only been "baptised in the name of the Lord Jesus" (Acts 8:16) and hadn't received the Holy Spirit, he doesn't say that people who believed in Christ with the heart and confessed him with the mouth had no gift of the Spirit at all. He means the receiving of the Spirit that brought miraculous power and visible gifts. In the same way the apostles are said to have received the Spirit at Pentecost (Acts 2:4), although Christ had long before told them, "It is not you who speak, but the Spirit of your Father speaking through you" (Matthew 10:20).
You who belong to God, see Satan's malicious and deadly trick. What was truly given in baptism is falsely said to be given in its confirmation, so that he can quietly lead the unwary away from baptism. Who can now doubt that a doctrine which separates baptism's own promises from baptism and moves them elsewhere is a doctrine of Satan? We've found the foundation on which this famous anointing rests. God's word says that everyone baptised into Christ has put on Christ with his gifts (Galatians 3:27). The anointers' word says that in baptism people received no promise to equip them for the fight. The first is the word of truth, so the second must be the word of falsehood. I can define this confirmation more truly than they have: it is a notorious insult to baptism, whose use it obscures, indeed abolishes. It is a lie of the devil that draws us away from God's truth. Or, if you prefer, it is oil defiled by the devil's lie, deceiving simple minds by wrapping them in darkness.
9. "Without it we can't be full Christians"
They add that all believers ought to receive the Holy Spirit by the laying on of hands after baptism so that they may be complete Christians, since there can never be a Christian who hasn't been anointed with the chrism of episcopal confirmation. Those are their exact words. I thought everything that belongs to Christianity was set out and contained in Scripture. Now I see the true form of religion has to be sought and learned somewhere other than Scripture! Divine wisdom, heavenly truth, the whole teaching of Christ merely begins the Christian; it is the oil that perfects him!
By this sentence all the apostles and the many martyrs are condemned, who, it's absolutely certain, were never anointed, since the oil hadn't yet been made with which they could be smeared to complete the Christian life, or rather to become Christians, which as yet they weren't. Even if I said nothing, they refute themselves thoroughly. How small a share of the people do they anoint after baptism! Why do they allow so many half-Christians in their flock when they could so easily remedy the defect? Why do they let people neglect, with such careless indifference, something they can't neglect without serious offence? Why don't they insist more strictly on a matter so necessary that without it salvation can't be had, unless perhaps sudden death anticipates it? When they allow it to be treated with such contempt, they quietly admit it isn't as important as they claim.
10. "More venerable than baptism"
Finally they conclude that this sacred anointing should be held in greater honour than baptism, because it is administered specially by the higher order of priests, while baptism is given by any priest whatever. What can you say except that they're plainly mad, boasting of their own inventions while carelessly despising God's sacred ordinances? Sacrilegious mouth! Do you dare set oil merely defiled by your foul breath and charmed by your muttering against the sacrament of Christ, and compare it with water sanctified by God's word? Even that wasn't enough for your wickedness: you had to put it first. Such are the answers of the holy see, such the oracles of the apostolic tripod.
Some of them have begun to moderate this madness, which even in their own opinion went too far. They say it is to be held in greater honour not perhaps because of greater power and usefulness, but because it's given by more distinguished persons and on a more distinguished part of the body, the forehead; or because it gives a greater increase of virtue, though baptism is more effective for forgiveness. But doesn't their first reason prove them Donatists, who judge the worth of a sacrament by the dignity of the minister? Suppose confirmation could be called more dignified because of the bishop's hand. If someone asks how bishops got this great privilege, what reason can they give but their own whim? The right was exercised only by the apostles, who alone gave the Holy Spirit. Are bishops alone apostles? Are they apostles at all?
Let's grant that too. Why don't they argue on the same ground that the cup in the Lord's Supper may be touched only by bishops? They refuse it to the laity because the Lord gave it to the apostles only. If to the apostles only, why not infer to bishops only? But there they make the apostles ordinary priests, while here a different giddiness takes them and they suddenly make them bishops. Besides, Ananias was not an apostle, yet Paul was sent to him to receive his sight, be baptised and be filled with the Holy Spirit (Acts 9:17). And if this office belonged to bishops by divine right, why have they dared to transfer it to common priests, as we read in one of Gregory's letters?
11. "Worth more because of where the oil goes"
How silly, pointless and stupid is the other reason, that their confirmation is worthier than God's baptism because in confirmation the forehead is smeared with oil, and in baptism the crown of the head. As if baptism were done with oil and not with water! I call all the godly to witness whether the one aim of these wretches isn't to adulterate the purity of the sacraments with their leaven. I've said elsewhere that what is of God in the sacraments can hardly be glimpsed among the crowd of human inventions. If anyone didn't believe me then, let them believe their own teachers now. Here they pass over water and make nothing of it, and set great value on the oil alone in baptism.
Against them we maintain that in baptism too the forehead is sprinkled with water, and compared with that we don't value your oil at a straw, whether in baptism or in confirmation. If someone says oil sells for more, I answer that this added price spoils any good it might otherwise have had, so far is it from being lawful to sell this wretched fraud. They betray their impiety most openly by the third reason, claiming that confirmation gives a greater increase of virtue than baptism does. By the laying on of hands the apostles gave the visible gifts of the Spirit. Where does their oil show any such fruitfulness? But enough of these guides, who cover one act of sacrilege with many. It's a Gordian knot, better cut than untied at the cost of so much labour.
12. The appeal to antiquity
When they see that God's word and every plausible argument fail them, they claim, as usual, that the practice is extremely ancient and confirmed by the agreement of many ages. Even if that were true, they'd gain nothing. A sacrament isn't from earth but from heaven, not from men but from God alone. They must prove God is the author of their confirmation if they want it counted as a sacrament. And why bring up antiquity, when the ancient writers, whenever they speak exactly, mention no more than two sacraments? If we wanted to build our faith's defences from men, we'd have an impregnable fortress in this: the ancients never recognised these men's invented sacraments as sacraments. They speak of the laying on of hands, but do they call it a sacrament? Augustine plainly says it's nothing but prayer (On Baptism against the Donatists 3.16).
Let them not squeal out one of their usual distinctions, that the laying on of hands Augustine meant wasn't the confirming kind but the healing or reconciling kind. His book is available and in people's hands. If I twist it to any meaning other than what Augustine wrote, they're welcome not only to load me with reproaches as usual but to spit on me. He is speaking of those who returned from schism to the unity of the Church. He says they don't need baptism repeated, because the laying on of hands is enough for the Lord to give them the Holy Spirit through the bond of peace. But since it might seem absurd to repeat the laying on of hands more than baptism, he shows the difference: "What is the laying on of hands but prayer over a person?" That this is his meaning is clear from another passage, where he says, "Because of the bond of love, which is the greatest gift of the Holy Spirit, without which all the other holy qualities a person may have do nothing for salvation, the hand is laid on reformed heretics" (5.23).
13. A confirmation worth restoring
I wish we could keep the custom that, as I said, existed in the early Church before this abortive mask of a sacrament appeared. It wouldn't be the kind of confirmation they pretend, one that can't even be named without insulting baptism. It would be catechising, in which children, or those just past childhood, would give an account of their faith before the Church. The best way to catechise would be to draw up a form containing, and briefly explaining, almost all the main points of our religion, on which the whole body of the faithful ought to agree without dispute. A ten-year-old boy would come before the Church to profess his faith, would be questioned on each point and answer each one. If he didn't know something, or didn't understand it well, he would be taught. So with the whole Church looking on as witness, he would profess the one true, sincere faith in which the body of believers with one accord worships one God.
If this discipline were in force today, it would certainly sharpen the laziness of some parents, who carelessly neglect their children's instruction as if it were no concern of theirs, but who then couldn't neglect it without public disgrace. There would be greater agreement in faith among Christian people and not so much ignorance and crudeness. Some people wouldn't be so easily carried away by new and strange teachings. In short, it would give everyone an orderly grounding in Christian doctrine.
Penance
14. The ancient laying on of hands in penance
The next place in their list goes to penance, which they discuss so confusedly and so unmethodically that consciences can get nothing certain or solid from their teaching. I've already explained at length (Book 3, chapters 3 and 4) what Scripture teaches about repentance and what these men teach. All I need to look at now is the ground for the long-held opinion that it is a sacrament. First, though, a word about the rite of the early Church, which they use as a pretext for their invention.
In the order followed in public penance, those who had completed the satisfactions laid on them were reconciled by a formal laying on of hands. This was the sign of absolution by which the sinner himself regained his confidence of pardon before God, and the Church was urged to lay aside the memory of the offence and receive him kindly back. Cyprian often calls this "giving peace." To give the act more weight with the people, it was ruled that the bishop's authority should always be involved. So the second Council of Carthage decreed, "No presbyter may reconcile a penitent publicly at the Mass." The Council of Orange ruled that the dying who had been in penance should be admitted to communion without the reconciling laying on of hands, but that if they recovered they should return to the order of penitents and, after their time was served, receive the reconciling laying on of hands from the bishop. The third Council of Carthage said, "A presbyter may not reconcile a penitent without the bishop's authority." The purpose of all these rulings was to stop the strictness they wanted kept in this matter from being lost through too much leniency, and so they wanted the bishop, who was likely to examine more carefully, to take charge. Cyprian does say somewhere that not the bishop alone but the whole clergy laid on hands: "They do penance for the proper time; then they come to communion and receive the right of communion through the laying on of hands of the bishop and clergy" (Letters 3.14).
Later, in time, the ceremony came to be used in private absolutions as well, without public penance. Hence Gratian's distinction between public and private reconciliation. I think the ancient practice Cyprian speaks of was holy and good for the Church, and I'd like to see it restored today. The more recent form I don't dare to disapprove, or at least to condemn strongly, but I think it less necessary. Either way, the laying on of hands in penance was a ceremony ordained by men, not by God. It belongs among indifferent things and outward exercises, which aren't to be despised but take a lower place than what the Lord's word commends to us.
15. Their disagreement over what the sacrament is
The Romanists and the Schoolmen, who corrupt everything by wrong interpretation, labour anxiously to find a sacrament here, and no wonder, since they look for it where it isn't. At best they leave the matter tangled, undecided and confused by a variety of opinions. Some say outward penance is the sacrament, a sign of inward penance, that is, of contrition of heart, which is the "matter" of the sacrament. Others say both together make one complete sacrament, but the outward part is the sacrament only, the inward part is both matter and sacrament, and forgiveness of sins is matter only and not sacrament.
Let those who remember the definition of a sacrament I gave earlier test what they call a sacrament by it, and they'll find it is not an outward ceremony appointed by God to confirm our faith. If they say my definition is no law that binds them, let them listen to Augustine, whom they pretend to revere: "Visible sacraments were instituted for the sake of carnal men, so that by the ladder of sacraments they might be carried from the things seen with the eye to those grasped by the understanding" (Questions on the Old and New Testaments). Can they see anything like that in what they call the sacrament of penance, or show it to anyone else? Elsewhere he says, "It is called a sacrament because in it one thing is seen and another understood. What is seen has bodily form; what is understood has spiritual fruit." None of this fits their sacrament of penance, where there's no bodily form to represent spiritual fruit.
16. Absolution would have been a better candidate
To beat these creatures on their own ground: if a sacrament is to be sought here, wouldn't it have been far more plausible to say that the priest's absolution is the sacrament, rather than penance, outward or inward? They could easily have said it's a ceremony to confirm our faith in the forgiveness of sins, and that it has the promise of the keys as they interpret it: "Whatever you bind or loose on earth will be bound or loosed in heaven."
Someone will object that most of those absolved by priests receive nothing from the absolution, while by their doctrine the sacraments of the new covenant must effect what they picture. That's ridiculous. In the Eucharist they invent a twofold eating, sacramental, common to good and bad alike, and spiritual, belonging only to the good. Why shouldn't they also say absolution is given in two ways? I've never been able to understand what they meant by their doctrine, and I showed how much it clashes with God's truth when we discussed it directly. Here I only want to show that nothing should stop them from calling the priest's absolution a sacrament. They could have answered with Augustine that there is sanctification without a visible sacrament and a visible sacrament without inward sanctification; that sacraments effect what they picture only in the elect; and that some put on Christ only as far as receiving the sacrament, others as far as sanctification, the first being done by good and bad alike, the second by the good alone. They were surely more deluded than children, and blind in full daylight, to labour so hard over something so plain.
17. Baptism is the sacrament of repentance
But lest they get puffed up, wherever they locate the sacrament, I deny that it can rightly be counted one. First, there's no special promise of God for it, and a promise is the only ground of a sacrament. Second, whatever ceremony is used here is purely a human invention, whereas, as already shown, the ceremonies of sacraments can only be appointed by God. So their fiction of a sacrament of penance was falsehood and fraud.
They adorned this fictitious sacrament with the fitting title of "the second plank after shipwreck," since anyone who had damaged by sin the robe of innocence received in baptism could repair it by penance. That was a saying of Jerome. Whoever said it, it's plainly impious if taken to mean that baptism is wiped out by sin, and not rather that the sinner should recall it whenever he thinks of forgiveness, to recover himself, take courage, and be confirmed in believing that he'll obtain the forgiveness promised him in baptism. Jerome spoke harshly and loosely when he said that baptism, which those who deserve excommunication have fallen from, is repaired by penance, and these worthy interpreters twist it to serve their own impiety.
You'll speak most correctly, then, if you call baptism the sacrament of repentance, since it is given to those who aim at repentance, to confirm their faith and seal their confidence. And don't think this is my invention. Besides agreeing with Scripture, it was generally held in the early Church as beyond question. In the short treatise on faith addressed to Peter, which bears Augustine's name, baptism is called "the sacrament of faith and repentance." But why turn to doubtful writings, as if anything could be clearer than the evangelist's statement that John preached "a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins" (Mark 1:4; Luke 3:3)?
Extreme Unction
18. The anointing of the sick in James
The third made-up sacrament is extreme unction, which only a priest performs, in extremis as they put it, with oil consecrated by the bishop and with these words: "By this holy anointing and his most tender mercy, may God forgive you whatever sin you have committed by sight, hearing, smell, touch, taste." They claim two effects for it: forgiveness of sins, and relief of bodily sickness if that's expedient, or if not, the salvation of the soul. They say it was established by James: "Is anyone among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the church, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord. And the prayer of faith will save the sick person, and the Lord will raise him up. And if he has committed sins, he will be forgiven" (James 5:14, 15).
The same answer applies here as to the laying on of hands: it is hypocritical stage-play by which, without reason or result, they try to look like the apostles. Mark reports that on their first mission, following the Lord's command, the apostles raised the dead, cast out demons, cleansed lepers and healed the sick, and in healing they used oil. "They anointed with oil many who were sick and healed them" (Mark 6:13). James had this in mind when he told the elders of the church to be called to anoint the sick. Anyone who considers how much freedom the Lord and his apostles used in outward things will easily see there was no deeper mystery in this ceremony. When our Lord was about to give sight to a blind man, he spat on the ground and made clay from the spittle (John 9:6). Some he cured by a touch, others by a word. In the same way the apostles cured some diseases by a word, others by touch, others by anointing.
It's likely that neither the anointing nor the other means were used at random. I grant that, but not as instruments of the cure; they were symbols to remind the ignorant where this great power came from, and to stop them crediting the apostles with the praise. Using oil to signify the Holy Spirit and his gifts is common enough (Psalm 45:7). But the gift of healing disappeared along with the other miraculous powers the Lord was pleased to give for a time, to make the new preaching of the gospel wonderful for ever. So even if we granted that anointing was a sacrament of those powers then administered by the apostles' hands, it has nothing to do with us, to whom no such powers have been given.
19. No better claim than other biblical signs
What better reason do they have for making a sacrament of this anointing than of any other sign mentioned in Scripture? Why don't they dedicate some pool of Siloam where the sick can plunge at certain seasons? That would be useless, they say. Certainly no more useless than the anointing. Why don't they lie on the dead, as Paul did when he raised the young man (Acts 20:10)? Why isn't clay made from dust and spittle a sacrament? "Those were special cases," they say, "but this is commanded by James." In other words, James spoke to the time when the Church still enjoyed this blessing from God. They insist their anointing still has the same power, but we know otherwise from experience.
No one should be surprised that they've so confidently deceived souls they knew to be dull and blind, cut off from the word of God, that is, from his light and life, when they aren't ashamed to try to deceive the physical senses of living people who have all their wits about them. They make themselves ridiculous by claiming the gift of healing. The Lord is certainly present with his people in every age and heals their sicknesses as often as needed, no less than before. But he doesn't show those open powers or work miracles by apostles' hands, because that gift was temporary and, partly through human ingratitude, soon ceased.
20. The anointing is no sacrament
The apostles, with good reason, declared openly by the sign of oil that the gift of healing committed to them was not their own but the power of the Holy Spirit. These men do the opposite and insult the Holy Spirit by making his power consist in a filthy, useless oil. It's as if someone said all oil is the Spirit's power because Scripture uses oil that way, and every dove is the Holy Spirit because he appeared in that form. Let them look to that. It's enough for us to see with complete certainty that their anointing is no sacrament, since it is neither a ceremony appointed by God nor has any promise.
When we require two things in a sacrament, that it be a ceremony appointed by God and that it carry a promise from God, we also require that the ceremony be handed on to us and that the promise be addressed to us. No one argues that circumcision is now a sacrament of the Christian Church, although it was God's ordinance and had his promise attached, because it wasn't commanded to us and its promise wasn't given to us on the same terms. The promise they boast of in anointing has not been given to us, as we've plainly shown and as they themselves show by experience. The ceremony should have been used only by those who had the gift of healing, not by these murderers, who do more by killing and butchering than by curing.
21. Even James doesn't match their practice
Suppose this command to anoint, which has nothing to do with the present age, did suit it perfectly. They would still have gained little. James wants all the sick anointed, but these men smear with oil not the sick but half-dead bodies, when life is flickering on the lips, in extremis as they say. If their sacrament has a present cure, to ease the bitterness of disease or at least comfort the soul, they're cruel never to apply it in time. James wants the sick man anointed by the elders of the church; they allow no anointer but a petty priest. They explain James's "elders" as priests and say the plural is used for honour, which is absurd, as if the Church then swarmed with priests who could process in long lines carrying a dish of holy oil.
James, in simply ordering that the sick be anointed, seems to me to mean ordinary oil and nothing else, and no other is mentioned in Mark's account. These men won't use any oil but what a bishop has consecrated, warmed with much breathing, charmed with much muttering, and saluted nine times on bended knee: "Hail, holy oil! Hail, holy chrism! Hail, holy balsam!" Where did they get these exorcisms? James says that when the sick man has been anointed and prayed over, if he has committed sins they will be forgiven him. His meaning is that when his guilt is forgiven he'll obtain relief from the punishment. He doesn't mean sins are wiped out by oil, but that the prayers with which believers commend their suffering brother to God won't be in vain. These men are impiously false when they say sins are forgiven by their holy, that is, abominable, oil.
See how little they gain even when allowed to misuse James as they like. To spare us laborious proof, their own annals relieve us: they record that Pope Innocent, who presided over the church of Rome in Augustine's age, ordered that not elders only but all Christians should use oil for anointing, in their own need or that of their friends. Our authority for this is Sigebert's Chronicle.
Holy Orders
22. Seven orders, thirteen sacraments
The fourth place in their list goes to the sacrament of Orders, so prolific that it produces seven lesser sacraments by itself. It's very funny that after affirming seven sacraments, when they begin to count they get thirteen. They can't say these are one sacrament because they all lead toward one priesthood and are steps to the same thing. The ceremonies in each differ, and they themselves say the graces differ, so if their teaching is accepted, no one can doubt they should be called seven sacraments. And why debate it, when they plainly say there are seven?
First I'll glance at these orders in passing and show into how many absurdities they lead us when they recommend them as sacraments. Then we'll see whether the ceremony churches use in ordaining ministers should be called a sacrament at all. They make seven orders or degrees, which they distinguish by the title of sacrament: doorkeepers, readers, exorcists, acolytes, subdeacons, deacons and priests. They say there are seven because of the seven kinds of grace of the Holy Spirit with which those promoted to them ought to be endowed. The number is consecrated by a misreading of Scripture. They think they read in Isaiah that there are seven gifts of the Spirit, but Isaiah mentions only six, and he didn't mean to include them all, since other passages speak of the spirit of life, of sanctification and of adoption as sons (Isaiah 11:2; Ezekiel 1:20; Romans 1:4; 8:15).
Others, who are sharper, make not seven orders but nine, in imitation, they say, of the Church triumphant. Even then they quarrel, some making the clerical tonsure the first order and the episcopate the last, others leaving out the tonsure and counting the archbishop among the orders. Isidore distinguishes psalmists from readers, giving the first the task of chanting and the second the reading of Scripture to instruct the people, and the canons keep that distinction. In this great variety, what do they want us to follow or avoid? Should we say there are seven orders? So the master of the schools teaches, but the most illuminated doctors say otherwise. They disagree among themselves, and the most sacred canons pull in a different direction again. Such is the harmony of men when they discuss divine things apart from God's word.
23. Christ as colleague in every order
The crowning folly is that in each of these they make Christ their colleague. They say he performed the office of doorkeeper when he drove the buyers and sellers out of the temple with a whip of cords, and showed himself a doorkeeper when he said "I am the door." He took the office of reader when he read Isaiah in the synagogue. He was an exorcist when he touched the tongue and ears of the deaf and mute man with spittle and restored his hearing. He declared himself an acolyte by saying, "Whoever follows me will not walk in darkness." He was a subdeacon when he girded himself with a towel and washed the disciples' feet. He acted as deacon when he gave out his body and blood in the Supper. He acted as priest when he offered himself as a sacrifice to the Father on the cross (John 2:15; 10:7; 8:12; 13:5; Luke 4:17; Matthew 26:26).
I can't hear this without laughing, and I wonder how people could write it without laughing, if they were men. Their finest subtlety is the speculation on the name "acolyte," which they render "ceroferarius," some magical word, I suppose, unknown to every nation and tongue, when in Greek it simply means "attendant." If I stopped to refute such things seriously, I'd deserve to be laughed at myself, they're so silly and ridiculous.
24. The minor orders are empty titles
Still, to keep them from imposing on foolish women, their emptiness has to be exposed in passing. With great pomp and ceremony they appoint readers, psalmists, doorkeepers and acolytes to perform services that they hand over to boys or at least to those they call laymen. Who generally lights the candles and pours wine and water from the jug but a boy or some lowly layman who earns his bread that way? Don't the same people sing? Don't they open and shut the church doors? Who has ever seen an acolyte or doorkeeper doing his job in their churches? When the boy who served as acolyte is admitted to the order of acolyte, he ceases to be what he begins to be called, as if they meant to throw away the office the moment they take the title.
See why they think it necessary to be consecrated by sacraments and to receive the Holy Spirit! It's to do nothing. If they say this is the fault of the times, that people neglect their duties, let them also admit that today the Church gets no use or benefit from these wonderfully praised sacred orders, and that their whole Church is full of anathema, since she lets boys and laymen handle the candles and jugs that only consecrated acolytes are fit to touch, and hands her chants, which should be heard only from consecrated lips, to children.
And what are exorcists consecrated for? I know the Jews had exorcists, named from the exorcisms they practised (Acts 19:13). Who has ever heard of these made-up exorcists giving one sample of their craft? They claim power has been given them to lay hands on the possessed and on catechumens, but they can't persuade the demons of it, since the demons not only don't obey their orders but give orders to them. You'll hardly find one in ten who isn't possessed by a wicked spirit. Everything they babble about their petty orders is a mixture of ignorant, stupid lies. I've already spoken of the ancient acolytes, doorkeepers and readers when explaining the government of the Church. All I meant to do here was to oppose the new invention of a sevenfold sacrament in ecclesiastical orders, which we read of nowhere except among raving Sorbonnists and canonists.
25. The tonsure
Let's look at their ceremonies. First, everyone enrolled in their ranks is initiated into the clerical state by a common sign. They shave the top of the head so that the crown denotes royal honour, because the clergy ought to be kings in governing themselves and others. They cite Peter: "You are a chosen race, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people for his own possession" (1 Peter 2:9). But it was sacrilege to claim for themselves alone what belongs to the whole Church, and proudly to boast of a title they've robbed the faithful of. Peter addresses the whole Church, and these men twist it to a few shaven crowns, as if only they were told to be holy, only they were bought with Christ's blood, only they were made kings and priests to God.
They give other reasons too. The crown is bared to show the mind free, with unveiled face, to behold God's glory; or to teach them to cut off the vices of the eye and lip. Or the shaving of the head is the laying aside of temporal things, and the ring of hair left is the remnant of goods kept for support. All of it is figure, because, they say, the temple veil isn't yet torn. Persuaded that they've done their part well by picturing such things in their crown, they do none of them in reality. How long will they fool us with such masks and impostures? By shaving off some hair the clergy signify that they've cast away abundant worldly goods, contemplate God's glory, and put to death the lusts of ear and eye; yet no class of men is more greedy, more stupid, more lustful. Why don't they show true holiness rather than a hypocritical appearance of it in false and lying signs?
26. The Nazarite excuse
When they say the clerical crown comes from the Nazirites, what are they saying but that their mysteries derive from Jewish ceremonies, or rather are mere Judaism? When they add that Priscilla, Aquila and Paul himself shaved their heads after a vow to be purified, they show gross ignorance. We never read this of Priscilla, and as for Aquila it's uncertain, since the shaving in Acts 18:18 could refer to Paul as well as to Aquila. But not to leave them what they ask for, an example in Paul, simple readers should notice that Paul never shaved his head for any sanctification, only to accommodate weaker brothers. I call such vows vows of charity, not of piety: not taken for the worship of God but only out of deference to the weak, as he says himself, "To the Jews I became as a Jew" (1 Corinthians 9:20). He did it once, for a short time, to adapt himself briefly to the Jews. When these men imitate the Nazirites' purifications for no purpose (Numbers 6:18), what else are they doing but setting up a new Judaism while wrongly aiming to rival the old?
The same spirit produced the decretal that orders the clergy, following the apostle, not to let their hair grow but to shave it all round, as if the apostle, in showing what is fitting for all men, were concerned about the round tonsure of the clergy. From this, readers can judge what force or dignity the later mysteries can have, when this is their introduction.
27. The real origin of the tonsure
Augustine alone makes clear where the clerical tonsure came from (On the Work of Monks, and Retractations). In that age only effeminate men and those who affected an unmanly elegance wore long hair, and it was thought a bad example to let the clergy do so. So they were told to cut or shave their hair, to avoid looking soft and self-indulgent. The practice was so common that some monks, to look holier than others by a notable difference in dress, let their hair hang loose. When long hair came back into use, and nations that had always worn long hair, such as France, Germany and England, became Christian, the clergy everywhere probably shaved their heads so as not to seem to affect ornament. In a more corrupt age, when ancient customs had either changed or decayed into superstition, they saw no reason for the tonsure (all they had kept was a foolish imitation), so they took refuge in mystery, and now superstitiously press it on us to support their sacrament.
At consecration the doorkeepers receive the keys of the church, to show that its care is committed to them; the readers receive the Bible; the exorcists, forms of exorcism for the possessed and catechumens; the acolytes, candles and the jug. These are the ceremonies that apparently hold so much hidden power that they can be not only signs and badges but causes of invisible grace, which is what their definition demands when they want them counted among sacraments. To settle it briefly: it's absurd for schools and canons to make sacraments of these minor orders, since by the admission of those who do it, they were unknown to the early Church and were devised many ages later. But sacraments, as containing a divine promise, must be appointed not by angels or men but by God alone, to whom alone it belongs to give the promise.
28. The priesthood and its false sacrifice
Three orders remain that they call major. The subdiaconate was moved into this class after the minor orders began to multiply. Since they think these have authority from God's word, they honour them especially with the name of Holy Orders. Let's see how they twist God's ordinances to their own ends.
We begin with the order of presbyter or priest. They give these two names one meaning, understanding by them those whose task, they say, is to offer the sacrifice of Christ's body and blood on the altar, to frame prayers and to bless God's gifts. So at ordination they receive the paten with the host, as symbols of the power given them to offer sacrifices to appease God, and their hands are anointed to teach that they've received the power of consecrating. I'll deal with the ceremonies later. As for the thing itself, it has not one particle of support from God's word, as they pretend, and they could hardly corrupt the order he appointed more wickedly.
First, it should be held as settled (we argued this when dealing with the papal Mass) that all who call themselves priests in the sense of offering expiatory victims wrong Christ. He was appointed and consecrated priest by the Father with an oath, after the order of Melchizedek, without end and without successor (Psalm 110:4; Hebrews 5:6; 7:3). He offered once a victim of eternal atonement and reconciliation, and now, having entered the sanctuary of heaven, he intercedes for us. In him we are all priests, but to offer praise and thanksgiving, in short ourselves and everything we have, to God. It was his alone to appease God and atone for sins by his offering. When these men usurp it, what follows but that their priesthood is impious and sacrilegious? It's wicked beyond measure to dare to honour it with the title of sacrament.
As for the true office of presbyter, commended to us by Christ's own lips, I'm glad to give it that place. In it there is a ceremony which is, first, taken from Scripture and, second, declared by Paul to be neither empty nor superfluous but a faithful sign of spiritual grace (1 Timothy 4:14). My reason for not giving it the third mark of a sacrament is that it isn't ordinary or common to all believers but a special rite for a particular task. But while this honour is given to the Christian ministry, Roman priests have no right to boast of it. Christ ordered dispensers of his gospel and sacred mysteries to be ordained, not sacrificers to be installed. His command was to preach the gospel and feed the flock, not to offer victims. He promised the gift of the Holy Spirit, not to make atonement for sins, but to take up and carry on the government of the Church properly (Matthew 28:19; Mark 16:15; John 21:15).
29. Breathing on the priests
The ceremonies match the reality perfectly. When our Lord sent the apostles out to preach the gospel, he breathed on them (John 20:22). By that sign he represented the gift of the Holy Spirit he was giving them. These worthy men have kept the breathing, and, as if they were bringing the Holy Spirit up from their throats, they mutter over their little priests, "Receive the Holy Spirit." They leave out nothing they don't mimic perversely. I don't mean like actors, who have skill and meaning in their gestures, but like apes imitating at random without choosing.
"We follow the Lord's example," they say. But the Lord did many things he never meant as examples. He said to his disciples, "Receive the Holy Spirit." He also said to Lazarus, "Lazarus, come out" (John 11:43), and to the paralytic, "Rise, take up your bed and walk" (John 5:8). Why don't they say the same to all the dead and paralysed? He gave a sample of his divine power when, by breathing on the apostles, he filled them with the gift of the Spirit. If they try to do the same, they rival God and all but challenge him to a contest. But they're very far from producing the effect and only mock Christ with that absurd gesture. Some are so shameless that they dare to claim the Spirit is conferred through them, but experience, which cries out against it, shows what truth there is in that: everyone consecrated priest turns from a horse into an ass and from a fool into a madman. I'm not arguing against them on that point here, only condemning the ceremony itself, which should not be made a precedent, since it was used as the special sign of a miracle, and so is far from giving them an example to follow.
30. The anointing of priests and the sons of Aaron
Where, then, did they get their anointing? They answer that they received it from the sons of Aaron, from whom their order derives. So they always choose to defend themselves with perverse examples rather than admit that any of their rash practices is their own invention. Meanwhile they don't notice that by claiming to be successors of Aaron's sons they wrong the priesthood of Christ, which alone was foreshadowed by all the ancient priesthoods. In him they were all fulfilled and ended, as we've said repeatedly and as the Letter to the Hebrews declares without any gloss.
If they're so taken with Mosaic ceremonies, why don't they hurry oxen, calves and lambs to their sacrifices? They already have a large part of the old tabernacle and of the whole Jewish worship. The only thing their religion lacks is the sacrifice of oxen and calves. Who can't see that this anointing is much more harmful than circumcision, especially when superstition and a Pharisaic belief in the merit of the act are added? The Jews put their confidence for justification in circumcision; these men look for spiritual gifts in anointing. So in their wish to rival the Levites they become apostates from Christ and cast themselves out of the pastoral office.
31. The "indelible character"
It is, they tell us, the sacred oil that stamps an indelible character. As if oil couldn't be scrubbed off with sand and salt, or stuck on tighter by soap! "But the character is spiritual." What has oil to do with the soul? Have they forgotten what they quote from Augustine, that if the word is taken from the water there is only water, and it is the word that makes it a sacrament? What word can they show in their oil? Is it that Moses was commanded to anoint Aaron's sons (Exodus 30:30)? But there he is also commanded about the tunic, ephod, breastplate, mitre and holy crown for Aaron, and the tunics, sashes and caps for his sons. He is told to sacrifice the bull, to burn its fat, to cut up and burn the rams, to consecrate the earrings and garments with the blood of one ram, and a host of other observances. They pass over all those, and I wonder why only the oil pleases them. If they like being sprinkled, why with oil rather than with blood?
They're attempting an ingenious scheme: by a kind of patchwork they're trying to make a single religion out of Christianity, Judaism and paganism. Their anointing is tasteless; it lacks salt, which is God's word. The laying on of hands remains. I admit it to be a sacrament in true and lawful ordination, but I deny it any such place in this fable, where they neither obey Christ's command nor look to the end to which the promise should lead us. If they don't want the sign denied them, they must fit it to the reality to which it is dedicated.
32. Deacons
About the order of deacons I'd raise no dispute if the office as it existed under the apostles and in a purer Church were restored. But what resemblance to it do we see in their fictitious deacons? I'm not speaking of the men, lest they complain that I'm unfairly judging their teaching by the vices of those who profess it. I'm saying that the deacons their doctrine describes get no support from the deacons the apostolic Church appointed.
They say their deacons' job is to assist the priests and serve in everything done in the sacraments, in baptism, the chrism, the paten and chalice; to bring the offerings and lay them on the altar; to prepare and dress the Lord's table; to carry the cross; to announce and read the gospel and epistle to the people. Is there one word here about the true office of a deacon? Now look at the ordination. The bishop alone lays hands on the deacon; he puts the prayer book and stole on his left shoulder, to show he has received the Lord's easy yoke and must bring everything on the left side under the fear of the Lord; he gives him a text of the gospel to remind him that he is its herald. What have these things to do with deacons? It's as if someone said he was ordaining apostles when he was only appointing people to light the incense, clean the images, sweep the churches, set traps for mice and put out dogs. Who can allow such men to be called apostles, or compared with Christ's own apostles? After this let them not pretend that those they appoint to mere play-acting are deacons. Indeed they declare the nature of the office by the very name, for they call them Levites and want to trace their nature and origin to the sons of Levi. For my part they're welcome to that, provided they don't afterwards dress themselves in borrowed feathers.
33. Subdeacons, and the conclusion on orders
Why speak of subdeacons? In fact they once had the care of the poor, but now they're given some trifling function, such as carrying the chalice and paten, the water jug and the towel to the altar, pouring water for the hands, and so on. And the offerings they are said to receive and bring in are those they swallow up as though devoted to destruction. There is an admirable match between the office and the way they are installed: they receive the paten and chalice from the bishop, and the water jug, hand towel and trinkets of that sort from the archdeacon. They call on us to admit that the Holy Spirit is contained in these trivialities. What godly person can be brought to grant it?
To finish at once, we can conclude the same of this as of the others, and there's no need to repeat at length what was explained above. For the modest and teachable, whom I've undertaken to instruct, it's enough that there is no sacrament of God unless a ceremony is shown attached to a promise, or rather a promise is seen in a ceremony. Here there is not one syllable of a sure promise, so it's pointless to look for a ceremony to confirm the promise. And on the other hand we read of no ceremony appointed by God for the practices they use, so there can be no sacrament.
Marriage
34. A good ordinance, but no sacrament
The last of all is marriage. Everyone admits it's an institution of God, but nobody saw it as a sacrament until the time of Gregory. Would it ever have occurred to any sober person? It is a good and holy ordinance of God. Farming, building, shoemaking and shaving are lawful ordinances of God too, but they aren't sacraments. In a sacrament it's required not only that it be a work of God but that it be an outward ceremony appointed by God to confirm a promise. Even children can judge that marriage has nothing of the kind.
"But it's a sign of a sacred thing," they say, "the spiritual union of Christ with the Church." If by "sign" they mean a symbol set before us by God to assure our faith, they miss the mark widely. If they mean only a sign in the sense that it's used as a likeness, let me show how cleverly they reason. Paul says, "Star differs from star in glory. So also is the resurrection of the dead" (1 Corinthians 15:41, 42). There's one sacrament. Christ says, "The kingdom of heaven is like a grain of mustard seed" (Matthew 13:31). That's another. "The kingdom of heaven is like leaven" (Matthew 13:33). A third. Isaiah says, "He will tend his flock like a shepherd" (Isaiah 40:11). A fourth. Elsewhere, "The Lord goes out like a mighty man" (Isaiah 42:13). A fifth. Where will it end? On this reasoning everything will be a sacrament, and all the parables and comparisons in Scripture will be so many sacraments. Even theft will be a sacrament, since it is written, "The day of the Lord will come like a thief in the night" (1 Thessalonians 5:2).
Who can put up with the ignorant chatter of these sophists? I agree that whenever we see a vine the best thing is to recall what our Saviour says, "I am the true vine, and my Father is the vinedresser," "I am the vine, you are the branches" (John 15:1, 5). When we meet a shepherd with his flock it's good to remember, "I am the good shepherd; I know my own and my own know me" (John 10:14). But anyone who ranks such comparisons with sacraments should be sent to the madhouse.
35. What Paul says in Ephesians 5
They cite Paul's words, in which they say marriage is given the name of sacrament: "He who loves his wife loves himself. For no one ever hated his own flesh, but nourishes and cherishes it, just as Christ does the church, because we are members of his body, of his flesh and of his bones. 'Therefore a man shall leave his father and mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh.' This mystery is profound, and I am saying that it refers to Christ and the church" (Ephesians 5:28-32). To treat Scripture this way is to confuse heaven and earth.
Paul, to show husbands how they ought to love their wives, sets Christ before them as the example. As Christ poured out his tenderest affection on the Church he has taken as his bride, so he wants each man to feel toward his wife. Then he adds, "He who loves his wife loves himself," "just as Christ does the church." And to show how Christ loved the Church as himself, indeed how he made himself one with his bride the Church, he applies to her what Moses records Adam said of himself. When Eve was brought to him, knowing she'd been formed from his side, he exclaimed, "This at last is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh" (Genesis 2:23). Paul declares that all this was fulfilled spiritually in Christ and in us when he says we are members of his body, of his flesh and of his bones, and so one flesh with him. Finally he breaks out, "This mystery is profound," and, lest anyone be misled by ambiguity, he says he is speaking not of the union of husband and wife but of the spiritual marriage of Christ and the Church. And it truly is a great mystery that Christ allowed a rib to be taken from himself to form us. That is, when he was strong he was pleased to become weak, so that we might be strengthened by his strength and no longer live ourselves, but he live in us (Galatians 2:20).
36. The mistake lies in the word "sacrament"
What misled them was the word "sacrament" in the common Latin translation. But was it right for the whole Church to be punished for these men's ignorance? Paul called it a mystery. The Latin translator could have dropped the word as unfamiliar to Latin ears, or turned it into "secret," but he chose to call it sacramentum, in no other sense than the Greek word mystērion has in Paul. Let them go on shouting against knowledge of languages, when their ignorance of it leads them so shamefully astray on a matter easy and obvious to anyone. And why do they press the word "sacrament" so hard in this one passage and ignore it elsewhere? The Vulgate translator uses it for "mystery" every time, both in 1 Timothy (3:9, 16) and in Ephesians. Still, let's forgive them this slip, though liars ought to have good memories.
Marriage is thus recommended with the title of sacrament. Can it be anything but giddy inconsistency afterwards to call it uncleanness, pollution and carnal defilement? How absurd to bar priests from a sacrament! If they say they bar them not from a sacrament but from physical union, they won't escape me that way. They say this union is part of the sacrament and so pictures our union with Christ in sharing his nature, since it is by this union that husband and wife become one flesh. Some have even found two sacraments here, one of God and the soul in bridegroom and bride, another of Christ and the Church in husband and wife. Be that as it may, this union is a sacrament from which no Christian can lawfully be barred, unless the sacraments of Christians agree so badly that they can't stand together. There's another absurdity in these teachings as well. They say that in a sacrament the gift of the Holy Spirit is conferred. They hold that this union is a sacrament, and yet they deny that the Holy Spirit is ever present in it.
37. The abuses that followed
And not content to mislead the Church on this one point, what a long chain of errors, lies, frauds and injustices they've attached to one error! You could say they were looking for nothing but a hiding place for abominations when they turned marriage into a sacrament. Once they had it, they claimed for themselves the hearing of marriage cases: being a spiritual matter, it wasn't to be meddled with by secular judges. Then they made laws to confirm their tyranny, laws partly impious toward God and partly unjust toward men. Examples are that marriages contracted between minors without their parents' consent are valid; that no lawful marriage can be made between relatives within the seventh degree, and that such marriages, if made, must be dissolved. They draw up degrees of kinship against the laws of all nations and even the polity of Moses. They rule that a husband who has divorced an adulteress may not marry again; that "spiritual kinship" is a bar to marriage; that marriage may not be celebrated from Septuagesima to the octave of Easter, nor for three weeks before the feast of John the Baptist, nor from Advent to Epiphany; and countless other rules too tedious to list.
We must now get out of their mire, in which our discourse has stuck longer than we wished. I think much has been gained if I have, to some extent, stripped these asses of their lion's skin.
Chapter 20
Civil Government
1. Why a book on faith ends with civil government
I've already shown that human beings live under a twofold government. One is placed in the soul, the inward person, and concerns eternal life. I've dealt with that at length. Now I have to say something about the other, which concerns only civil institutions and the outward regulation of conduct. It may seem unrelated to the spiritual doctrine of faith I've undertaken to teach. But as we go on, you'll see that I have good reason to join them. In fact I have no choice. On one side, wild and violent men are furiously trying to overturn the order God has established. On the other, the flatterers of princes praise their power without limit and don't hesitate to set it against the government of God. Unless we meet both extremes, the purity of the faith will perish. It also matters a great deal for us to see how kindly God has provided for the human race here, so that a devout zeal may push us harder to give thanks.
First, before we enter the subject, we must hold to the distinction I laid down earlier (Book 3, chapter 19, section 16, and chapter 10 above). Otherwise we'll do what many do and carelessly confuse two things of completely different natures. Some people hear that the gospel promises liberty, a liberty that acknowledges no king and no magistrate among men but looks to Christ alone. They conclude that they can get no benefit from this liberty while any power is set over them. So they think nothing will be safe until the whole world is remade, with no courts, no laws and no magistrates to interfere, as they suppose, with their freedom.
But anyone who knows how to distinguish the body from the soul, and this passing life from the life that is future and eternal, will have no trouble seeing that Christ's spiritual kingdom and civil government are very widely separated. It's a Jewish folly to look for Christ's kingdom among the elements of this world. Scripture teaches plainly that the blessings we receive from Christ are spiritual. So let's keep the liberty promised and offered to us in him within its proper limits. Why does the same apostle who tells us to "stand firm in the freedom with which Christ has set us free, and not be burdened again by a yoke of slavery" (Gal. 5:1) tell slaves in another place not to be anxious about their condition (1 Cor. 7:21)? Because spiritual freedom is perfectly compatible with civil servitude. That's how we should read passages like these: "There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female" (Gal. 3:28), and "There is no Greek and Jew, circumcised and uncircumcised, barbarian, Scythian, slave, free; but Christ is all, and in all" (Col. 3:11). They tell us it doesn't matter what your condition is among men or under what laws you live, since Christ's kingdom doesn't consist in any of these.
2. Civil government isn't unworthy of a Christian
The distinction doesn't go so far as to make civil government a pollution that Christians should have nothing to do with. Fanatics, who love unrestrained licence, shout that we're dead with Christ to the elements of this world, that we've been carried into God's kingdom and sit among the heavenly beings, and that it's beneath our dignity to be occupied with the profane and impure business of an alien world. What are laws for, they ask, without courts and tribunals? And what has a Christian to do with courts? If killing is forbidden, what use are laws and judges?
But as I've just taught that this kind of government is distinct from Christ's spiritual and inward kingdom, so we should understand that the two aren't opposed. The spiritual kingdom already begins the heavenly kingdom in us, here on earth, and starts an immortal and incorruptible blessedness within this mortal, fading life. Civil government has the job, as long as we live among men, of fostering and protecting the outward worship of God, defending sound doctrine and the standing of the Church, fitting our conduct to human society, shaping our manners to civil justice, reconciling us to one another, and keeping the common peace and quiet. I admit all this would be unnecessary if God's kingdom, as it now exists in us, put an end to the present life. But if God's will is that we remain pilgrims on earth while we aim at true godliness, and if that pilgrimage needs such helps, then those who take them away rob people of their humanity.
They also claim that the Church of God ought to be so perfect that her own guidance would be enough in place of law. They stupidly imagine a Church that can never be found in any human community. The insolence of the wicked is so great, and their wickedness so stubborn, that even the harshest laws barely restrain it. What do we expect would happen if people who can hardly be forced to stop doing evil were to see their wickedness go entirely unpunished?
3. What civil government is for, and how we'll treat it
There will be a better place to speak of its use. For now I only want it understood that it's sheer barbarism to think of abolishing it. Its use among men is no less than that of bread and water, light and air, and its dignity is far higher. It doesn't only enable people to breathe, eat, drink and keep warm, though it does include all that while it lets people live together. Its purpose is also that idolatry, blasphemy against God's name, slanders against his truth and other offences against religion shouldn't break out and spread among the people; that public peace shouldn't be disturbed; that everyone's property should be secure; that people can trade with each other without harm; that honesty and decency are encouraged. In short, it's so that a public form of religion may exist among Christians, and humanity among men.
Don't be surprised that I now give human government the task of setting religion in order, when I seem earlier to have put religion beyond the will of man. I no more allow people to make laws about religion and worship at their own pleasure than I did before. I'm approving a civil order whose aim is to stop the true religion, contained in God's law, from being openly violated and defiled by public blasphemy, with no consequence.
To help the reader see the whole order of civil government clearly, I'll treat its parts separately. There are three: the magistrate, who is the guardian and president of the laws; the laws by which he governs; and the people, who are governed by the laws and obey the magistrate. So first: what is the magistrate's function? Is it a lawful calling that God approves? What is the nature of his duty, and how far does his power go? Second: what laws should shape a Christian polity? Last: what use are these laws to the people, and what obedience do the people owe the magistrate?
4. God approves the magistrate's office
As for the magistrate's function, the Lord hasn't only declared that he approves and delights in it. He has also commended it to us by the very honourable titles he gives it. When the holders of this office are called gods (Exod. 22:8-9; Ps. 82:1, 6), no one should think the title carries little weight. It tells us they have a commission from God, that they're clothed with divine authority and in fact represent God's person, acting as his substitutes. This isn't a quibble of mine. It's Christ's own interpretation: "If he called them gods to whom the word of God came" (John 10:35). What does that mean but that the work was committed to them by God, to serve him in their office? Moses and Jehoshaphat said exactly this to the judges they appointed over each city of Judah: judge, "not for man but for the Lord" (2 Chron. 19:6; Deut. 1:16-17).
Wisdom says the same through Solomon: "By me kings reign, and rulers decree what is just. By me princes rule, and nobles, all who govern justly" (Prov. 8:15-16). It's as though he'd said that supreme power on earth isn't held by kings and other rulers through human perversity. It comes by divine providence and the holy decree of the One who has chosen to govern human affairs this way, because he is present and presides when laws are made and justice is done.
Paul teaches the same when he lists governing among God's gifts, distributed in different ways according to the measure of grace, to be used by Christ's servants to build up the Church (Rom. 12:8). There he's speaking strictly of the council of grave men appointed in the early Church to oversee public discipline. In the letter to the Corinthians he calls this office "governments" (1 Cor. 12:28). But since civil power has the same goal, there's no doubt he's commending every kind of just government. He speaks much more clearly when he takes up the subject properly: "there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God"; rulers are God's ministers, "a terror not to good conduct but to bad" (Rom. 13:1, 3).
We can add the examples of saints. Some held the office of kings, like David, Josiah and Hezekiah. Others were governors, like Joseph and Daniel. Others were civil magistrates among a free people, like Moses, Joshua and the Judges. The Lord expressly approved their work. So no one can doubt that civil authority is, in God's sight, not only holy and lawful but the most holy and honourable of all stations in mortal life.
5. The gospel doesn't make rulers obsolete
People who want to introduce anarchy (the French says: those who'd like people to live pell-mell like rats in straw) object that kings and judges may have been fine for a rude people long ago, but that this servile way of governing doesn't suit the perfection Christ brought with his gospel. They show not only their ignorance but a devilish pride, claiming a perfection of which not a hundredth part is found in them. Whatever they are, the answer is easy.
When David says, "Now therefore, O kings, be wise; be warned, O rulers of the earth. Kiss the Son, lest he be angry" (Ps. 2:10, 12), he doesn't tell them to lay down their authority and return to private life. He tells them to put the power they hold under Christ, so that he may rule over all. In the same way, when Isaiah predicts of the Church, "Kings shall be your foster fathers, and their queens your nursing mothers" (Isa. 49:23), he doesn't tell them to abdicate. He gives them the honourable title of patrons of the godly who worship God. The prophecy refers to Christ's coming.
I'm deliberately leaving out many passages that run through Scripture, especially the Psalms, which assert the proper authority of all rulers. The best known is Paul's instruction to Timothy that prayers be offered in public worship for kings, with the reason attached: "that we may lead a peaceful and quiet life, godly and dignified in every way" (1 Tim. 2:2). In these words he commits the Church's welfare to their protection and guardianship.
6. What this should mean to magistrates themselves
Magistrates should keep this consideration constantly in mind. It's a strong spur to doing their duty, and it also brings real comfort in the difficulties of an office that is certainly weighty and demanding. What zeal for integrity, prudence, gentleness, self-control and innocence should rule people who know they've been appointed ministers of divine justice! How will they dare to let injustice into their courtroom when they've been told it is the throne of the living God? How will they venture to pass an unjust sentence with a mouth they know has been appointed as an instrument of divine truth? With what conscience will they sign wicked decrees with a hand they know has been appointed to write the acts of God? In short, if they remember they're God's representatives, they must watch with all care, diligence and industry to show in themselves a kind of image of his providence, protection, goodness, kindness and justice.
They should also keep this in view: if a curse is pronounced on the one who does "the work of the Lord with slackness" (Jer. 48:10), a much heavier curse falls on anyone who acts deceitfully in a righteous calling. That's why Moses and Jehoshaphat, when they wanted to stir their judges to their duty, had nothing more powerful to appeal to than this: "Consider what you do, for you judge not for man but for the Lord. He is with you in giving judgment. Now then, let the fear of the Lord be upon you. Be careful what you do, for there is no injustice with the Lord our God, or partiality or taking bribes" (2 Chron. 19:6-7; compare Deut. 1:16). Another passage says, "God has taken his place in the divine council; in the midst of the gods he holds judgment" (Ps. 82:1; Isa. 3:14). The point is that they'll be roused to their duty when they hear that they're God's ambassadors and must one day give an account of the province entrusted to them.
This warning should have the greatest effect on them. If they sin in any way, they don't only wrong the people they wickedly torment. They also insult God himself, whose sacred tribunals they pollute. On the other hand, they have a wonderful source of comfort when they reflect that they aren't engaged in some profane business unfit for a servant of God, but in a most sacred office, since they're God's ambassadors.
7. Those who attack this office attack God
Some people aren't held back by all these passages from railing against this sacred ministry as if it were foreign to religion and Christian godliness. What are they doing but attacking God himself, who can't help being insulted when his servants are disgraced? These men don't only "speak evil of dignitaries." They wouldn't even have God reign over them (1 Sam. 8:7). If that was truly said of Israel when they rejected Samuel's authority, how can it be less true today of those who let themselves break loose against all the authority God has established?
But, someone says, didn't our Lord forbid his disciples to be kings or governors when he said, "The kings of the Gentiles exercise lordship over them, and those in authority over them are called benefactors. But not so with you. Rather, let the greatest among you become as the youngest, and the leader as one who serves" (Luke 22:25-26)? Clever interpreters! A dispute had arisen among the disciples over which of them was the greatest. To put down this empty ambition, our Lord taught them that their ministry wasn't like the power of earthly rulers, where one stands far above another. What in that comparison, I ask, belittles royal dignity? What does it prove at all, except that the royal office isn't the apostolic ministry?
Besides, though the offices of government take different forms, they're alike in this: we must receive them all as ordinances of God. Paul includes them all together when he says that "there is no authority except from God." And the form of government that was by no means the most popular received the highest testimony: I mean the rule of one person. Because it carries with it the public servitude of everyone except the one to whose will all is subject, heroic and nobler spirits disliked it in ancient times. But Scripture, to answer these unjust judgments, says expressly that it's by divine wisdom that "kings reign," and gives a special command to "honour the emperor" (1 Pet. 2:17).
8. The three forms of government
It would be a very idle occupation for private people to debate what the best form of government would be where they live, since their deliberations can't influence any public decision. And the question couldn't be settled in the abstract without rashness, since the answer depends on circumstances. If you compare the different states with each other without regard to circumstances, it isn't easy to say which has the advantage in usefulness, so evenly are they matched.
Monarchy tends toward tyranny. Aristocracy tends just as much toward the factions of a few. Popular rule is strongly inclined to sedition. (The French explains: three kinds of civil government are counted. Monarchy is the rule of one, whether he's called king, duke or anything else. Aristocracy is government by the leading and eminent men. Democracy is popular government, in which each of the people has power.)
Considered in themselves, I'm far from denying that the form that greatly surpasses the others is aristocracy, either pure or tempered by popular government. I don't say this because it's best in itself. It's because kings so rarely govern themselves so as never to depart from what is just and right, and so rarely have enough sharpness and wisdom always to see correctly. Because of the faults and defects of men, it's safer and more bearable when several rule, so that they can help, instruct and warn one another, and if one of them goes too far, the others act as censors and masters to curb his excess. Experience has already shown this, and the Lord himself confirmed it by authority when he set up among the Israelites an aristocracy bordering on popular government, and kept them under it as the best form until he gave an image of the Messiah in David.
I willingly admit that no kind of government is happier than one where liberty is framed with proper moderation and set up to last. I count those very fortunate who are allowed to enjoy it, and I grant that they do nothing contrary to their duty when they work strenuously and steadily to preserve it. Magistrates, indeed, ought to do their utmost to keep the liberty they're appointed to guard from being weakened, let alone violated. If they're sluggish or careless about it, they're faithless traitors to their office and their country.
But when the Lord has assigned one form of government to a people, it would be not only foolish and pointless but very harmful for them to long anxiously for a change. If you look beyond one state and survey the world, or at least regions far apart, you'll see that divine providence has had good reason to arrange for different countries to be governed by different forms of polity. Just as only elements of unequal temperature hold together, so in different regions an unequal form of government is best. All this is said needlessly, though, to people for whom God's will is reason enough. If it has pleased him to appoint kings over kingdoms and senates or burgomasters over free cities, then whatever form he has appointed where we live, our duty is to obey and submit.
9. The magistrate's duty to both tables of the law
Here I'll point out briefly what the word of God says about the nature of the magistrate's duty and what it involves. That it extends to both tables of the law, we could learn from secular writers even if Scripture didn't teach it. No one has written about the duty of magistrates, the making of laws and the common good without beginning with religion and divine worship. All have agreed that no polity can be successfully established unless piety is its first concern, and that laws are absurd which disregard God's rights and look only to men's. Since religion holds first place among philosophers, and nations have always agreed on it, Christian princes and magistrates should be ashamed of their heartlessness if they don't make it their concern.
I've already shown that God specially assigned this office to them. It's right for them to work at asserting and defending the honour of the One whose representatives they are and by whose favour they rule. That's why Scripture especially praises holy kings for restoring God's worship when it had been corrupted or overthrown, or for making sure religion flourished under them in purity and safety. On the other hand, the sacred history counts anarchy among the vices, when it says there was no king in Israel and so everyone did what was right in his own eyes (Judg. 21:25). This rebukes the folly of those who would neglect divine things and give themselves only to administering justice among men. As if God had appointed rulers in his name to settle earthly disputes and left out what matters far more, his own pure worship as his law prescribes! Restless men take this view, in their eagerness to make all kinds of changes without penalty, and would like to get rid of everyone who defends violated piety.
As for the second table of the law, Jeremiah says to rulers, "Thus says the Lord: Do justice and righteousness, and deliver from the hand of the oppressor him who has been robbed. And do no wrong or violence to the resident alien, the fatherless, and the widow, nor shed innocent blood" (Jer. 22:3). The Psalm urges the same: "Give justice to the weak and the fatherless; maintain the right of the afflicted and the destitute. Rescue the weak and the needy; deliver them from the hand of the wicked" (Ps. 82:3-4). Moses likewise told the leaders he'd put in his place, "Hear the cases between your brothers, and judge righteously between a man and his brother or the alien who is with him. You shall not be partial in judgment. You shall hear the small and the great alike. You shall not be intimidated by anyone, for the judgment is God's" (Deut. 1:16-17). I say nothing of passages like these: the king "must not acquire many horses for himself or cause the people to return to Egypt," "neither shall he acquire many wives for himself," "nor shall he acquire for himself excessive silver and gold," "he shall write for himself in a book a copy of this law," "it shall be with him, and he shall read in it all the days of his life, that he may learn to fear the Lord his God," "that his heart may not be lifted up above his brothers" (Deut. 17:16-20).
In explaining magistrates' duties here, I'm aiming less to instruct the magistrates themselves than to teach everyone else why magistrates exist and what God appointed them for. We say they're the appointed guardians and defenders of public innocence, decency, honour and peace, so that their only concern should be the common peace and safety. David promises to set an example of this once he's on the throne: "A perverse heart shall be far from me; I will know nothing of evil. Whoever slanders his neighbour secretly I will destroy. Whoever has a haughty look and an arrogant heart I will not endure. I will look with favour on the faithful in the land, that they may dwell with me; he who walks in the way that is blameless shall minister to me" (Ps. 101:4-6).
But rulers can't do this unless they protect the good from the injuries of the bad and give help and protection to the oppressed. So they're armed with power to restrain open evildoers and criminals, whose misconduct disturbs or harasses public peace. We've seen for ourselves the truth of Solon's saying that all public affairs depend on reward and punishment, and that where these are missing the whole discipline of a state totters and collapses. In many minds the love of fairness and justice grows cold if virtue isn't honoured, and the licence of the wicked can't be restrained without strict discipline and the infliction of punishment.
The prophet includes both when he commands kings and other rulers to do "justice and righteousness" (Jer. 21:12; 22:3). Righteousness is to take charge of the innocent, to defend and avenge them and set them free. Judgment is to stand against the boldness of the wicked, to restrain their violence and to punish their faults.
10. Can a Christian magistrate shed blood?
A difficult and apparently perplexing question comes up here. If all Christians are forbidden to kill, and the prophet predicts of the Lord's holy mountain, which is the Church, "They shall not hurt or destroy" (Isa. 11:9; 65:25), how can magistrates be both godly and shedders of blood?
The answer removes every doubt once we understand that when the magistrate inflicts punishment, he isn't acting on his own. He's carrying out God's own judgments. The Lord's law forbids killing. But so that murder shouldn't go unpunished, the Lawgiver himself puts the sword into his ministers' hands to use against all murderers. It isn't for the godly to afflict and hurt. But to avenge the afflictions of the godly at God's command is neither to afflict nor to hurt. (The French adds: so it's easy to conclude that in this respect they aren't subject to the common law. The Lord ties everyone's hands by it, but he doesn't tie his own justice, which he exercises through magistrates' hands. It's like a prince who forbids all his subjects to carry a weapon or strike anyone, but doesn't thereby stop his officers from carrying out the justice he's specially committed to them.)
I wish this were always present to our minds: nothing here is done by human rashness. It's all done in obedience to God's authority. When he is the guide, we never stray from the right path. We stray only if divine justice is to be held back and not allowed to punish crimes. If we don't dare to give law to it, why should we accuse its ministers? "He does not bear the sword in vain," says Paul. "For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God's wrath on the wrongdoer" (Rom. 13:4). So if princes and other rulers know that nothing is more acceptable to God than their obedience, let them give themselves to this service if they want to grow in godliness, justice and integrity before God.
That's how Moses felt (Exod. 2:12; 32:26; Acts 7:21). He knew he was destined to deliver his people by the Lord's power, so he laid violent hands on the Egyptian, and later avenged the people's idolatry by killing three thousand of them in one day. David felt the same when, near the end of his life, he ordered his son Solomon to put Joab and Shimei to death (1 Kings 2:5). Among the virtues of a king, one is to destroy all the wicked in the land and cut off all evildoers from the city of the Lord (Ps. 101:8). The same goes for the praise given to Solomon: "You have loved righteousness and hated wickedness" (Ps. 45:7).
Why did the gentle spirit of Moses become so inflamed that, stained and dripping with his brothers' blood, he ran through the camp bringing fresh slaughter? Why did David, who showed such mildness all his life, almost with his last breath leave his son that bloody testament, not to let the grey hairs of Joab and Shimei go down to the grave in peace? By their severity they both made holy the hands they would have defiled by showing mercy, since they were carrying out the vengeance God had committed to them.
Solomon says, "It is an abomination to kings to do evil, for the throne is established by righteousness" (Prov. 16:12). Again, "A king who sits on the throne of judgment winnows all evil with his eyes" (Prov. 20:8). Again, "A wise king winnows the wicked and drives the wheel over them" (Prov. 20:26). Again, "Take away the wicked from before the king, and his throne will be established in righteousness" (Prov. 25:5). Again, "He who justifies the wicked and he who condemns the righteous are both alike an abomination to the Lord" (Prov. 17:15). Again, "An evil man seeks only rebellion, and a cruel messenger will be sent against him" (Prov. 17:11). Again, "Whoever says to the wicked, 'You are in the right,' will be cursed by peoples, abhorred by nations" (Prov. 24:24).
If it's true justice in rulers to pursue the guilty and ungodly with a drawn sword, then to sheathe the sword and keep their hands clean of blood while wicked men wade through murder and slaughter wouldn't redound to their praise as kind and just. It would make them guilty of the greatest impiety. This holds provided they avoid reckless and cruel harshness, and avoid a tribunal that could fairly be called a rock on which the accused must founder.
I'm not one who'd favour untimely severity, or think a court can be called just unless mercy presides over it. Mercy is the best and surest counsellor of kings and, as Solomon says, "upholds the throne" (Prov. 20:28). It was rightly said by a writer of old that this should be the first quality of princes. The magistrate must guard against both extremes. He mustn't wound rather than heal by excessive severity. Nor, through a superstitious show of leniency, may he fall into the cruellest inhumanity by giving way to soft, lax indulgence that destroys many. Someone living under the emperor Nerva said it well: it's bad to live under a prince who allows nothing, but much worse to live under one who allows everything.
11. War can be lawful
Kings and states sometimes have to take up arms to carry out public vengeance. The reasoning just given shows us how to judge when wars of this kind are lawful. If power has been given to rulers to maintain the peace of their subjects, restrain the riots of the turbulent, help those who are violently oppressed and punish crimes, can they use it more fittingly than to stop the fury of someone who disturbs both the quiet of individuals and the common tranquillity of all, who stirs up riots and commits violent oppression and gross wrongs?
If it's their job to guard and maintain the laws, they must put down the attempts of everyone whose criminal conduct weakens the laws' discipline. If they rightly punish robbers whose injuries have fallen on only a few, will they let the whole country be robbed and laid waste without penalty? It makes no difference whether a hostile, destructive raid into a district over which they have no authority is made by a king or by the lowest of the people. All of them are to be regarded and punished as robbers.
So natural fairness and duty require that princes be armed, not only to repress private crimes by judicial penalties, but to defend the subjects entrusted to their care whenever they are attacked by an enemy. The Holy Spirit, in many passages of Scripture, declares this lawful.
12. War in the New Testament, and the restraint it demands
Someone may object that no passage or example in the New Testament teaches that war is lawful for Christians. I answer first that the reason for waging war, which existed in ancient times, still exists today, and that there's no ground for forbidding magistrates to defend those under them. Second, we shouldn't look in the apostolic writings for a distinct treatment of these matters. Their aim wasn't to form a civil polity but to establish Christ's spiritual kingdom. Last, even there it's indicated in passing that our Saviour's coming made no change in this respect.
To use Augustine's words: if Christian discipline condemned all wars, then when soldiers asked for advice about the way of salvation, they would have been told to throw away their weapons and leave military service altogether. Instead it was said, "Do not extort money from anyone by threats or by false accusation, and be content with your wages" (Luke 3:14). Those whom he tells to be content with their pay he certainly doesn't forbid to serve (Augustine, Letter 5, to Marcellinus).
But all magistrates must take particular care not to give in to their passions at all. When punishments are to be inflicted, they mustn't be swept along by anger, carried away by hatred or burning with unrelenting severity. They must, as Augustine says (City of God 5.24), "even pity our common nature in the one whose individual fault they punish." And when they have to take up arms against an enemy, that is, an armed robber, they mustn't seize the opportunity eagerly. They shouldn't even take it when it's offered, unless the strongest necessity compels them. If we are to do far more than that pagan, who wanted war to look like a desire for peace, then surely every other means must be tried before resorting to arms.
In both cases they mustn't let any private feeling carry them away. Regard for the public alone must guide them. Acting otherwise, they wickedly abuse a power given not for their own benefit but for the good and service of others.
The right of war underlies the right of garrisons, alliances and other civil defences. By garrisons I mean the forces stationed in states to defend the frontiers. By alliances I mean the agreements neighbouring princes make to help each other if trouble arises in their territories, and to join forces against the common enemies of humankind. Under civil defences I include everything that belongs to the military art.
13. Taxes and public revenue
Finally, we should add that taxes and levies are the legitimate revenues of princes. They are chiefly to use them to bear the public burdens of their office. They may also use them to maintain their household, which is in a way bound up with the dignity of the authority they exercise. We see that David, Hezekiah, Josiah, Jehoshaphat and other holy kings, and also Joseph and Daniel, in proportion to the office they held, spent generously from public funds without offending godliness. And we read in Ezekiel that a very large territory was assigned to kings (Ezek. 48:21). There he's describing the spiritual kingdom of Christ, but he borrows his picture from lawful rule among men.
Princes in their turn must remember that their revenues aren't so much private chests as the treasuries of the whole people (Paul testifies to this in Rom. 13:6). They can't squander or waste them without manifest injustice. More than that, they're almost the lifeblood of the people, and it would be the harshest inhumanity not to spare it. They should also consider that their levies, contributions and other kinds of taxes are only subsidies for public need, and that it is tyrannical greed to burden the poor with them without cause.
None of this is meant to encourage princes in extravagance and luxury. There's certainly no need to inflame passions that are already more than inflamed on their own. But since it matters enormously that whatever they venture to do, they do with a clear conscience, they must be taught how far they can lawfully go, lest through ungodly confidence they bring God's displeasure on themselves. Nor is this teaching unnecessary for private people. It keeps them from rashly and petulantly condemning princes' spending, even when it exceeds the usual limits.
14. Laws, and the three kinds in Moses
In a state, the thing next in importance to the magistrates is the laws, the strongest sinews of government, or, as Cicero calls them after Plato, its soul. Without them the magistrate's office can't exist, just as the laws have no force without the magistrate. So it was well said that the law is a silent magistrate and the magistrate a living law.
Having undertaken to describe the laws by which a Christian polity is governed, I shouldn't be expected to give a long discussion of the best kind of laws. The subject is vast and belongs elsewhere. I'll only note briefly which laws can be piously used with reference to God and rightly administered among men. I'd rather have passed over it in silence, but I know that many dangerous errors are made here. Some people deny that any commonwealth is rightly ordered which neglects the law of Moses and is ruled by the common law of nations. How perilous and seditious that view is, others can judge. For me it's enough to show that it's foolish and false.
We must attend to the well-known division that sorts the whole law of God, as given through Moses, into the moral, the ceremonial and the judicial law, and look at each part to see how far it does or doesn't concern us. Don't be troubled by the thought that the judicial and ceremonial laws also have to do with morals. The ancients who adopted this division knew that the latter two classes touched morals. They didn't call them moral because they could be changed and abolished without affecting morals. They gave the name especially to the first class, without which there can be no true holiness of life and no unchanging rule of conduct.
15. What each part of the law is, and what binds us
The moral law, to begin with it, is contained under two heads. One simply commands us to worship God with pure faith and godliness. The other commands us to embrace people with sincere love. It is the true and eternal rule of righteousness, prescribed to people of all nations and all times who want to shape their lives according to God's will. His eternal and unchanging will is that we all worship him and love one another.
The ceremonial law of the Jews was a tutelage. The Lord was pleased to train that people, as it were in their childhood, until the fullness of time came when he would fully show his wisdom to the world and display the reality of what was then pictured in figures (Gal. 3:24; 4:4).
The judicial law, given to them as a kind of polity, handed on certain forms of fairness and justice by which they could live together innocently and peacefully. The practice of ceremonies properly belonged to the teaching of godliness, since it kept the Jewish Church in the worship and religion of God, and yet it was distinguishable from godliness itself. In the same way the judicial form looked only to the best way of preserving the love that God's eternal law commands, and was still something distinct from the precept of love itself. So just as ceremonies could be abolished without touching godliness at all, so too when these judicial arrangements are removed, the duties and commands of love can remain for ever.
Each nation, then, is left free to make whatever laws it judges beneficial. But these are always to be tested by the rule of love, so that while they differ in form, they proceed from the same principle. Barbarous and savage laws, for instance, that gave honour to thieves, allowed promiscuous sexual relations, or enacted other things even fouler and more absurd, I don't think deserve to be called laws at all. They are not only abhorrent to justice but to humanity and civilised life.
16. Equity, and why laws may differ
What I've said will be clear if we notice, as we should, two things connected with all laws: the enactment of the law, and the equity on which the enactment rests. Equity, being natural, can't differ from one people to another, and so every law ought to aim at it, according to the nature of the matter being legislated. Constitutions depend partly on circumstances, so nothing stops them from varying, provided they all alike aim at equity as their end.
It's clear that the law of God we call moral is nothing other than the testimony of natural law and of the conscience God has engraved on human minds. So the whole of the equity we're speaking of is prescribed in it. It alone, then, ought to be the aim, rule and end of all laws. Wherever laws are formed by this rule, directed to this aim and held to this end, there's no reason for us to disapprove of them, however much they differ from the Jewish law or from each other (Augustine, City of God 19.17).
God's law forbids stealing. The punishment appointed for theft in the civil polity of the Jews can be seen in Exodus 22. Very ancient laws of other nations punished theft by making the thief pay back double. Later laws distinguished between theft caught in the act and theft not so caught. Others went as far as exile or branding, and others made it a capital crime. Among the Jews the punishment for a false witness was "you shall do to him as he sought to do to his brother" (Deut. 19:19). In some countries the penalty is infamy, in others hanging, in others crucifixion. All laws avenge murder with blood, but the manner of death differs. In some places adultery was punished more severely, in others more leniently. Yet amid this diversity we see that they all aim at the same end. With one voice they speak against the crimes God's eternal law condemns: murder, theft, adultery and false witness. They don't agree on the mode of punishment, and this is neither necessary nor even desirable.
There may be a country that would instantly fall prey to robbery and slaughter if murder weren't visited with fearful punishments. There may be an age that needs punishments made harsher. If the state is in turmoil, the things that usually cause disturbances must be corrected by new edicts. In wartime, civilised life would disappear in the noise of arms unless people were held in check by unusual severity. In famine or plague, everything would get worse without stricter discipline. A nation might be more prone to a particular vice if it weren't repressed with the greatest severity. How spiteful it would be, and how envious of the public good, to take offence at this diversity, which is wonderfully suited to keeping God's law observed!
The charge that insult is offered to the law of God given through Moses, when it's repealed and other new laws are preferred, is absurd. Other laws aren't preferred as better in themselves. They're preferred because of time and place and the condition of the people, or when we abolish what was never enacted for us. The Lord didn't deliver his law through Moses to be proclaimed in all countries and enforced everywhere. He took the Jewish nation under his special care, patronage and protection, and chose to be its particular lawgiver. Like a wise lawgiver, he had special regard to that people in making laws.
17. What the common society of Christians gains from laws and courts
It remains to see, as proposed at the start, what use the common society of Christians gets from laws, judicial proceedings and magistrates. Connected with this is another question: what respect should private people give to magistrates, and how far should obedience go?
To very many it seems that among Christians the magistrate's office is superfluous, because they can't properly ask for his help, being forbidden to take revenge, to summon anyone before a judge, or to go to law. But Paul says on the contrary that the magistrate is God's servant "for your good" (Rom. 13:4). From this we understand that he was appointed by God so that, defended by his hand and help against the dishonesty and injustice of wicked men, we may live quiet and secure. If he'd been appointed over us in vain unless we used his help, then it can't be wrong to appeal to it and ask for it.
Here I have two kinds of people to deal with. Very many are so consumed with a rage for litigation that they can never be at peace with themselves unless they're fighting with others. They pursue lawsuits with the bitterness of deadly hatred and a mad eagerness to hurt and take revenge, and they stick to them with implacable stubbornness, even to the ruin of their opponent. Meanwhile, so that they may be thought to do nothing but what is legal, they use the pretext of legal proceedings as cover for their perverse behaviour. But even if it's lawful for brother to go to law with brother, it doesn't follow that it's lawful to hate him and doggedly pursue him with a furious desire to harm him.
18. How to go to law rightly
Let such people understand that legal proceedings are lawful for the one who uses them rightly. The right use, for the defendant, is to appear on the appointed day and, without bitterness, argue what he can in his defence, wanting only to maintain his right justly. For the plaintiff, when he's undeservedly attacked in his life or property, the right use is to put himself under the magistrate's protection, state his complaint and ask for what is just and good. He must do this far from any wish to hurt or take revenge, far from bitterness and hatred, far from the heat of strife. He should be readier to yield and to suffer something than to cherish hostile feelings toward his opponent.
When minds are full of ill will, eaten up with envy, burning with anger, breathing revenge, or in short so inflamed by the heat of the contest that they lay charity aside to some degree, then the whole case, even of the justest cause, can only be ungodly. It ought to be an axiom among all Christians that no suit, however fair, can be rightly conducted by someone who doesn't feel as kindly toward his opponent as if the matter in dispute were being settled amicably.
Someone may break in and say that such moderation in legal proceedings is so rare that an example of it would be a kind of prodigy. I admit that in these days it's rare to meet an honest litigant. But the thing itself, untouched by the addition of evil, doesn't stop being good and pure. When we hear that the magistrate's help is a sacred gift from God, we should be all the more careful not to pollute it by our own fault.
19. Those who condemn all legal proceedings
People who flatly condemn all legal proceedings should know that they reject the holy ordinance of God and one of those gifts which are pure to the pure. Unless, that is, they want to charge Paul with a crime. He answered the slanders of his accusers, exposing their craft and wickedness (Acts 24:12), and before the tribunal claimed the privilege of a Roman citizen (Acts 16:37; 22:25), and when necessary appealed from the governor to Caesar's judgment seat (Acts 25:10).
This doesn't conflict with the prohibition that binds all Christians to refrain from revenge (Lev. 19:18; Matt. 5:39; Rom. 12:19), a feeling we drive far away from every Christian court. In a civil action, the right course is taken by the person who in plain innocence commits his cause to the judge as the public protector, with no thought of returning evil for evil, which is the spirit of revenge. In a graver action directed against a capital offence, the accuser required is not one who comes to court carried away by revenge or resentment over some private injury, but one whose only aim is to prevent some bad men's attempts to harm the commonwealth. Take away the vindictive mind, and you offend in no way against the command that forbids Christians to take revenge.
But they're not only forbidden to thirst for revenge. They're also commanded to wait for the Lord's hand, since he promises to be the avenger of the oppressed and afflicted (Deut. 32:35). Don't those who call on the magistrate for help, for themselves or for others, get ahead of the vengeance of the heavenly Judge? Not at all. We have to remember that the magistrate's vengeance is not man's vengeance but God's, which, as Paul says, he carries out through human service for our good (Rom. 13:4).
20. "Do not resist the one who is evil"
We're no more at odds with the words of Christ, who forbids us to resist evil and adds, "If anyone strikes you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also. And if anyone would sue you and take your tunic, let him have your cloak as well" (Matt. 5:39-40). He wants his followers' minds to be so far from anything like retaliation that they would sooner let an injury be doubled than want to pay it back. We don't discourage that patience.
Christians were truly meant to be a people born to endure insults and injuries, exposed to the dishonesty, deceit and mockery of abandoned men. Not only that, they were to bear all these evils calmly. That is, they were to be so settled in the whole frame of their minds that, after receiving one offence, they'd get ready for another, expecting nothing in all their life but the enduring of a perpetual cross. Meanwhile they must do good to those who wrong them, and pray for those who curse them, and (this is their only victory) strive to overcome evil with good (Rom. 12:20-21).
So disposed, they won't demand eye for eye and tooth for tooth, as the Pharisees taught their disciples to long for vengeance. They'll follow Christ's teaching: they'll let their bodies be maimed and their goods be taken maliciously, ready to forgive the wrongs the moment they're done, and to pardon them freely.
But this fairness and gentleness won't prevent them, with complete friendship toward their enemies, from using the magistrate's help to protect their property. Nor will it prevent them, out of zeal for the public good, from calling for the punishment of a wicked and destructive man whom they know nothing will reform but death. Augustine rightly explains all these precepts as preparing the just and godly person to bear patiently the malice of those he wants to become good, so that he increases the number of the good and doesn't add himself to the number of the bad by copying their wickedness. They have more to do with the preparation of the heart within than with the deed done openly. Patience and goodwill must be kept in the secret of the heart, while what is done openly may be whatever we see will do good to those we ought to wish well (Augustine, Letter 5, to Marcellinus).
21. Paul and lawsuits among Christians
It's often objected that Paul condemns lawsuits altogether (1 Cor. 6:6). That's false. It's easy to see from his words that a rage for litigation had taken hold in the church at Corinth to such a degree that they exposed the gospel of Christ, and the whole religion they professed, to the slanders and quibbles of the ungodly. Paul rebukes them, first, for dragging the gospel before unbelievers through their undisciplined quarrels, and second, for fighting each other as brothers. They were so far from bearing injury from another that they greedily coveted each other's possessions and deliberately provoked and wronged one another.
So he attacks that madness for litigation, not every kind of dispute. He declares it a fault and a weakness that they wouldn't accept the loss of their goods rather than fight, even to the point of strife, to keep them. In other words, since they were so easily moved by every loss, and ran to the courts at every occasion however slight, he says they showed themselves too easily irritated and unprepared for patience.
Christians should always be more ready to give up part of their right than to go into court, from which they can scarcely come out without a troubled mind and a heart inflamed with hatred of their brother. But when someone sees that he can defend his property, whose loss he'd feel grievously, without any loss of charity, and does so, he doesn't offend against that passage of Paul at all. In short, as we said at the start, charity is every person's best counsellor. Anything we engage in without charity, and all the disputes that carry us beyond it, are unquestionably unjust and ungodly.
22. Honouring those in authority
The first duty of subjects toward their rulers is to hold the highest view of their office, recognising it as a jurisdiction delegated by God, and so to receive and revere them as God's ministers and ambassadors. You'll find some who are very obedient to magistrates and wouldn't want to be without anyone to obey, because they know it serves the public good, yet who regard magistrates as a kind of necessary evil. Peter asks for more than that when he says, "Honour the emperor" (1 Pet. 2:17), and so does Solomon: "My son, fear the Lord and the king" (Prov. 24:21). Under the word honour, Peter includes sincere and generous esteem. Solomon, by joining the king with God, shows that the king is clothed with a kind of sacred reverence and dignity.
We also have Paul's remarkable instruction: "Therefore one must be in subjection, not only to avoid God's wrath but also for the sake of conscience" (Rom. 13:5). He means that subjects shouldn't submit to princes and governors merely out of fear, as people submit to an armed enemy when they see vengeance ready if they resist. They obey because the obedience they give is given to God himself, since the rulers' power is from God.
I'm not speaking of the men themselves, as if the mask of dignity could cover folly, cowardice, cruelty or wicked and shameful conduct, and so win for vice the praise due to virtue. I'm saying that the position itself deserves honour and reverence, and that those who rule should be held in esteem and veneration for the sake of their office.
23. Obeying in practice, and what private people must not do
From this follows a second consequence: we must show our obedience to them readily, whether in complying with edicts, paying taxes, taking on public duties and burdens that relate to the common defence, or carrying out any other orders. "Let every person be subject to the governing authorities," says Paul. "Whoever resists the authorities resists what God has appointed" (Rom. 13:1-2). Writing to Titus, he says, "Remind them to be submissive to rulers and authorities, to be obedient, to be ready for every good work" (Titus 3:1). Peter also says, "Be subject for the Lord's sake to every human institution, whether it be to the emperor as supreme, or to governors as sent by him to punish those who do evil and to praise those who do good" (1 Pet. 2:13-14).
To show that their subjection isn't pretended but sincere and heartfelt, Paul adds that they should commend to God the safety and prosperity of those under whom they live: "First of all, then, I urge that supplications, prayers, intercessions, and thanksgivings be made for all people, for kings and all who are in high positions, that we may lead a peaceful and quiet life, godly and dignified in every way" (1 Tim. 2:1-2).
Nobody should deceive himself here. We can't resist the magistrate without resisting God. An unarmed magistrate may seem to be despised with impunity, but God is armed, and he will visibly avenge this contempt.
Under this obedience I include the restraint private people must put on themselves in public: not meddling in public affairs, not rashly invading the magistrate's province, not attempting anything of a public nature. If something in a public ordinance needs correcting, they shouldn't act tumultuously or put their hands to a work where they ought to feel their hands are tied. They should leave it to the magistrate's judgment, since his hand alone is free here. My meaning is that they shouldn't dare to do it without being ordered. When the magistrate gives the command, they too are clothed with public authority. As the common saying has it, the prince's eyes and ears are his counsellors, and so we may fairly say that those who manage affairs at his command are his hands.
24. When the ruler isn't what he should be
So far I've described the magistrate who truly is what his title says: the father of his country and, as the poet puts it, the shepherd of the people, the guardian of peace, the president of justice and the defender of innocence. Anyone who disapproves of such authority is rightly thought mad.
But in almost every age we see princes who ignore all their duties and live carelessly in luxurious idleness. Others, intent on their own profit, put every right, privilege, judgment and decree up for sale. Others rob the poor of their money and then waste it on insane giveaways. Others act as plain robbers, plundering houses, violating women and killing the innocent. Many people can't be persuaded to recognise such men as princes, whose commands, as far as they are lawful, they are bound to obey.
In such unworthy conduct, in atrocities so foreign not only to a magistrate's duty but to a man's, they see no trace of the image of God that should shine in the magistrate. They see no sign of the minister of God appointed to praise the good and terrify the bad. So they can't recognise the ruler whose dignity and authority Scripture recommends. And certainly the natural feeling of the human mind has always been as ready to hate and curse tyrants as to look up to just kings with love and respect.
25. Even unjust rulers hold their power from God
But if we pay attention to God's word, it will take us further. It will make us subject not only to the authority of princes who honestly and faithfully do their duty toward us, but to all princes, however they've come to power, even though they do nothing less than a prince's duty.
The Lord declares that a ruler who maintains our safety is the highest gift of his kindness, and he lays down for rulers their proper sphere. But he also declares that whatever kind they are, they have their power from him alone. Those who rule for the public good are true examples and samples of his kindness. Those who rule unjustly and tyrannically are raised up by him to punish the people's wickedness. Yet all alike have that sacred majesty with which he has clothed lawful power. I won't go further without adding some plain passages to this effect (Job 34:30; Hos. 13:11; Isa. 3:4; 10:5; Deut. 28:29).
We needn't labour to prove that a wicked king is a mark of the Lord's anger. I assume no one will deny it, and that this is no less true of a king than of a robber who takes your goods, an adulterer who defiles your marriage bed, or a murderer who goes after your life, since Scripture counts all such calamities among God's curses. What we must press at greater length, because it doesn't fit so easily with human opinion, is this: even a person of the worst character, utterly unworthy of any honour, if clothed with public authority, receives that glorious divine power which the Lord has by his word given to the ministers of his justice and judgment. So, as far as public obedience goes, he is to be held in the same honour and reverence as the best of kings.
26. Scripture on God's giving of kingdoms
First, I'd like the reader to pay careful attention to that divine providence which Scripture so often sets before us, with good reason, and to God's special act of distributing kingdoms and setting up as kings whomever he pleases. In Daniel it says, "He changes times and seasons; he removes kings and sets up kings" (Dan. 2:21). Again, "that the living may know that the Most High rules the kingdom of men and gives it to whom he will" (Dan. 4:17, 25). Similar statements appear throughout Scripture, especially in the prophets.
What kind of king Nebuchadnezzar was, who stormed Jerusalem, is well known. He was an energetic invader and destroyer of other countries. Yet the Lord declares in Ezekiel that he gave him the land of Egypt as wages for the devastation he'd caused (Ezek. 29:19-20). Daniel also told him, "You, O king, the king of kings, to whom the God of heaven has given the kingdom, the power, and the might, and the glory, and into whose hand he has given, wherever they dwell, the children of man, the beasts of the field, and the birds of the heavens, making you rule over them all" (Dan. 2:37-38). And he said to his son Belshazzar, "The Most High God gave Nebuchadnezzar your father kingship and greatness and glory and majesty. And because of the greatness that he gave him, all peoples, nations, and languages trembled and feared before him" (Dan. 5:18-19).
When we hear that the king was appointed by God, let's at the same time recall those heavenly commands to honour and fear the king, and we'll have no doubt that we must regard even the most wicked tyrant as holding the position with which the Lord has honoured him.
When Samuel told the people of Israel what they would suffer from their kings, he said: "These will be the ways of the king who will reign over you: he will take your sons and appoint them to his chariots and to be his horsemen, and to run before his chariots. And he will appoint for himself commanders of thousands and commanders of fifties, and some to plough his ground and to reap his harvest, and to make his implements of war and the equipment of his chariots. He will take your daughters to be perfumers and cooks and bakers. He will take the best of your fields and vineyards and olive orchards and give them to his servants. He will take the tenth of your grain and of your vineyards and give it to his officers and to his servants. He will take your male servants and female servants and the best of your young men and your donkeys, and put them to his work. He will take the tenth of your flocks, and you shall be his slaves" (1 Sam. 8:11-17).
Certainly kings couldn't do these things lawfully, since the law trained them most carefully to every kind of restraint. But it was called the king's "justice" with respect to the people, because they were bound to obey and couldn't lawfully resist. It's as though Samuel had said: kings will go so far in tyranny that you won't be able to restrain them. All that will remain for you is to receive their commands and obey their words.
27. Jeremiah on Nebuchadnezzar
The most remarkable and memorable passage is in Jeremiah. It's rather long, but I'm happy to quote it, because it settles this whole question most clearly. "It is I who by my great power and my outstretched arm have made the earth, with the people and the animals that are on the earth, and I give it to whomever it seems right to me. Now I have given all these lands into the hand of Nebuchadnezzar, the king of Babylon, my servant, and I have given him also the beasts of the field to serve him. All the nations shall serve him and his son and his grandson, until the time of his own land comes. Then many nations and great kings shall make him their slave. But if any nation or kingdom will not serve this Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon, and put its neck under the yoke of the king of Babylon, I will punish that nation with the sword, with famine, and with pestilence, declares the Lord, until I have consumed it by his hand" (Jer. 27:5-8). Therefore, "Bring your necks under the yoke of the king of Babylon and serve him and his people and live" (v. 12).
We see how great an obedience the Lord was pleased to demand toward this dreadful and savage tyrant, for no other reason than that he held the kingdom. In other words, the divine decree had placed him on the throne and admitted him to royal majesty, which couldn't lawfully be violated.
If we keep constantly before our eyes and minds that even the most wicked kings are set up by the same decree that establishes all royal authority, we'll never entertain the seditious thought that a king is to be treated as he deserves, or that we needn't act as good subjects to one who doesn't act as a king to us.
28. This command wasn't only for Israel
It's no use objecting that this command was given specially to the Israelites. We have to look at the ground on which the Lord puts it: "I have given the kingdom to Nebuchadnezzar; therefore serve him and live." We shouldn't doubt that whoever has been given a kingdom, we are bound to serve. Whenever God raises someone to royal honour, he declares that it's his pleasure that he should reign. We have general statements to that effect in Scripture. Solomon says, "When a land transgresses, it has many rulers" (Prov. 28:2). Job says, "He loosens the bonds of kings and binds a waistcloth on their hips" (Job 12:18). That being granted, nothing remains for us but to serve and live.
There's another command in Jeremiah in which the Lord tells his people: "Seek the welfare of the city where I have sent you into exile, and pray to the Lord on its behalf, for in its welfare you will find your welfare" (Jer. 29:7). Here the Israelites, stripped of all their property, torn from their homes, driven into exile and thrown into miserable bondage, are told to pray for the prosperity of their conqueror. This is not as we're elsewhere told to pray for our persecutors. It's that his kingdom may be kept in safety and peace, so that they too may live prosperously under him.
So David, though he was already king-elect by God's appointment and anointed with his holy oil, was attacked without cause and unjustly by Saul. Yet he held sacred the life of the man who was seeking his life, because the Lord had clothed him with royal honour. "The Lord forbid that I should do this thing to my lord, the Lord's anointed, to put out my hand against him, seeing he is the Lord's anointed." "I will not put out my hand against my lord, for he is the Lord's anointed" (1 Sam. 24:6, 10). And again: "Who can put out his hand against the Lord's anointed and be guiltless? As the Lord lives, the Lord will strike him, or his day will come to die, or he will go down into battle and perish. The Lord forbid that I should put out my hand against the Lord's anointed" (1 Sam. 26:9-11).
29. Reverence for rulers whatever their character, and how to bear tyranny
We owe this feeling of reverence, even of piety, to all our rulers to the full, whatever their character. I repeat it so often so that we learn not to look at the individuals themselves, but to count it enough that, by the Lord's will, they hold a position on which he has stamped and engraved inviolable majesty.
"But rulers," you'll say, "owe duties in return to those under them." I've already admitted that. But if from this you conclude that obedience is owed only to just rulers, you reason absurdly. Husbands are bound by mutual duties to their wives, and parents to their children. If husbands and parents neglect their duty, if parents are harsh and severe to the children they're commanded not to provoke to anger and wear them out with their severity, if husbands treat with the greatest contempt the wives they're commanded to love and spare as the weaker vessels, are children any less bound in duty to their parents, or wives to their husbands? They are subjected to the harsh and undutiful.
Since everyone's duty is not to look behind them, that is, not to inquire into each other's duties, but each to look to his own, this should hold especially for those who are under the power of others.
So if we're cruelly tormented by a savage ruler, if we're plundered by a greedy or extravagant one, if we're neglected by a lazy one, in short, if we're persecuted for righteousness' sake by an ungodly and sacrilegious prince, let's first call to mind our own sins, which the Lord is surely chastising with such scourges. In this way humility will curb our impatience. And let's reflect that it isn't for us to cure these evils. All that remains for us is to ask help from the Lord, in whose hands are the hearts of kings and the turnings of kingdoms (Prov. 21:1).
"God has taken his place in the divine council; in the midst of the gods he holds judgment" (Ps. 82:1). Before his face all kings and judges of the earth shall fall and be crushed, who haven't kissed his Anointed (Ps. 2:10), who have made unjust laws to oppress the poor in judgment and do violence to the cause of the humble, to make widows their spoil and rob the fatherless (Isa. 10:1-2).
30. How God delivers his people from tyranny
Here the goodness, power and providence of God are wonderfully displayed. At one time he raises up open avengers from among his own servants and gives them his command to punish accursed tyranny and rescue his people from calamity when they're unjustly oppressed. At another time he uses for this purpose the fury of men who have other thoughts and other aims.
So he rescued his people Israel from Pharaoh's tyranny by Moses, and from the violence of Cushan-rishathaim, king of Syria, by Othniel, and from other bondage by other kings or judges. So he tamed the pride of Tyre by the Egyptians, the insolence of the Egyptians by the Assyrians, the fierceness of the Assyrians by the Chaldeans, and the confidence of Babylon by the Medes and Persians, Cyrus having first subdued the Medes. The ingratitude of the kings of Judah and Israel and their ungodly stubbornness after all his kindness he humbled and punished, at one time by the Assyrians and at another by the Babylonians.
All these things weren't done in the same way. The first class of deliverers were brought forward by God's lawful call to do these deeds. When they took up arms against kings, they didn't violate in any way the majesty with which kings are clothed by divine appointment. Armed from heaven, they curbed a lesser power by a greater, just as kings may lawfully punish their own governors. The second class, though directed by God's hand as he saw fit, and doing his work without knowing it, had nothing but evil in their thoughts.
31. Private people must obey; popular magistrates are different
Whatever may be thought of the men's own acts (the French adds: for the former acted in full confidence that they were doing right, and the latter from a different motive, as we've said), the Lord by their means equally carried out his own work when he broke the bloody sceptres of insolent kings and overthrew their intolerable dominions. Let princes hear and be afraid. But at the same time let us guard most carefully against despising or violating the venerable and majestic authority of rulers, an authority God has sanctioned by the surest decrees, even though those who hold it are most unworthy of it and, as far as they can, pollute it by their wickedness. Though the Lord takes vengeance on unbridled domination, let's not suppose that this vengeance has been committed to us, to whom no command has been given but to obey and suffer.
I'm speaking only of private people. Where popular magistrates have been appointed to restrain the tyranny of kings, the case is different. Such were the ephors set against the kings of the Spartans, the tribunes of the people against the Roman consuls, and the demarchs against the Athenian senate. Perhaps there's something similar to this in the power exercised in each kingdom by the three estates when they hold their principal assemblies. So far am I from forbidding these officers from officially checking the undue licence of kings that, if they connive at kings who tyrannise and trample on the humbler people, I affirm that their dissimulation is not free from outrageous treachery. They fraudulently betray the people's liberty, while knowing that by God's ordinance they are its appointed guardians (Dan. 9:7; Prov. 21:1; Ps. 82:1; Isa. 10:1).
32. Obedience to rulers stops where it would mean disobeying God
In the obedience we say is due to the commands of rulers, we must always make an exception, indeed we must take particular care that it isn't incompatible with obedience to Him to whose will the wishes of all kings must be subject, to whose decrees their commands must yield, to whose majesty their sceptres must bow. How preposterous it would be, in pleasing men, to give offence to Him for whose sake you obey men! The Lord is King of kings. When he opens his sacred mouth, he alone is to be heard, in place of all and above all. We're subject to the men who rule over us, but subject only in the Lord. If they command anything against him, let's pay no attention to it at all, and let's not be moved by all the dignity they have as magistrates. No injury is done to that dignity when it is subordinated to the special and truly supreme power of God.
On this ground Daniel denies that he had sinned in any way against the king when he refused to obey his ungodly decree (Dan. 6:22). The king had overstepped his limits, and had not only wronged men but, by raising his horn against God, had in effect cancelled his own power. On the other hand, the Israelites are condemned for obeying too readily the ungodly edict of the king. When Jeroboam made the golden calf, they left the temple of God and, in submission to him, turned to new superstitions (1 Kings 12:28). Later generations bowed just as readily before the decrees of their kings. For this the prophet sharply rebukes them (Hos. 5:11).
So the praise of modesty is far from being due to the pretence behind which flattering courtiers hide and deceive the simple, when they deny that it's lawful to decline anything their kings impose. As if the Lord had handed over his own rights to mortals by appointing them to rule over their fellows! As if earthly power were diminished when it's subjected to its author, before whom even the principalities of heaven tremble as suppliants!
I know the great danger subjects run by this firmness, since kings are most angry when they're defied. As Solomon says, "A king's wrath is a messenger of death" (Prov. 16:14). But since Peter, one of heaven's heralds, has published the edict, "We must obey God rather than men" (Acts 5:29), let's console ourselves with the thought that we're giving the obedience the Lord requires when we endure anything rather than turn aside from godliness. And so that our courage may not fail, Paul adds another spur (1 Cor. 7:23): we were redeemed by Christ at the great price his redemption cost him, so that we shouldn't give slavish obedience to the corrupt wishes of men, still less pay homage to their ungodliness.
End of Book Four